Bill Gates Backs Climate Scientists

And just the fact that we might be causing this should be enough to start doing something. If we take that action, in the worst case scenario, we aren't causing it and well... it wasn't out fault in the end. But to do nothing if it is our fault, how stupid the generations down the line will think we were for not doing anything, especially when we somewhat seriously began to consider the possibility. But again, their problem right? :rolleyes:
 
And I keep forgetting to add this : no I don't support this. I kept forgetting to add that. Brilliant idea to not have an edit button in this forum. :eek:
 
A bunch of folks I know who do research into geo-engineering schemes seem to have the viewpoint that since we may have to rely on such ideas at some point, we might as well research them now so that we don't screw things up too badly when we actually do try and implement them. ;)

Exactly. How is having lots of data to go on going to be a bad thing? Either we'll figure out we shouldn't do it, or we'll figure out we should do it, or we'll figure out that we don't know enough to know if we even *can* do it let alone should, but the point is that we'll be learning *something* rather than *nothing*.

And just the fact that we might be causing this should be enough to start doing something. If we take that action, in the worst case scenario, we aren't causing it and well... it wasn't out fault in the end. But to do nothing if it is our fault, how stupid the generations down the line will think we were for not doing anything, especially when we somewhat seriously began to consider the possibility. But again, their problem right? :rolleyes:

I know, right? I mean as if we're going to put all this effort into trying to clean up and improve the air we breathe and the environment we live in, and then some scientist proves beyond a doubt that we weren't the cause of the Earth's climate changes, and everyone will be like 'Oh man, we made the world a better place and it was all for *nothing*!'
 
First, thank you very much for your insightful posts, drako. It is refreshing to hear viewpoints from the perspective of someone who actually understands the science, and it is unfortunate that this discussion has become so politicized.

In response to bbqrooster's post, I would like to clarify that I am still an undergraduate student who is majoring in Atmospheric Science and I have taken several courses on the subject of climate and radiation, as well as worked with actual researchers in the field. Of course the actual science behind the greenhouse effect is a bit more complicated than what I have posted (the reason that CO2 absorbs longwave radiation from the Earth can be attributed to its atomic structure), but it is a simple enough explanation that everyone here should understand. I am not an expert an expert on ice core or tree ring temperature approximations, that is why I consulted a source written by the actual experts, though I can explain the basics. Ice cores can trap air from the moment they were frozen, and this allows us to approximate the concentration of greenhouse gases in the past. Furthermore, Milankovitch cycles provide an explanation for the historical variability of the insolation at the top of the Earth's atmosphere. You can then approximate the mean surface temperature at various points in time using these two factors. As for tree rings, it is true that ringwidth can be affected by the temperature of the surrounding environment. However, they are a less reliable indicator for climate change because there are several other factors besides temperature that effect ringwidth, so actual samples must be chosen very carefully.

Also, 1934 is not the warmest year on record. It is the hottest for the United States, but globally, it ranks only at 47th. Data including what was presented by NASA continues to show that 2010 was indeed the hottest year on record, and that a warming trend is expected. The global mean surface temperature is more relevant than the temperature of a single country in the study of climate science.

Lastly, the main reason for discussing the fact that there is consensus is to prove the validity of the sources presented. Most climate scientists agree that the world is warming and that human induced emissions of greenhouse gases into our atmosphere are the primary cause. This consensus was not reached overnight, but through many years of research by a lot of scientists. One study alone that is reported in a newspaper does not instantaneously disprove that, though if more and more experiments from actual climate scientists supported the hypothesis of this particular study, then you could say otherwise. However, as this has not been the case, deniers can only resort to the argument that the actual process climate scientists have used to reach that conclusion is flawed, or perhaps even an outright conspiracy (aka "climategate"), which encourages the inaction of policymakers continues and is why the debate has become more political than scientific.

Nasty_Savage, it is true that greenhouse gases do not have a permanent residence in our atmosphere. However, the problem is that it takes more than 100 years for it to leave our atmosphere. Since our CO2 emissions from fossil fuels are increasing, the net concentration of CO2 will also increase over time. Hence, even if we were to stop all of our emissions today, we would expect some amount of warming attributed to the greenhouse effect to occur.
 
And just the fact that we might be causing this should be enough to start doing something. If we take that action, in the worst case scenario, we aren't causing it and well... it wasn't out fault in the end. But to do nothing if it is our fault, how stupid the generations down the line will think we were for not doing anything, especially when we somewhat seriously began to consider the possibility. But again, their problem right? :rolleyes:

When governments thought they understood ocean sequestration we had Norway loading CO2 into ocean aquifers rather than venting to the atmosphere. This turned out to be a catastrophic problem for ocean acidification.

When governments thought they understood the synthesis of herbicides and defoliants they encouraged widespread use and we ended up with soil toxicity and agent-orange sickness.

