Blu-ray’s Fuzzy Future

Pardon my Icelandic, but, really, who gives two shits?

Don't sweat it bro, you have a few people that cry every time something is posted against their favorite company. They ignore the positive stories, cry about the negative stories and blame the news poster (not the people that actually wrote the article)....yet here they are, day after day, all day long, waiting for another story to complain about.

Out of 20 Blu-ray news items we posted in the last month or so, the majority have been positive stories about Blu-ray going mainstream, price drops, 400GB discs, Vista support for Blu-ray, Blu-ray/DVD hybrid discs, Blu-ray doing well in Europe, Holiday price cuts and so on.

Any time you hear the crying start, go to the front page of the [H], hit "search" type in Blu-ray and see if it is "always negative."

;)
 
I'm sold on Blu-Ray and I even got my wife to "let" me buy a PS3 for that reason. :D Yea, the movies are still on the expensive side, but the quality of the audio and video is just amazing, and personally, I'm willing to pay the extra $$$. If there's a movie I'm interested in buying, I just wait till it comes out on sale. I just paid $22 for The Dark Knight.
 
I'm sold on Blu-Ray and I even got my wife to "let" me buy a PS3 for that reason. :D Yea, the movies are still on the expensive side, but the quality of the audio and video is just amazing, and personally, I'm willing to pay the extra $$$. If there's a movie I'm interested in buying, I just wait till it comes out on sale. I just paid $22 for The Dark Knight.

Give Fye a shot sometimes. They have used Blu-ray sales and every one I've bought were in mint condition.
 
One thing that people rarely mention is that a blu-ray disc is pretty scratch resistant because of a special coating on the disc. For that alone, I will pay an extra 5 bux a movie..
 
One reason is that discs of all kinds may become obsolete as a new wave of digital media services starts to flow into the living room. On Monday, for example, the Korean television maker LG Electronics plans to announce a new line of high-definition televisions that connect directly to the Internet with no set-top box required. The televisions will be able to play movies and television shows from online video-on-demand services, including Netflix.

I for one welcome our digital download masters. Goodbye Blu-ray.
 
I for one welcome our digital download masters. Goodbye Blu-ray.
As long as it takes to download a regular movie online, now, to download a Blu-Ray/HD movie!? Until they figure out a way to allow faster download speeds, downloading HiDef movies still has a long way to go. Or maybe my download speeds just suck...:eek:
 
I for one welcome our digital download masters. Goodbye Blu-ray.

you and everyone else here fails to realize hd digital downloads will choke the internet. furthermore their will no free meal for us given by our isp's they will cap and charge us more
 
Like I mentioned in another thread, I think the lossless audio stuff on Blu-ray is pretty silly. I doubt very highly my ears could discern the difference between good 'ol 1.5mbps DTS and lossless DTS-HD MA, even on my ~$800 headphone setup, and I have a pretty decent ear for lossy artifacts. User accounts of being able to tell a difference are meaningless unless the trials are blind or, preferably, double-blind, even if there's a supposed "night and day difference".

The lossless stuff is gravy, of course, but I have a hard time seeing that as a major advantage to what alternative formats could offer (regular DTS and lossy DTS-HD, AC3 or AC3+). People tend to be too leery about lossy audio compression these days when there's usually no real cause for any alarm.

Now, obviously, cable companies compressing the bejeesus out of their 720 streams (video, that is) is what gives Blu-ray the real advantage. For those lucky enough to have FO TV, that advantage is somewhat negated.


Pardon my Icelandic, but, really, who gives two shits?



I'm on a 720P projector with an 84" 16:9 screen, and an Onkyo SR600B HTIB setup that is 5.1. By no means a high-end setup, yet the sound quality difference blew me away on "Iron Man" even though I only thought the video was supposed to be much different when I was first starting to use Blu Ray. The video is a huge difference too, but the sound really nailed it for me when I wasn't even expecting it to in the slightest.

If my $200 HTIB setup (usually $350ish online) plus nice 720P (Epson Powerlite Home Cinema 550) projector that I got for $700 shipped as a reconditioned with full 2-year warranty + brand new bulb can show just how wildly better Blu Ray is than a standard DVD, then most people's $1k setups which aren't too rare nowadays probably can as well. I'm not an audiophile but I am technically knowledgeable so I can tell differences. I have tried some of the 720p broadcasts from HBO HD etc. and they're nowhere near as good on the sound, much less the compression artifacts on the video.
 
