buying a 5850 or 5870 Depending

4LC4PON3

DERP!
Joined
Jan 18, 2005
Messages
4,230
i got a ? for everyone qon 2 diff companies same cards. Would you buy a XFX 5870 for the 2 year warranty or buy the HIS 5870 with a Free Game. also between the 2 companies who MAKES the better card.
 
If I had to go on brand recognition alone, I'd go with XFX. Dirt2 with the HIS? Too bad, that was JUST on sale on Steam for $19.99. I'd prolly go with XFX, but that's just me. Dirt2 will be worth $9.99 in no time. That 2 years warranty is ... good for 2 years; and it's transferable if that's still something XFX does. Is it? You may want to look into that, don't take my word for it.
 
Actually if you live in the US XFX has double (transferrable) lifetime warranty, not 2 year.
 
ok i was thinking that also about dirt 2. i knew in my head to get xfx but wanted a free game:)
 
Oh, I assumed you were in Europe. The XFX warranty is different over there. If you're talkin' double-lifetime transferable it's a no-brainer ...

XFX +1
 
i got a ? for everyone qon 2 diff companies same cards. Would you buy a XFX 5870 for the 2 year warranty or buy the HIS 5870 with a Free Game. also between the 2 companies who MAKES the better card.
\

Do not buy an HIS video card! They did have a 2-year warranty (in the US) But...They went back to a 1-year. Anyway...Here is my link for my HF thread:

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1488322

Here in the states...They really suck! I was told 4 weeks for my 4870 1GB (fan died & cooked the GPU) Received an e-mail on Friday saying it "might" be an additional 2 weeks (6 weeks total) They are some of the worst in the VC market! DO NOT even consider them! From here on out, it's all XFX for me! I learned my lesson!!! Plus...Look @ any ( I mean..any VC) reviews on Newegg. TONS of people complain that the fan dies. Doesn't really matter which VC, many people complain they fail! Just my 2 cents worth!
 
I went with XFX for the warranty. In a years time that card will still have the same great warranty backing it and Dirt2 will be in the discount bin (no offense to Dirt2; that's just the way game sales work)
 
what do you guys think of sapphire as a company. i was reading on a diff set of forums and they favore the sapphire vaporx's over xfx. even stated that xfx has been slipping and sapphire is a better company per performance
 
Go with the XFX

Don't know but my XFX 5870 came with a steam code to get Dirt2 as well so you might look closer at the box contents.
 
what do you guys think of sapphire as a company. i was reading on a diff set of forums and they favore the sapphire vaporx's over xfx. even stated that xfx has been slipping and sapphire is a better company per performance

Performance should be identical with all the cards, unless you're getting an overclocked version. Each manufacturer just slaps their own sticker on it. So here, usually advise to get the brand that has the best warranty/support.
 
I had bought the sapphire vapor-x version only for the convenience with the performance of the stock cooler, as an upgrade for my current system (it was also $10 cheaper than the XFX at the time due to instant rebate). when I get into a new build I'll definitely go with XFX for their warranty coverage if that helps you any.
 
I went with the HIS 5850 only because I found it at $299 canadian when it was still selling for $350+ US and I didn't want to spend $400+ on one of the 5870s they had there.
I am not really regretting it too much, I wanted to get an SSD instead but am going to wait for a couple more months.
 
doesn't XFX 5870 come with Dirt 2? at least mine did. haven't even redeemed it yet
 
hey guys without overclocking how much better is a 5850 to a 5870. is it worth the 100 dollars. my taxes just hit my account so i want to order a card tonight. i need a card that will rock crysis and stalker and No im not buying a 5970
 
Last edited:
hey guys without overclocking how much better is a 5850 to a 5870. is it worth the 100 dollars. my taxes just hit my account so i want to order a card tonight. i need a card that will rock crysis and stalker and No im not buying a 5970
I would just stick with the 5870 thats in your sig. :p
 
i bit the bullet and grabbed the 5850 and bought my daughter a new Dora bed :) the 5870 in my Sig was just there for now until i got my taxes back. ive been using onboard video on my Rig for now. im sure ill be happy Unless it comes DOA
 
Last edited:
i bit the bullet and grabbed the 5850 and bought my daughter a new Dora bed :) the 5870 in my Sig was just there for now until i got my taxes back. ive been using onboard video on my Rig for now. im sure ill be happy Unless it comes DOA
Dora bed??? wut? lol j/k. You're a good dad. I'm sure the 5850 will do just fine...or you could return the bed and get a 5970. :D
 
lol no its ok. im actually getting 2 5850's one is on order now and im going to order another in a week. My daughter comes first. i just completely redid her entire room in Dora like you wouldnt believe. It cost me just below a grand. Shes well worth it
 
lol no its ok. im actually getting 2 5850's one is on order now and im going to order another in a week. My daughter comes first. i just completely redid her entire room in Dora like you wouldnt believe. It cost me just below a grand. Shes well worth it
Man, I hate to go a little ot but people with kids must REALLY enjoy tax season...I have friends/family that get 6/7 thousand dollar checks. Me and my wife barely get like 500 bucks...and she's already talking about spending it on bedroom furniture...:(
 
Yeah believe me I put WAY more into my daughter per year then what i get back but it does help.between us 2 we pull almost 8 grand back. its nice but it doesnt last long when you got bills bills bills
 
Last edited:
Back
Top