When governments thought they understood the science precursor of genes, some sought out to employ the science of eugenics.

Do you see what I'm getting at here?
The dangers of trying large-scale, poorly understood solutions to large-scale poorly understood issues is tremendous.
The cure is worse than the disease.
 

One of the things about the tree ring study is that it was found to be badly flawed, it used an incredibly small section of trees which were cherry picked... It ignored other trees from the site and sites nearby that showed very different data.

The question isn't as to whether CO2 influences global temperature as it clearly does, the question is to what extent and as to whether it is worth transitioning to a non fossil fuel based economy in a matter of decades as we are hearing. I'm all for renewable energy, but it is now becoming more apparent to me that CO2 does not affect the earths temperature to anything like the extent that the sun does and we are about to enter a 30 year cooling period. The last decade all I've been hearing is unless we act now the planet is going to go to shit by 2020. Well it's 2012 now and the worlds temperature hasn't risen in 15 years.

We should transition to renewable as best as we are able, we should invest in technology that conserves energy, but it's nice we can stop panicking now.
 
Do you see what I'm getting at here?
The dangers of trying large-scale, poorly understood solutions to large-scale poorly understood issues is tremendous.
The cure is worse than the disease.
While I agree with your point, I don't think the other poster was advocating for geo-engineering solutions, but rather a gradual reduction of our reliance on CO2 and CH4 emitting technologies and fuels.
 
The question isn't as to whether CO2 influences global temperature as it clearly does, the question is to what extent and as to whether it is worth transitioning to a non fossil fuel based economy in a matter of decades as we are hearing. I'm all for renewable energy, but it is now becoming more apparent to me that CO2 does not affect the earths temperature to anything like the extent that the sun does and we are about to enter a 30 year cooling period. The last decade all I've been hearing is unless we act now the planet is going to go to shit by 2020. Well it's 2012 now and the worlds temperature hasn't risen in 15 years.
I don't agree with your 30 year prediction of global cooling nor your conclusion about the relative influence of the sun and GHGs, but the nice thing about such a time frame is that it will be easy to test/evaluate. :)

Anybody who told you that there would be dire consequences by 2020 was either not a scientist or a very poor one. The IPCC, for example, uses 2100 as a prediction year, and for good reason. Climate is similar to weather except on longer timescales, and thus you can expect variability on top of the overall trend. The example I like to think of when comparing to the slowing of warming observed during the past decade is a springtime thaw. Let's say that during the entire month of March, temperatures rose as one would expect during the Spring. But then, in the first week of April, a cold spell hit and temperatures actually dropped 5 degrees. Would we then decide that Summer would never arrive? Of course not, because we understand the underlying science and know that orbital changes make the progression of the seasons inevitable regardless of whatever other variability is observed on daily or weekly timescales.
 
While I agree with your point, I don't think the other poster was advocating for geo-engineering solutions, but rather a gradual reduction of our reliance on CO2 and CH4 emitting technologies and fuels.

The reality is that we are not faced with the decision of whether or not to "gradually reduce CO2 emissions."

Governments, under the false and dangerous belief that they understand the science, will do the only thing they can: enact large-scale sweeping regulations.

Forgive me for paraphrasing Bruce Willis: Government is not a scalpel, it's a broadsword.
 
Cap and trade could be made to work towards gradual reduction. Unfortunately people are very resistant towards the idea, even though it is already in use in this country for sulfur emissions and has worked quite well towards reducing acid rain.
 
Cap and trade could be made to work towards gradual reduction. Unfortunately people are very resistant towards the idea, even though it is already in use in this country for sulfur emissions and has worked quite well towards reducing acid rain.

Cap and trade is a direct restriction on economic output. Sulfur can be dealt with without capping energy use.
 
Cap and trade is a direct restriction on economic output. Sulfur can be dealt with without capping energy use.
One could fashion a CO2 cap and trade market that only targets the power production industry, much like the SO2 market now. My point is that cap and trade isn't inherently evil but because of some folks with dogmatic positions, we can't even have a discussion on how it could be implemented to maximize impact on emissions while minimizing economic impact. The devil is in the details but we can't even get to that point.

I'd also argue that our current economic model of infinite growth is ridiculous, but that's another discussion for another day.
 
The fact that you harbor so much anger over something that doesn't even really affect you shows that you are approaching the science from a biased viewpoint. And I'm not concerned about being manipulated... thank you very much. I have a Masters in atmospheric science and can evaluate the literature on my own.

