BTX Style Boards?

BTX is a redesigned motherboard form factor that optimizes component placement for better heat management. as of now, i have not heard of any plans to incorporate this into any intel motherboards, and i know that AMD will not use it for a while. i would guess that BTX mobos would be different sizes and would incorporate different dimnsions for things like mounting holes, header placement etc., which would require modification of current or the purchase of a new case.
 
Case design and power design are also different. Current ATX cases will not work with BTX boards but newer BTX cases could be backwards compatible from what I've seen.
 
Anandtech has articles here and here.

The Inquirer has some more articles also that say the mobo makers are very unhappy, big surprise. Also AMD has no plans for BTX at this time. Short story, don't worry about BTX yet, unless you're a die hard Intel fanboy.
 
I would not worry about the upgrade being a "must" for at least a year. Boards will trickle in Q4.
 
I believe the intel website has a whole section to why BTX is better than ATX.. it seems like the main reason is, air can get pushed through the system faster.. Intel claims that even hardcore systems can be cooled well with just two case fans.
 
BTX is the poorest excuse for a form factor I've ever seen. Even (Baby)AT and NLX boards are more practical, not only in terms of leaving room for optimization (too many things are defined in the spec), but especially in terms of thermal management. Having the air drawn from outside the case pass over the CPU (the hottest part of the case) first, and then use this air to 'cool' (if you can still call it that) the RAM, NB, voltage regulator circuits, expansions cards (GPU!), etc. is absolutely horrible. The CPU's heat should be removed from the system (case) as quickly as possible, something ATX can do, but BTX can not.

As an example of over-defining placement of components, look at Opteron and Athlon64 systems which can not be fit on BTX boards, because the RAM slots can not be placed in the optimal position, since other components would be in the way.

In other words, if BTX ever arrives (perhaps in OEM systems?), it'll most likely be Intel-exclusive, and perform very poorly compared to ATX systems (too many design contrains with BTX).

BTX is dead. Long live ATX ;)
 
From AnandTech: "At the Fall 2003 Intel Developer Forum, Intel officially branded Big Water as the Balanced Technology eXtended form factor - or BTX for short."

No doubt Intel thought of the acronym BTX (gee, I wonder how they arrived at that?) first, and then found the words to fit. It's the same logic we always joked about for USB. I always pictured a bunch of programmers sitting around a table brainstorming, with one of them saying "Hey, I got an idea, let's call it the B-U-S bus!" I wouldn't be surprised if they would've gone along with that if the suits wouldn't have their asses for it, and rearranged the letters to USB instead and thought of Universal Serial Bus after. I guess USB has a better ring to it than SBU or UBS....
 
Elledan said:
BTX is the poorest excuse for a form factor I've ever seen. Even (Baby)AT and NLX boards are more practical, not only in terms of leaving room for optimization (too many things are defined in the spec), but especially in terms of thermal management. Having the air drawn from outside the case pass over the CPU (the hottest part of the case) first, and then use this air to 'cool' (if you can still call it that) the RAM, NB, voltage regulator circuits, expansions cards (GPU!), etc. is absolutely horrible. The CPU's heat should be removed from the system (case) as quickly as possible, something ATX can do, but BTX can not.

As an example of over-defining placement of components, look at Opteron and Athlon64 systems which can not be fit on BTX boards, because the RAM slots can not be placed in the optimal position, since other components would be in the way.

In other words, if BTX ever arrives (perhaps in OEM systems?), it'll most likely be Intel-exclusive, and perform very poorly compared to ATX systems (too many design contrains with BTX).

BTX is dead. Long live ATX ;)

There was nothing on earth practical about AT. As far as BTX's thermal design, it makes tons of sense. The air comes in through the front of the machine and goes directly over the CPU and goes out the exhaust vent. What's more practical than that? It keeps fresh air moving through. Colder air is always comming in and hot air is moving out. .

The BTX form factor specifications also define the font of the processors thermal solution as being clear from obstructions thus improving air flow. The design is supposed to be better than any current ATX case and uses only 2 120mm fans. I'd say that's improvment all around.

That being said I don't like the motherboard being accessed on the right side of the case instead of the left. That pisses me off. It's like working on a damn Mac.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
That being said I don't like the motherboard being accessed on the right side of the case instead of the left. That pisses me off. It's like working on a damn Mac.

Yeah I don't like it either, but the change in motherboard orientation isn't just random, it has a thermal basis for the design behind it also. With BTX the heat-producing components on the graphics / PCI cards are now facing UP as opposed to DOWN as with ATX. Since heat rises this means the heat goes straight off the card into the air stream instead of heat-soaking the PCB board and rest of components on the card. This should result in vastly improved cooling of peripheral cards and thus increased lifespan.

