Budget build ($500) Intel vs. AMD

AlexisBV

n00b
Joined
Jul 7, 2007
Messages
30
Hello all,

I'm helping my dad to select parts for a new PC, and his budget for CPU+Mobo+RAM is about $500. There will be no gaming, just "regular" windows stuff, however he does want DVI-out. Snooping around I came up with a few preliminary configs (all prices in CAN $):

Option1: Budget AMD

CPU: X2 6000+ $185
Mobo: Asus M2A-VM (microATX...) $69
RAM: Corsair 2x1Gb DDR800 5-5-5-12 $95 (after $30MIR)
No GPU required (integrated graphics and DVI-out on mobo)

Total with 6% tax: $370


Option2: Budget Intel

CPU: C2D4400 $160
Mobo: Intel DG33FB $115
RAM: Corsair 2x1Gb DDR800 5-5-5-12 $95 (after $30MIR)
GPU: MSI NX7100GS-TD128 with DVI $40

Total with 6% tax: $435


I've never built a microATX system before which is why I have absolutely no idea if the Asus config for the AMD makes any sense for a regular-sized case. Any inputs? If it would work, I'd of course consider the same thing for the intel config...

Thanks!
 
If you are not going to overclock. Im sure that 6000+ will be a better performer then the 4400. Also im sure you can find a cheaper matx board the intel.
Thanks
 
Hmm the AMD setup is looking good so far. I forgot to mention the prices are in canadian dollars (and will be shipped to canada). I don't think that OC'ing will be in the picture.
 

... all prices in CAN $):

Last I checked, Newegg doesn't ship to Canada.


I'd stick with the AMD setup. Here's an alternative board, good for a HTPC system, in case he wants to use it for viewing HD movies or anything like that:
$95 - BIOSTAR TForce TF7050-M2 Socket AM2 NVIDIA GeForce 7050PV Micro ATX
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but do you really need an X2 6000+ for "regular Windows stuff?" I'd drop the budget to under $400 if he's not planning on doing anything intensive on it, using an X2 3600+ Brisbane or something instead.
 
I don't have plans for PSUs yet, just something small and cheap (as in affordable, not flimsy). In other words, nothing fancy (modular, etc), just reliable. As for an X2 3600+, it's $100 cheaper, but even with the 6000+ it's well under his budget (still $130 to go), and the idea being to get the best possible config for the target price. The AMD config needs no GPUs, so I'm guesstimating max 400W, with one HD and one DVD burner (the drives he already has, so that doesn't go into the budget)
 
So, could you list all the parts you have that you will be re-using and replacing, then stating which part you replacing them with?
 
New parts are all those listed previously, plus PSU.

To avoid all the annoying scrolling around, here it is again:

target price: ~$500 (canadian)

CPU
Mobo
RAM (2Gb)
GPU (only if Mobo doesn't have integrated graphics with DVI-out)
PSU

The only hitch I see with the AMD config so far is that the AM2 socket means it's the end of the line for future cpu upgrades.
Old parts:

HD
DVD burner
Case
Monitor (19" LCD)
Speakers, mouse, etc
 
The only hitch I see with the AMD config so far is that the AM2 socket means it's the end of the line for future cpu upgrades.

Why? All the new CPUs AMD plans on releasing will all be compatible with AM2. They kept the power requirement the same for the socket, and just expanded on it. So, AM2+ and AM3 CPUs will all work in AM2 mobos... at least thats their plan.

Ok, so your option 1 looks good.
 
AM2 isnt dead yet and their next line will work in the Am2 socket i recall hearing, along with DDR3 since the memory controller is built into the cpu.


www.pccanada.com

no GPU intel

Code:
Checkout 
 
  Intel® Core™2 Duo E4300, 1.80-GHz @ 800Mhz w/ 2Mb Cache (Socket 775) (Retail Box) w/ Heat Sink & Fan {Invis:7035} $139.99  x    $139.99 
  Seasonic® S12-430 430W ATX12V v.2.0 Power Supply (Retail Box) {Invis:5383}   *Special Order* $94.99  x    $94.99 
  Asus® P5GC-MX, Socket 775, Intel® 945GC Chipset w/ PCI Express x16 (mATX) {Invis:7581} $79.99  x    $79.99 
  Corsair™ 2Gb PC5400 XMS2 DDR2 TwinX Matched Pair Series (TWIN2X2048-5400C4) {Invis:6142} $99.99  x    $99.99 
    
SubTotal:  $414.96  

GST (6%) / HST: (14%) $24.89  
PST (8%):  $33.19  
 
  Total:  $473.04


sure you could lower that PSU and get a decent $100 vid card.
 
over budget by $41 CAD :( so amd may be a better option.