Sure, one goal of scientists is indeed to get grant money. I'm sure whatever job you do is purely motivated by altruistic goals and you would be just as happy to have no salary. Most scientific studies approach the question from a pragmatic standpoint. Researchers are neither looking to prove something is valid nor invalid. They just make an observation and then seek to explain it. For example, Arctic sea ice is receding. A typically study does not begin with "Is this the result of global warming?" but rather "What is the cause of this trend?" and it just so happens that global warming fits the best. But new theories are always on the horizon. The beauty of science is that there aren't any rigid dogmatic positions, but rather our picture of a particular system is always evolving. Of course, that philosophy is rather incompatible with our polarized political system, so I'm not surprised that it is twisted by certain folks and the result is opinions such as yours.

For the record, the ocean is neither a permanent source nor a permanent sink. It wants to equilibrate with the atmosphere, so if concentrations are higher in the ocean CO2 will make its way to the atmosphere and vice versa. And on geologic timescales the ocean is most definitely a CO2 sink, as CO2 is absorbed by the water and then deposited as carbonate rocks. That process is the reason that our atmosphere is not like that of Venus.

Btw, your volcano idea is completely wrong. The largest eruption in recent history, Mount Tambora, released an estimated 100 million tons of CO2 into the atmosphere. In recent times humans have been emitting about 30 billion tons of CO2 yearly.

This post gives me faith that the Hard forum still has some intelligence left.
You rabid anti GW people have made this into a politcal fight and now regardless of the facts you are not willing to accept anything because it would compromise the political situation.
 
One could fashion a CO2 cap and trade market that only targets the power production industry, much like the SO2 market now.

Are you retarded? You want rolling blackouts world wide? Christ.
 
I don't agree with your 30 year prediction of global cooling nor your conclusion about the relative influence of the sun and GHGs, but the nice thing about such a time frame is that it will be easy to test/evaluate. :)

Anybody who told you that there would be dire consequences by 2020 was either not a scientist or a very poor one. The IPCC, for example, uses 2100 as a prediction year, and for good reason. Climate is similar to weather except on longer timescales, and thus you can expect variability on top of the overall trend. The example I like to think of when comparing to the slowing of warming observed during the past decade is a springtime thaw. Let's say that during the entire month of March, temperatures rose as one would expect during the Spring. But then, in the first week of April, a cold spell hit and temperatures actually dropped 5 degrees. Would we then decide that Summer would never arrive? Of course not, because we understand the underlying science and know that orbital changes make the progression of the seasons inevitable regardless of whatever other variability is observed on daily or weekly timescales.

You haven't really being paying attention then.

2020 is tipping point

Bill Gates is funding some mad scientist experiment with geo engineering... If we had until 2100 do you think this sort of thing would even get discussed?

We will see if we hit a cooling cycle, very soon, we're also going to see that climate change is going to become a much lesser issue in the next few years
 
Are you retarded? You want rolling blackouts world wide? Christ.
Scaremongering. But thanks for the insult.

And in response to matteos, you are correct that I haven't been paying much attention to popular literature. But in scientific journals, 2020 is not an oft looked at year. Perhaps for sea ice melt, but not much else. Sure, it holds a certain appeal in that it will be easier to verify than 2100, but that's about it. Oh, and I love winter and snow, so bring on this cooling! I don't see it though.

Personally I have three predictions I'm confident in:
1) Global temperatures will be warmer on average in 2100 than now.
2) The majority of Americans won't accept that fact until something drastic happens... like significant coastal flooding.
2) Regardless of acceptance, we won't reduce our reliance on fossil fuels until we face serious supply shortages, at which point global stability will go down the tubes as we fight each other for dwindling resources. This may already be starting.

Ultimately though, I'm a scientist (and I don't even look at climate in my own research), not a policy advocate or lobbyist. I don't really care what other folks believe. I only popped in here because of the baseless attacks on climate scientists by folks who have probably never in their life met one. I don't go around attacking the character of oil rig workers, even though I'd prefer we move away from that type of economy. I'm sure they are good people who just want to make an honest living. Global warming seems to be an issue where people work themselves up into such a frenzy that they forget that we are all humans and we should show each other respect.
 
Scaremongering. But thanks for the insult.
Scaremongering? Is that what you call capping electricity production? I call it crippling the economy and putting even more pressure on the poor, many of whom live in 3rd world countries and have just recently gotten access to electricity and the internet.
 
Scaremongering? Is that what you call capping electricity production? I call it crippling the economy and putting even more pressure on the poor, many of whom live in 3rd world countries and have just recently gotten access to electricity and the internet.
Well here is the fundamental problem with your argument: it isn't a cap on production, it is a cap on emissions. To claim it as so is disingenuous. The idea being to get energy producers to either move to cleaner technologies like renewables and nuclear, or to clean up existing methods using technologies like carbon sequestration.

The alternative, of course, is to subsidize companies to move to cleaner production methods... but the same people who don't like cap and trade don't like subsidizing either.
 
Why tweak some other variable with unknown consequences. Why not just fund research on ways to do carbon sequestering more cheaply? Blocking out light from the sun is so Mr. Burns.
 
even if there is no global warming its still not good at all for us to keep polluting the air with all these emissions.
 
