Budget card for WoW

TheGardenTool

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Mar 12, 2006
Messages
4,038
The new computer I'm building will only be used for a few things, and World of Warcraft is one. I'm wanting to get a 20" Widescreen LCD and run WoW using max settings at 1680x1050. What would be the best choice for that?

I don't even think I'll be playing too many other new games on the machine. Other uses will include school work, photo editing and maybe video editing.
 
I forgot where I had seen that review. Thank you very much.

So would those be the lowest-end cards to consider?
 
Yes. You have to shell out at least $300 for a decent widescreen 20" monitor...what's another $150 for proper video acceleration?

Anything less, and you will have to start turning off features. These aren't exactly "expensive" cards, you can buy an eVGA overclocked 7600 GT for $140 after MIR.

If you don't like rebates, you can probably find one for $150 or so if you shop around.
 
I third the 7600gt, I think they are usually cheaper than the x1800gto anyways.

MH
 
I have come up with a few more questions, mostly concerning last generation cards.

What is the difference between a 6800 XT and 6800 Ultra? If I remember correctly, the specs look about the same?

And now back to the specifics for WoW and other gaming:
How would a 6800 XT or Ultra compare to the 7600 GT or x1800GTO?
How would an x850XT compare to the newer cards?
How would the 6800s compare to the x850XT?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814150130
$132.99 with a $35 mail-in rebate. So it would save me about $40 bucks compared to the eVGA 7600 GT

Newegg also has a few open-boxed x850XT's starting at $116.99.

ATI.com has refurbished Crossfire editions for $139.99. That would give me the opition of Crossfire with a compatible motherboard for the same inital price as the eVGA 7600 GT.

This new build should not see too many current-gen and future-gen games. I mainly stick to games as old or older than WoW. I just want to be able to run those games with playable framerates with high or max settings at 1680 x 1020.

I bought an Xbox 360 to play new games and it cost me a lot less than a high-end PC. If I were to play newer games on my PC I would have no problem toning down the resolution or settings to make them playable as I do understand I'm wanting to build a system using yesterday's parts.
 
TheGardenTool said:
I have come up with a few more questions, mostly concerning last generation cards.

What is the difference between a 6800 XT and 6800 Ultra? If I remember correctly, the specs look about the same?

They are not. The XT is a cut-down version compared to the Ultra with only 8 pipelines. They are budget-priced in order to clear 6800 stock.

And now back to the specifics for WoW and other gaming:
How would a 6800 XT or Ultra compare to the 7600 GT or x1800GTO?

6800 XT: less than half the speed. 6800 Ultra is probably similar performance levels in WoW, but slightly slower in recent games.

How would an x850XT compare to the newer cards?

Similar performance to them, but the lack of PS 3.0 makes this a bad investment. Saving yourself 20 bucks now will mean you can't enjoy all the spiffy PS 3.0 games that are soon to be released (nor the ones that are already out).


How would the 6800s compare to the x850XT?

Slightly slower (Ultra), and MUCH slower (XT).

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814150130
$132.99 with a $35 mail-in rebate. So it would save me about $40 bucks compared to the eVGA 7600 GT

BAD deal. As you can plainly see from one of the comments on the front page, it barely beat a 6600 GT by %5. The 7600 GT, by contrast, is almost twice the speed of the 6600 GT.

Newegg also has a few open-boxed x850XT's starting at $116.99.

ATI.com has refurbished Crossfire editions for $139.99. That would give me the opition of Crossfire with a compatible motherboard for the same inital price as the eVGA 7600 GT.

If you want to take your chances with open-box items, and don't care about the fact that the tech in the x850 XT is SEVERLY outdated (not necessary for WoW, but will be a necessity for newer games)...sure. There's a reason these cards are priced to move...because they wouldn't move any other way.

I'm not seeing your logic about Crossfire, though. This is a new system build you're performing, so you could just as easily pick up an Nforce SLI chipset motherboard and get that 7600 GT, and give yourself an SLI upgrade path for the same price as a crossfire card.

This new build should not see too many current-gen and future-gen games. I mainly stick to games as old or older than WoW. I just want to be able to run those games with playable framerates with high or max settings at 1680 x 1020.

I bought an Xbox 360 to play new games and it cost me a lot less than a high-end PC. If I were to play newer games on my PC I would have no problem toning down the resolution or settings to make them playable as I do understand I'm wanting to build a system using yesterday's parts.

So, let me get this straight: you find scaling WoW so annoying that you've just gotta have a card that plays it in native resolution...but then again, you don't think you'll be bothered if you have to scale to a lower resolution to play other games.

