Bill Gates: Robots Should Pay Taxes

Generally speaking taxes are taken from after operating expenses are deducted and on profits. If a company earns no profits it doesn't get taxed. Also Econ101 is just a introductory course and you need to know a hell of a lot more on this subject before you try commenting on it.

+ if you lose money, you don't have to pay taxes for future years until you make up the amount you lost. Reminds me of Trump losing like $900 million in the mid-1990s, and he didn't have to pay federal taxes for next 18yrs. Even if he profited all 18yrs. I don't know how that works, and whether the average American taxpayer can do that, but if you have great accountants and lawyers, you can make it happen. I'm sure companies can do it as well.

Donald J. Trump explicitly acknowledged for the first time during Sunday’s debate that he used a $916 million loss that he reported on his 1995 income tax returns to avoid paying personal federal income taxes for years.

Mr. Trump’s response — “Of course I do. Of course I do” — was the fullest the wealthy developer had provided since The New York Times reported that he had declared the loss, and that the tax deduction could have been large enough to allow him to avoid federal income taxes for up to 18 years.

Previously he had declined to comment on the documents, issuing a statement that neither challenged nor confirmed the $916 million loss.

Asked directly during the debate if he would say how many years he had avoided paying federal income taxes, Mr. Trump responded, “No.”

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/10/us/politics/donald-trump-taxes.html?_r=0
 
I'm sure Bill Gate never shed a tear over all the secretaries that lost their jobs to word processors and would have fought any effort to penalize his products for this.
 
I'm sure Bill Gate never shed a tear over all the secretaries that lost their jobs to word processors and would have fought any effort to penalize his products for this.
If he did or didn't is irrelevant to the topic at hand and given his current actions and comments on this subject its quite possible he'd have done things differently if he had to go back then knowing what he knows now.
 
Loss carried forwards is what you're referring to, blade.

This is a slippery slope as robots are already widely dispersed in industry if you go past the humanoid looking expectation. E.g. one place I work with has dual turret CNC lathes with auto feed magazines. You ensure it's all set and ready, then put the brass feed stock in, push a button, check it, then let it run all weekend. You come back and you have 400x intricate brass pieces for laser optics without doing a thing.

It partially replaced paying a dude who couldn't focus and kept crashing the more manually loaded 5 axis machine. Funny how I didn't have that same problem running them all night often. Not really saving money, more so reliability, repeatability and new capabilities.

And if that dual turret CNC lathe isn't a robot, then I'm a mannequin.
 
If he did or didn't is irrelevant to the topic at hand and given his current actions and comments on this subject its quite possible he'd have done things differently if he had to go back then knowing what he knows now.

He would've not created Word? Lol.
 
TBH I think that it's only a matter of time before we move to a UBI (universal basic income.) I don't believe that this automation trend will slow down even if we did tax them.

Honestly a poor replacement in automation is 10:1 for jobs and I have seen 100:1 in places I have been at. If companies are replacing ~1k workers at a time with 10-20 robotic machines being maintained by 2-3 or so technicians and ran by say 5 people (just for redundancy around the clock...) you are going to face an unemployment lag that will never catch up. I think that is what is happening right now tbh.
Your scenario about robot replacement is exactly the sort of thing I'm envisioning as well. Where I disagree is it being only a matter of time before we implement UBI. Look at our government. It hasn't been representing the people for decades and our Congress consistently sets records for the lowest approval rating since we started measuring it. I can easily believe a robot will take away jobs I wouldn't suspect, but seeing our government actually respond to the needs of the people, THAT'S what feels like science fiction to me. I heard a quote before that I liked saying something like "all our biggest problems are sociological, not technological." The idea being we can do almost anything we put our minds to, but we have to put our minds to it in the first place.
 
Back
Top