British Clampdown on Illegal Downloads

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Britain's biggest Internet providers have signed an agreement with the country's recording industry to clamp down on illegal downloading. The ISPs will begin sending letters out to the biggest offenders, all 6.5 million of them, later this month.

Under the deal to get tough on the estimated 6.5 million Britons who have downloaded music and video illegally, letters will be sent to the most prolific offenders warning them that they have been detected.
 
So in brittan you get a letter that says stop, in the US you get a letter that says you should go ahead and sell your house, car, etc.. as the RIAA has just claimed all of your money as compensation for the music you listened to.
 
lol.....

how does the saying go?

The first rule of USENET is, you do not talk about USENET. our meetings are every saturday night in an abandoned warehouse by the.... oh... crap.... not supposed to tell you that!

I love how they try to stop piracy by "cracking down" on things like torrents.... give me a freakin break.
 
So basically everybody in Britain gets a free warning. Does anyone else think this might actually encourage MORE illegal downloading/sharing?
 
They're not sending 6.5 million letters, they're selecting the most prolific from the 6.5 million they (claim to) know about.
 
I bet the ISPs love it as a way to stealth cap the bandwidth of these "prolific" downloaders. As for it just being a letter, I suspect that's because the British authorities are too inept to accurately prove that the downloads were illegal (and that's coming from a Brit).
 
I wonder how much slush funds exchanged during this agreement.
 
It's almost worth just downloading all the PAR files from USENet over SSL, lower the signal to noise ratio a bit :)
 
this is crap, i know some one who is on virgin media isp and got a letter for exeeding his limit last week. he only just got a 360 and ps3 and started downloading game trailers and e3 videos and demos and some psn and xbla games.
 
this is crap, i know some one who is on virgin media isp and got a letter for exeeding his limit last week. he only just got a 360 and ps3 and started downloading game trailers and e3 videos and demos and some psn and xbla games.

that sucks. that's why those systems are flawed.
 
Correct me if my analogy is incorrect but would this not really be the same as someone walking into say, a computer store, picking up a sealed copy of Adobe CS3 walking out and getting caught - then get told "Don't do that again" and can just go on about their business?
 
Correct me if my analogy is incorrect but would this not really be the same as someone walking into say, a computer store, picking up a sealed copy of Adobe CS3 walking out and getting caught - then get told "Don't do that again" and can just go on about their business?

In your example it's pretty darn obvious that the person was attempting theft. It's far more difficult trying to prove that someone was illegally downloading; the possibility of false positives are much higher too.
 
If a person did as you say, this would be actual theft because they have stolen something tangible that will prevent someone else from being able to purchase the sealed copy of CS3. The store paid Adobe for the item to be placed on their shelf and they will not be able to recoup their expense since the product is gone.

Now, if the same person downloaded a copy of CS3 and they had no intention of buying it, they are not denying anyone else the ability to purchase the software. Since the person was never going to purchase CS3 anyway, nobody is losing out.

It is not right for the person to use something that they didn't pay for, but it is not a theft as compared to taking something physical from a store.


Originally Posted by The Donut
Correct me if my analogy is incorrect but would this not really be the same as someone walking into say, a computer store, picking up a sealed copy of Adobe CS3 walking out and getting caught - then get told "Don't do that again" and can just go on about their business?
 
Oh, and there's also the whole "making available is piracy!" argument that doesn't work well with your analogy.
 
"Making available" is no longer holding up in courts as an argument.
 
Guess the Brits never heard of encryption. Then again a few years ago they were still paying by the minute to access the tubes.
 
Back
Top