Broadband Future: Pay More for Less

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
GigaOM has an interesting piece about the sad trend that broadband providers are exploring: tiered broadband services. Frontier and Time Warner have been testing these for a while but AT&T joined the bandwagon this week with their own tests in NV. Looks like the end of the all-you-can-eat bandwidth buffet may be sooner rather than later.

“Carriers are all seeing a fundamental growth in traffic, and very few of them are seeing the equivalent growth in subscriber acquisition, so they’re spending billions more on bandwidth capacity but are seeing no new revenue,” Dobbins says. “This is an answer to how they will grow revenue.”
 
I hate this so much. Speeds are still as crappy as ever and then they want to throttle and cap internet usage. What the hell!?!! When will people wake up to see how far behind the US broadband is compared to other countries.
 
I hate this so much. Speeds are still as crappy as ever and then they want to throttle and cap internet usage. What the hell!?!! When will people wake up to see how far behind the US broadband is compared to other countries.

Once FIOS spreads out more, then the other companies will wake up. Hopefully more will take on something similar to FIOS,
 
its simple business, it has nothing to do with how much bandwith is out there (they can always add more of that)

you see, you get people hooked first. 10mbs/unlimited is a good start. then, you roll out the teir-system- however, instead of keeping the same package as now and offering slower, cheaper alternatives as you think they would, they add those cheaper services at the same price as your paying now, and tack on a high premium for the full service version. *COUGH COUGH* windows vista ultimate retail, anyone?*COUGH COUGH*
 
I am an example of the extreme but if at&t brings that crap to Chicago i will stop using broadband and go back to getting my information from magazines/newspapers/television. Broadband for me is not the be all end all of my life.
 
This is a interesting article. However, as a WISP (Wireless ISP) among other things, the simple fact is that broadband providers bank on over subscription. This is that we would take 10 meg and sell 6 10 meg accounts. This is as basic as you can get. With more and more business models counting on cheap bandwidth (NETFLIX with Microsoft), I can see how this usage changes.

Traditionally, internet access is burst traffic. Web pages, e-mails, even downloads (typically anyways) are very busty. That means you can fit more customers into the same bandwidth cause not everyone uses it at the same time. P2P users are really bad, cause of the constant usage.

I use the internet for business needs all the time, reloading computer, etc, and I don't use more than 20 gig of transfer in a month. But with other applications, again I am going to the NetFlix and XBox360 model, being able to suck up part or your entire pipe for hours on end is going to change this model. You just can't supply it and be feed your family.

Dennis - Linktechs.net
 
our torrents are being capped here in toronto

negates the aspect of BROADBAND when it's limited to 30KB/s doesn't it... :mad:
 
Im wondering what the hell they are gonna be charging as far as the Tiers goes, Its all gonna be a big piece of Shit as far as im concerned just another way for us users to take it in the Ass.
 
So can I get back pay for my bandwidth being capped ever since, oh, I don't know, the beginning of broadband's existence? Where ever were my 5mb/s download speeds? I never, NEVER - not a single time - EVER(!) have hit even close to the speeds that any of my ISP's have advertised.

NEVER.
 
..meanwhile in Sweden and many other countries with better IT infrastructure and nicer telecoms businesses, people get to pay less for more (up until the economical crisis hit anyway).

I do miss the time before peer to peer crap. That sucks up a lot of traffic on all fat pipes worldwide.
 
Along the lines of what a poster above said, there is still a good chance that what we are seeing in this news is the complaining from a dying industry.

Verizon and its FIOS service is continuing to expand bandwidth. I just got a bump in speed from 15 to 20 down at the same price. Meanwhile, Comcast is bitching about not having enough bandwidth to serve everyone and is putting in more and more restrictions.

IMHO the endgame comes when services like Netflix begin to offer on-demand 1080p streaming movies. The services that have the bandwidth to offer it, like FIOS, will explode in popularity and the services that can not will begin to die.

As video media continues to grow in size in spite of compression, Comcast's bandwidth limit would be downright EASY to hit if you watched several streaming 1080p movies in a month. No one in their right mind will pay the overage fees which means the momet a competing service like FIOS becomes available in the same area almost everyone will switch.

The same scenario will happen as we reach a point where webcams and video calls all reach high def quality. It's going to require bandwidth. And 100GB of bandwith that seems like so much today will be pathetic in five years.
 
Sorry for taking up two posts but I had another point.

My FIOS connection is already so fast that even if I were to turn into a total P2P junkie, I could fill up several 1TB hard disks in a very short time. At that point, affordability of storage would slow down my usage again. I'd be out of space and therefore would use less bandwidth.

So the OTHER solution is to make sure that broadband tech is so fast no one can really make use of it all. That's the best possible solution.

Hell, Verizon has been throwing around rumors of going to 100-200MB download speeds in the next couple of years. Obviously they aren't out of bandwidth.
 
Advil: Do you also have FIOS tv service? If yes, how many HD channels can you get before you've maxed your bandwidth out or are suffering from increased compression rates? A friend of a friend of mine bought and canceled the service in the baltimore area a month or two after it first came out because at the time ATT wasn't providing enough bandwidth to watch 2 HD channels at once.
 
