Bottleneck..... is it me?

Jynio

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 6, 2004
Messages
232
Hey guys,

It's that time again; my computer is 'old'. It's just over three years to be exact, but when converted to computer years, it's a grandpa.

I'm not sure how you guys build your rigs, but usually I end up buying near top of the line hardware, then using it for three or four years until it's completely out of date, then starting from scratch. I'm not much for upgrades, although it's probably a better investment to start midrange and keep it midrange over time. Anyway, I'm getting off track. I just wanted to make a few points and get some advice from the [H]ard members. First off, my rig:

p4 northwood 2.8@3.3
1gb corsair pc4000 running 1:1
ati 9800pro 128mb
74gb raptor

Like I mentioned, three years ago this was a good rig. Now it's close to that time where dell is selling faster budget systems then my 'grandpa' pc, and that mom next door just bought a better computer for word processing. Three years ago I knew what was what, and was up to the minute on current technology. Every time though, after I build my system, I don't keep up, and now, I need to figure everything out once again. No worries though, that's half the fun, the other half is sitting beside boxes of new computer parts.

I use my system for everything, occasional gaming, but for the most part, lots of photoshop, after effects, and 3d rendering. I could use another gb of ram, as working with large scenes tends to eat up 1gb fairly quick. For the most part though, everything works great, aside from rendering which can obviously never be fast enough, where you can easily wait weeks or months on renders.

So, for my questions. If I get back up to date, and pickup a Q6600, or Q6800 (prefer quad, just for rendering), should I be expecting much improvements for day to day computer tasks, photoshop, and post production work?

I mean, how much better can things get? I feel now, I'm almost the slowest factor. On my older systems, I was always waiting for this or that application to load, or getting frustrated by random holdups. Now, everything seems to work fine, and like I said, my creativity and overall workflow is taking the most time. As the title mentions, I think I'm the bottleneck of the system.

So I wonder, will we ever hit a dead end for the average user, where there's no need to upgrade? I feel I'm more demanding on my computer then the average person, and with a three year old rig... it seems to be holding up great (although the [H]ard part of me will build a new system, just for enjoyment). Obviously Vista is more resource hungry then previous operating systems, but to me, it just feels like for someone doing average day to day computer tasks and work, there's no reason to go much farther. Gaming and rendering is another thing, it'll never be fast enough, but for everything else... aren't we close? I'm sitting here working with million polygon scenes or multitasking with photoshop/after effects/dreamweaver all at once, and..... it's running smooth as silk. Why do I need a new computer again?
 
That, my [H]ard compadre, is the reason to purchase a PC instead of a Mac.

I started working at my current job in January (developer) and I thought I had a fairly decent system. It was top of the line (512 Mb of RAM, 100 GB HD, 2 Ghz processor) PC about 6 years ago and cost me a pretty penny. I had used it all through college for dev work and it performed admirably.

Then I started work and got a laptop with 2 GB RAM, 3 Ghz processor, and a 100 GB HD. The build time for a project, the ability to run Virtual Machines, Vista Ultimate, and even mundane tasks like starting Word took far less time to run.

Now when I'm at home (like I am now) and on my home PC it feels like a HS girlfriend your sophmore year of college. Sure it works fine and does all the normal stuff well, but it just feels slower and less mature.

Therefore, I am purchasing the computer below in October (after my birthday). Having waited 6 years to upgrade, nothing but the fans (and maybe not even those) is salvageable for the new build. You, on the other hand, can throw in new RAM sticks (don't go out and buy just 1 1GB stick, in order to play right RAM needs to be identical, but of course you knew that) and possibly upgrade your processor and send that High School sweetheart to the room down the hall as a college freshman ;)

Nate
 
I feel your pain flipflop. I had to spend the last couple weeks on a 5 year old laptop with 256mb ram. I literally spend 3/4's of my time waiting on the system. That has to be one of the most frustrating experiences in life.

Ram prices are ridiculous anymore. Three years ago I spent $450cad on this 1gb, and now you can pickup 2gb ddr2 for $100cad. That's technology though..... but I love it.

When do you think I should jump in with a new system? I mean, do I wait for the price drop july 22 and put together a new rig, or hold off for the new intel chips. I have some cash to kill, but I might invest it into something that'll keep it's value longer (tv, [H]ard furniture, etc). I think I'll wait till September and see what's on the horizon. I guess I'll hold off as long as I can, either because my systems performance doesn't keep up, or the [H]ard side of me decides it needs to tinker with something.
 
The only think keeping me sane right now is an Excel spreadsheet that I'm using to keep track of prices etc. My components change every once in awhile and I like to see what the best is out there and then watch the price drop.

If you need any other reason to not go out and buy an 8800 GTX, the new C2D, and 4 GB of RAM, go to newegg, search wishlists for $ and sort by date, descending. It's crazy to see how much prices have dropped since December.

$2,000 machines are $1300, $4800 machines are $3400, and down the line. My advice to you is to pick out the components you want, do [H]ard research, change them based on quality and reviews, and see what you can do in a few months. Price drops before Christmas will be schweet.

If I think of the first wishlist I created 3 weeks ago, it's amazing 1) how much I've learned and 2) how bad my initial decisions actually were :) Can't wait to see what I think of my current wishlist in October when I order it....

Nate
 
Back
Top