Brand New Build - hard drive options???

RazorOye

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 15, 2005
Messages
150
Alright -

It's been years since I've had a new system - my current rig is a 500 MHz P3 with 128 MB RAM and a 13.6 GB hard drive. It was good enough to type papers in college but now I want to get more serious. And I've been saving. Here's what I've settled on:

DFI nf4 SLI-DR
AMD 64 3800+
2 x BFG 6800 GT OC
1 GB Corsair XMS 4400 Dual Channel
Audigy 2 ZS
Viewsonic 22" CRT
PC Power Supply and Cooling 510SLI

I'd assumed for a while now that I was going to go with a RAID 5 array with 4 SATA 160 GB Seagate Barracudas. But the more I've read on the [H] forums - I'm hesitant.

I've built about a half dozen systems for friends, but never RAID. I would like to run more than one hard drive but I'm thinking the following are my options:

1. one large capacity hard drive for everything

2. one 74GB Raptor for games and programs that need the hd speed and one large capacity hard drive (7200 RPM) for music, video, etc...

3. RAID 5 with SATA hard drives.

Right now, for back up, I have a 160 GB Seagate hard drive that I run out of an external enclosure and I back up regularly - I have grad school research that can't be lost. Otherwise, I'm royally fucked.

Do I need RAID 5? I thought it would be something cool to have and say I had - but I don't see a real reason. Other than bragging rights (I know - that's a stupid reason).

I'm just worried now that it's not solid backup - a virus could still wipe it out and there's so much more complexity to it.

If I just want fast access to some programs and storage for media files - should I bypass RAID5?

I just don't know what questions to ask myself and I've done a ton of reading, but not sure if the RAID5 is worth it now.

As always - everyone's been great around here already. Thanks, in advance, for your help.
 
a raid solution is not going to give you any extra FPS in games. As for a raid5 solution, if you want to run it (its not going to hurt) you will want a hardware based controller (hardware XOR) instead of the cheaper (<$200 US) controllers.

To get the most out of your raid setup, you have to have a decent bus to run it. PCI isnt going to cut it, you're gonna need the bandwidth of PCI-X or PCI express.

Sidenote, anyone know of any hardware raid controllers that are PCI express yet?

Raid5 doesnt hurt, there's a good bit of redunancy built into that setup, but the price/performance ratio doesnt make for a solid gaming upgrade.

There's no replacing a good backup strategy, incremental, full and offsite storage.

as for your options IMO:

1) Decent, but offers no redundancy
2) Greater performance for Apps/OS but lacks redunancy
3) Good I/O performance, good redundancy, but not the "bang-for-the-buck" when it comes to gaming.

If I had reasonable funds for a disk array, I would do a combination of options 2 and 3, perhaps 1.

Data files need redundancy, and not neccesarily speed. Perhaps a raid1 setup with 300gig for pure data. Raptor for OS drive and apps.

Or, raptor (insert any high-performance single drive) for OS and a raid5 for apps/data, say a TB storage across 5 250gb drives paired with an appropriate HARDWARE based raid controller.

Its all in how much money you have to spend and how valuable the data is.
 
Then here are my final two options:

RAID 1 with two drives: one 74GB Raptor for games and OS; one 250 or 300 GB for data

RAID 5 with three Seagate 160 GB drives; one Raptor for games and OS

I am not running anything fancy and I still plan on backing up to my external hard drive all of my important files once a month.

My primary reason for this system is gaming.

I do some light video editing/storage and some slightly more music editing/storage.

Will RAID 1 be enough? Should I go RAID 5?

I know that RAID 0 isn't an option because there's no redundancy. And I don't want to spend over 500 bucks on data storage because I'm already spending more on the performance premium parts - the 3ware cards I've been looking at are 250-300 bucks. Then I have to add the cost of the drives on top of all that.
 
