Broadband Future: Pay More for Less

Once upon a time, I was the person responsible for a multiple DS3 backbone when the biggest Tier1 link in the country was UUNet's OC3 through Denver.

Sure, once you get the lines laid, it's easy. Okay. Now get the lines laid against NIMBY, construction permits, and your capital budgets. One of the reasons I wanted to get in bed with Williams Energy so bad back then, was because they had Right Of Way on damned near every railroad from Maine to California.

This attitude of "oh the switch can do it so it's easy" drives me absolutely nuts. So what if the switch can do it, if you can't deliver it? And frankly, you can't. ONS or not, there's virtually zero chance they're going to drop effective 50/125 - effective 62.5/150 if you're really really lucky. If you're running effective 62.5/150 even to your edge, that's gonna limit you to 2.5Gbit effective (~OC3) per link to POP, with your POPs at a 1:1 to COs. You start giving everybody and their brother a DS3+ as a PPP link, you start banging on your CPUs much harder, and you start pushing your oversold ratio past the already ridiculous 10:1 "acceptable" (ProTip: it's NOT acceptable any more, 5:1 is more realistic.)
This is before you account for your peering overselling, which has gotten to the point where I am seeing some with total aggregate peering to customer ratios of over 25:1.

The end result at this point, is that on this path we are going to end up with AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast becoming full Tier1's with SprintLink, Level3, etcetera getting turned into marginalized Tier2's - likely with some being bought out by the new Tier1's - and Tier3 flat out disappearing. In other words, 99.9% of the internet traffic in the US will pass through AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast - quite literally. They will be the sole major transit providers, enabling them to dictate terms to every ISP in the country.
And it makes me laugh so much when people say "oh, they can't, because that's not how the Internet works." Actually, it is - SprintLink can dictate terms to me on a DS3, like "no spamming, no resale, average utilization over 50% makes your bill go up" easily. There's nothing to stop them from saying "no torrents, you can only use 10% average of the line you pay for, and all your customer modems must be blue" once they're carrying the traffic.
 
thats when government will have to step in with 'net neutrality' and force the companies to play nice.

.......... sorry if i gave you a heart-attack with that joke....
 
does verizon hold the sole ownership of fiber optic internet technology? Not that I have any issues with verizon, i have been praising fios since it came out (yay for being one of the first cities). But to help speed up the switch to real internet service, could smaller companies get going in some of those remote towns.

also, i hear people bitch about the net backbones. My understanding of networking is that as demand grows we should be able to grow the backbones, i mean its not like we found this shit underground, we can build more of them. It costs money yes, but i think companies need to realize that a one time significant investment will pay off in the future, i don't get why people are so short sighted like that.
 
EndersGame: Thanks for the info, I'll pass it on to my friend.

One question though, is there any way/where to get information about rollout plans to new neighborhoods?
 
I hear nothing but good things for FIOS, which is why I hope they'll come in the next 2 years. As of now I'm going to have to take it up the bum hole with Comcast business $60/month on 6/1Mbps. It does burn a little to have to spend extra $20 for unlimited bandwidth over Comcast residential, but hey... the service has been solid for me and hopefully they won't change that over the next coming years.

I do hope Obama looks into this issue!
 
EndersGame: Thanks for the info, I'll pass it on to my friend.

One question though, is there any way/where to get information about rollout plans to new neighborhoods?


Unfortunatly due to the 1996 Telecommunications Act the growth is limited to cities / areas where permission is granted by the local municipalities. You would be amazed how many local providers provide funding and support to local schools or build football stadiums etc.. for high school teams etc.. and where the price of that funding is too deny permission to outside companies wanting access. Of course everyone plays that game.

Fios rollouts as soon as they are negotiated are released via webcast to there respective news outlets etc... current coverage areas are always expanded with NJ getting good focus and NY at the momment by years end. The goal is at least another 500 thousand house holds.
 
Once upon a time, I was the person responsible for a multiple DS3 backbone when the biggest Tier1 link in the country was UUNet's OC3 through Denver.

