Building New Computer Within 5 Days? Suggestions?

tzk

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 21, 2007
Messages
274
Hey Everybody...

My uncle wants a new computer so I'm building one for him and I need suggestions and answers to some questions just to make sure I've got everything right...

Here's what's going in it:

Case: Cooler Master RC-690
CPU: E6750
RAM: G.Skill 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2 800 [Dual Channel]
Motherboard: GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3R
Videocard: POWERCOLOR X1950PRO 512MB 256-bit
PSU: GameXStream 700W
Optical Drives: Lite-On 20X DVD Burner and Lite-On DVD-Rom
Fans: 2x AeroCool Streamliner 140mm
Other: SUPER TALENT INT-AIN1-C All-in-one USB 2.0 Card Reader
Hard Drives: 2x 500GB Wester Digital SATA
OS: Windows XP

Here is the NewEgg Wishlist

Total Cost: $1145, $1035 after MIR

Notes:
  • He's not a 'gamer'.. he does play poker games and always buys the latest ones.
  • He backs up his DVDs and might be getting into video editing sonn (for home movies and such)
  • Those hard drives won't be running in RAID

Now for the questions...
1) Will this computer be able to last him upwards of 5 years with incremental CPU Updates?
2) Is the video card sufficient enough for what he's doing, for future things?
3) Any other suggestions or changes that you can think of?

Much Help would be appreciated..
Thank You,
Zach
 
Its all major overkill except the ram.

If I were building somone a computer who isnt a gamer I would probably set them up with a cheapy AM2 system with onboard video and about a 400watt psu. Even if it takes them twice as long to encode a video, they probably werent going to be sitting at the desk watching the progress bar anyway so it just means they watch 2 TV shows instead of 1. Pick a board that supports phenom and if he really gets into it, you can always bump him up to a cheap quadcore later.

Computer requirements for watcing a dvd:
"Pentium 2 400MHz or faster (Macintosh G3 450 or faster).
128MB+ RAM.
Windows 98SE or higher (Macintosh OS 9.2.2 or higher)
DVD-ROM drive.
DVD-Video codecs (COmpression/DECompression software - these are usually installed alongside DVD hardware).
A video player application that can use the DVD-Video codecs."
Source: http://centraal.uk.knowledgebox.com/kbase/idx/53/119/article/

I know it really hurts to build something weak and slow, but think of it as a challenge to get somone a kick arse system for cheap. I built my aunt a x2 3600+ system for less than 200 bucks (reusing her old PSU, case, drives etc...) and its very fast during general desktop usage. If she ever asks for more ill just overclock the sucker since when I was piddling with it, it could do 2.9ghz on stock voltage (lucky chip!, but I imagine 2.5 atleast is possible for most).
 
Skip the expensive stuff and since is going to be doing DVD backup/video editing just get a quad now, they are cheep enough

COOLER MASTER RC-690 $80
ASUS M3A AM2+ $99
AMD Phenom 9500 $199
GIGABYTE 2400Pro $43
OCZ DDR-800 2gb $49
Thermaltake Purepower 500W $60
LITE-ON Black 20X DVD+R $35
Rosewill RCR-FD200 All-in-one USB 2.0 Black 3.5" Card Reader with 1.44MB Floppy Drive $26
Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 ST3500320AS 500GB 7200 RPM 32MB $120x2

Total $832.90

or you could use Intel and use everthing from above but include

DFI P35-T2RL $108
Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 $280

Which would bing the total to $920
 
If he's not a gamer, why even build a system? Why not go for a Dell instead?

But eh, if you do build...

Ditch the X1950 since he's not a gamer and doesnt need to render any 3D stuff. Go for an HD2600XT or 8600GT if he watches any HD content. If not, just go with onboard video or a cheap $25 vidcard instead.

Make sure the optical drives are SATA. It makes for a cleaner case and easier wire management.

Ditch the GXS700W... it has ripple at high loads on the +12V rail. While you may never stress the PSU that much, there are better choices. Go for a Corsair 450W, 550W, or 520W from either zipzoomfly, buy.com, or clubit.com -- newegg overcharges for PSUs that aren't OCZ brand. Any of those Corsairs I listed will handle your planned system and still have room for upgrades -- they're good quality units.

If he does video editing, consider a Q6600 instead of the E6750.