This just doesn't make any sense. Either you're deluding yourself, or you're one cheap bastard.
 
You're right. I do not wish to waste money if I do not need to spend it. I'm building the system for more than just gaming, but I want the option to play older games that I cannot play on a console. None of the new PC-exclusive games interest me, nor do any of the ones coming soon.

The reason I brought up the older cards was to see if they would perform the needs I would require out of them. Those needs are to merely play WoW and other plays with high settings at a resolution of a monitor I'm buying shortly.

I guess the 7600GT is the best option. I was asking about Crossfire because the x850 series will drop in price faster than the 7600s will because they are older. It doesn't matter anymore because I discovered no mATX motherboards support Crossfire.

Thanks for the input and I'll keep my eyes open for a 7600GT.
 
Pretty convenient that this thread came up. Playing WoW at 1600x1200 usuallly means the frame rate is right around 10-15fps for me. I'm in the market for a replacement AGP card that costs under $250 and I'm not looking to overclock. This would replace my current Ti4200 and hopefully last a couple years through the iterations of CPU upgrades on my current motherboard. I've got a 2Ghz socket 939 AMD CPU and 1GB of memory on a K8T800 based motherboard.

The cards I am considering:

ATi
x800 XT
x850 Pro
x1600 Pro

nVidia
6800 XT
7600 GS

I've been out of the computer enthusiast loop for a couple years and spent the last couple days trying to play catch-up. For games like WoW and also RTS's like Age of Empires, I don't know which specifications are most important. I put a quick spreadsheet of data together based on the data from gpureview.com and prices on Newegg:
vidcards.jpg

I think I've narrowed my choices down to 2 cards, x800 XT and 6800XT. Both seem to represent opposite approaches. The x800 looks to have considerably higher fill rates and 16 pipelines but doesn't support SM3 and has "only" 256mb of memory. In contrast, the 6800 XT has much lower fill rates, and less pipelines but supports SM3 and 512mb of memory.

For slower paced (i.e. not an FPS) games it seems that the memory amount is pretty important, and that fill rate and memory bandwidth isn't as critical. How does the pipeline amount figure into this? Would 512mb be useless considering the rest of my PC specs? What about down the road where I may want to upgrade to a 2.8Ghz CPU and 1.5GB of system memory?
 
Of those two the x800 is the better one. (the 6800xt will be a dog, might as well run a Geforce 4)

The 7600GT would be so much better than either one though.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814143064&CMP=OTC-pr1c3watch&ATT=14-143-064

I realize it is $70 more, but it is worth it if you are wanting to run full res.

edit: amount of memory on a video card basically NEVER MATTERS.

edit: I see you are on AGP.. so forget the 7600GT, it is PCIe I have a 6600GT and it is faster than the 6800xt.. same number of cores, faster GPU clock.. if you must cheap out.. or consider the 7600GS.. not as good as the GT.. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814121020



==>Lazn
 
Lazn-

I presume your comments are directed towards me and if so, thanks for commenting. However, I don't think the 7600GT is available with an AGP interface and $70 is a boatload more to spend on just a video card. I could probably swing an extra $10, but at $70, I may as well buy a PCI Express motherboard and a new video card at the same time.

EDIT: I just saw your edit. Oops. Yes, AGP. The only 6600GT options I see are in 128mb versions. Your comment about how video memory never matters doesn't seem to match the reviews I've seen. Maybe I missed something.
 
actually, I would avoid the 7600gt. I before I put mine in SLI, I had issues running at that res. It wasn't BAD, but it would dip below 30fps constantly. I tried it last night with my sli setup and it worked great.. but 1 wasn't quite enough.
 
So two votes for the x800 XT. Is this due to the number of pipelines? Does the fact that it doesn't support SM3.0 matter? Why is 512mb not beneficial to my situation?
 
WaR-ped said:
So two votes for the x800 XT. Is this due to the number of pipelines? Does the fact that it doesn't support SM3.0 matter? Why is 512mb not beneficial to my situation?

Fill rates, operations/sec ect. Those are the actual performance numbers. Number of pipelines is like number of cyl in an engine, you can have a V8 that is slower than a turbo 4cyl, etc. So the actual HP rating is how much it can do.

As far as amount of video memory, if you set the textures to a high enough quality that it would use all that RAM, the card is not fast enough to display that at a reasonable speed.

Read this: http://www.pureoverclock.com/article33.html even with a 7800 it doesn't make any significant difference at medium or high quality, only at ultra quality, and with a x800 or 6800xt you will not be able to run Ultra quality no matter how much RAM your video card has.