I work for one of the TOP5 or so ISPs and I can tell you we're not even investigating a tiered system right. Our big package is 20/10Mb and you get every bit of it. Mainly we've implemented 10 GigE networking across the board and are moving everything to that to conserve bandwidth. Once we can get everyone off TDM which is gonna happen one way or another, and we move over to Digital in 2009 we'll be just fine bandwidth wise. Mainly what we are seeking is to keep pushing higher available Bandwidth as the new standards come out. It'll be easy fighting the competition because theres nothing more annoying than having your bandwidth dropping to dialup mid way through the month and seeing your neighbor with a full Gigabit pipe all month long.
 
Welcome to Australia with capped speeds. Although, I dont exactly understand what the situation is in the US: is speed and usage already capped? I have a combined phone and internet bundle, and get unlimited calls to anyone anywhere and 20GB of 20Mbps (I think cable can go faster than that) cable internet each month for $99AUD (about $66USD). It is impossible to get an unlimited service in Australia - there is always a download limit. How is that compared to the US?
 
I live in Tennessee where this is no Verizon FIOS currently. However, I am on a ISP similar to fios. Fiber optic cable is ran to the home. However, even though there is a HUGE potential for speed, the highest package is only 12mbps down, 256kbps up @ $60 a month. It pisses me off so bad. I am on the 4mbps package at $40 a month with 256kbps up. Every one of the packages is 256kbps up and it totally sucks. The only time they raise their speed is if another local ISP (which on are coaxial) raise their speed. I say it is down right pitiful that the only way a fiber optic ISP will raise its speed is if a coaxial based ISP raises its speed.
 
I believe the ISP's should be able to charge what they want and how they want.
BUT ONLY IN A SITUATION WHERE A MONOPOLY OR DUOPOLY DO NOT EXIST.
When there is not a monopoly or duopoly in place, the free market generally takes care of itself so long as everyone plays by the rules. Unfortunately, that is not the case in most places outside of the largest cities in the US. In some cases, even in the largest cities you have the choice of one Cable, one DSL, or a craptastic satellite service.
I am all for a flat per gigabyte, or tiered pricing schemes. But we need some competition to keep prices in check.
 
Most wired internet in the US is uncapped (or at least advertised as such), although they may have a shadowcap to hit the heaviest users in locations where thier capacity is maxed. A few months ago comcast (biggest cable ISP) annouced they were going to replace their shadowcap with a 250GB/mo cap. During the discussion of it here it was pointed out that the average cap set by smaller providers who explicitly had one was typically an order of magnitude slower, and that the current average (not sure if mean or median) user only consumed 2-3GB/month; obviously if/when streaming HD takes off that number is going to soar.

I'm in a small city in the country and I pay ~$40ish/mo for 5/512 cable, with the $60 premium package being 8/512 (this'll probably be my upgrade level next year). ABB and verizon generally match each others service rates fairly closely, but with verizon supposedly starting to roll out FIOS in the area I don't know what's going to happen. (I've seen FIOS signs in a local boxmart, but am not finding any local hits when googling for availability. I never talked with the store people becuase I know my area's not a priority for rollout.)
 
My relatives in Russia get double the speeds I get for about $7. I get my internet for $30.
 
I live in Reno, NV. I was actually thinking of switching to their full bundle w/ satellite service and all since it's cheaper. Now, no way in hell is that going to happen. Sticking w/ Charter cable now.
 
AT&T's started deploying packet rate throttles on resold ATM in quite a few areas now, to boot. Step 1) Eliminate competition that offers unmetered, untiered Internet service by throttling customers. Step 2) Switch customers to AT&T. Step 3) Cap throttle and meter customers.

Never thought I'd go back to cable, but can't be worse than the round after round of arguing with AT&T. They claim it's my line, then claim my line is clean and say they "do not use TCP RST filtering" in the same breath. Exact words; nevermind that's not what I'm asking.
 
I do not have the FIOS tv service, but do know several people who do. Based on my understanding of how the system works I don't know how you could be "limited" in the number of HD channels you can watch. Each receiver is doing the decoding. Although becuase of the costs involved in having more than one HD receiver with FIOS I do not know anyone currently trying to do this.
 
Meh

It is a shame because a lot of other countries like Japan are so ahead of the curve....

The US just gets what is left over...
 
Seems little no choice these days. Its all about the almight dollar and what you can charge to the hilt for offering so little.
 
I don't know if FIOS will ever get out this far. I just recently moved, and had to move to a substandard cable provider. My old cable provider is a few blocks away service wise.

I hate this monopoly shit. My speeds are crap now, and I'm paying more. I wish FIOS was here.
 
I don't know if FIOS will ever get out this far. I just recently moved, and had to move to a substandard cable provider. My old cable provider is a few blocks away service wise.