Sorry if I missed anything, I'm in a hurry, lol.
 
Well he is currently using an ATI X300SE and his poker games are now becoming choppy and yeah... he was thinking about starting to play Doom 3 also, but that's about it.

I do appreciate all of your feedback... here is my situation... He wants the best, I've tried talking him out of it, but if I don't do it, then he'll just go to his usual computer guy and pay a lot more probably because of labor and such... So I might as well build it for him and get what he wants, which is a beast of a machine he doesn't have to worry about for years.

I don't know about the Phenom I think I'll still go Intell...

Cooler Master RC-690 $80 w/ $45 (MIR) = $35

Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3R - $126.99
Why go with the DFI instead of the Gigabyte, I've read great reviews of this board, is there any reason to consider the DFI instead, other than the cost?

Corsair 550VX - $100 - $15MIR = $85
I always wanted to go with this PSU, I've also read great reviews...

EVGA 8600GT 512MB 128-bit - $150 - $20MIR = $130
Will this be able to handle poker 3D games and maybe possible Doom 3? It's also got HDCP support...

G.Skill 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2 800 $47
Why should I go with the OCZ, I believe this ram is only 1.8V and the OCZ is 2.1V. Is there a reason why I should choose OCZ over G.Skill?

2x Western Digital 500GB 16MB Cache $105 x 2 = $210
I see the Segates are about $15 more for 32MB Cache and 5 year warranty, though the Seagate seems to have more bad reviews than the WD. Should I go with the Segates or the WD's?

Intel E6750 $190

Base Total: $824 after MIR

I believe that's it other than the peripheries such as SATA Burner and Card Reader...

He will go out and spend the money, I just don't want him to overspend with tax and labor charges when I'm willing to build for free... or lunch..

I would love to hear your responses to my questions because I am genuinely intrigued with the responses that I get.

Trust me, I've tried to talk him out of it...
Thank You!
Zach
 
Case seems less aesthetic than it should be for someone who is older.
 
8600 is junk, spend 25 more dollars and get a HD3850

:confused:
that 8600 has 512mb of gddr3. It also has free shipping.
and I'd like to see the link to the HD3850 that costs $155 (that's from a reputable dealer)
So a g84 w/ 512 VS a 3850 w/ 256 for more than $30 more, when I doubt they would even come close to needed half that 8600.
xfx 8600 xxx, half the memory, but OCed clocks, save $30 more

IMO, given what you say about what he wants, go with your latest list, including the 512mb 8600.
 
He was looking at the cases and I showed him that one cause it's cheap and has lots of cooling, and he liked that one... so I guess whatever works...
 
I'm looking at the HD3850... would that actually be a better buy for the longer term?

It's only about $40 (and he doesn't care about money...)

Now if I do decide to do that, will the Corsair 550W be able to run the system?

Also, I might just put Folding@Home on it, just so that the computer gets used for something good... It's bound to support the HD3850 soon, so for $40 more, he could be helping with protein folding?

Sounds good, or should I just stick with the 8600GT?
 
:confused:
that 8600 has 512mb of gddr3. It also has free shipping.
and I'd like to see the link to the HD3850 that costs $155 (that's from a reputable dealer)
So a g84 w/ 512 VS a 3850 w/ 256 for more than $30 more, when I doubt they would even come close to needed half that 8600.
xfx 8600 xxx, half the memory, but OCed clocks, save $30 more

IMO, given what you say about what he wants, go with your latest list, including the 512mb 8600.

An HD3850 w/ 256mb would rock an 8600 with 512mb.

And whats this about reputable dealers? The smaller guys are all better then the bigger guys, power color being the only exception. Sapphire and HIS RMA services suck.

But I vote you go in the other direction. You don't need an 8600 or HD3850 or even HD2600 if hes not going to be gaming. Doom 3 can be murdered by any card above low end two generations back. However, if hes going to be playing doom 3, theres a good chance he'll play something else.

And as I recall, every poker game I've seen is anything but graphically demanding. Theres something else wrong with the system if its slowing down.

anyways, the advice so far has been bad.

If this things main purpose is to DVD backups then lets focus around that. I vote 4 gigs of ram. Thats a pretty good and fast DVD burner tho, donno really, not something I look into too much.

