BlackIce GTS or GTX?

hemi

Gawd
Joined
Mar 9, 2000
Messages
685
Hi,

I'm currently running a BIP x-flow 120 with a D5, Storm and Maze4 GPU, on a Conroe @ 3.2GHz and a 7800GT @ 485/1200. The C2D has some more room, but the temps ramp up once I get up over 3.4 and apply more voltage. At the current settings, the C2D idles at 37, peak at 46. The 7800GT idles at 39, peak somewhere around 50.

I'm rebuilding my rig with a 680i board. I want to move to a larger rad to support the load, especially if I crank up the CPU and move to a 7-series SLI setup or maybe even an 8800 or two.

I picked up a few Scythe S-Flex fans, which I plan on running at 7V. They should run around 900RPM and push roughly 40CFM @ ~20db. I want a dual 120 (240) sized radiator, but a 360 isn't out of the question either. What's the best choice given the fans I plan to run? 240 GTS, GTX? A 360? I might add a plenum to pull the fans back off the rad about an inch. If the Thermochill PA rads are better than the BI GT series, then lemme know. The name of the game is quiet cooling capacity...


Thanks!
Tom
 
Undervolted S-Flex fans? Thermochill, hands down (or Swiftech's MCR-QP series, if you're on the cheap).

As far as quiet cooling goes, people should just stay away from the GT series--you'd get better results from a BIP2 than a GTS240 with low CFM fans.
 
I would rather have a thermochill PA 120.2 over a GTX.
I would rather have a swiftech MCR 220 over a GTS.

So the answer to your topic question is, neither.
 
So the real answer is a 120.2 or 120.3. Now I just have to find them in stock somewhere. I know the topic has been covered before, but assuming I have the space, is the 120.3 the natural choice? Is there marked improvement over a .2?

Thanks again. I appreciate the help in getting this right.


Tom
 
If you have room for the 120.3 then definitely get it. The price difference is negligible, and you're getting basically 50% more cooling capacity than the 120.2.
 
I am sure the thermochill is a better rad. I just finished my setup a few weeks ago using a GTS 360 and am very happy. Cpu loads at 42-44. Was getting 54-58 on air.
 
The PA 120.3 won't fit in my case, too big by about a half inch - not to mention it and the 120.2 are out of stock at every vendor I checked (about 6 of them). What's the second best 'low-airflow' triple 120 rad? The Swiftech MCR320-QP? The Coolingworks 32T? The BIP III?

Thanks,
Tom
 
The PA 120.3 won't fit in my case, too big by about a half inch - not to mention it and the 120.2 are out of stock at every vendor I checked (about 6 of them). What's the second best 'low-airflow' triple 120 rad? The Swiftech MCR320-QP? The Coolingworks 32T? The BIP III?

Thanks,
Tom

An old and unanswered question I would love to hear some opinions on. Anyone?
 
LOL...this is a bit old.

I ended up putting a Coolingworks 22T in because I wanted to retain a spot for an internally mounted optical drive. I would have preferred a PA120.2, but couldn't find one at the time. The 22T turned out to be a good, inexpensive alternative. I'm running a Conroe @ 3.5 (1.52v) and an 8800GTS @ 650/2000. I'm using Scythe FDB fans at 7v (~800RPM/30CFM). The 22T seems to keep up just fine as idle temps hover near 40C and peaks are right around 50C, but we'll see how it goes when summer gets here... ;)


Tom
 
The coolingworks, Swiftech and BIP are all roughly the same however I would say the order goes

Coolingworks > Swiftech >> BIP

The difference beween the coolingworks and swiftech is smaller than that between the BIP and Swiftech.

However any of the three will serve you pretty much the same.
 
so i'm guessing going from a BI GTS to a BI GTX would be a bad move?

i'm redoing my loop and only cooling my cpu this time and was thinking of upgrading to the BI GTX120, do you guys think its worth it? i have a BI GTS120.
 
aiya, it depends on the CPU. If it is a Core2Duo, I'd grab a PA120.1. It will serve you well for just a CPU loop.
 
so i'm guessing going from a BI GTS to a BI GTX would be a bad move?

i'm redoing my loop and only cooling my cpu this time and was thinking of upgrading to the BI GTX120, do you guys think its worth it? i have a BI GTS120.

The GTX is a fairly good radiator... But it's too expensive for what it is.
 
its for the opty thats in my sig. i would go for the thermochill PA120.1 but they're sold out everywhere.

what temps difference would i see if i went with the GTX from GTS?
 
Just grab a PA120.3 from PPC =D. its only $35 more than a PA120.1, and then you can put your GPU on it too, and still OC them both to the moon!
 
Back
Top