better RAM timings or FSB

FYI, DDR 800 actually runs at 400MHz. DDR 400 actually runs at 200MHz. Something to take into consideration if you being confused at what BIOS and CPU-Z are saying (drove me mad when I was a young lad)

Anywho, an extra 200MHz on CPU trumps getting timings as low as 2-2-2-4 IMHO. I would go with the extra CPU MHz, especially since the difference in your case is sooo minimal.

I think the agreement will be unanimous.

However, I am curious as to why your ram is performing so mediocre, It is OCZ gold PC6400. Try pumping some extra voltage into it, i suspect you'll be able to push well past what you have currently
 
When overclocking, which is faster, a slower FSB but with tighter ram timings or a faster FSB with slower ram timings?

for reference..

e4300 oem with gigabyte 965p - S3 w/ OCZ pc6400
@ 3.0ghz with ram timings of 5-6-6-17 at 833mhz
@ 2.8ghz with ram timings of 5-5-5-15 at 800mhz

which should i opt for?

Have you attempted to see what you could do for max fsb? How about higher than 2.8 or 3.0?

From your numbers, I'm assuming you're running 3ghz at 9x333 with 4:5 (2.5x) for ram, and 2.8ghz at 7x400 and 1:1 (2.0x) ram?

I can't recall how exactly the s3 responds to a native 200fsb running up there in terms of strap adjustments (internal motherboard latencies), so I don't know how well you'd scale (some have experienced a lot of success with a bsel modification with ink to trick the motherboard into thinking it's a 266fsb native cpu).

But at 400fsb, you should be having the best internal latencies (and you won't get there again until you hit 466fsb), so that's definitely a plus. Latencies don't matter too too much with c2d's (they still do, but if you can gain a lot more speed, then it'd be better off). That said, a 33mhz difference might not be enough to overcome the weaker timings. And at the same time, when you run a ram divider other than 1:1, you're not making the most effective use by upscaling. So the 7x400 scenario would be your best bet.

That said, what voltages are you running for your ram? Also, what are your subtimings looking like? They could be set too aggressively, although from what I remember of the s3/ds3, subtimings are set by default pretty horribly weak.
 
Have you attempted to see what you could do for max fsb? How about higher than 2.8 or 3.0?

From your numbers, I'm assuming you're running 3ghz at 9x333 with 4:5 (2.5x) for ram, and 2.8ghz at 7x400 and 1:1 (2.0x) ram?

I can't recall how exactly the s3 responds to a native 200fsb running up there in terms of strap adjustments (internal motherboard latencies), so I don't know how well you'd scale (some have experienced a lot of success with a bsel modification with ink to trick the motherboard into thinking it's a 266fsb native cpu).

But at 400fsb, you should be having the best internal latencies (and you won't get there again until you hit 466fsb), so that's definitely a plus. Latencies don't matter too too much with c2d's (they still do, but if you can gain a lot more speed, then it'd be better off). That said, a 33mhz difference might not be enough to overcome the weaker timings. And at the same time, when you run a ram divider other than 1:1, you're not making the most effective use by upscaling. So the 7x400 scenario would be your best bet.

That said, what voltages are you running for your ram? Also, what are your subtimings looking like? They could be set too aggressively, although from what I remember of the s3/ds3, subtimings are set by default pretty horribly weak.

I can't run the 7x400 because the mobo just won't let me do the 400fsb. the 2.88 scenario was running it with a fsb of 320 and setting the ram to 2.5, effectively 800mhz. To have it stable, my current voltage for my ram is +.2 (runs at 2.0 i think) and for the cpu is set at 1.55v. (i have the oem chip so it needs more volts to be stable than the retail).

My temps however are in the mid 20's idle and max 55 C on load. I ran OCCT and it never got above 55. Should i be concerned with my volts even though the temps are more than okay?

Unfortunately for the S3, you can't manually set the ram timings, at the 3.0ghz, it has a frequency of 416, 4:5 ratio and 5-6-6-17.

At the 2.88, the ram settings are 5-5-5-15, but the ratio is still some 4:5, not 1:1.
 
I've always solved that problem by running a memory benchmark like everest or sandra. At each speed, do say 10 runs and record the highest numbers. whichever comes out with the highest score is the better speed to run at. With the rig in my sig, I can raise the FSB, but to do that I have to loosen my timings, and since I can only get about 5 more mhz fsb out, it's not enough to even the performance out.
 
I can't run the 7x400 because the mobo just won't let me do the 400fsb. the 2.88 scenario was running it with a fsb of 320 and setting the ram to 2.5, effectively 800mhz. To have it stable, my current voltage for my ram is +.2 (runs at 2.0 i think) and for the cpu is set at 1.55v. (i have the oem chip so it needs more volts to be stable than the retail).

My temps however are in the mid 20's idle and max 55 C on load. I ran OCCT and it never got above 55. Should i be concerned with my volts even though the temps are more than okay?

Unfortunately for the S3, you can't manually set the ram timings, at the 3.0ghz, it has a frequency of 416, 4:5 ratio and 5-6-6-17.

At the 2.88, the ram settings are 5-5-5-15, but the ratio is still some 4:5, not 1:1.


lol next time you're in the bios, hit ctrl-f1. as for not being able to scale that high in fsb, if you drop to 7x multiplier, what's roughly the max fsb you can obtain? use 1:1 (2.00x)

set as follows:
vcore 1.5v
vmch +0.3v
vfsb +0.3v
vpcie +0.1v
vdimm +0.3v
pcie @ 105
multiplier at 7x.

what's the maximum fsb you can obtain?
 
lol next time you're in the bios, hit ctrl-f1. as for not being able to scale that high in fsb, if you drop to 7x multiplier, what's roughly the max fsb you can obtain? use 1:1 (2.00x)

set as follows:
vcore 1.5v
vmch +0.3v
vfsb +0.3v
vpcie +0.1v
vdimm +0.3v
pcie @ 105
multiplier at 7x.

what's the maximum fsb you can obtain?

I WISH i could try that, but man for some reason the mobo is so flaky, it took me a lot of work to get it up to FSB333. For some reason, if i just right in, it will not save my overclock settings, so i have to do 310 and do a step process slowly raising it to 333. Took me HOURS... i dunno if i want to go through all that again ahahah. I'll see, but thanks so much for your help. I might try those, from what i remember 7x415 won't post either. It just reverts the fsb back to 200. Like i said.. my mobo has a hard time saving my settings.
 
should i be concerned with the fact that i'm pumping 1.55 volts to my CPU even though the temps are great?
 
It's possible you need to manipulate your bsel pins to trick the board into thinking it's native 266. It may not be adjusting strap properly.

What bios are you using anyway?

Yeah I agree, the s3/ds3 is extremely flakey. When it works, it works wonderfully. But there's only a thin line between disaster
 
It's possible you need to manipulate your bsel pins to trick the board into thinking it's native 266. It may not be adjusting strap properly.

What bios are you using anyway?

Yeah I agree, the s3/ds3 is extremely flakey. When it works, it works wonderfully. But there's only a thin line between disaster

Currently, i'm running F8 on the S3. I'm scared of modding the pins and what not.. im kind of a nOOb when it comes physical modding. Yeah, i PRAY everytime i overclock, the computer doesnt shut off, cause then when it does... i resets my settings... sucks bad. I'm happy it's running correctly at 3.0ghz... stable with OCCT 30min test. I think i'm just gonna keep it as is, but yeah i would LOVE to run 400x8 = 3.2 and 1:1.. but alas... just a pipe dream.
 
Back
Top