And yeah, ditch the PSU. You don't need nearly that much power, and even when you do draw that much power its ugly power. Get something else, the first that comes to mind being a corsair.
 
:confused:
that 8600 has 512mb of gddr3. It also has free shipping.
and I'd like to see the link to the HD3850 that costs $155 (that's from a reputable dealer)
So a g84 w/ 512 VS a 3850 w/ 256 for more than $30 more, when I doubt they would even come close to needed half that 8600.
xfx 8600 xxx, half the memory, but OCed clocks, save $30 more

IMO, given what you say about what he wants, go with your latest list, including the 512mb 8600.

VisionTek - ATI RADEON HD3850 Graphics Card $160

VisionTek 900203 Radeon HD 3850 $170

The Radeon HD 3850 is really the star of the show at its price point of $179. The fact that it contains the full 320 streaming processors as the Radeon HD 3870, with simply lower clock speeds means it is one lean mean fully featured machine. We consistently saw it smacking around the 8600 GTS factory overclocked video card. The gameplay advantages weren’t small; they were night and day noticeable in many instances.
 
An HD3850 w/ 256mb would rock an 8600 with 512mb.

And whats this about reputable dealers? The smaller guys are all better then the bigger guys, power color being the only exception. Sapphire and HIS RMA services suck.

But I vote you go in the other direction. You don't need an 8600 or HD3850 or even HD2600 if hes not going to be gaming. Doom 3 can be murdered by any card above low end two generations back. However, if hes going to be playing doom 3, theres a good chance he'll play something else.

And as I recall, every poker game I've seen is anything but graphically demanding. Theres something else wrong with the system if its slowing down.

anyways, the advice so far has been bad.

If this things main purpose is to DVD backups then lets focus around that. I vote 4 gigs of ram. Thats a pretty good and fast DVD burner tho, donno really, not something I look into too much.

And yeah, ditch the PSU. You don't need nearly that much power, and even when you do draw that much power its ugly power. Get something else, the first that comes to mind being a corsair.

Hmm... I'd probably just stick with an 8600GT for now and save him $40 - just for the HDCP for the possible future. Stupid DRM...

He'll be running XP 32bit so 4gig of RAM right now wouldn't be useful, he doesn't want Vista yet, and until it works pretty awesomely like XP SP2, he won't upgrade... just the way he is...

I know he's crazy... really he would do fine with a $400 system...

I did put a corsair in my updated listing, I originally went for that, though he liked the Blue LED from the GameXStreamer, yet he wouldn't see it because of the case...
 
If he wants to play any new games at all, the HD3850 for $160 from bestbuy would be a good choice. The 8600GT is too weak to make use of 512MB of ram, so just stick with the 256MB version if you choose it. What size monitor does he have or plan on getting?

Cases are 90% personal preference, and the one you chose fulfills the other 10% criteria of good airflow and ample space for all your parts.

DFI boards are for people who really love to tweak all the settings they can in their system. If he doesnt OC and tweak his system a lot, don't bother with the DFI. The DS3R is a good choice if you need RAID. If you don't need RAID, the DS3L or IP35-E are cheaper alternatives. If he needs both RAID and Firewire, check out the DS3P, DS4, P5K-E, IP35 vanilla, and IP35 Pro (the crowd favorite). With that said, I love my DS3R. :D

The Corsair 550W will be fine with any single vidcard you choose. I personally like the modular 520W version better (seasonic built, quieter, modular).

The G.Skill you chose is fine. RAM is cheap, so even though XP-32 won't be able to utilize all 4GB, its not much of a waste. 2GB is still fine though, for what he uses the system for.

Yah, he's lucky he has you around to do this for him. :p I do the same thing with my fam/friends. "build me a comp?" "sure, bring some carne asada fries" "ok"... :p
 
Thank you for all of your advice, it was awesome to hear from all of you.

I hope this all goes well, this would be my first time building a computer fully... I'm pretty sure I've built a computer over a span of years with different part replacements and what not...

So yeah, Thank you all.

- Zach
 
Hunt around and find the 8600 for less, ive seen em as low as 105. 8600 is about 10-15% faster than the 7600gt, which was about the same speed as a 6800ultra (Top end when Doom 3 was released, what it was designed to max out on).

