Building a New PC and need Component Advice

T

Tokey

Guest
First of all a quick 'hello' as this is my first post. Have been reading the site for a while and have greatly appreciated the quality of reviews and posts on this site.

That said I was hoping for a little help.

Im currently in the process of replacing my hugely aged desktop (P4 1.8, 1024MB DDR PC2100, you get the idea)

Im looking to build a gaming rig and my dear wife has offered to put in some cash for me as its our wedding anniversary in a couple of weeks. That said funds are a little limited so Im looking to build something that has high potential but current low cost. Also based in the UK so prices are even more ridiculous here than normal.

I was planning on basing the system on an Asus P5N32-E SLI which seems to be the best of all the NForce 680i options and then an Intel E6400 or E6600 Core 2 Duo as my primary components.

After that everything depends on cost.

I need reasonable Ram, I was aiming for 2GB with gaming in mind

250GB HDD probably a cheap western digital sata II such as Western Digital WD2500KS Caviar SE 250GB

Mid range graphics such as BFG 7600GT 256mb which can make a cheap SLI until prices of 8800s come down

The idea is to build something that will give me a good platform for upgrades once cash becomes more available but should see me through the next 12 months before upgrading is required.

I chose the motherboard above as it seemed to give the most options without costing the earth and Asus for me have always been reliable in the past and hopefully the other components wont cost me too much performance until I can upgrade them.

If somebody could help me out and advise components to go for I would be very grateful
 
That is a very nice motherboard, and your choice of e6400 or e6600 depends entirely on your budget.

I am a big fan of the Western Digital KS series drives, I have two of the 250GB flavor and they are both fast and quiet.

If you're looking at a mid-range setup, then putting two older cards in SLI is a poor choice compared to a single card solution. SLI was never meant as a real upgrade path, since one of the newer generation of cards inevitably outperforms two of the older generation. A single 7600GT or x1950 Pro would serve you well up to 1280x1024.

Don't forget to choose a high-quality power supply. You should stay away from any models below $50 as a rule of thumb. Brands like Corsair, Silverstone, and PC Power and Cooling are a few you might want to look at. The Corsair HX520 and HX620 have been getting rave reviews.
 
Thanks for that.

Forget to mention power. A friend of mine has a spare Antec true power 2 550w PSU that he is giving me which seemed a stable PSU to use. All the reviews Ive seen have been favourable.

The only reason I was going for the 7600GT is realistically with only £600 to spend I cant fork out more than £100 on the graphics card and afford all the other components. I figured that a 7600 would do me until i can save up the pennies to get myself a 8800GTX.

Nice to know that a single card solution is better than SLI mind. The reason for making sure SLI is available was to add further life to the PC. My last one has lasted me 5 years with careful investment.

The only issue I can see is that my monitor is a 22" CRT and so the graphics card would preferably need to support 1600 x 1200 as I will finally have the processing power to run that.

You should see the old P4 1.8 try and cope with 1600 x 1200 on Call of Duty 2. Its a sight to behold!

Are there massive advantages for going for the E6600 over the E6400? Baring in mind the price difference and the impact it will have on the other components that I can afford.
 
I would imagine an P965 Express chipset board being much cheaper than that nForce 680i. Since you're on a budget, a 680i is a rather poor choice if you don't have a huge LCD (greater than 22"). With a 20" CRT, the X1950Pro will serve you just fine, as well as a P5B-E instead of the P5N32-SLI. Save your money on the mobo, and go for the Gigabyte DS3 or P5B-E or Deluxe models... those will be much nicer on your budget and should fit your needs nicely. There isn't a whole lot of performance gain going from the 6400 to the 6600. The E6400 can clock as high as the E6600, but it just has a lower multiplier. A lower multiplier means you need a board that can push a nice FSB (which those boards I listed above could all do). The extra cache only improves performance by about 10% at most.