I don't like BTX since it means change from the long-established ATX standard and obsolescing of all our current cases. But as we all know change is the only constant with computers. We always embrace the newest CPUs, mobos, and video card and so on. This time everything is changing at once.

On a thermal basis BTX is a hell of a lot better than ATX, but IMO that's all it for. Those one-kilo heatsinks and accompanying support structure are what's really going to suck. No more Lan Party for some folks. Then again with Intel ditching the P4 in favor of the P-M maybe they just might ditch BTX also, but I doubt it.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
There was nothing on earth practical about AT.
AT wasn't so bad, as long as you didn't want to use those 1-meter long expansion cards, as the CPU would be in the way in many cases. Other than that it's more similar to ATX than one might think (just download the ATX 2.03 spec or earlier. It has a nice comparison of AT and ATX in it).
As far as BTX's thermal design, it makes tons of sense. The air comes in through the front of the machine and goes directly over the CPU and goes out the exhaust vent. What's more practical than that? It keeps fresh air moving through. Colder air is always comming in and hot air is moving out. .
You clearly lack the in-depth understanding of the thermal absorption properties of air to see why BTX is the best way to shorten the lifespan of your system's components.

Air absorbs more thermal energy the larger the difference in degrees between itself and the surface it comes into contact with. Further, air absorbs less thermal energy the warmer it becomes. It does not absorb thermal energy in a linear manner.

For this reason you want to move the airflow first over the colder components, and only at the end over the hottest components. Furnaces follow this principle, to name just one example, as this way the thermal absorption properties of air used in the most efficient manner, i.e. as much thermal energy is removed from the system by the air.

ATX is very close to being ideal in this regard, as it places the hottest components near the exhaust fans (voltage regulator circuits, NB, GPU, CPU).

The BTX form factor specifications also define the font of the processors thermal solution as being clear from obstructions thus improving air flow. The design is supposed to be better than any current ATX case and uses only 2 120mm fans. I'd say that's improvment all around.
In a decently build ATX system there don't have to be any significant obstacles obstructing airflow, especially not after the introduction of SATA. The same system also requires no more than three fans (PSU, HSF, exhaust) for sufficient airflow.

That being said I don't like the motherboard being accessed on the right side of the case instead of the left. That pisses me off. It's like working on a damn Mac.
And just what is wrong with Macs?
 
Elledan said:
AT wasn't so bad, as long as you didn't want to use those 1-meter long expansion cards, as the CPU would be in the way in many cases. Other than that it's more similar to ATX than one might think (just download the ATX 2.03 spec or earlier. It has a nice comparison of AT and ATX in it).

You clearly lack the in-depth understanding of the thermal absorption properties of air to see why BTX is the best way to shorten the lifespan of your system's components.

Air absorbs more thermal energy the larger the difference in degrees between itself and the surface it comes into contact with. Further, air absorbs less thermal energy the warmer it becomes. It does not absorb thermal energy in a linear manner.

For this reason you want to move the airflow first over the colder components, and only at the end over the hottest components. Furnaces follow this principle, to name just one example, as this way the thermal absorption properties of air used in the most efficient manner, i.e. as much thermal energy is removed from the system by the air.

ATX is very close to being ideal in this regard, as it places the hottest components near the exhaust fans (voltage regulator circuits, NB, GPU, CPU).


In a decently build ATX system there don't have to be any significant obstacles obstructing airflow, especially not after the introduction of SATA. The same system also requires no more than three fans (PSU, HSF, exhaust) for sufficient airflow.


And just what is wrong with Macs?

I think that the people designing BTX probably have a better understanding of electronics and thermal considerations including air flow than you likely do. This is why YOU are not designing it. It's harsh but the designers and engineers behind this stuff are usually smarter than us. Sometimes cost cuts down what an engineer can do in a given situation, but generally a move like this is done for a reason. And that reason is thermal constraints of the current ATX design.

Also from doing work with AC's in the aircondioning industry I know that pulling colder air in is better than just taking heated air out for cooling. If you want to test this. try sitting in front of a fan in a hot room and then seeing how it cools you. Next try putting that fan behind you and sitting in front of it. Tell me which is better.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
I think that the people designing BTX probably have a better understanding of electronics and thermal considerations including air flow than you likely do. This is why YOU are not designing it. It's harsh but the designers and engineers behind this stuff are usually smarter than us. Sometimes cost cuts down what an engineer can do in a given situation, but generally a move like this is done for a reason. And that reason is thermal constraints of the current ATX design.
I provided some of the underlying principles of aircooling, which might suggest that I've done at least some research. Also, if you feel that any part of my posts is wrong, you're more than welcome to say so, and specify what you disagree with, and why (references would be nice). I prefer that to being called an ignorant person (not with these exact words, but close).

