Building Battlefield 1942 System...Advice

brenthamm

n00b
Joined
Dec 20, 2001
Messages
27
A friend of mine wants a system for Battlefield 1942 and he wants me to build him a new system. He is on a bit of a budget. Here is what i was going to build for him:

$171 Sapphire 9600XT 256 MB
$ 67 Asus A7N8X-x NForce2
$ 88 AMD XP 2500 retail
$ 68 SamSung 512MB PC3200
$ 69 WD 80GB JB
Total = $463

He has case/powersupply (a good one), burner, floppy, keyboard, mouse, joystick and good 19" monitor already.

His 19" Monitor can get over 1600x1200 (not sure what it was, one higher then that)

I was trying to choose between AMD or Intel, ATI or Nividia. Not sure which to go with, but want to stay under $525 total.

Any advice?

Thanks alot guys!
 
If its battlefield you want, then your gonna want to put more RAM in that thing. Battlefield is a RAM FIEND. Other than that it looks good. Why dont you get a Abit NF7-S instead of the A7N8X though? Theyre the best bet for performance. Getting both more RAM and the NF7 should keep you around your goal price, and it should be a pretty good battlefield machine
 
That setup would be plenty for BF1942. I play it all the time on my XP1600+, 768MB PC2100, and GeForce 4 MX440 w/64mb. I've got it at 1024x768 @ 32 bit with all the eye candy turned on, and dedicated 50% of CPU time for the artificial intelligence, and get no lag whatsoever, runs smooth and perfect. The 512MB would be fine for now, and adding another 512MB stick later would boost performance a bit.
 
well lets put it this way, my system runs around 80-99 fps with my settings on the highest they can go so im happy as can be! i would definitely go with the Abit NF7-S as everyone is recommending, they are great boards and definitely get another stick of 512

-warsaw
 
The NF7-S supports SATA, so might as well get a SATA 80GB if i go with that.

If i do not want SATA, is there much difference between the NF7 and the NF7-S?
 
If you want to go cheap, get the shuttle an35n ultra. If its a rig based 100% around BF1942 it has to have 1 gig of ram... not 100% needed but its 100% recommended. I'd recommend 768megs for a cheaper alternative but 1 x 512 + 1 x 256 would not enable dual channel operation.

Alternatively:

A Shuttle MN31N would have an mcp-t southbridge (Soundstorm, firewire and onboard video for as a backup, see sig) highly recomended but limited oc potential. An Abit NF7-S would have the mcp-t southbridge as well + serial ata + adapter + high oc potential (see sig again). The biggest benefit for a gamer imho is the mcp-t/soundstorm audio, which sounds a crapload better than the standard Nforce2 audio on the other mobo's. Maybe i'm just biased but i have solid reasons :p
 
Originally posted by brenthamm
The NF7-S supports SATA, so might as well get a SATA 80GB if i go with that.

If i do not want SATA, is there much difference between the NF7 and the NF7-S?
Yea theres a big difference, the plain vanilla NF7 lacks the mcp-t southbridge (read my post above), meaning no sata + adapter, no soundstorm (basic audio bites hard and sounds tinny) and no Firewire which can come in handy with all the high end peripherals being sold today.

Your cpu barely takes a hit with soundstorm in games + its quality is somewhere inbetween an audigy + audigy 2...
 
you could probably get the 128MB Sapphire 9600XT (9600XT only has 128-bit memory bus anyway, so 256MB on the video card might be overkill) and put the saved money towards another 512MB RAM.

I play BF1942 with 1GB RAM and Ti4200, but my brother's system plays it well with 128MB 9600XT and 512MB RAM. I just load maps a bit faster than he does.
 
$171 Sapphire 9600XT 256 MB
$ 98 Abit NF7-S
$ 88 AMD XP 2500 retail
$ 68 SamSung 512MB PC3200
$ 68 SamSung 512MB PC3200
$ 75 80 GB DiamondMax Plus 9 SATA

Total = $568
 
Looks like a perfect budget system. If you can find a 9600XT with 128 megs of ram for less $$$ then go for it. 256 megs on the crippled bandwidth of the 9600 series is a total waste and marketing gimmick. Sometimes cheaper(slower) memory is used to make up for the cost of 256 megs...something to keep in mind.
 
