Broadband Internet Definition Changed

I'm just pissed because with my "broadband" service, I'm only getting ~550Mbs down and ~480Mbs up. If I'm paying $59.00 a month for an asymmetrical Gb package, shouldn't I be getting at least 75% of that? :)

I'm sure you are, you lucky, smug sonofabitch! ;) Sigh...
 

Ah, that is kind of what I was looking for, but their data is a bit bias. Since it is only based on speed tests that have been performed on their site.

Kind of surprised that our average is that high, but after looking around on the map more it seems like unless you live in a major city your speeds are quite a bit lower. Comparing NY, it shows around 20 for Buffalo/Rochester but then 40+ for all the tags in NYC.

Looking at something that more then just people that are running speed tests for, like Akamai that serves up data, the average connection speeds are much lower.

http://www.akamai.com/stateoftheinternet/soti-visualizations.html
 
Maybe now Centurylink will give me more than 900kb up on my 26mb down connection.
 
1GB Fiber up/down here in Seattle through Centurylink. Upgraded from Comcast 100 down/20 up a few weeks ago. The sucky part is that I might be moving back east to be closer to my family later this year if my mom's cancer comes back....then it is back to Comcast. :-(
 
While I'm glad they increased the definition, they should probably do it more regularly in smaller increments.
 
Haha guess my parents don't count at all.. I tested there dsl the other day because they wanted to stream on netflix and hulu with there new smart TV.. They get 1.2 down and .3 up. I called to see what they should be getting it was 3 down and 1 up. Asked what the highest speed they could get was ... 6 down and 1 up. Tech came out said they were to far off the road and they couldn't get 6. Which is BS lol .. Tried to get them to switch to TWC but they don't want to give up there home phone for a digital phone. grrr
 
Haha guess my parents don't count at all.. I tested there dsl the other day because they wanted to stream on netflix and hulu with there new smart TV.. They get 1.2 down and .3 up. I called to see what they should be getting it was 3 down and 1 up. Asked what the highest speed they could get was ... 6 down and 1 up. Tech came out said they were to far off the road and they couldn't get 6. Which is BS lol .. Tried to get them to switch to TWC but they don't want to give up there home phone for a digital phone. grrr

My mom went through something along the same lines with her Verizon DSL. She had always used her internet for email and to lightly surf the web. It served her well for years. Then she got into Facebook and Netflix. She literally tore me apart because I am the one that told her to get DSL 14 years ago where she lives, lol. I just said to her "Mom, you're shit out of luck, get comcast."
 
Ah, that is kind of what I was looking for, but their data is a bit bias. Since it is only based on speed tests that have been performed on their site.

It also has the issue of what server people choose to test. Some ISPs don't have much backhaul so speeds to them and their network is good, but to the rest of the Internet it isn't so great. In some places it is to the point you are more like on a giant WAN. Sure you get a "100mbit" connection or whatever but as a practical matter it is 20mbit to most of the net.

So you'll see people post impressive speedtest results to a server that is <5 miles away and is clearly on their ISP. The real test is to something farther away and off network.
 
In Malaysia, anything faster than 64kbps is broadband.
 
Broadband should also have a qualifier of: No data caps!
 
Lawsuits by Comcast, Verizon and AT&T in 3...2...1...
 
lets face it, for netflix especially 4k content, 20-25mbps dl/ul will be needed ..... so under the old definition of broadband that would not have been possible, which would in mind call into question why on earth anything that cannot support this medium of online entertainment be called broadband lelz...

that said, using 10mbps dl/ul ftth for gaming, torrent and regular usage seems quite adequate for me, except for the 4k netflix example mentioned.
 
In Malaysia, anything faster than 64kbps is broadband.

yeah but everyone knows the mcmc and it's other governmental bodies are corrupted and hadn't been serving the public interests in a long time now ... which is why the broadband standard definition is so low .... because then isps aren't held to account despite being protected as monopolies to prevent competition which would had led to cheaper and better broadband for the masses.

that said, broadband in Malaysia has improved compared to years back when adsl copper was the only viable option. but prices are still unfair due to the monopolies/oligopolies in the broadband sector in the country ...
 