==>Lazn
 
Ah ha! That makes good sense. So in that sense, the x850 Pro and x800 XT probably perform similarly(within about 10%?) despite the differences in pipeline numbers. It also looks like I may have a hard time finding a new x800 XT for under $250. But then it looks like it's fairly easy to find x850 Pro models for around $220.
 
x850XT PE (Well mines at 600/600) will play WoW without any dips below 45 at 1600x1200 4xFSAA 8xAF, I played WoW for a 2 weeks and didn't like it, but it never dropped below 45, even with what seemed like hundreds of players on screen.
 
WaR-ped said:
I wouldn't make a decision based on what you get from that chart....

As you can see from above posts, they are very misleading.

Sure it can help, but I would personally go by benchmarks of games you play.
 
WaR-ped said:
Ah ha! That makes good sense. So in that sense, the x850 Pro and x800 XT probably perform similarly(within about 10%?) despite the differences in pipeline numbers. It also looks like I may have a hard time finding a new x800 XT for under $250. But then it looks like it's fairly easy to find x850 Pro models for around $220.

Yep, it depends on what you are doing.. Notice the decrease in shader ops and texture fill rate, so those type of things will be slower on the 850, while raw pixel pumping power is very similar.

Really as said, find benchmarks for the games you play to know for sure.

The x850 would not be a bad choise at all.

==>Lazn
 
A friend uses x800XL to play on his 2405FPW at native res and is damn happy about it, tried convincing him a couple of times to buy something beefier but hes good, Ive seen it myself and looks great too.
 
Lazn-

Thanks for your patience. As you, and others have said in this thread (and I agree), benchmarks are key. Unfortunately I don't believe WoW offers a benchmark program so I haven't come across any site offering relevant data. So I've tried to find benchmarks for games that play similarly. Obviously a game like Doom 3 is wrong, but maybe something like Oblivion would be closer?

In what sorts of games would Texture Fille Rate and Shader Operations be critical and which games would it not matter as much? I'd guess these features would be most important in an FPS, but I could be wrong. Maybe resolution also matters? I.E. A slower paced game at 1600x1200 versus an fast paced game at like 1280x1024.

Would it be relevant to include the fact that I hope to pick up a 20" widescreen monitor in the next 6 months?
 
WaR-ped said:
Lazn-

Thanks for your patience. As you, and others have said in this thread (and I agree), benchmarks are key. Unfortunately I don't believe WoW offers a benchmark program so I haven't come across any site offering relevant data. So I've tried to find benchmarks for games that play similarly. Obviously a game like Doom 3 is wrong, but maybe something like Oblivion would be closer?

In what sorts of games would Texture Fille Rate and Shader Operations be critical and which games would it not matter as much? I'd guess these features would be most important in an FPS, but I could be wrong. Maybe resolution also matters? I.E. A slower paced game at 1600x1200 versus an fast paced game at like 1280x1024.

Would it be relevant to include the fact that I hope to pick up a 20" widescreen monitor in the next 6 months?

Hmm, well you can always use FRAPS to benchmark any game. Here is an article on WoW performance considerations: http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2381

As far as what games use what.. I am not sure anymore.. Last game I played intensivly was Neverwinter nights.. Any my 6600GT handles that just fine. lol.. Actually it plays even Farcry and HL2 decently.. no HDR of course.

==>Lazn
 
That's a tough call. I just found out (thanks Froogle!) that CompUSA is selling the X800 XT for $199. If the local store has one in stock, it seems like the price : performance at that price point would be hard to beat for just about any AGP card on the market right now.

As far as the specs go, it's interesting to see that the differences in ratings for the 7800 GS versus the X800 XT. It looks like the ATi card has the upper hand on Shader Operations and Texture Fill Rate, but the nVidia card has a higher memory frequency, higher memory bandwidth, and more pipelines.
 
Review: http://techreport.com/reviews/2006q1/geforce-7800gs/index.x?pg=3
3DMark's synthetic fill rate tests illustrate the problem, especially the multitexturing test. The Radeon X800 XT PE, like the Radeon X850 XT, has gobs of texturing capacity thanks to its very high clock speeds. The 7800 GS OC can't keep up in terms of pure fill rate.

Texturing Capacity. Relevant to RPGs and RTS'?

From the same article:
Guild Wars' simpler lighting favors the Radeon X800 XT PE's strengths over the 7800 GS OC's.

I'd imagine the performance in Guild Wars would be pretty close to World of Warcraft, right?
 
Back
Top