CableCARD supported Win7 WMC Alternatives?

iRpilot

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 4, 2011
Messages
102
I'm having a lot of issues with Win7 Windows Media Center lately and I'm just curious:

Are there any good alternatives to Windows Media Center out there with CableCARD compatibility, specifically Ceton InfiniTV 4?

*EDIT*

Specs, just in case:

HTPC:

OS- Win7 x64 WMC
Mobo- Foxconn H67S
CPU- Core i3 2105
GPU- Intel HD 3000
RAM- 2 x 2GB DDR3 1333 Mushkin
Boot HDD- 60GB Corsair Force 3
Recording HDD- Seagate 5400.6 320gb 2.5"
Tuner- Ceton InfiniTV 4 PCIe
PSU- PicoPSU 150, 120 watt brick
Case- Wesena ITX7

Server:

OS- unRAID
Mobo- Intel DQ965GF Sata II x 6
CPU- Intel Core 2 Duo 6420
RAM- 2 x 2GB dual channel OCZ
Parity- 1TB Western Digital WD1003FBYX
Disk 1- 1TB Western Digital WD10EADS
Disk 2- 1TB Western Digital WD10EACS

Network:

Router- Rosewill Rosewill RNX-N300RT
Switch- TRENDnet TEG-S50g 5 port gigabit switch

Server, HTPC, and PS3 wired to TRENDnet switch wired to Rosewill router.
 
Last edited:
Nope, none that I've found.

What issues are you having? I had a shit ton before I got my cablecard replaced. Now everything is pretty much ok.
 
I'm not really having any issues with the CableCARD itself (at least I don't think, but I've had weirder stuff happen) and I'm using a Ceton InfinitiTV 4. I'd love to get the most bang for my 300 bones, and get high marks for the WAF, but it seems like Windows or WMC is complicating things. Okay, here's the longest post ever:

I tweaked a ton of settings and made custom macros for my Harmony One that have resolved a lot of my issues. Some of the issues are specifically just WMC, or are a combination of WMC and my HTPC itself. The majority of my issues are concerning putting the HTPC into a sleep/standby state without problems, and then resuming without problems. Also, the infamous Video Playback Error, which is indeed an audio error. That seems to be resolved for the time-being, but occasionally it comes up again and I have to reconfigure my audio to get WMC to work properly.

My main issue is that when I power my home theater down I have my HTPC power plan set to sleep when the power button is pressed. No matter what, it always forces sleep and terminates any recording that is presently taking place. I've tried the Power Off and Power Toggle buttons set up for my HTPC on the Harmony One, I've tried selecting sleep in WMC itself, and I've tried the actual physical power button on the HTPC case itself thinking that maybe the Harmony is sending a different power command. They all terminate any running services including eHome for recording, and any current transfers or downloads occuring, and force the HTPC into a sleep/standby.

Secondly, sometimes when I resume from a sleep, either the display doesn't resume at all on my TV without a reboot (I'm assuming this is a machine issue), or when WMC starts up, it's in a really weird aspect ratio and looks extremely distorted. I've combated the latter issue by creating a custom button on the Harmony that runs a script that restarts WMC.

I've tried eliminating the sleep issues by just setting the HTPC to run all the time and just never power down. This just amplifies the display issues, resulting in a forced reboot most of the time to resolve the issue.

I've done countless hours of research, tweaks, and experiments and so far the WAF is very low. Sometimes I imagine my wife in a field somewhere going Office Space style on my poor HTPC with a baseball bat in slo-mo... This woman needs to see the full episode of Army Wives, not the first 60% or she's going to put me and my HTPC in the ground. Lol

Don't get me wrong, WMC is great, I love it, there are just some kinks that I (perhaps Microsoft for some issues) need to work out... It's too bad MediaPortal doesn't support CableCARD at all, and hopefully XBMC adds direct LiveTV support someday without add-ons.