I hate this monopoly shit. My speeds are crap now, and I'm paying more. I wish FIOS was here.

sooo true! When I first moved out here (somewhere in the bay area), I used ATT Yahool DSL; speed was 1.5mbps, then after four years, I dropped ATT and jumped onto Comcast 3mbps for $42 (discount from having reg cable service). After 5 years, I dropped Comcast and jumped onto ATT ($36, cheaper faster uploading speeds, nearly same dling speed, plus free wifi usage @ Starbuck's and MCD). I am still waiting for verizon FIOS. After I jumped ship from Comcast...I heard the news of the cap which is totally stupid.

Comeon Verizon FIOS! :D
 
FIOS doesn't change anything. They still have to have the backbone to support everyone. Like mentioned above, most ISPs operate in the same manor as a bank. A bank doesn't have everyone's money as they loan some of it out. So if everyone trired to take their money out of a bank, that bank would not have the money on hand to give it to everyone. Same goes for internet. ISPs do not pay to have enough bandwidth to supply every customer the max possible connecton at the same time. They assume a certain percent and look at usage to decide what they need. It doesn't matter if you have 1MB or 50MB, they aren't going to be wasting money.

Problem is that more and more people are geting online and using more bandwidth so the companies are stuck at a point of either upgrading their backbone or trying to come up with ways to deter customers from using their connections very much so that they can keep what that have. Most choose to try to put limits in place as it keeps them from having to spend money and they hope that most people will just deal with it.
 
FIOS doesn't change anything. They still have to have the backbone to support everyone. Like mentioned above, most ISPs operate in the same manor as a bank. A bank doesn't have everyone's money as they loan some of it out. So if everyone trired to take their money out of a bank, that bank would not have the money on hand to give it to everyone. Same goes for internet. ISPs do not pay to have enough bandwidth to supply every customer the max possible connecton at the same time. They assume a certain percent and look at usage to decide what they need. It doesn't matter if you have 1MB or 50MB, they aren't going to be wasting money.

Problem is that more and more people are geting online and using more bandwidth so the companies are stuck at a point of either upgrading their backbone or trying to come up with ways to deter customers from using their connections very much so that they can keep what that have. Most choose to try to put limits in place as it keeps them from having to spend money and they hope that most people will just deal with it.


As I am one of the sole people responsbile for infastructure/bandwidth expansion for FIOS I believe I can answer this question, in regards to verizons policy on backbone acceptable use levels and even stricter controls on fios I can tell you that the model you mention is incorrect. Teir1 ISP's mandates are usually 50% burst utilization will cause a bandwidth upgrade, here at FIOS we have more strict controls. The unique thing about fiber is once you lay the glass down it is very easy to expand bandwith. When I expand bandwidth to our MAP's its a simple matter of going into our Brocade or Nexus and activating another port.

What you also have to realize is that all fiber is multimode, not only are not all cable pairs even utilized but the technology exists to put more "bandwidth" or actually "channels" down the same strands of fiber. With multimoe fiber you can put sevral channels down a single fiber filliment.

As far as bandwidth potentials, Brocade's DCX Backbone can field as many as 768 8Gbps Fibre Channel ports, with 10Gbps Ethernet ports to come. Cisco's Nexus 7000 is a high-capacity core switch with up to 512 10Gbps Ethernet ports, where bandwidth on the backplane is measured in terrabytes per second. For smaller metropols Cisco ONS devices are utilized which once again provide many many years of potential user requirement increases.

Not too mention last month we erradicated all Analog across the network going 100% digital freeing up a vast chunk of bandwidth, to the user who replied too the comment of "2 HD channels at the same time causing problems" that is not possible anymore, also when you order now pay per view content or stream any programing etc, we also raise the softlimits imposed at the modem while you are streaming these services. But I could flip a switch here and give you 100 megs down with no upgrades, no modifications needed at all. Since 2007 that capacity was added, in our testing traditional users do not see any improvment at all as most websites are designed at around 8 megs of max throughput. This of course does not exclude anyone using say reget deluxe or firefox's multi download option, where both programs use multiple sessions and cap each session against the site/server they are accessing.. in those cases yes you can easily fully max at 7 megs per second on the 50 meg plan.

Hope some questions were answered.
 
Must add that I can understand capping the lines and increasing price due to traffic jams when you're like Australia and Iceland and cannot easily lay larger pipes to the rest of the world, if at all.
 
Hmmmmm...so people think that downloadable digital media will replace physical media yet we have this mess going on.
 
My speed just got upped by my ISP, and it's pretty decent.

15mbit download / 2mbit upload
no caps
80% speed guarantee 24/7

but, it's still $60/mo. :(
 
My speed just got upped by my ISP, and it's pretty decent.

15mbit download / 2mbit upload
no caps
80% speed guarantee 24/7

but, it's still $60/mo. :(

I would kill for that...

8mbit download / 768kbit upload

0% of the time I got the download im paying for.
65% of the time I got the upload im paying for.

All for the wonderful price of $80 a month. :rolleyes:
 
Hmmmmm...so people think that downloadable digital media will replace physical media yet we have this mess going on.

Seriously. This is a major detriment to dl content.

You would expect companies to expand their systems to accomodate the growth of new customers, not cap them.
 
Back
Top