120/12 here... Still qualifies.

Good thing that there is actual competition here.
 
My 10/768K DSL is alright for my needs,but it would be nice to have faster options available. Local cableco only offers 3 megs,I wish they would get their crap together.
 
Bwah hahaha, I can already hear the cable provider CEO's and stock holders crying out in rage from here.
 
Lawsuits by Comcast, Verizon and AT&T in 3...2...1...

Against what? FCC is the government, and they regulate what is and isn't broadband.

Don't want to provide broadband? Don't list your packages as broadband if they don't meet those speeds. That simple.
 
While I'm glad they increased the definition, they should probably do it more regularly in smaller increments.

Google, the kings of knowing where internet traffic goes and how its used, says the infrastructure for the states is far more than capable, ISP's just have american's in a strangle hold over speed and prices.

Considering every city Google gets near that offers Gigabit internet, suddenly all cable customers in the are get a "Free upgrade" to 50/2 is enough proof of that.

When you're a monopoly, you can snow the consumer all you want cause they don't know any better.
 
Comcast pushed for this because their only competitors are competing technologies and small niche upstarts. DSL has roll-off problems, so even with new technologies that will beat cable hands down if you're close, at any range you will have consumers below 25, so they won't be able to use the term 'broadband' which isn't used much now, but will be soon as cable beats them with it in advertizing. The alternative is to not offer service outside of the 25 Mb boundary and lose customer base to roll out the new technologies.
 
I am more curious, how many websites and other sites that %99 of people use, even saturate a 10Mb line..

i have 10Mb/2Mb in Costa Rica and things load fast and fine.. i can stream amazon prime fine as well..

So 25Mbps seems a bit...high..

If you had more users streaming concurrently you would want a faster connection.(you could also improve the quality of streams if the average connection was faster) It would allow for large digital download of programs and improve upload speeds The goal is likely two fold. To increase investment (to obtain the right to market services as broadband).(which seems to be a increasingly unpopular term) Secondly for legal definition and likely legislation issues. It also helps with labeling the market and pushing back against mergers due to their status as being the only "real broadband" provider in most areas.
 
Correction, the US average of people who go to Speedtest.net is 32.6. i.e. a lot of people pushing sub-10Mbps connections probably test once if that, where as those who want to swing around and show off their mighty e-Penis with their new 100Mbps connection, or fiber connection probably test every other day... because why not you got fast internet!

Yep, that's why I like the Akamai numbers better. They act as the edge servers for so many Major web sites including Verizon, Microsoft, Apple, The US Treasury, BBC, NPR...
http://www.akamai.com/html/customers/customer_list.html

They get a massive sample of regular traffic statistics that something like Speedtest, steam or the like just can't match. The world average connection speed doesn't even come close to 25Mb.
 
In my experience talking with people they keep saying.."Less Gov Regulation, more Capitalist Competition"......

Here is my problems with this whole ordeal, for starters all this does is simply change an effective marketing term they may be able to use. Grant it, their are probably effects that go beyond what we know like tax breaks if they reach the broadband quota and certain civil access points benefits.

For the most part they all run monopolies, price fixed(almost reminds me of flat panel price fixing) when they do have competition and have very little incentive to do upgrades on the infrastructure in return pocketing the money.

Pocketing money for shareholders, I have seen numerous times from many companies. Instead of making proper profits and reporting them, they abuse the industry they represent and simply degrade the company running it into the ground, cheap labor practices, broken equipment, degrading services. These companies basically are doing it for that mighty imaginary number called "Stock" that because of these practices is worthless, at one time the stock market may have been a good thing, now companies rely on accountants pretending to be analysts to abuse the stock numbers making it pointless.

