Once upon a time, I was the person responsible for a multiple DS3 backbone when the biggest Tier1 link in the country was UUNet's OC3 through Denver.
Sure, once you get the lines laid, it's easy. Okay. Now get the lines laid against NIMBY, construction permits, and your capital budgets. One of the reasons I wanted to get in bed with Williams Energy so bad back then, was because they had Right Of Way on damned near every railroad from Maine to California.
This attitude of "oh the switch can do it so it's easy" drives me absolutely nuts. So what if the switch can do it, if you can't deliver it? And frankly, you can't. ONS or not, there's virtually zero chance they're going to drop effective 50/125 - effective 62.5/150 if you're really really lucky. If you're running effective 62.5/150 even to your edge, that's gonna limit you to 2.5Gbit effective (~OC3) per link to POP, with your POPs at a 1:1 to COs. You start giving everybody and their brother a DS3+ as a PPP link, you start banging on your CPUs much harder, and you start pushing your oversold ratio past the already ridiculous 10:1 "acceptable" (ProTip: it's NOT acceptable any more, 5:1 is more realistic.)
This is before you account for your peering overselling, which has gotten to the point where I am seeing some with total aggregate peering to customer ratios of over 25:1.
The end result at this point, is that on this path we are going to end up with AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast becoming full Tier1's with SprintLink, Level3, etcetera getting turned into marginalized Tier2's - likely with some being bought out by the new Tier1's - and Tier3 flat out disappearing. In other words, 99.9% of the internet traffic in the US will pass through AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast - quite literally. They will be the sole major transit providers, enabling them to dictate terms to every ISP in the country.
And it makes me laugh so much when people say "oh, they can't, because that's not how the Internet works." Actually, it is - SprintLink can dictate terms to me on a DS3, like "no spamming, no resale, average utilization over 50% makes your bill go up" easily. There's nothing to stop them from saying "no torrents, you can only use 10% average of the line you pay for, and all your customer modems must be blue" once they're carrying the traffic.
Sure, once you get the lines laid, it's easy. Okay. Now get the lines laid against NIMBY, construction permits, and your capital budgets. One of the reasons I wanted to get in bed with Williams Energy so bad back then, was because they had Right Of Way on damned near every railroad from Maine to California.
This attitude of "oh the switch can do it so it's easy" drives me absolutely nuts. So what if the switch can do it, if you can't deliver it? And frankly, you can't. ONS or not, there's virtually zero chance they're going to drop effective 50/125 - effective 62.5/150 if you're really really lucky. If you're running effective 62.5/150 even to your edge, that's gonna limit you to 2.5Gbit effective (~OC3) per link to POP, with your POPs at a 1:1 to COs. You start giving everybody and their brother a DS3+ as a PPP link, you start banging on your CPUs much harder, and you start pushing your oversold ratio past the already ridiculous 10:1 "acceptable" (ProTip: it's NOT acceptable any more, 5:1 is more realistic.)
This is before you account for your peering overselling, which has gotten to the point where I am seeing some with total aggregate peering to customer ratios of over 25:1.
The end result at this point, is that on this path we are going to end up with AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast becoming full Tier1's with SprintLink, Level3, etcetera getting turned into marginalized Tier2's - likely with some being bought out by the new Tier1's - and Tier3 flat out disappearing. In other words, 99.9% of the internet traffic in the US will pass through AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast - quite literally. They will be the sole major transit providers, enabling them to dictate terms to every ISP in the country.
And it makes me laugh so much when people say "oh, they can't, because that's not how the Internet works." Actually, it is - SprintLink can dictate terms to me on a DS3, like "no spamming, no resale, average utilization over 50% makes your bill go up" easily. There's nothing to stop them from saying "no torrents, you can only use 10% average of the line you pay for, and all your customer modems must be blue" once they're carrying the traffic.