Same ol Same ol chart
http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphics_2007.html?modelx=33&model1=855&model2=720&chart=275

Look up there at the 3850 though :/ Then again it is 60% more expensive for about 225% more performance. But you have to draw the line somewhere.
 
Yeah. Well the reason I chose this 8600GT is because it's HDCP and the cheaper 8600GT's aren't.

I'll give him the option of the HD3850, he'll probably bite on it... he's crazy like that... though I'll just install Folding@Home, and hopefully his GPU will help cure cancer or some disease like that.
 
If he does want the HD3850, will the Corsair 550W be able to handle the system with 2 Optical Drives, about 4 Fans, 2 HDs, and any additional HDs?
 
If he does want the HD3850, will the Corsair 550W be able to handle the system with 2 Optical Drives, about 4 Fans, 2 HDs, and any additional HDs?

It sure can. It can handle 41A on the +12V rail, and your planned system should use around 22A max without OC'ing (8600GT, 2 HDDs, etc). So, as you can see, you have PLENTY of room for growth, as well as a better vidcard.

BTW, my 8600GT was $80 after a $20MIR and it has HDCP.
 
If he does want the HD3850, will the Corsair 550W be able to handle the system with 2 Optical Drives, about 4 Fans, 2 HDs, and any additional HDs?

The proccupation with super PSUs has to do with last generations power hungry cards etc... It took a monster PSU to handle some of them in SLI or Xfire mode.
The stuff this generation isn't bad at all.
 
The proccupation with super PSUs has to do with last generations power hungry cards etc... It took a monster PSU to handle some of them in SLI or Xfire mode.
The stuff this generation isn't bad at all.

...not really true. The G80/G92 cards can still pull quite a bit, especially when OCed.

The real reason the GPU manufacturers recommend such crazy high numbers is to cover their own asses. Older/lower quality supplies have very little in the way of amperage available on the 12v rail/rails and often aren't capable of actually supplying what they're rated for, so recommending an 800 watt supply when a 400 watt high quality supply with the bulk of the power available on the 12v rails where it's needed saves them a lot of trouble.

That said, current SLI/Crossfire systems can pull 700+ watts at the wall under load. It's not all scaremongering/misinformation.

The Corsair 450VX or better will be fine for the system the OP is considering.

Also, to the OP: forget the E6750. Spend the extra $80-90 on the Q6600 G0 now, and don't bother with it anymore. Should last him pretty much indefinitely unless what he's doing with it changes substantially.
 
I agree, if he keeps this system for a while, go with the Q6600 as I suggested earlier.
 
With NewEgg are you likely to get a G0 stepping of the Q6600 or would clubit be better. I've read that Clubit guarantees the G0 stepping, my uncle would like to keep all the purchases together and such...

Once again, Thanks everybody.
 
Go with ClubIT to make sure you get a G0. NewEgg still sends out older chips at times. It'll add maybe $3 to the purchase grand total. Very much worthwhile. Most other things you can get via NewEgg, but it isn't the end all be all. You might also get your PSU via ClubIT or buy.com rather than NewEgg as they tend to overcharge a bit.
 
Hi, folks. I'm uncle. :)

BTW, my pockets aren't that deep, I just don't mind spending more now and have something I won't need to worry about, than potentially spend it all again in a few years. Oh, and more intense gaming just ain't in the cards... my eyes are getting too old for that. :)

I wanted to thank you for your time on this. I'm total beginner when it comes to this stuff, but I'm getting a better understanding as I read the opinions here and elsewhere, and study a bit on how these contraptions go together. Still a bit overwhelming, but I think I might be able to build it myself, with the guidance of you kind folks and Zach. The assembly all looks rather straightforward, actually easier than a long-block with far fewer measurements! It seems proper and compatible components are the keys, which is where I would be lost.

Anyhoot, thanks for the guidance.

Dean
 
Oh yeah, if you can go through a rebuild you can throw a PC together in under an hour. There are only what... 8, 10 major components and some wiring.
 
I second on the Dell. There are many Dell coupons on the net for a desktop system. You might come out the same or even save money. For some people, you will also save time, and time is money. Dell might suck at CS but they do have good products.

If you want to do the build for experience, that would be fine too. Good luck.
 
HUGE apologies! I posted on the wrong thread!!!

tzk, please forgive me.

Dean

(stupid, stupid, stupid...)
 
Back
Top