Sorry for the last one but I had to get it out of the way as it leads to the point.

Which is? We need Gov Reg, but only to any given point, to stop monopolies and abuses. We need a capitalist system with a competitive market to push services forward and make them better while making prices plummet but that needs to be within a fair market, which the Gov should ensure happens, instead lobbying and pak funds have made buying a politician the most effective investment. This is a straight corruption of the system, the Capitalist market was never ever supposed to influence the Democratic political machine, well it has, and then we go from Democracy to a sort of Aristocracy or more known as an Oligarchy, the rich and companies influence Political agendas and the Gov. thus making it no longer concerned over the People but instead only catering to the smallest denominator.

You simply can't correct the market, with out correcting the Gov. simply put we need a Title II put on these companies, and we need them regulated. When their is no competition the state should be entitled and responsible for adding its own services in order to compete( at the monopolistic parties involved), or hell I would pay the military to support them while they offer a decently priced service to us.

Is there potential for abuse? Well there always will be. Something needs to change.
 
Does anyone know when this will actually take effect?

Last time they made a change it took about 2 years to go into effect

However it means nothing and won't effect you in any way even when it does go into effect.
 
In my experience talking with people they keep saying.."Less Gov Regulation, more Capitalist Competition"......

Here is my problems with this whole ordeal, for starters all this does is simply change an effective marketing term they may be able to use. Grant it, their are probably effects that go beyond what we know like tax breaks if they reach the broadband quota and certain civil access points benefits.

For the most part they all run monopolies, price fixed(almost reminds me of flat panel price fixing) when they do have competition and have very little incentive to do upgrades on the infrastructure in return pocketing the money.

Pocketing money for shareholders, I have seen numerous times from many companies. Instead of making proper profits and reporting them, they abuse the industry they represent and simply degrade the company running it into the ground, cheap labor practices, broken equipment, degrading services. These companies basically are doing it for that mighty imaginary number called "Stock" that because of these practices is worthless, at one time the stock market may have been a good thing, now companies rely on accountants pretending to be analysts to abuse the stock numbers making it pointless.

Sorry for the last one but I had to get it out of the way as it leads to the point.

Which is? We need Gov Reg, but only to any given point, to stop monopolies and abuses. We need a capitalist system with a competitive market to push services forward and make them better while making prices plummet but that needs to be within a fair market, which the Gov should ensure happens, instead lobbying and pak funds have made buying a politician the most effective investment. This is a straight corruption of the system, the Capitalist market was never ever supposed to influence the Democratic political machine, well it has, and then we go from Democracy to a sort of Aristocracy or more known as an Oligarchy, the rich and companies influence Political agendas and the Gov. thus making it no longer concerned over the People but instead only catering to the smallest denominator.

You simply can't correct the market, with out correcting the Gov. simply put we need a Title II put on these companies, and we need them regulated. When their is no competition the state should be entitled and responsible for adding its own services in order to compete( at the monopolistic parties involved), or hell I would pay the military to support them while they offer a decently priced service to us.

Is there potential for abuse? Well there always will be. Something needs to change.

Some ISP (ILECS) are regulated, those are the ones with the higher prices because of it because the regulations set the prices so high
 
I for one am glad they did this. I know it won't change a lot overnight, but it is a step in the right direction.
 
Some ISP (ILECS) are regulated, those are the ones with the higher prices because of it because the regulations set the prices so high

Uhm, that isn't regulation. ILCES makes them comply with current Federal/State laws, ie Child laws, and such. There is no higher price by making a corp. follow Federal and State laws, its what they call the cost of doing business in any country, even then by your logic the EU that has 50x stricter standards than us should pay 50x more, but they simply don't in fact, in about 60% of cases they pay less and have more bandwidth. They have more regulation and more capitalistic options. Internet, phone(cell/landline) and cable we pay more for less in the US, and in most cases we invented the crap.

