Best Upgrade Path: Physx card, or two new GPUs

herald

n00b
Joined
Dec 28, 2002
Messages
38
Now this is not a simple choice! :)

I'm running a modestly oc'ed system. The key specs are:
ASUS Crosshair Mobo
AMD Athlon 64 X2 6000 @ 3.3 GHz
4GB of Corsair TwinX DDR 6400
4 Seagate 320Gb HDs in a RAID 0
Sound Blaster Fatality
3 DVD drive (2 ROM, 1 RW)
Thermaltake 850w PSU
and two "old school" BFG 8800GTS OC with 640Mb each

So I'm thinking - should I buy an ASUS Agiea Physx Card for $120?
or upgrade the GPU's (which would probably also necessitate a bigger PSU)

Its a question of balancing performance and cost - i.e. whats my most cost effective upgrade path from here? It should also be noted that my LCD is a Samsung 245BW, which limits me to 1920x1200

I await your opinions on this one!
 
Upgrade to a single 4870 X2 or 2x GTX260s in SLI... PhysX cards still, and IMO forever will, do relatively little.
 
Any of this ati 4000 series will run fine on that psu. You could always grab a pair of 4850s and have a kick ass setup for about 400 bucks.
 
To be honest, this all depends on what graphics cards you are going to be putting into your system. For example, you could sneak in two 8800 Ultras and still have enough power to handle max loads. On the other hand if you are going to be installing two 4870s or god forbid two 4870X2s then you would definitely have to upgrade your PSU. It seems physx is important to you, so you should really try to kill two birds with one stone by picking up a couple of nvidia cards for their added physx software. On the other hand, you could pick up one of the new 4870s that come equipped with 1GB of DDR5 for about $290. In my opinion, that is the card to get right now.

As you could probably tell, I don't suggest getting a Physx card as it will not effect your in-game performance nearly as much as a set of new graphics cards.
 
yeah, no need for a ppu card. you can run physx off your 2x 8800gts 640mb if you wanted to, and it would work just as well. if you still wanted to run physx, the gtx series will work even better. question is are you just upgrading for the fun of it, or is there a game or games you want to run better, or with physx support?
 
If u have extra money to speare, ppls selling their agiea physx card on ebay for less than $50 shipped... newer nvidia gpus all have CUDA sdk intergrated...
 
To be honest, this all depends on what graphics cards you are going to be putting into your system. For example, you could sneak in two 8800 Ultras and still have enough power to handle max loads. On the other hand if you are going to be installing two 4870s or god forbid two 4870X2s then you would definitely have to upgrade your PSU. It seems physx is important to you, so you should really try to kill two birds with one stone by picking up a couple of nvidia cards for their added physx software. On the other hand, you could pick up one of the new 4870s that come equipped with 1GB of DDR5 for about $290. In my opinion, that is the card to get right now.

As you could probably tell, I don't suggest getting a Physx card as it will not effect your in-game performance nearly as much as a set of new graphics cards.

You could run a system with 2 4870x2's in crossfire X on a 850 watt psu. [H]ard did it in their 4870x2 preview review here
 
Back
Top