A very important thing to remember about RAID - it only protects the user from HARDWARE failure. If a virus, errant overclocking, or user error/mistake/goof-up causes data to be overwritten or erased, it is GONE from ALL of the drives in the array. RAID does not know a good write from a bad one - that is the user's job. "But DougLite, how do I protect my data?" The answer is simple - BACKUP onto a PERMANENT removable media, with multiple copies stored in multiple locations. Get a safe, and keep a copy there. Get a bank deposit box, keep a copy there. If you have a secure place at work or school, keep a copy there. If those grad school papers are as important as you say they are, you will not trust them to a mechanical device that WILL fail in its normal life cycle, and is subject to software activities. BACKUP that data on to high quality permanent media - good DVD+Rs/CD-Rs - and verify that the backups are complete and correct before storing them.

Now, as for your storage solution, I would go with one Raptor, and 2x 160GB Seagates in RAID-1 with a third as a hot spare (or cold if the controller doesn't support hot spares) Only bring the third 160GB drive online if one of the first two fails. Another possibility is to hook up the third 160GB, allow the RAID array to be copied onto it, then disconnect it to save it from a potential power supply disaster or other catastrophic physical system failure. Reliability wise, Seagate's entire line and the Raptor are unbeatable, each with enterpise class 5 year warranties. Maxtor MaxLine III brings a 5 year warranty to the table as well, IIRC. Samsung also makes quiet drives with a solid 3 year warranty. Hitachi drives are a world apart from the IBM DeathStar days, and their 8MB drives feature 3 year warranty as well. I would stay away from Maxtor and Western Digital's consumer drives - there's a reason why they only ship with one year warranties now.

RAID 5 is out of the question. Without an enterpise level coprocessor, the parity calculations will eat CPU time and slow the drives down considerably - every time you write to a RAID 5 array, the CPU has to make the parity calculations, then write the data with parity to the disk. A top flight RAID controller with a hardware accelerated XOR engine helps a lot, but even that has a single point of failure - if the controller goes out, your data is inaccessible until its replacement arrives, whereas with RAID 1 using integrated SATA ports, you can migrate the drives to another system with the same SATA controller and get them back online. Check my sig - 3 TB hard drive space - I might know a thing or two about storage.
 
Thanks for the feedback - the muddled picture is clearing slowly but surely.

I think I'll opt for RAID 1 with a 74 GB Raptor for apps/games/os and 2 or 3 larger hard drives running RAID 1.

Next question -

my motherboard comes with a software RAID control for RAID 1, but I've read that they aren't nearly as reliable as hardware RAID. I've looked at 3ware since they seem to be the strongest - but they are a bit pricey. If I was running RAID 5, I could see spending over 300 bucks. Is there any way I could find a good hardware SATA RAID card for RAID 1 for 100 - 150 bucks? 3wave has a 2xSATA for 127 bucks. Should I consider that - having just the two SATA drives in the case and not a third?

Now, I've not bought a SATA 160 GB hard drive - just knew I could get my hands on a couple of them for not much money.

Or, should I just get IDE with larger capacity, since my capacity is split in half already and I only use it for data storage? Not for apps or anything like that.

Would this be an option:

74 GB Raptor (OS/apps)
2 X 250 GB SATA hard drives (data storage in RAID 1 array)
3ware 8006-2LP RAID controller

Seems to be the best option from what I've read and what I've been told - relatively low cost with data redundancy.

Thoughts? And I hate to bug everyone - but the help/elucidation is sincerely appreciated.

Thanks -
 
3ware is overkill for 2 drives. A cheaper controller will stand you in good stead, and this one's only $29. Never had problems with a buslink controller before, see no reason it'd start now.
 
Other than bragging rights (I know - that's a stupid reason).

nonono that is not a stupid reason. it is the [H] way

another option to you for back is online backup.... i know at my school i get so much space on a server and as a grad student can ask for more which is great and the more backups you have the better....
 
Yea, I would recomend an offsite backup. If, God forbid, something catostrophic were to happen, you would need a backup somewhere else.
 
RazorOye said:
Thanks for the feedback - the muddled picture is clearing slowly but surely.

