Building new pc: advice needed on 64-bit

karnick

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 3, 2004
Messages
183
Ok guys heres the situation, my current plans are to spend about $400 on a case, cpu, ram, mobo... now what i was going to do is get the XP 2500 Mobile 512K and overclocking it with air cooling, preferably a Thermalright SLK900/947 because apparently people have gotten to around 2.7 at 39c idle with just the SLK copper heatsink and an 80 mm fan.. now, i must say i am a big time gamer, i have an X800 XT PE on the way...

should i:
a) Screw the barton and go for a 64-bit AMD at the same price
b) Go with the overclocked mobile....

suggestions?
oh yeah and i know alot of ppl say they aint going 64 bit til pci express, what are your opinions on this..thanks
 
Well PCI-Express has no real bearing on 64bit right now. Right now and for the forseeable lifetime of a gamers or enthusiests machine I don't think 64bit will matter.

I think the real reason people are wanting 64bit now is because it gives them a warm fuzzy knowing that they COULD run 64bit code. This warm fuzzy is deep inside thier pants.
 
icthus13 said:
You aren't going to get an A64 for the same price as a Barton.

That's true also. But 64bit isn't important right now for mainsteam machines.
 
first, i'd be surprised if you could get a case/mobo/proc/mem for $400. if you can, though, it's probably going to be cheap stuff you'll regret later. get a good case, think lian li or so, and a good power supply so your system will be stable voltage-wise when you get enough cash for the mobo/proc/mem. if you have a computer now, this is what i'd do. then wait for christmas and see about the nforce4. if you're currently computerless, tho, get an xp. older, stabler, more revisions. i wish i could recommend a64 for this budget but i can't. :(
 
My advice is don't buy an A64 simply because of the 64 bit part. It's going to be quite some time before you'll need that feature. It is a very fast processor now though.

I went with the P4 line because of the chipsets. The 865/875 have been the best chipsets out there period....regardless of platform. Nothing the AMD side has can match them in performance, memory bandwidth, etc. That's always been my complaint about an AMD system....is the boards...not the processors. I don't know much about the boards for an A64, so I can't comment on them. I would not consider an AthlonXP anymore if your building a true top of the line system. I would be deciding between P4 and A64. But, $400 isn't going to get you top of the line, so your pretty much stuck with an AthlonXP...unless you up your budget.
 
karnick said:
Ok guys heres the situation, my current plans are to spend about $400 on a case, cpu, ram, mobo...

should i:
a) Screw the barton and go for a 64-bit AMD at the same price

If you can find a way, let me know :D
 
djnes said:
I went with the P4 line because of the chipsets. The 865/875 have been the best chipsets out there period....regardless of platform. Nothing the AMD side has can match them in performance, memory bandwidth, etc.

Well...the A64 system's don't have a chipset anymore "per se."

They have an integrated memory controller that beats Intel's memory bandwidth, etc
 
Xrave said:
Well...the A64 system's don't have a chipset anymore "per se."

They have an integrated memory controller that beats Intel's memory bandwidth, etc

By chipsets I meant overall motherboards. Not just the specific northbridge, etc. I like the integrated memory bandwidth idea. However, I stated I didn't know much about the A64 line....I was referring to P4 boards vs AthlonXP boards.
 
Xrave said:
Well...the A64 system's don't have a chipset anymore "per se."

They have an integrated memory controller that beats Intel's memory bandwidth, etc
agree, but just bc 64bit software isnt out right now doesnt mean that you shouldnt get it, the P4 cant touch the athlon 64 for gaming, if thats what you want to do
 
advanced101101 said:
the P4 cant touch the athlon 64 for gaming, if thats what you want to do

Actually they're pretty close....trading top spots depending on the games. Don't forget either that the new 9xx series Intel chipsets are on their way out as well. I'm not trying to make a case for just Intel. Both platforms are flat out awesome. I'm just trying to point out that these forums are littered with AMD fanboys who refuse to admit either platform is perfectly fine to build on.
 
djnes said:
By chipsets I meant overall motherboards. Not just the specific northbridge, etc. I like the integrated memory bandwidth idea. However, I stated I didn't know much about the A64 line....I was referring to P4 boards vs AthlonXP boards.


Well, for P4 vs AXP, the P4C's are quite nice and yes, I'd agree the P4's are better, but for $400, I don't think you can really buy a case, cpu, ram, and mobo.

I'd go for a mobile 2500+ and overclock the hell out of it with air cooling. You could keep the price under 400 with that setup.
 
Xrave said:
I'd go for a mobile 2500+ and overclock the hell out of it with air cooling. You could keep the price under 400 with that setup.

my initial plan, i think i might just do this unless its worth waiting and saving for xmas?
 
I plan on waiting since any upgrade in the AXP area will just require another upgrade fairly soon.

If you do save and get an A64 system, you'll be able to hold off for another upgrade/do more upgrades in the future.
 
Back
Top