Building a new computer for a recording rig

johnbegone

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
1,171
Hey guys, so I used to be way into hardware and built a few awesome gaming machines in my day, but the last day of that was about four years ago. At which point I decided to focus on music rather than computer engineering. But now it's come full circle, and I'm building a new computer for my studio (I'm still in college, so it's not a full on professional studio yet, but I'm going to start recording some bands in my house). The name of the game is for it to be fast (able to record a lot of tracks at once without dragging or dropping beats) and quiet. I still want a somewhat decent graphics card, because I enjoy gaming from time to time, and this computer will be used for other things as well, it's not an independent studio machine.

I'm thinking of the Antec P180 for the case, seems like its one of the quietest out there, plus they sell it at the Best Buy near me (I just started working there last week, so employee discount on it is pretty decent). And then I'm kind of open to suggestions after that, let me know if anyone has experience building a computer mainly for recording. I will likely be using ProTools. I don't need speakers or a monitor or a mouse or anything, just the machine. Thanks in advance to any help you guys can provide, I really appreciate it!
 
How long can you wait to put the system together? I'd recommend waiting until at least July 24, when Core 2 Duo will be released and both Intel and AMD slash prices on their CPUs. By that time, the prices for memory will likely drop also.
 
^^ wait before..

some questions

How much $$ do u have

What applications specifically do you plan to use.. ?


if you had to buy right now a dual socket / dual core opteron system with say 4G of ram min, a raid 0 array as a working drive with a raid 1 for saving data and an x1900 XT would do godo..., dual DVD burners for making your copies on the fly as needed.
 
I love the suggestions/questions on CPU power/memory for a recording rig, first off
rolleyes.gif
The current gen Ath64s handle it just fine, giving you the ability to run a couple of VSTs/etc easily with acceptable latency.

One of my friends built a rig geared for recording and shelled out a lot more for the recording components than the backbone. First and foremost, you'll need the proper I/O card. A Creative X-Fi isn't going to cut it...that's not designed for the type of recording you're gonna do. Most of the proper cards go from $200-$300, meet the M-Audio Delta 1010LT for example. Couple that with a copious amount of RAM (>= 1GB) and something in the mid-high range Athlon64 class, speedy HDD, and you'll be set to go. Also should note that many of those cards have certified drivers that'll couple nicely with the likes of Cubase, etc.

*EDIT*: WTF? A X1900? Dual Socket Opty's? Someone's VASTLY over-estimating the hardware needed for audio recording. Don't forget, digital audio recording didn't just magically start three or four years ago...it was being done on P2-400s with dedicated add-in cards and DSPs.
Min Sys. Reqs said:
Windows 98SE / Me / 2000 (SP4) / XP (SP1)
For 96kHz operation: Pentium III 500mHz w/ 128MB RAM
For 48kHz operation: Pentium II 400 w/ 64MB RAM
While hardly ideal, it proves that insane amounts of CPU power are not needed. Audio data is by nature, an entirely different subset of signal processing, and has different requirements than a machine designed for serious video work, for example.

Should also be noted that the linked card is fully compatible with ProTools, which OP stated he would be using.
 
i had thought if doing alot of mixing, if the case, more ram would be wanted to do real time mixing and the such and not have to wait... ?

i personally dont do any recording recently, just thinking back a few years in my early p4 days where things would chug using things like acid studio and such,
 
Thanks guys so much for the help thus far, good tips. I figure memory and processor speed will be important, but memory more so. I'm thinkin 2gigs to start with? As far as my time frame, I just want to finish it before the summer ends. Like I said, I'm working at best buy (in the geek squad) for the summer, so prices are decent for me. I don't have the money to do this now, I plan on buying the parts piece by piece every paycheck.

My goal is to definitely use ProTools, because my school's studio is strictly an analog studio (which is great, until I get out of college and everyone wants me to engineer with protools), but I was thinking about using a thing like a Firepod , it's got 8 preamps. Then I could use mutiples of those down the line to go up to say, 24 tracks. Right now I have a E-MU sound card which is pretty good for playback, but I might consider a better one as well.

So I really have lost touch mostly in motherboards, what are you guys thinking there?
And no one really addressed the volume issue with a case. It the Antec P180 going to be my best choice?