P.S. Posted Specs in OP.
 
Last edited:
You might need one of those EDID Doctors that tricks the video card into thinking the TV is always on.

I bet you could even use a cheap, powered HDMI splitter to trick the vid card too.
 
Yep - you have an EDID issue. Swapping in an nVidia card fixed all my issues.
 
EDID issues? Would that cause the force sleep/standby issue? I'll have to do some research on it.

Thanks guys.
 
Does your MSO set the Copy-Once flag on any channels? That's going to be a big determining factor if you're looking to try and use XBMC.

The simplest answers to your problem is to not have your PC sleep. I have mine sleep and have no issues; HOWEVER, I do not use the main HTPC for viewing - I use extenders.

If you want a high WAF, why not try using an extender instead? They won't have the sleep issues and image blackout like most HTPCs CAN have. My wife has been happy with the Ceton/WMC setup for about a year now. Anyways, worth a shot.
 
You might fix the EDID issue with HDMIyo. Description here.

I have HDMIyo at home that I can share if you need it.
 
Does your MSO set the Copy-Once flag on any channels? That's going to be a big determining factor if you're looking to try and use XBMC.

Possibly a dumb question, and not meant to hijack the thread - but how do you determine if a copy once flag has been set? I've looked in 7MC as well as the details tab of the actual file, and I can't see any indicator as to copy once vs copy freely...
 
I don't put my HTPC to sleep (as it has folding to do), so I don't have any of the sleep issues. If it isn't viable for the location you're using it in, park it somewhere out of the way and get an extender to use to watch the content. I've always found sleep/standby/hibernate/power save optoins to be wonky in my 10 year history of doing the HTPC thing...

Possibly a dumb question, and not meant to hijack the thread - but how do you determine if a copy once flag has been set? I've looked in 7MC as well as the details tab of the actual file, and I can't see any indicator as to copy once vs copy freely...

Not at home at the moment, but if I'm remebering correctly, the protected shows say "Copy Protected" within MCE's detailed description.
 
Does your MSO set the Copy-Once flag on any channels? That's going to be a big determining factor if you're looking to try and use XBMC.

The simplest answers to your problem is to not have your PC sleep. I have mine sleep and have no issues; HOWEVER, I do not use the main HTPC for viewing - I use extenders.

If you want a high WAF, why not try using an extender instead? They won't have the sleep issues and image blackout like most HTPCs CAN have. My wife has been happy with the Ceton/WMC setup for about a year now. Anyways, worth a shot.

I've never asked if my provider is Copy-Once, but I have moved some of my recordings to my server and played them from Win7 WMC on a laptop over my network, so I'm assuming Copy-Freely?

I've tried the No Sleep solution before and starting running into the display issues. It didn't happen every time, but usually while I was at work and the wife was trying to watch TV. lol. I actually set it up for a semi no-sleep configuration today and so far it's successful. Power Plan is set to Do Nothing when power or sleep button pressed, and I used MCEStandby Tool to send it into s3 after 2.5 hours of no user input. I tested it, and it doesn't force standby while recording and using the MCE tool function.

I'm assuming the display issues when leaving the HTPC on all the time are the EDID issue everyone is referring to? I've just never heard the term, I'll definitely check it out.

The extender idea is a damn good one tho, I've planning on using them but never thought of just using them to eliminate problems on the main TV. That way I could stash my HTPC, Server, and all the networking crap in a closet or my bedroom instead of in my entertainment center. I'm very interested in the Ceton Echo that's coming out soon.

Thanks for the help. Excuse any errors, I'm on the cellular device.
 
Ah, it seems the EDID issue is the culprit of my mute issue after resume as well! I have so many scripts and custom buttons for my Harmony which runs them via EventGhost to resolve these little issues. It's rather annoying. haha.
 
You can either purchase a Gefen HDMI Detective or an nVidia card to fix the EDID problem.
 
Back
Top