Blue Man Group Opens A School

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Do you want your child to attend kindergarten in a padded “wonder room?” Got an extra $27,300 lying around for tuition? If so the Blue Man School is for you! Yes, it is “those” blue dudes.

"It isn't that we just think that teaching the arts would be 'nice,' " said Chris Wink, who along with Phil Stanton and Matt Goldman founded the Blue Man Group and Blue School - and who make occasional cameos as instructors.
 
Seriously...
What if your kid grows up and wants to be an engineer? They didn't learn jack shit for math in a 'padded room'

What if you kid grows up and wants to be a musician? They didn't learn jack shit for music in a 'math book'
 
Yeah but in a general school they DO learn music, but also math, english etc. In this school it's ONLY music and arts. That's not a way to get your kid a well rounded education.
 
Did you guys read it? It says the schools won't only focus on arts. Seriously,unless you'
re a teacher or are aware of how kids absorb information, you shouldn't comment. Kids learn much better when the things theyre learning are tangible, not lecture.
 
Did you guys read it? It says the schools won't only focus on arts. Seriously,unless you'
re a teacher or are aware of how kids absorb information, you shouldn't comment. Kids learn much better when the things theyre learning are tangible, not lecture.

I read it. I agree with the philosophy of less structured learning environments- this spurs creativity and individual thought.

However, did you read this part??? :

"Its themes are echoed in the school's philosophy - where kids are encouraged to take risks and what they learn is less important than how they learn it."

What they learn is less important than how they learn it????

Um, that may all be well and good in imaginary everyone has puppies and rainbows liberal-arts land, but guess what?

If you don't build basic mathematic and scientific reasoning skills early-on, you're fucked.

As a musician AND engineer, I know the need for creativity and thinking outside the box. I understand the importance of the arts in education, and also understand that children need more free-thought in the learning process.

But the school's "philosophy".... is fucking retarded.
 
Wow, ROFL, kids that go there are really going to be fucked up.
lol.gif
 
What if you kid grows up and wants to be a musician? They didn't learn jack shit for music in a 'math book'

Music is mostly talent, not skill. Math is mostly skill, not talent.
 
Just because you possess a skill to do something doesn't mean you're talented in that skill. Perhaps that's what he means.
 
Just because you possess a skill to do something doesn't mean you're talented in that skill. Perhaps that's what he means.

I meant that creating music takes talent. Sure, anyone can learn to play something, but anything beyond that is an talent most people, myself included, do not posses.

Math only takes skill - you don't need anything beyond the understanding of a the concepts, and either a piece of paper or a calculator.
 
That is true.

However, "music" being "mostly talent" and not "skill" is not really true....

"Math" being mostly "skill" and not "talent" is not really true either.....

Musicians, with practice, can become extremely good. There are various talents that may help them. However, sometimes there is no hope.

Mathematicians/physicists/engineers (etc) have to be able to think a certain way to be good. They can not "practice" and become good.

So, actually, it appears that "Math" is mostly "talent" and "music" is a mixture of both. (if you want to use talent and skill as comparisons)
 
AVT:

I was replying to the post above your's.

Math does not "only" take skill.

You seem to be equating "Math" with basic arithmetic and structured rules.

There is a lot more to mathematical /engineering thought than structured rules.


Also, I have known many musicians with mediocre natural talent, who excelled greatly with practice, and became very good.
 
AVT:

I was replying to the post above your's.

Math does not "only" take skill.

You seem to be equating "Math" with basic arithmetic and structured rules.

There is a lot more to mathematical /engineering thought than structured rules.


Also, I have known many musicians with mediocre natural talent, who excelled greatly with practice, and became very good.

We define the words "math" and "music" differently.

My definition of "math" is basic arithmetic, geometry, etc - stuff you learn in high school. Anything beyond that is an application of math, which is another story when it comes to skill/talent.

My definition of "music" includes not just playing music, but also writing your own. The ability to create music, in my opinion, is something you are born with - I definitely can't do it. Therefore, it takes talent.
 
We define the words "math" and "music" differently.

My definition of "math" is basic arithmetic, geometry, etc - stuff you learn in high school. Anything beyond that is an application of math, which is another story when it comes to skill/talent.

My definition of "music" includes not just playing music, but also writing your own. The ability to create music, in my opinion, is something you are born with - I definitely can't do it. Therefore, it takes talent.

Would not your definition of "math" (which is arithimetic, not math) not apply to "music" as well? If, you learn the technique and practice to build your skill, you can play anything you want. Writing a score would be the application of music.

There's far more to math than adding, subtracting, differentiation, etc. To be an engineer, you have to know how to manipulate mathematical models to accomplish what you're doing. It takes a creative mind to see beyond the paper in front of you and create new models that no one else thought of, just like musicians do.
 
I read it. I agree with the philosophy of less structured learning environments- this spurs creativity and individual thought.

However, did you read this part??? :

"Its themes are echoed in the school's philosophy - where kids are encouraged to take risks and what they learn is less important than how they learn it."

What they learn is less important than how they learn it????

Um, that may all be well and good in imaginary everyone has puppies and rainbows liberal-arts land, but guess what?

If you don't build basic mathematic and scientific reasoning skills early-on, you're fucked.

As a musician AND engineer, I know the need for creativity and thinking outside the box. I understand the importance of the arts in education, and also understand that children need more free-thought in the learning process.

But the school's "philosophy".... is fucking retarded.