Another week, another anti-pro Blu-Ray Disc™ discussion! ;)

So it's not looking good for BR. Should we pretend otherwise? BR wingnuts whining that the GP aren't sharing their enthusiasm for their preferred media isn't going to help either.

BR wouldn't find itself in this position if BR players and discs were priced to compete with the format that's keeping them in the basement. It doesn't help that upscaled DVD's are so good.
 
I'm sold on Blu-Ray and I even got my wife to "let" me buy a PS3 for that reason. :D Yea, the movies are still on the expensive side, but the quality of the audio and video is just amazing, and personally, I'm willing to pay the extra $$$. If there's a movie I'm interested in buying, I just wait till it comes out on sale. I just paid $22 for The Dark Knight.

I share your outlook on Blu-ray. I bought a Blu-Ray / HD/DVD combo drive and every movie I rent or buy from this point forward will be Blu-Ray. Whatever, I don't care what anyone else says about the format, its worth it to me.

Dropping the prices on the movies would be awesome, but right now I just Netflix stuff anyway--all for just an extra dollar a month.
 
It doesn't help that upscaled DVD's are so good.

Yes, because I assume that YOU did the test, from picture quality to sound quality, on the same movie, upscaled DVD to Blu-Ray and you still think that upDVD are good?

Unless you have a crap lowend setup, it's quite easy to see/hear the difference.
 
Give Fye a shot sometimes. They have used Blu-ray sales and every one I've bought were in mint condition.

Then there's Amazon. On top of no tax in most states and free shipping, they are always running some insane deal on BR discs, whether it is 50% off MSRP or buy 2 get 1 free deals. Their normal prices are already well below any brick-and-mortar chain out there, so the other things I mentioned just put them way over the top.
 
Yes, because I assume that YOU did the test, from picture quality to sound quality, on the same movie, upscaled DVD to Blu-Ray and you still think that upDVD are good?

Unless you have a crap lowend setup, it's quite easy to see/hear the difference.

QFT.
 
Yes, because I assume that YOU did the test, from picture quality to sound quality, on the same movie, upscaled DVD to Blu-Ray and you still think that upDVD are good?

Unless you have a crap lowend setup, it's quite easy to see/hear the difference.

I can't believe people still trot out this whole upscaled DVD argument. If you don't care for the better image and audio quality you get with Blu Ray, that's totally fine, but if you supposedly care about these things and then come out and say that an upscaled DVD comes anywhere close in quality, man, eyeglasses, hearing aids, now...
 
Yes, because I assume that YOU did the test, from picture quality to sound quality, on the same movie, upscaled DVD to Blu-Ray and you still think that upDVD are good?

Unless you have a crap lowend setup, it's quite easy to see/hear the difference.
Agreed. I'm sorry, but upconverted DVD's don't even come close to Blu-Ray movies. I watched The Dark Knight on Blu-Ray, and then my daughter watched one of her movies upconverted and it was knight and day! :D ;)
 
Yes, because I assume that YOU did the test, from picture quality to sound quality, on the same movie, upscaled DVD to Blu-Ray and you still think that upDVD are good?

Unless you have a crap lowend setup, it's quite easy to see/hear the difference.

Oh man...It's not a matter of which format provides the best image. It's...sigh...nevermind...
 
As long as it takes to download a regular movie online, now, to download a Blu-Ray/HD movie!? Until they figure out a way to allow faster download speeds, downloading HiDef movies still has a long way to go. Or maybe my download speeds just suck...:eek:

They've already figured out how, it's old technology now. It's just a matter of ISPs willing to spend the money on it. US broadband speeds just suck in comparison to many other countries.
 
Oh man...It's not a matter of which format provides the best image. It's...sigh...nevermind...

There will obviously be some sort of compromise, be it image quality or price, when it comes to mass market media like DVD and BD. That's the point. If prices drop, then Blu-Ray will be overwhelmingly superior for the average consumer--they are the target demographic/audience. No disrespect, but the average consumer doesn't know what's good for them--ergo the death of HD-DVD.

However, I'm perfectly happy scoring deals on Amazon or Netflixing BDs. They provide better quality picture and sound that I can appreciate and therefore will pay a premium for, end of story. So, to me it IS all about which format provides the best image.
 