This is like Ford selling a Mustang and even though we are in the "Home" of where the company resides we pay more for the product than foreign nations do. Funny I can go to Germany and buy a Mercedes for a lot cheaper have it imported and still save a quarter(in some rare cases half) of the price and that is their home country. Glad Musk with Tesla wants to change things, and in his quest is shaping new laws and regulations to work with the market rather than against it. As we all should know the car industry is just as bad if not 10x worse than ISP companies.
 
The FCC should kick providers square in the nuts by stating Broadband and/or high speed data service is now defined as:

1. At least 30 Mbps download for home/business service and 2 Mbps for wireless/mobile.
2. At least 6 Mbps upload for home/business and 0.4 Mbps for wireless/mobile.
3. Unlimited data with no caps, throttling, or penalties of any kind for any type of provider or service, regardless of where the customer resides or uses the service, including roaming.
 
So if they arent broadband service is that the second part of the internet not under FCC control?
 
Never made sense to me how a static word can have a moving target definition. Why don't they do something like the phone industry and call it 3G, 4G speeds. All that will happen from here out is the cable cos will CTRL-H broadband, high speed internet. Have a good laugh and call it a day. Personally I think they just need to get rid of all of these silly definitions and force them to advertise minimum sustained updload and download 99% of a month. No more boost shit.
 
Those are pretty high speeds.

I find this BS (since I had 10mbps for 10 years or so and it was fine) but if it gets providers to provide faster speeds, well then who am I to complain?
 
Those are pretty high speeds.

I find this BS (since I had 10mbps for 10 years or so and it was fine) but if it gets providers to provide faster speeds, well then who am I to complain?

As more and more services have moved to the "cloud" our dependence on high-speed Internet service has grown. 10Mbps has been available for a decade or more and is still a significant boost over 56k or the lower 1.5 - 3Mbps DSL plans. The problem is that the technology has grown to a point where today's 10Mbps Internet service can be sluggish depending on what you're doing with it, but there has been little incentive for most ISPs to increase speeds further, even with the technology advancing. As literally everything moves to a cloud-based model (streaming audio/video, e-mail, file storage, data backups) it will take more bandwidth to accommodate all of those services simultaneously without perceivable slowdowns.

tl;dr - as we use the Interwebs for more stuff, we need faster Interwebs
 
Uhm, that isn't regulation. ILCES makes them comply with current Federal/State laws, ie Child laws, and such. There is no higher price by making a corp. follow Federal and State laws, its what they call the cost of doing business in any country, even then by your logic the EU that has 50x stricter standards than us should pay 50x more, but they simply don't in fact, in about 60% of cases they pay less and have more bandwidth. They have more regulation and more capitalistic options. Internet, phone(cell/landline) and cable we pay more for less in the US, and in most cases we invented the crap.

This is like Ford selling a Mustang and even though we are in the "Home" of where the company resides we pay more for the product than foreign nations do. Funny I can go to Germany and buy a Mercedes for a lot cheaper have it imported and still save a quarter(in some rare cases half) of the price and that is their home country. Glad Musk with Tesla wants to change things, and in his quest is shaping new laws and regulations to work with the market rather than against it. As we all should know the car industry is just as bad if not 10x worse than ISP companies.

I am not referring to the cost of doing business, but the actually prices that they are told to charge. For example if you get phone service from Comcast, Vonage or any CLEC they can charge you $1 if they want and that is fine. Of course they would probably want to at least charge enough to cover the 911 fees but they could sell you the service at a loss if they wanted. An ILEC on the other hand due to regulations are told that local phone service for a residence has to be priced no less than $X amount and businesses must be charged more at the rate of $Y. There are similar things in place for internet speeds. Rules state that customers given certain speeds must be charged at least a certain rate, which is higher than the rates that a CLEC would charge the customers for the same speeds.

That said there is no max that they can charge, only a min. And nothing is said about where money has to be spent.
 
Back
Top