The system in my sig is mainly used for bf1942- it runs sweet at 1280x960 32bit with everything maxed out, looks really sweet. But get 1gig of ram!!!! it makes so much difference, especially to loading times and general smoothness- especially when you are trying to host to server for big games of desert combat.
The 9600pro runs fine with everything maxed out, not sure what sort of framerates im getting but its perfectly playable with everything on full :), especially with the new 4.1 drivers which seem to make it look better- things like reflections on windows and stuff looks really good noe, id never even noticed them before.
And ocing that 2500 helps things along too when playing desert combat- it seems to need better specs to run smoothly than normal 1942.
 
Originally posted by Roost426
Get 2x512 of the ram he will thank you.
EDIT: maybe some Mushkin Level II instead though, since you have a little bit more room on his budget?
EDIT2: maybe a 9700PRO instead? if he's not gonna OC you can use W1zzard's hack to softmod a 9500PRO to 9700PRO and he won't have to fear artifacts (since he's not OCing..)
 
sorry if i'm intruding, but what's the difference between nf7-s and nf7-s ver.2? i'm assuming the ver. 2 is better?
 
Originally posted by brenthamm
Will probably go with the 128 MB 9600 then.
Is the NF7-S picky about ram?
Make it the 9600 pro or XT and my particular nf7-s has tried out about 6 different ram manufacturers with no problem; Twinmos, Crucial, 2 generics & Kingston


Originally posted by misfitsfiend
sorry if i'm intruding, but what's the difference between nf7-s and nf7-s ver.2? i'm assuming the ver. 2 is better?
all new nf7-s mobo's are v2.0. Only someone carrying very old stock would have the older version. Order it from a popular vendor to assure yourself a V2.0
 
$150 Sapphire 9600XT 128 MB
$ 98 Abit NF7-S
$ 88 AMD XP 2500 retail
$ 79 Buffalo Technology 512MB PC3200 Winbond Module
$ 79 Buffalo Technology 512MB PC3200 Winbond Module
$ 75 80 GB DiamondMax Plus 9 SATA

Total = $569

I should be able to overclock this one a bit too.
 
The buffalo ram and Nforce2 mobo is a sure win combo. You've got that system fine tuned...hit that order button now! ;)

edit: it may not run cas 2-2-2 but it'll def run cas 2-2-3. with 2.5-2.7 mem voltage
 
Originally posted by SJetski71
Your cpu barely takes a hit with soundstorm in games + its quality is somewhere inbetween an audigy + audigy 2...
If you use digital out. Analog isn't so hot with SS.
 
Took the guy longer to say go then i thought, so going to order tonight.

System choices down to this:

$149 Sapphire 9600XT 128 MB
$ 92 Abit NF7-S
$ 80 AMD XP 2500 retail
$ 84 Buffalo Technology 512MB PC3200 Winbond Module
$ 84 Buffalo Technology 512MB PC3200 Winbond Module
$ 81 80 GB DiamondMax Plus 9 SATA
--------
$570

Or....

$213 Sapphire 9800PRO 128 MB
$ 92 Abit NF7-S
$ 80 AMD XP 2500 retail
$ 84 Buffalo Technology 512MB PC3200 Winbond Module
$ 81 80 GB DiamondMax Plus 9 SATA
--------
$550
 
Thats tough. If that was the only game he was ever going to play. I would say get more ram. If its the other way around (and im sure it is) get the better vid card and he can add the ram later if he wants. I would go over both options with him and tell him hte pros and cons of each. That way he cant yell at you when you decide.
 
Darn..now i cannot find this ram anymore. Anyone know who stocks it?

Or, a good substitute?
 
Originally posted by brenthamm
Darn..now i cannot find this ram anymore. Anyone know who stocks it?

Or, a good substitute?
If he's not going to oc past 200fsb then crucial's your best bet. It has a worry-free lifetime warranty.
 
Adding ram is cheap. Upgrading to another video card thats faster when you decide the 9600XT is too slow is not.
Go with the 512mb and the 9800pro, you can always save up 60-70.00 and add in another stick later on. If the video card becomes your bottleneck, you have a 150.00 vid card in your system that you would have to spend 200+ to get a faster one ;)
 
My two other suggestions are that he has a good joystick and/or the Nostromo n50/n52 speedpad and that he use a program such as Alcohol 120% to mount the games on his harddrive. That will also speed up map loads and keep him from having to hear the optical drive spin everytime a map loads. Image mounting and a gig of ram will put him on the map before anyone else. I do this and am always the first or one of the first on a map.