Unless you have a crap lowend setup, it's quite easy to see/hear the difference.


One of the biggest problems people have with Blu-ray advocates is the all out snobbery / condescending attitude that has people calling other people names or insulting strangers on the intarweb:

You are stupid
You’re blind
An idiot
Retarded
Lame
Ignorant
Deaf
Own shitty TV
Own shitty upscaling DVD player
On welfare
Your wife is fat and must be blocking the TV….
So on and so forth…

All of that just because people do not agree with their opinion of Blu-ray. It turns people off right off the bat. True, those people seem to be everywhere (cars, computers, etc. etc.) but it doesn’t make it any less pleasant to have to deal with them.

I would literally shit my pants if someone said “I totally see what you are saying about <insert why I don’t own Blu-ray> but here are the reason I like it and if you ever get the chance, I recommend this / check out that and blah blah blah.” Instead of leading with “you’re a fag if you don’t have Blu-ray…it’s a fact.”
 
One of the biggest problems people have with Blu-ray advocates is the all out snobbery / condescending attitude that has people calling other people names or insulting strangers on the intarweb:

You are stupid
You’re blind
An idiot
Retarded
Lame
Ignorant
Deaf
Own shitty TV
Own shitty upscaling DVD player
On welfare
Your wife is fat and must be blocking the TV….
So on and so forth…

All of that just because people do not agree with their opinion of Blu-ray. It turns people off right off the bat. True, those people seem to be everywhere (cars, computers, etc. etc.) but it doesn’t make it any less pleasant to have to deal with them.

I would literally shit my pants if someone said “I totally see what you are saying about <insert why I don’t own Blu-ray> but here are the reason I like it and if you ever get the chance, I recommend this / check out that and blah blah blah.” Instead of leading with “you’re a fag if you don’t have Blu-ray…it’s a fact.”


Isn't that what the internet was invented for?
 
No disrespect, but the average consumer doesn't know what's good for them--ergo the death of HD-DVD.

Actually, it was more sony buying out WB & Fox that killed HD DVD. The consumer HAD chosen HD DVD over BR, hence why it sold so much better, and why there is an occasional new title released on HD DVD these days. I've got an A20 and an A3 around (as well as the xbox add-on drive) and enjoy them, both as upconverting players (damn toshiba players not handling non-anamorphic DVDs) and for the meager HD DVD collection I have.

I would never have heavily invested in HD DVD, nor will I invest in BR. The world is moving away from optical media - for the better. If you want a decent ISP for streaming, check out FIOS...at current, streaming is only DVD quality or so, but it is getting better as time goes on. I think it will not be long until both DVD and BR are eclipsed by downloadable - or some other format (gee, wouldn't flash based be kinda nice? Would certainly take less space...run faster....be more expandable...etc.)
 
Drop the price, then ill be interested. While I was able to purchase my A20 and 20 or so HD's cheaply because HD was losing the war, its the only reason I bought them. Until BR is as cheap or nearly as cheap as regular DVD's, im simply not interested, period.
 
The video is a huge difference too, but the sound really nailed it for me when I wasn't even expecting it to in the slightest.
What was the test? What Blu-ray was it, how did you set it up, did you switch from X to Y, was it blind, double-blind, etc.?

Sometimes even the expectation that a change won't be observable (i.e. suppression of an expectation of change) isn't enough to keep the brain from perceiving a difference or exaggerating the perception of a difference. In this case, if you're switching from a lossy format to a lossless format, the expectation of a difference is potentially pretty significant. I'm not saying that nobody can tell the difference, but all the data I've seen suggests that, all other things being equal, there's no significant difference between AC3, DTS and uncompressed PCM. In other words, the majority of listeners can't discern significant differences on mid- to high-end equipment in a double-blind environment (i.e. no significant difference between sample ratings).

That being said, there may be potential differences that aren't directly attributable to the differences between the lossy and lossless formats. So, the comparison isn't between lossy and lossless but between something and something else.

When it comes to video, it's pretty straightforward. Switch back and forth two sources and note the differences. When we're talking about audio, it gets much, much more complicated.
 
Although I'll likely never get Blu-ray, as I am happy with my Oppo, I will admit to walking by a nice TV in Sams playing some Disney animation movie in Blu-ray and it just looks really, really good.
 
Back
Top