I think I'll opt for RAID 1 with a 74 GB Raptor for apps/games/os and 2 or 3 larger hard drives running RAID 1.

Next question -

my motherboard comes with a software RAID control for RAID 1, but I've read that they aren't nearly as reliable as hardware RAID. I've looked at 3ware since they seem to be the strongest - but they are a bit pricey. If I was running RAID 5, I could see spending over 300 bucks. Is there any way I could find a good hardware SATA RAID card for RAID 1 for 100 - 150 bucks? 3wave has a 2xSATA for 127 bucks. Should I consider that - having just the two SATA drives in the case and not a third?

Now, I've not bought a SATA 160 GB hard drive - just knew I could get my hands on a couple of them for not much money.

Or, should I just get IDE with larger capacity, since my capacity is split in half already and I only use it for data storage? Not for apps or anything like that.

Would this be an option:

74 GB Raptor (OS/apps)
2 X 250 GB SATA hard drives (data storage in RAID 1 array)
3ware 8006-2LP RAID controller

Seems to be the best option from what I've read and what I've been told - relatively low cost with data redundancy.

Thoughts? And I hate to bug everyone - but the help/elucidation is sincerely appreciated.

Thanks -

No, Mobo SATA RAID is still hardware RAID. Software RAID is literally run on software, usually an operating system. Microsoft Server Products and most Linux distribution allow you to combine individual drives into arrays using various methods.

In this world, there are three levels of storage adapters (I'm just making this up, this isn't official/standardized, but all storage interfaces fall into one of the three categories, for the most part):

1 - Basic - each drive is its own volume, and each drive is seen separately.
2 - RAID - The controller can simply recognize several simple drives, or combine them into arrays with either striping (RAID-0), mirroring (RAID-1) or a combination of both (RAID 10, RAID 0+1), However, these controllers are still dumb - they can only work with data that's already been 'computed' so to speak - They can slice it, dice it, and copy it, but what comes in is what goes to the disk(s)
3 - Smart RAID - Does everything level 2 can, plus these systems can: Make their own parity calculations for RAID-5 and RAID-3, automatically rebuild on a hot spare drive if a member of an array goes down, and intelligently monitor the staus of the array to ensure the integirty of any RAID sets on the controller. Many 'Level 3' controllers also have cache RAM on the board to speed access to data.

When you get a mobo without RAID, you get level 1. You must use software, such as your operating system, to combine drives. A mobo with 'RAID' and the less expensive add in cards (<$100) gets you to level 2. You can now stripe and mirror, but anything more complex than that is done in software. 3Ware, LSI Logic, Adaptec, etc get you to level 3, with all that crazy enterprise level storage fault tolerance goodness. We have already discussed why that is really not a fit in your environment, and that the 'level 2' features you get on a Mobo with RAID are going to be just fine for your purposes. All of the RAID features you need you get at level 2, hardware assisted - why pay for level 3?

Software RAID is accomplished in the operating system. Win 2K and above and many Linux distros support it. Windows XP allows you to stripe (RAID-0) volumes or span (JBOD) volumes across multiple dynamic disks. Mirrored (RAID-1) volumes and RAID-5 (well, it's uhh, like hardware RAID-5) volumes are only available on systems with a Windows 2000 or 2003 Server product installed. However, all of the RAID functions using this method are done in, you guessed it, software, so they load your CPU for all RAID functions.
 
DougLite said:
No, Mobo SATA RAID is still hardware RAID. Software RAID is literally run on software, usually an operating system. Microsoft Server Products and most Linux distribution allow you to combine individual drives into arrays using various methods.

I feel really stupid now. Not that I didn't before. Just to a greater degree now.

I didn't even stop to think what software and hardware RAID might actually mean. I just thought that all mobo RAID controllers sucked.

If I'm running RAID 1 - do you believe, then, that the MOBO RAID 1 controller will be enough?

If so, then my problem of PCI slots is solved. I wanted a RAID card, sound card, and TV tuner - but my DFI SLI-DR board only has two PCI slots.