Sure, once you get the lines laid, it's easy. Okay. Now get the lines laid against NIMBY, construction permits, and your capital budgets. One of the reasons I wanted to get in bed with Williams Energy so bad back then, was because they had Right Of Way on damned near every railroad from Maine to California.

This attitude of "oh the switch can do it so it's easy" drives me absolutely nuts. So what if the switch can do it, if you can't deliver it? And frankly, you can't. ONS or not, there's virtually zero chance they're going to drop effective 50/125 - effective 62.5/150 if you're really really lucky. If you're running effective 62.5/150 even to your edge, that's gonna limit you to 2.5Gbit effective (~OC3) per link to POP, with your POPs at a 1:1 to COs. You start giving everybody and their brother a DS3+ as a PPP link, you start banging on your CPUs much harder, and you start pushing your oversold ratio past the already ridiculous 10:1 "acceptable" (ProTip: it's NOT acceptable any more, 5:1 is more realistic.)
This is before you account for your peering overselling, which has gotten to the point where I am seeing some with total aggregate peering to customer ratios of over 25:1.

The end result at this point, is that on this path we are going to end up with AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast becoming full Tier1's with SprintLink, Level3, etcetera getting turned into marginalized Tier2's - likely with some being bought out by the new Tier1's - and Tier3 flat out disappearing. In other words, 99.9% of the internet traffic in the US will pass through AT&T, Verizon, Time Warner, and Comcast - quite literally. They will be the sole major transit providers, enabling them to dictate terms to every ISP in the country.
And it makes me laugh so much when people say "oh, they can't, because that's not how the Internet works." Actually, it is - SprintLink can dictate terms to me on a DS3, like "no spamming, no resale, average utilization over 50% makes your bill go up" easily. There's nothing to stop them from saying "no torrents, you can only use 10% average of the line you pay for, and all your customer modems must be blue" once they're carrying the traffic.


I cannot argue with a single point you have made, you are exactly right... that cpu utilization is always the deciding factor vs backplane bandwidth. Especially when you involve any form of filter sets or use any form of dynamic route distribution. Which is why all hardware has at least double if not tripple redunancys with backplane redundancy activated as well, if cpu utilization increases we can cross failover traffic too other backplanes too compensate. We actually can acomplish that via clever tricks of fiber bridging and multimode, channel redistribution to different segments. But you are entirely correct in your assesment and you are correct in your assesment about the convergence of tier providers and assimilation of lower providers, its the natural course of the game and its how these billions and billions of dollars in hardware and fiberrollouts are justified to the shareholders.
 
The Business Fail Train is boarding on this thread now. All posters aboard the Business Fail Train.

It works like this: ISPs buy bandwidth from SOMEONE ELSE then sell to users. They depend on users not using their connection 24/7 fully saturated. If that is not the case then the ISP loses money.

Try this, indignant users: ping a national backbone provider and ask for the cost for a 24/7 link to your home at your current speed. Then discount it a little bit. That is about what your ISP pays for you if you saturate your connection 24/7.

There ain't no such thing as a free lunch folks.

I'm all for metered use, personally. Why should I subsidize the torrent porn junkie/pirate/etc next door?

Queue whiny arguments:

1) Whaaaaa, in overpopulated Asian country they have 100mbps for $30 a month! Whaaaa! Yeah? And if the USA were the size of California, had an insane population density and a single government run telco maybe it would too. Learn to read a map, newb.

2) Whaaaaa, I run BT 24/7 because all (movies||games||music) (suck||cost too much||(suck && cost too much)). Yeah? Obviously they don't suck enough to stop you from wasting bandwidth leeching them.

ISPs will charge what the market will bear. They are not a charity. The good news is when Comcast and Verizon FiOS go head to head in a community things are good for users. That is hapening where I live. Times are good.
 
I live in Tennessee where this is no Verizon FIOS currently. However, I am on a ISP similar to fios. Fiber optic cable is ran to the home. However, even though there is a HUGE potential for speed, the highest package is only 12mbps down, 256kbps up @ $60 a month. It pisses me off so bad. I am on the 4mbps package at $40 a month with 256kbps up. Every one of the packages is 256kbps up and it totally sucks. The only time they raise their speed is if another local ISP (which on are coaxial) raise their speed. I say it is down right pitiful that the only way a fiber optic ISP will raise its speed is if a coaxial based ISP raises its speed.

