Building A Crash-Proof Internet

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Building a crash-proof internet? Is there really such a thing or is it just a pipe-dream lying at the bottom of the ocean waiting to be dug up by a boat anchor?

Eight years on, and events have proved otherwise. A series of catastrophic failures seems to suggest that the internet is rather more vulnerable to accidents, earthquakes or misplaced ships' anchors than people thought. At tens, perhaps hundreds, of places around the world, the net seems to be hanging by a thread.
 
This is going to lead into regulation and taxation of the net. I only see this getting bad from here.
 
Something that is electronic that is crash proof? Hmmm. Impossible I say. Even a light bulb burns out, and that is a very simple electronic device.
 
Article is full of phail.


It was not the routers which caused the large congestion, it was rather the small alternate pipes. When you have something such as the FLAG capacity go down, it's hard for the other already loaded pipes to maintain the request load.

Routers are not the problem and I'm pretty sure that most will object to a single piece of command software that can change its flow or alter the data flow. Not only that, but you will still have issues when your primary pipes are severed.


The real key here is path diversity. The failures in the past has shown budget cuts and lazyness, such as all the fiber communications using a single train tunnel.
 
well if you take topologies to make a local network, and we have wan.. you end up with mesh networks for fail safe options.

-basically alternate paths incase a node is down.

the global internet does this on a wider scale. we just need more fail safe options to rely on.

cut one cord, and we only have 1 cord then yes as humans we failed.

but if you have many cords and cut one cord, your ok... and we can make repairs.
 
This is going to lead into regulation and taxation of the net. I only see this getting bad from here.

MFT or QFT

Leave it alone and leave it free. If you don't, I will destroy you government, destroy you.
 
just because some knucklehead drags up some cables and the *outside* access/internet goes down for a few small countries, the INTERNET is not down.
 
I like how they title it "Crash Proof Internet", site how a major line being down causes all sorts of havoc, discuss a great new router setup, then they say it wouldnt work if a large cable or supply line went down....

I also like how one of their "catastrophes" was when a router screwed up and Czech Republic had slow internet for an hour. Oh my god, the horror, a while HOUR. Slow internet!!!! Thats torture by all rights if I ever saw it...

Personally, from my limited experience, I think going from a huge pipe to a more mesh system seems to be the easiest/best way? IDK, im not too up to date on my networking, etc, just IMHO.
 
internet down for an hour can reak havok on medical companies that are now required by law to do everything digitally and not on paper (or will be in 2009/2010 required by law).

you wouldn't want someone dieing because the internet is down or thousands of dollars gone because you didn't submit medicaid papers in time.
 
internet down for an hour can reak havok on medical companies that are now required by law to do everything digitally and not on paper (or will be in 2009/2010 required by law).

you wouldn't want someone dieing because the internet is down or thousands of dollars gone because you didn't submit medicaid papers in time.

IIRC the medical companies are locally connected, while they rely on the internet, they also rely more on local exchanges rather than national exchanges (EX. Beaumont hospital in Michigan won't need to get to Japan for information). So these scenarios would not materialize. Also, I have yet to see a hospital refuse patient care because they are unable technically to get a document because of downed communications.
 
The day US hospitals refuse people en masse cause the intenet is down, Ill burn all 8 of my PC's in my front yard. While they may be required to keep digital copies, Im sure its on a local basis. Anything offsite would be backups, etc. While I can see them needing WAN access, I doubt not having it would cripple them.
 
I still don't believe that was an accident with the anchor, 3 lines days apart; someone cut the internet to the middle east on purpose.
 
Just like that IP routing problem someone posted about in Networking and Security forum awhile back.

Someone (either it was a company or a little ISP, I don't remember) basically made a route change in their router for Google. Which resulted in the failure of many people worldwide to either reach Google.com at all, or experience very very slow links to it.

You'll never have something 100% stable unless there's a single controlling entity at the top. And as an above poster stated: taxes and regulations is all that would come of that.
 
One medium sized hospital having to reroute for 2 hours isnt quite what I was thinking when I spoke....:D
 
Back
Top