Boughta D5100, keep it or get a D7000?

jbailey

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 10, 2003
Messages
502
So I bought a Nikon D5100 as my first DSLR. I love it, but I got to hold and "feel" a D7000 a few days ago and it definitely feels better in my hands than the D5100. I think I'm going to bite the bullet and spend the extra dough and exchange my camera for the D7000.

Wise decision? The built in motor for older lenses is really nice, plus the 39 points for autofocus. I don't really care about losing 1080p 30fps video (it does 24fps at 1080p). The swivel screen is kind of nice on the D5100, but not necessary for me to use the camera.

So far I'm mostly shooting in aperture priority and am really enjoying the camera, but after holding the D7000 it just feels that much better. I also don't want to be wishing I'd gotten the D7000 a few months down the line in. I do like the I can get a battery grip for it and can use older lenses, but that brings me to another question...

Are all lenses coming out from this point forward going to be AF-S? If they are, then I'd guess the motor in the D7000 isn't too big of a deal.

Any input would be appreciated.
 
With an exception of specialty lenses (PC-E) I'd imagine that all future lenses will be AF-S (or similar technology). So no, the screwdriver isn't as necessary these days as it used to be, especially if all your lenses are AF-S, and you're not planning on getting anything but AF-S.

As for the D5100 vs. D7000. If you have the money.. why not? As you already pointed out, both cameras have their own strengths and weaknesses, but if the pros outweigh the cons, the small increase in price tag is worth it. I say, do it.
 
The D5100 has pretty much all the base features of the D7000 in a slightly lighter body. I picked up the D7000 not too long ago and love it with the 35mm f/1.8. Would've traded in my D40 and D7000 combo for a D5100 and D700 to keep the D7000's features and go FX for future projects but that's just me.

Invest more in lenses since you already have the D5100. It's solid and the upgrade isn't worth it.
 
There is a lot to be said about the better feel of the D7000 in your hands. On the other hand the D5100 is lighter and smaller, which will make it potentially easier to carry around with you and hold for extended periods of time.

All of the new lenses Nikon releases with have AF-S motors in them. The built-in motor on the D7000 is only beneficial if you plan on getting some of the old lenses which you'd need to buy used. The 50mm f/1.8 D (just recently replaced with an AFS) or a lot of the old telephoto primes like 400mm, 500mm, 600mm, 800mm. All these telephoto lenses cost a very pretty penny, and if you go this route you could just buy a new body then.

The D5100 has the tilt screen which I'd highly value.

You'll have the initial outlay of extra money to upgrade to the D7000. I'd recommend putting the extra money into lenses instead. You don't mention if you are looking at any lenses. Maybe a 35mm f/1.8, or 70-300mm VR, or something really wide like the 10-24mm, 10.5mm Fisheye, or sigma 8-16mm, or Tokina offerings. This may be a good time strongly consider whether you would want any of the very popular lenses that don't have a built-in motor like Nikon's 85mm f/1.4 (which has been replaced by an AF-S lens, but some people really like the rendering of the old version).

I'd do a serious comparison of the features. The 39point AF would be handy if you will be taking pictures of moving subjects. Off the top of my head I don't know the other differences. Edit D7000 has a pentaprism display, 100% coverage and a higher .94x magnification which will make a broader larger view when you look through the viewfinder. Not the end of the world if you don't have that. Live view will be 100% and anyways if you aren't using a tripod what you snap won't be 100% exactly what you saw do to your hands moving and camera shake. D7000 has a 1/8000 shutter speed which is greater than the D5100 at 1/4000th. Normally you can just stop down the aperture or lower the ISO, this discrepancy would only be an issue if you are shooting wide open with primes, or right into the sun, but in these instance a lot of the pros also add a ND filter to block some of the sun.

There are also accessories. Extra batteries, camera cases, backpacks. You may also want to consider getting a SB700 or SB900 flash with the money. Or a strong sturdy tripod that wont sway in the breeze, for instance a Manfrotto or the like (couple hundred dollars+). There are interesting things like circular polarizers, 10stop filters, gradient filters. I can recommend the Phottix Plato 2.4ghz RF remote releases. The cool video microphone Nikon released, or something by another brand.
 
Last edited:
I do plan on getting a few lenses and a flash. I've definitely got my eye on the 35mm f/1.8 but no one seems to have it in stock right now. Nikon apparently is in the middle of a shortage on some of those things, so I'm just going to wait for Best Buy to get them in again for $199.

Is the 70-300mm VR really that much better than the less expensive 55-300mm?

I really appreciate the input, everyone.
 
I do plan on getting a few lenses and a flash. I've definitely got my eye on the 35mm f/1.8 but no one seems to have it in stock right now. Nikon apparently is in the middle of a shortage on some of those things, so I'm just going to wait for Best Buy to get them in again for $199.

Is the 70-300mm VR really that much better than the less expensive 55-300mm?

I really appreciate the input, everyone.

If you get it at Best Buy, have them price match whatever online retailer you find it cheapest. (Usually Amazon works - advice from an ex-employee.)

As for the 70-300mm vs. 55-300mm, consider your range of zoom. Both, from what I've seen personally, aren't very wide, compared to the 18-105mm or the 18-55mm kit lenses so expect to feel that crop sensor more with these lenses.

Also don't expect these to be that fantastic in low-light due to variable apertures of both lenses. (Almost certain these are anywhere f/3.5 to f/5 which sucks in low-light settings). For this, I always recommend at least the SB-700 as it produces wonders in the worst settings.
 
Yeah, the main reason I'm going with Best Buy is because of the employee discount.. it knocks the $199 down to like $160... which is why there's no way I'm going to spend the $280 most websites are wanting for the lens right now. :)
 
If you get it at Best Buy, have them price match whatever online retailer you find it cheapest. (Usually Amazon works - advice from an ex-employee.)

As for the 70-300mm vs. 55-300mm, consider your range of zoom. Both, from what I've seen personally, aren't very wide, compared to the 18-105mm or the 18-55mm kit lenses so expect to feel that crop sensor more with these lenses.

Also don't expect these to be that fantastic in low-light due to variable apertures of both lenses. (Almost certain these are anywhere f/3.5 to f/5 which sucks in low-light settings). For this, I always recommend at least the SB-700 as it produces wonders in the worst settings.

In addition to range of zoom, do not forget build quality. From what I've read the 55-300 is build just like the 55-200. I went with the 70-300 for a couple reasons: Build quality and the ability to mount and use it on an FX camera, should I ever upgrade to one.
 
I ended up getting the D7000. After spending some more time with it and also testing the 70-300mm with it, it's just too good to pass up. It just feels like a faster camera in general. So now my next purchase is going to be the 70-300mm, and then an SB-700.
 
It begs more research, but I'm aching over wanting a D7000.

If I save 60 pounds a week I can get it in under five months!
 
Back
Top