Scaremongering. But thanks for the insult.

And in response to matteos, you are correct that I haven't been paying much attention to popular literature. But in scientific journals, 2020 is not an oft looked at year. Perhaps for sea ice melt, but not much else. Sure, it holds a certain appeal in that it will be easier to verify than 2100, but that's about it. Oh, and I love winter and snow, so bring on this cooling! I don't see it though.

Personally I have three predictions I'm confident in:
1) Global temperatures will be warmer on average in 2100 than now.
2) The majority of Americans won't accept that fact until something drastic happens... like significant coastal flooding.
2) Regardless of acceptance, we won't reduce our reliance on fossil fuels until we face serious supply shortages, at which point global stability will go down the tubes as we fight each other for dwindling resources. This may already be starting.

Ultimately though, I'm a scientist (and I don't even look at climate in my own research), not a policy advocate or lobbyist. I don't really care what other folks believe. I only popped in here because of the baseless attacks on climate scientists by folks who have probably never in their life met one. I don't go around attacking the character of oil rig workers, even though I'd prefer we move away from that type of economy. I'm sure they are good people who just want to make an honest living. Global warming seems to be an issue where people work themselves up into such a frenzy that they forget that we are all humans and we should show each other respect.

Literally for the last decade all I've been hearing is how runaway climate change will end life on earth and we have a year or two to act before its too late. Perhaps there is a massive divergence between Media reports and scientific consensus but the vast majority of us do not get our scientific news from reading peer reviewed journals.

When you get scandals like "climategate" and now the doomsday scenarios appear to be unfounded, for better or for worse the whole thing is likely to get dismissed.

The planet may be warming, but with the rate of technology I very much doubt our primary energy source will be fossil fuels by 2100. Whether it is a mixture of renewable or nuclear fusion, we will have weaned ourselves of it, not least for political reasons and rising costs.
 
Literally for the last decade all I've been hearing is how runaway climate change will end life on earth and we have a year or two to act before its too late. Perhaps there is a massive divergence between Media reports and scientific consensus but the vast majority of us do not get our scientific news from reading peer reviewed journals.

When you get scandals like "climategate" and now the doomsday scenarios appear to be unfounded, for better or for worse the whole thing is likely to get dismissed.

The planet may be warming, but with the rate of technology I very much doubt our primary energy source will be fossil fuels by 2100. Whether it is a mixture of renewable or nuclear fusion, we will have weaned ourselves of it, not least for political reasons and rising costs.
I think you underestimate the power of the media in defining the dialog... both when those doomsday scenarios were in vogue and also afterwards when every lapse in judgement was hyped into some Watergate-esqe scandal.

Btw, I also doubt fossil fuels will be our primary source of energy by 2100, but only because we have used a lot of the readily available supplies up. The question of course is how quickly do supplies run dry. If it is slowly, then yeah we can technologically transition to an alternative fuel (though it is interesting that you point to nuclear fusion when the prospects of us getting good returns out of that process are much lower than the odds global warming will continue... fusion has been the miracle solution to our energy issues that is just around the corner for 50 years now). But, if production collapses as fast as it ramped up, we will be in trouble.
 
Opps... forgot this one too...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKQs-jDI7j8&feature=endscreen

It's all about Eugenics. Once you get your head around that then everything else makes sense. It's not about Money (that's illusionary), It's not just about Control (although that is a big part of it), it's about Eugenics... (Codex Alimentarius). Just Google it... You'll get educated real quick...
 
I think you underestimate the power of the media in defining the dialog...

I think drako is onto something here when it comes to the media. Especially when it comes to the how the media is in on this Eugenics thing. Don't believe me? Then watch good 'ol Ted Turner... Corporate Money Junkie who wants nothing more than everybody to think his way...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMd0mGlKDEw

Well, Ted if you believe the world is overpopulated then YOU lead the way and be a martyr to your own cause and do away with yourself... I'm sure everyone will follow you... yeah, right...
 
Came to this thread for the crazy... leaving satisfied. This is why I consider reporting by media outlets on most things entertainment. Like Drako, I will read the peer-reviewed journals myself and make up my own mind after examining the data sans the editorial dumbing down for the tmz crowd.
 
As usual in these threads, nebulous claims of billions of dollars being spent with no actual citation or evidence. Climate change deniers consistently claim that billions or tens of billions of dollars are being scammed but never give any detail beyond that.

Show us the money you think is being wasted, and do try not to vaguely overstate annual budgets of NASA or the UN by 10000% while you're at it.

Ok...Chevy Volt, Solyndra, Willard & Kelsey Solar Group...Yeah, it's billions of tax payer dollars thrown away to political 'affiliates'.
 
Back
Top