But I wanted my hard drives to be SATA - and the RAID controller onboard (Silicon Image model) says: "The RAID controller supports two-channel ATA 133, enabling users to build Maximum 4 ATA-133 hard disk as an RAID 0, 1 , 0+1 , JBOD array. "

problem, right?

Should I just use the onboard RAID and get ATA hard drives instead since they'll only be for storage?

Gawd, I'm such a n00b.

Sorry.
 
No, Mobo raid is not true hardware raid. I really hate to push the point, but hardware raid is independant of the OS's. You can't take that fake hardware raid and slap it into a linux box and have it be happy.

What I mean by true hardware raid is that all parity data is computed by onboard hardware processor and not by the hosts's CPU. You have got to compare a software raid to the onboard video who say's its AGP. Is it AGP? Technically yes, is it a viable replacement for a dedicated GPU? No, the host CPU does most of the work to perform the graphics computations.

" It's not hardware RAID. It is software RAID, provided by the BIOS on the card."

Is it a hardware device that provides RAID functionality? Technically speaking, yes, you are not running a software program that mimics raid. Is it true hardware raid? No. Not by a damn sight :)

This is a droll site, heavily linux based, but if you want a hardware raid controller, look at these options:

http://www.linuxmafia.com/faq/Hardware/sata.html

Is my raid controller hardware based? Check here:
http://linux.yyz.us/sata/faq-sata-raid.html

A true hardware based raid controller will DESTROY any software based device. It wont suck up the CPU cycles that onboard/fake-hardware raid devices will.

You can get a hardware raid controller for <$200 for 2 ports, 4-ports will run about $200 and 6-8-10-ports will be considerably more.



I dont want to push anyone into buying a particular card, but I do want to show the limitations and the shortcomings to better educate your buying decision.


Will fake-hardware/software raid work: Yes
Will it have the bang-for-the-buck: Maybe

Will hardware raid work : Yes
Will it have the bang-for-the-buck: No, costs are higher
Why do hardware raid?: Because it works better in the larger scheme of things (better I/O lower CPU overhead.
 
According to http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NzE3 here on the [H], you can connect a total of 12 drives to the DFI NF4 SLI-DR. On nFocre4 SLI MCP, you get 2 ATA-133 ports with 2 devices (master and slave on each of two ports) for a total of four paralell ATA devices, and 4 SATA ports. DFI, forseeing a situation like yours, thought that this might not be enough, so they added a second controller from Silicon Image for 4 more SATA ports.

Most likely, one of your ATA ports will be used by Optical (CD/DVD) drives, but you can still connect 6 drives to NF4 MCP (2 P-ATA and 4 SATA) and 4 more to the SI 3114 controller for a total of ten. The NF4 MCP allows you to combine paralell and serial drives into one large array of 6 drives, and the SI 3114 can have another array of 4 drives, but you can't span arrays across controllers. The NF4 ports will give better performance, as they are built into the chipset, rather than competing with other devices on an expansion bus for bandwidth.

You could, for example, pick up a pair Raptors and another 160GB SATA drive to go with the one you already have, and mirror both of those. Then you might be able to find 160GB IDE drives on (fairly frequent) rebate specials at CompUSA/Best Buy/Staples, etc - if you get two rebate specials, you can mirror those drives too on an ATA port and get another 160GB mirror for as little as $100 out of pocket. That maxes out your NF4 ports, but let's say you decided to get into video editing or some other task that requires large quantiies of HDD space. You could then pick up a pair of Maxtor DiamondMax10/MaxLine III drives, and put them on the SI 3114 controller and have a monster 300GB array. Even after all this with 694GB of HDD space, all mirrored and faul-tolerant, you'd still have two SATA ports left. I really don't foresee you maxing out the storage capability of the NF4 SLI-DR, and if you do, you should be able to get a PCI Express x1 add in SATA card by then.

Also, as I've posted in another thread about hard drive failure, clean power is very important to keeping hard drives running smoothly. Invest in a quality battery packup for your PCP&C PSU to ensure the longevity of every drive you purchase.
 