Thanks :)
 
Well, if your going to go intel - and dont plan to over clock get an intel board or a tyan / supermicro - pure stability in those

even for AMD, if you dont plan to overclock and just want stability look into Tyan's / SuperMicro / Iwill workstation boards
 
Yeah, your case choice isn't a problem, as long as you stick with an ATX form factor board. The P180 has 4 5.25 inch bays, so that should be enough for any bay ports things that might come with your stuff.
 
The P180 is one of the best cases (probably the best) out there to minimize noise. If you do get one, I'd try to get one that's of the newer revision.
 
i just upgraded from my system below (in sig), got a 3800+ Venice going to o/c on watercooling (fast and quiet), 2 gigs of pc3200 2-3-2. I run Cubase 3 sx and I use Emulator X 2 for sampling and what not, sound card is a Emu 1820m. The pic is my setup a few months ago, i have recently moved everything to a different area in my apartment..

brainc0de-100_0997.JPG
 
also my old setup of a m~ Barton o/ced was sufficient for everything I needed but as projects get more and more complicated I didn't want to run into future problems in the middle of things.. if you are going to do live recording mainly then i wouldn't stress at all, its when you are running multiple vsts with complex processes that a high end system would be needed, although having a fast system always helps everything.. but saving a few hundered on a proc and what not gives you more money for soundcard/equipment/programs, i spent 140 for my 3800 and that overclocked will be perfect for my needs..

i'll write more when i get home, concerning sounds issues with the case i can't really say, i do guitar/vocal recordings in my bedroom..
 
Hey, thanks man. It looks like you've got a pretty nice set up going on. I've got a dual 19" lcd setup right now, but I'm thinking about investing in a larger widescreen monitor. Not really out of necessity, but just for fun. Let me know any other suggestions you've got.
 
by the way, what studio monitors are you using? I am looking to buy some powered speakers that will be somewhat easy to transport in between here and our school's studio.

As far as the application of this computer, for now I will actually mainly be doing mixes on it. My school's studio is well equipped for tracking, but the only way to mix is to mix live (we have an analogy Angela II board with automation, but the automation is a little tedious), so I will be mostly mixing my projects at home. So that's why I want to take a set of near-fields in between so I have some reference. Our main monitors are Tannoy's with dual 15s. They're amazing needless to say.
 
johnbegone said:
by the way, what studio monitors are you using? I am looking to buy some powered speakers that will be somewhat easy to transport in between here and our school's studio.

As far as the application of this computer, for now I will actually mainly be doing mixes on it. My school's studio is well equipped for tracking, but the only way to mix is to mix live (we have an analogy Angela II board with automation, but the automation is a little tedious), so I will be mostly mixing my projects at home. So that's why I want to take a set of near-fields in between so I have some reference. Our main monitors are Tannoy's with dual 15s. They're amazing needless to say.


nice.. i run Alesis MK2's but you might want to ask some advice for monitors over at www.studio-central.com.. keep us posted on your progress .' /
 
OK, forgive me naivety once again, but I'm currently researching processors. Should I be considering the dual core route for my needs right now? If not, I've tentatively picked out the AMD Athlon 64 3700+, seems like a bargain all things considered. Someone mentioned that prices could be going down in late July, will the Athlon's dual core prices come down into a more manageable range for me (like maybe around $300-400 instead of 500-600).

Will dual core make that much of a difference?
 
johnbegone said:
OK, forgive me naivety once again, but I'm currently researching processors. Should I be considering the dual core route for my needs right now? If not, I've tentatively picked out the AMD Athlon 64 3700+, seems like a bargain all things considered. Someone mentioned that prices could be going down in late July, will the Athlon's dual core prices come down into a more manageable range for me (like maybe around $300-400 instead of 500-600).

Will dual core make that much of a difference?

yeah it should, for example i use Cubase 3 sx for sequencing and it makes use of dualcore (i'm pretty sure) but then i use Emulator x 2 for all my sound work and it doesn't make use of dual core. I do think though that a 3700 will be definitely sufficient! But if you aren't going to buy for another month i think the AM2 prices will drop, i didn't want to wait and am very content with my 3800+ Venice, still working on finding my max o/c but its awesome.
 
Back
Top