As for HDDs, I found the Seagate 7200.10 320GB to be alot faster than my WD2500KS. My KS does about 55MB/s while my Seagate does around 65MB/s (while my raptor does 78MB/s). I'd go for Seagates 7200.10 250GB model if I were looking for speed. The WD drives, however, are more quiet than the Seagate drives.
 
I was under the impression that for upgradeability (probs not a word) SLI was the way to go hence the major outlay on the mobo. Im not really worried about the other parts as Im sure in the next 12-18 months they will all be changed anyway.
 
If you ever plan to own a 22" or larger LCD, then yes, you would want SLI as an upgrade path. However, as Antimatter stated above, SLI isn't a great upgrade path if you're talking about buying one card now, then the same card later, when prices are lower. Chances are, later, you wont find any new cards of the same model, so you'll have to buy a used one. Even then, there will be a much better single card solution. I believe the optimal upgrade path would be to sell your old card to help offset the cost of a new, more powerful, single card solution. The cost of an nForce 680i SLI motherboard just isn't worth it unless you need to power a 22" (or larger) LCD at native res for gaming. In which case, you'll most likely be buying both vidcards at the same time instead of "upgrading to SLI later."
 
Well during the course of the year Im planning on getting myself either a 32" monitor (looking at dell and apple) or a LCD TV. Weighing up different options due to resolution, contrast ratio and available inputs so the ability to run my PC into this is going to be essential.

As for getting the low end card and finding another one later this wasnt the plan. Im getting the low end card to serve me until I can outlay for 2 8800GTX in SLI or whatever the top performer at this time is.

As before im looking to build a platform that I can expand on within the next 12-18 months however I have to buy now as the wife wants to get me an anniversary present.

Also selling the old graphics card isnt an option as its only an AGP 6600GT 128MB and as the machine basically isnt worth anything but runs perfectly fine (not bad for a 5-6 year old pc in all honesty) I was planning on turning it into a media centre and internet station so that my new games machine doesnt get clogged up with internet related crap, movies, MP3s etc.

My prime concerns are choosing the best motherboard and cpu combination as well as trying to save some pennies futher down the line where possible.

Assuming that the P5N32-E is the best mobo for me to go for, what RAM would be the best bet baring in mind my budget limitations. I was looking at 2GB possibly from the corsair value range?
 
In that case, you'll need an SLI board, hehe. What's your budget? and where will you be buying your parts from? The Corsair VS DDR2-667 sticks are pretty good for their price, but if you can find some G.Skill/GeiL/Patriot/OCZ DDR2-800 for around the same price, then go for those instead. If you do go with those VS sticks, here's the timings anandtech got for them:
$200 - CORSAIR ValueSelect 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2-667 VS2GBKIT667D2
CPU Ratio // Memory Speed // Best Memory Timings // Voltage
4:3 // DDR2-400 // 3-2-2-5 // 1.9V ..... 1:1 // DDR2-533 // 3-2-2-7 // 2.1V
4:5 // DDR2-667 // 3-3-3-8 // 2.1V ..... 2:3 // DDR2-800 // 4-3-3-8 // 2.2V

How far do you plan on pushing the CPU?
 
How far I push really depends on what I can do without killing the life of the PC. Whatever I buy now Im planning on making do with for the next 5 years.

Also as you can tell from the age of my PC that messing with PC innards isnt something ive done in a while so ill probably overclock on the side of caution rather than performance.

The parts are probably coming from a friend of mine who works as an IT contractor. He reckons he can buy parts for me at least 15% cheaper than I can get online. If that fails to come off some of the retailers I use include:

http://www.aria.co.uk
http://www.ebuyer.co.uk
http://www.scan.co.uk

Im planning on spending roughly £600 which is around $1156 that may seem like a reasonable amount but bare in mind the prices of buying on a tiny island and 17.5% Value Added Tax!

ps thanks for all the advice by the way :)
 
Sorry for the double post, I just wanted to say that my IT Contractor friend is giving me a list of components and prices for me to have a look at.

Ill post up the details on Monday morning. If people could share their opinions on them, that would be great.
 
Back
Top