The joystick will make it easier to fly planes and heli's and the speedpad IMO is easier and more comfortable than a keyboard.
 
I'd go with the first system, it's better balanced. The other rig has the 9800 Pro, but I like the first system because it's got the 1gb of RAM. The 9600XT is no slouch either, it'll play BF1942 more than well.
 
How exactly is the first system better balanced? I would think the system with the faster video card is going to be faster on a whole for gaming (15-20fps or >)would be more balanced than the one with the more ram, with the exception being 1 or 2 games that would run better with more ram (though with the faster video card, every game is going to run faster for the most part) not to mention, its much simpler and less expensive later on to upgrade ram, if he upgrades his video card he will either have to take the loss on the money, or spend countless hours trying to sell the 9600XT for anywhere near what he paid for it.

Run farcry on a 9600XT with FSAA and AF enabled, then try the same with a 9800 pro. the 9800 is going to have faster in game framerates, with the 9600xt and a gig of ram it will have faster load times but the framerates wont be quite so high.

Besides, if he overclocks, the 9600XT is going to be a speed bottleneck ;) the 9800 pro wouldnt be.
 
I am going to go with the 9800 Pro. I told him the new price, and gave him the option of adding 512MB. He is going to get back to me today, but i think it will end up being a 9800 Pro + 1 Gig of ram.

Is there a website that talks about tweaking a system for 1942, or are there not that many little tweaks on can do for it?
 
I would try to do some of the tweaks that are mentions in the sticky at the top of the General Hardware forum. I don't know af anything specifically to tweak for BF42. You may want to check out some fo the BF42 site forums though.

One usefull utility you can get is MaxMem from www.analogx.com. It will allow you to set the memory boundaires the game is allowed to use but it probably isn't necessary if you go with the gig. I really only use it to see how much ram I have free on my system at any given time. With a gig I usually have about 800mb free when idle (Trillian and other apps are running in background w/o performance loss) BF42 usually uses about 800mb though since I let it.
 
I would get a better video card. I think 9800's are going for like 199.
 
With my box I am getting some smooth gameplay out of BF1942 running windows XP pro. Only real mod to the OS I have done is cut the swap file from 2 gig to 512meg.

Doesn't even swap to the drive during gameplay. Sooo very smooth.
 
Referencing my rig below, I'm running 12x7 with moderate to max details with very few problems. The video card is the weak spot, not the "missing" half gig o'RAM. Every once in a while I get laggy when there are several aircraft or lots of explosions nearby in quick succession, but that's the only time. I don't believe that bit of lag is RAM related (I had a friend's rig over for a week for troubleshooting and I snagged her 512 stick for a night - didn't eliminate the problem), though I may be mistaken. Since the GF3 is several generations behind already, I'm placing the blame squarely on its shoulders.

As for tweaks, some folks have had to adjust the sound settings within the game to eliminate a big performance bottleneck. Most people seem to suggest dropping from 44 kHz audio down to 22kHz. I haven't had any trouble with it, but I know lotsa folks have done that little tweak to drastically improve the gameplay - going from nearly unplayable to running perfectly fine.

In addition to the aforementioned joystick, I also recommend a good set of headphones or headphone/mic combo. For myself, I find that I get better audio cues from my headphones than I do with the Klipsch 5.1s. This one simple thing has made a huge difference in how well I play.
 
Yea for your Bitchnmoan I would say the Video card is your pirmary bottleneck.

I love my system. Was able to turn everything to max on the farcry demo <beauty of a game btw> and it runs like a champ.
 
I wouldn't recommend this but just so you know I play Battlefield all the time at 1024x768 32b with all the options set to high but not with any AA with no problems whatsoever on a 1800+ with 512MB RAM and a Ti4200 oc'd to Ti4600.
 
$215 Sapphire 9800 Pro 128 MB
$ 90 Abit NF7-S
$ 80 AMD XP 2500 retail
$102 Buffalo Technology 512MB PC3700 Winbond Module
$102 Buffalo Technology 512MB PC3700 Winbond Module
$ 77 80 GB DiamondMax Plus 9 SATA
$ 45 PowMax Dream Star Case 400w
--------------

$711 A little more then original but...he wants it.

Hoping that ps is enough for this system.
 
Back
Top