I agree, a balance needs to be struck. But people are incessantly bashing this school for the wrong reasons.
 
Its themes are echoed in the school's philosophy - where kids are encouraged to take risks and what they learn is less important than how they learn it.

"It's for a new generation of kids who aren't taught to the test but taught how to be creative problems solvers," said Nancy Simko, who left a private school in Brooklyn to teach kindergarten at the Blue School.

When the kids recently learned about tornadoes, for instance, they also created one - a tempestuous cloth construction that they strung across the room.

And while Simko and her fellow instructors don't paint themselves blue, they've created a fun environment where, for example, kids are encouraged to say "Good morning" in foreign and fictitious languages.

Sounds like they want the kids to learn the best way to problem solve to me. I'm not sure how it was for everyone else going through public education, but I got tired of teachers telling me how things had to be done and to prove it they copied some proof or other miscellaneous piece of knowledge from a book to demonstrate. I realize we're talking elementary here, but the whole public educational experience for me sucked because if there was one teacher out there who was a little different and interesting...their classes were either full of students whose parents DEMANDED their children into the class or the teacher was offered a job somewhere else within a year.

I see no harm in someone not knowing much about specific subjects, as long as they were given the chance and a taste of the subject. Enough of an experience with all subjects to get them through the basics of life, and then they could spend time on subjects they were really interested in and would most likely excel in.

I'd like to think we've all had a teacher who no matter what they said, you'd be lucky to retain the information after the test. I tended to believe this was because I sucked at the subject, but later found out I just wasn't learning anything besides how to respond to questions from this teacher. There was no discussion, there was no asking why, and still to this day I wonder if the teacher could have even answered her own questions without the teacher's version of the books she taught from.

Bottom line is, knowing and utilizing how an individual child learns versus teaching them subjects at all costs is what this boils down to. There are adults today who probably don't know how they learn a subject best, because they were too busy trying to memorize subject material for tests rather than truly learn.

Education is important, but the current system in place for it just doesn't stimulate interest or a desire to learn just because you WANT to learn. If it takes some band to create a school to spark a little creativity on how to educate, then so be it.
 
So is a tree. Learning math doesn't make me any more of a musician, than it makes me a tree.
I didn't say anyone needed to know complex mathematics to play music. But with a comment like that, perhaps you don't even know the beginning of how much mathematics is involved in music. Perhaps some music theory and looking into all the complex mathematics that is behind some of the greatest music in history would help you understand better.
 
Perhaps some music theory and looking into all the complex mathematics that is behind some of the greatest music in history would help you understand better.

Having been a musician for over 12 years, taken college level theory classes, and teaching music for over 6 years, I can tell you with full confidence that knowing an A5 is a string vibrating at 440hz a second and knowing the ratios of the harmonic series does not help you play a piano any better. Knowing why music works and actually playing music are two entirely different things. This on top of the fact that only western music, fits within western mathematics. There was tons and tons of music long before the well tempered scale came into fashion, along with centuries of eastern music that doesn't fit within our current mathematical musical formulas. Math can be applied to music to analyze it, but music is not mathematical.
 
Having been a musician for over 12 years, taken college level theory classes, and teaching music for over 6 years, I can tell you with full confidence that knowing an A5 is a string vibrating at 440hz a second and knowing the ratios of the harmonic series does not help you play a piano any better. Knowing why music works and actually playing music are two entirely different things. This on top of the fact that only western music, fits within western mathematics. There was tons and tons of music long before the well tempered scale came into fashion, along with centuries of eastern music that doesn't fit within our current mathematical musical formulas. Math can be applied to music to analyze it, but music is not mathematical.
That's what I said.. If you would have read, I said nobody needs to know complex mathematics to play music. :p
 
oh, I didn't see the last part. Indeed music is mathematical. Even musicians from hundreds of years ago used deliberate mathematically spaced tones to create music (ex: Costeley) We've even seen it mathematically calculated out in Arabic and Persian music from centuries ago. Hell, music has been traced back to even using the golden ratio. To say music is not mathematical is sheer ignorance. There is quite a bit of mathematics that goes into the creation of instruments, creation of patterns, analyzing what is pleasing to the ears/mind, etc. Music is so loaded with mathematics that we have graduate level courses based around the whole concept of mathematics embedded in music.
 
oh, I didn't see the last part. Indeed music is mathematical. Even musicians from hundreds of years ago used deliberate mathematically spaced tones to create music (ex: Costeley) We've even seen it mathematically calculated out in Arabic and Persian music from centuries ago. Hell, music has been traced back to even using the golden ratio. To say music is not mathematical is sheer ignorance. There is quite a bit of mathematics that goes into the creation of instruments, creation of patterns, analyzing what is pleasing to the ears/mind, etc. Music is so loaded with mathematics that we have graduate level courses based around the whole concept of mathematics embedded in music.

Math can be applied to a tree. Does that make a tree mathematical?

Music existed before mathematics did, music existed in cultures with relatively little mathematics, and music still exists today that does not follow our standard mathematical scales and ratios of notes. Yes, music can be analyzed and explained with math, but to say music is mathematical, is no more accurate than saying a snowflake is mathematical.
 
I guess you really just don't get it. We've had centuries old musicians creating music based off mathematics, and nearly everything in music can be explained with mathematics, yet it isn't mathematical. Great logic.
 
the blue man group sucks......unless you hit the shroombong with some beers and get wasted. Then it rocks. Get them pot heads at a young age.
 
Back
Top