The problem the ISPs don't realize is that a large difference in UL and DL speeds causes retransmissions and dropped frames from the clients not being able to answer fast enough. Upload should be no less than a third of the download speed. I have cox's low speed service (1.5/256k) and it's almost unusable with VPN. I use a Verizon USB stick for my work VPN.
 
This discussion is full of win just from the various technical insider info from you guys that actually worked it. Thanks for sharing!
 
So can I get back pay for my bandwidth being capped ever since, oh, I don't know, the beginning of broadband's existence? Where ever were my 5mb/s download speeds? I never, NEVER - not a single time - EVER(!) have hit even close to the speeds that any of my ISP's have advertised.

NEVER.

It's not your ISP's fault that website a/b/c cant upload data to you at your advertised rate, just as it's not Ferrari's fault that you cant drive 200mph on your local highway. I have used 3 different ISP's in my region and 5 across the nation, and I was easily able to peak their advertised rates depending where I was downloading from. Apple, Nvidia, Ati etc etc provide huge amounts of upload bandwidth and were great ways to test my download rates. If you're downloading some bunk from a low end web server located in Russia guess what, you probably wont be maxing out your connection rates from such a poor host.

By the way I hope you didnt expect to see 5 megabytes/sec in your IE download box when you signed up for 5mb/sec broadband.
 
Another fine reason to GTFO of this country.

FUCK NO. its a reason to fight for who you are. FUCK these corporations, stick it to them every chance you get. FUCK THEM IN THE ASS not the other way around. you think cut and running will help you? it helps THEM. corporate domination in america is the fastest way to achieve global domination, they must be STOPPED HERE. THIS IS YOUR COUNTRY NOT THEIRS.
 
I'm all for metered use, personally. Why should I subsidize the torrent porn junkie/pirate/etc next door?
.

your not, they are paying for their own service, so they should suddenly be punished because they choose to use it and you don't... :rolleyes: get over yourself. They pay for an advertised service like anyone else and should be able to use it 24/7 as they see fit, since they pay for their usage, just like you! They were promised a fast connection, unlimited speeds! share photos and videos with friends and family!

Mm, you know what since you barely use your service, lets lower your speeds, you don't it.

i can see some clashing coming up with all these places getting into HD content delivery, and ISP capping monthly limits... ISP need to change with the times.
 
FUCK NO. its a reason to fight for who you are. FUCK these corporations, stick it to them every chance you get. FUCK THEM IN THE ASS not the other way around. you think cut and running will help you? it helps THEM. corporate domination in america is the fastest way to achieve global domination, they must be STOPPED HERE. THIS IS YOUR COUNTRY NOT THEIRS.

grest so go do something... this has been going on for how long.. and just not comcast got nailed by the FCC and the result, now comcast just openly admits they havea 250G limit, nothing went back to the customer, i didnt see any refunds to customers cause comcast was throttling traffic and denying it, basically right out lying to it's customers and fucking them over....

These companies have so much money, they can make any problem go away easily enough as comcast did with the FCC.
 
Forgive me if this has been mentioned but I just got some news in the mail today and thought I'd share, ran through and didn't see anyone had mentioned it yet(Could have missed it though).

Anyways, I just received a letter from Time Warner today informing me that rates will be going up across the board in Central New York(first time in over five years, it states). Raises are going up from the current $45.99 to $49.99 for standard speed customers and $29.99 up to $34.99 for roadrunner lite customers. Promotional periods will continue of course. I still get 10 megs down and 1 meg up for $30 a month until May...:rolleyes: I guess it's do.:(


Actual speeds may vary.
 
Stop your fucking whining :p

My Dorm room internet is limited to 80kb/s for external access... This is like, cable internet in 1997.
 
thats called move the fuck out speed. and take a shit in the coms closet on the way out.
 
ISPs have slowed over the past 15 years or so. I remember I had a 10 Mbps connection with @Home ten years ago, and I only paid about 40 bucks a month.
 
Back
Top