Bullitt said:
No, Mobo raid is not true hardware raid. I really hate to push the point, but hardware raid is independant of the OS's. You can't take that fake hardware raid and slap it into a linux box and have it be happy.

What I mean by true hardware raid is that all parity data is computed by onboard hardware processor and not by the hosts's CPU. You have got to compare a software raid to the onboard video who say's its AGP. Is it AGP? Technically yes, is it a viable replacement for a dedicated GPU? No, the host CPU does most of the work to perform the graphics computations.

" It's not hardware RAID. It is software RAID, provided by the BIOS on the card."

Is it a hardware device that provides RAID functionality? Technically speaking, yes, you are not running a software program that mimics raid. Is it true hardware raid? No. Not by a damn sight :)

This is a droll site, heavily linux based, but if you want a hardware raid controller, look at these options:

http://www.linuxmafia.com/faq/Hardware/sata.html

Is my raid controller hardware based? Check here:
http://linux.yyz.us/sata/faq-sata-raid.html

A true hardware based raid controller will DESTROY any software based device. It wont suck up the CPU cycles that onboard/fake-hardware raid devices will.

You can get a hardware raid controller for <$200 for 2 ports, 4-ports will run about $200 and 6-8-10-ports will be considerably more.



I dont want to push anyone into buying a particular card, but I do want to show the limitations and the shortcomings to better educate your buying decision.


Will fake-hardware/software raid work: Yes
Will it have the bang-for-the-buck: Maybe

Will hardware raid work : Yes
Will it have the bang-for-the-buck: No, costs are higher
Why do hardware raid?: Because it works better in the larger scheme of things (better I/O lower CPU overhead.

Will we have plenty of CPU time on a 3800+? I think so. Do we care about a hardware XOR engine, intelligent rebuild, caching algorithms, etc? Not really - we're only running RAID 1 here folks. Also, nVidia's storage sub system is pretty well optimized and the drivers are pretty darn good. Any of you guys remember when the Radeon Xpress 200 "Bullhead" reference boards made the review rounds? The "Bullhead" was as fast or slightly faster than nForce3 in games, but trailed significantly behind in office and productivity benchmarks, because the nForce storage perfromance was much better - lower CPU overhead and better I/O - oh wait - that's what some people think you have to spend $200+ on a separate add in card for. Don't forget that nVidia makes server/workstation products now with the nForce Pro 2200 and 2050 MCPs, and I get the feeling that they didn't have to change too many of the SATA features from NF3/NF4 to get a solid workstation/server level product. We can get 8 ports with the motherboard, four of them on a pretty darn good subsystem, and one of them on admittedly only average subsystem, but I still firmly believe that will be great for this particular build.

And your link to http://linux.yyz.us/sata/faq-sata-raid.html only proves what I said about their being three kinds of storage systems - non RAID, sorta RAID, and real RAID. RazorOye isn't going to need real RAID - 'sorta RAID' will do everything he needs. Also, you yourself admit that "6-8-10-ports will be considerably more." Genuine hardware RAID will use a few percent less CPU time - but for the cost of it, I could get a 4000+ instead of a 3800+ and get the CPU time back - and get more FPS in games, something a hardware RAID controller will never do.
 
Thanks so much for all of the help, y'all!

I am going about this in a different way than I was going to a coupla days ago. I was going to strap 3 hard drives in RAID 5 with 3 160 GB Seagates

Now, though, I'm gonna go with 74 GB Raptor for my games and apps and RAID 1 with 2 x 200 GB Seagate SATA hard drives for storage. And I am going to use the onboard RAID controller. My needs aren't demanding. And I still have the external hard drive for backup.

Also, I need those two pci slots for tv tuner and sound card. I will keep an eye out, though, for a pcie RAID controller and consider an upgrade in the next year or so when it's time for a clean install of the OS and in the event my RAID needs change.

But I know y'all put a lot of time and thought into your replies to me and it really has helped me learn a great deal about something I was clueless about.

Thanks sooooo much!
 
Back
Top