Also from doing work with AC's in the aircondioning industry I know that pulling colder air in is better than just taking heated air out for cooling. If you want to test this. try sitting in front of a fan in a hot room and then seeing how it cools you. Next try putting that fan behind you and sitting in front of it. Tell me which is better.
How in the world does this disprove anything I said? I described what is commonly known to be the best way to get as much thermal energy out of a given system using air alone, while keeping every single component within thermal limits. That's what one attempts to do when cooling a system, right?
 
My only point was is the fact that moving colder air across an item vs. simply taking it away is more efficient.

The air removal with very little air intake design of ATX is inferior to the higher/colder air intake of BTX with close to or equal removal. BTX seems logical to me. I never meant to call anyone ignorant.

I can see the bennifit of BTX's cooling. It makes sense to me. I don't like the idea of changing cases and even accessing my case from the opposite side. That sucks in my opinion.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
I think that the people designing BTX probably have a better understanding of electronics and thermal considerations including air flow than you likely do. This is why YOU are not designing it. It's harsh but the designers and engineers behind this stuff are usually smarter than us. Sometimes cost cuts down what an engineer can do in a given situation, but generally a move like this is done for a reason. And that reason is thermal constraints of the current ATX design.

Also from doing work with AC's in the aircondioning industry I know that pulling colder air in is better than just taking heated air out for cooling. If you want to test this. try sitting in front of a fan in a hot room and then seeing how it cools you. Next try putting that fan behind you and sitting in front of it. Tell me which is better.

Just because an engineer comes up with an idea does not mean its better than the last design decision.
Im sure some very smart people came up with rambus. And the many sockets which last months, and are immediately eclipsed by something better.

AMD processors produce ruffly the same amount of heat as p4's. Ruffly. Yet AMD has no major BTX plans. Or, at least no immediate btx plans. Thats going by what ive read.

The benefits of the btx Case spec, cant be much better than completely removing the entire motherboard from the case. Yet even that only accounts for a small drop, depending on how well the case was ventilated to begin with.

However, Intel may need it, since from what i hear the new chips are gonna be hot. So maybe that extra couple degrees celcius is going to really matter.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
My only point was is the fact that moving colder air across an item vs. simply taking it away is more efficient.
Wha...?! Do you realize how silly that sounds?

With every system out there, be it AT, NLX, WLX, ATX, BTX or some other obscure form factor, airflow is established through the entire case. Unless it's watercooled, of course. Or you cool using lots of heatpipes, as with that Zalman case. How in the world can you "simply take away" air from within a case, without automatically causing cold air to be drawn inside the case?

Airflow is airflow. It either sucks (har, har) or not, and with ATX good airflow is relatively easy to establish, as long as you know what you're doing (ever taken a look at OEM systems?).

The air removal with very little air intake design of ATX is inferior to the higher/colder air intake of BTX with close to or equal removal. BTX seems logical to me. I never meant to call anyone ignorant.
What is this '"very little air intake design of ATX" you're talking about? I never read about it in the spec, or anywhere else for that matter. Here I was, foolishly thinking that implementing the optimal cooling solution was left as an exercise by the ATX spec to the one putting the system together.

I can see the bennifit of BTX's cooling. It makes sense to me. I don't like the idea of changing cases and even accessing my case from the opposite side. That sucks in my opinion.
I can see that BTX thermal solution offers no benefits over ATX whatsoever. That is will only increase case temperature, and shorten the lifespan of all components excluding the CPU by attempting to cool them with air that was first heated by the CPU (do the math: a Prescott P4 @ 103 Watt load; what will it do to your precious cold air?).

I've got an overview of the thermal gradients inside a working BTX system in front of me right now, and just one look is enough to conclude the following:

- the RAM gets a lot of warm air blown over it.
- the expansion cards (excluding the GPU!) are almost completely isolated from the airflow. In other words, don't try putting a videocard in that place without any ducting or other measures.
- there's nearly zero airflow over the HDDs. This is bad, especially with Raptor-style 10k RPM IDE HDDs becoming more common (and think about the SCSI frea^H^H^H^Hpeople!).

ATX has none of those problems.
 
Back
Top