Code:
Checkout 
 
  Intel® Core™2 Duo E4300, 1.80-GHz @ 800Mhz w/ 2Mb Cache (Socket 775) (Retail Box) w/ Heat Sink & Fan {Invis:7035} $139.99  x    $139.99 

  Asus® P5GC-MX, Socket 775, Intel® 945GC Chipset w/ PCI Express x16 (mATX) {Invis:7581} $79.99  x    $79.99 

  Corsair™ 2Gb PC5400 XMS2 DDR2 TwinX Matched Pair Series (TWIN2X2048-5400C4) {Invis:6142} $99.99  x    $99.99 

  Thermaltake® PurePower™ TR2 430W ATX 12V v.20 Power Supply (Retail Box) {Invis:6737}   *Special Order* $44.99  x    $44.99 

  BFG Tech GeForce™ 8500 GT - GeForce™ 8500 GPU w/256Mb DDR2 & PCI Express x16 Retail Box {Invis:7566} $109.99  x    $109.99 
    
SubTotal:  $474.95  
Please enter your postal code to calculate preliminary shipping fee:      
GST (6%) / HST: (14%) $28.49  
PST (8%):  $37.99  
 
  Total:  $541.43
 
AMD bild, i dont know much about AMD mobo's, but also not sure what taxes you have where you are. this is ontario %14.

Code:
Checkout 
 
  AMD® Athlon™ 64 - 3800 (Socket AM2) [Orleans Core] Retail Box w/ Heatsink and Fan {Invis:5858} $79.99  x    $79.99 

  Thermaltake® PurePower™ TR2 430W ATX 12V v.20 Power Supply (Retail Box) {Invis:6737}   *Special Order* $44.99  x    $44.99 

  BFG Tech GeForce™ 8500 GT - GeForce™ 8500 GPU w/256Mb DDR2 & PCI Express x16 Retail Box {Invis:7566} $109.99  x    $109.99 

  Asus® M2N, Socket AM2, NVIDIA® nForce® 430 MCP Chipset w/ PCI Express x16 (ATX) {Invis:6472} $89.99  x    $89.99 

  Corsair™ 2Gb PC5400 XMS2 DDR2 TwinX Matched Pair Series (TWIN2X2048-5400C4) {Invis:6142} $99.99  x    $99.99 
    
SubTotal:  $424.95  

GST (6%) / HST: (14%) $25.49  
PST (8%):  $33.99  
 
  Total:  $484.43
 
Happy to hear about some hope for the AM2 family...

thanks for the tips MrGuvernment, I'll look into them. Although any GPU better than a Geforce2MX is already overkill for stuff like solitaire :D which is as hardcore gaming as my dad's going to get.

On the other hand, he really does want to use his DVI-capable monitor and cables (quite an investment back in the day), so a DVI-out is a must. He does some pretty intensive ms office stuff though (huge files), and a bit of photoshopping, so RAM and cpu upgrades are warranted (it's an old rig).

I'm in Montreal, so total taxes here would be about 14% as well, but if I order from directcanada I only have to pay the 6% federal tax, and I believe shipping is free over a certain amount)

$45 for that PSU seems pretty good!
 
Looks very good! However I would consider the 3600 Brisbane, or 3800 Windsor 65 watt, to save a hundred or so. I have the Asus M2A-VM with 3800X2 and it does every thing very well and very fast for me. I don't game, with the exception of freecell :)

You may also want to consider the Enlight case with the 350 watt PSU made by Delta, more than enough power for what you're doing. But hey, if you can afford the extra for the 6000X2 then by all means do it.
 
Back
Top