Best Upgrade from 9700 Pro

guito13

Midnight Mulcher
2FA
Joined
Jan 6, 2004
Messages
7,586
Hey All,

I have had my 9700 Pro for a couple years now but lately my games (farcry, wow) have been freezing up. I reduced the acceleration and removed some settings from the games to make them more stable.

I do not want to have to deal with this so I think the time has come to upgrade cards. What do you think is the best card / value to upgrade to.

I have no restrictions other than that it has to be an AGP card. It will be paired up with a A64 3200+ on a gigabyte board with a gig of shitty ram on a 2005FPW.

Thanks!
 
bradyapba said:
All depends how much dough you got to spend. Whats your price range?

I really dont have one however I dont want to spend any more than i have to. I just need something that runs smoothly in 1680x1050 on high settings in Farcry and WoW.

Thank you in advance for your help.
 
You're probably going to want either a X800 XL, or a 6800GT. They both seem to deliver roughly the same performance, give or take a game, but the 6800GT is a tad more expensive (at least as i have noticed). The any of the X800 XL's are probably ok, but for the 6800GT, i would try to get eitehr the asus one, or the BFG OC series. STAY AWAY FROM THE PNY CARDS, they seem to have a reputation for capacitors falling off.

I personally would go with the 6800 GT, as it runs the Open GL stuff better than its radeon counterparts. Open GL means, DOOM 3, QUAKE 4, etc. the 6800 gt also has shader model 3.0, and support for HDR lighting. the X800 XL does not have those features as i recall.

Barring those feature discrepancies, if all your going to play is direct x games, go with the X800 XL.

Good luck
 
Well here are some reviews for you.

WOW - which pretty much breaks down to this, if you want 16x12 and all the eye candy on... the ATi 800's and the 6800 GT ran it in the 45-50 FPS range, and the ATI 850's and the 6800 Ultra ran it in 55 FPS.

Surprisingly the 6600 GT ran it at 43 FPS.. which is decent considering its half the price of a 6800 GT..... which leads me to think a 6800 NU at about $200, can run WOW near 50 FPS as well... If it was me i might buy a 6800 NU, try to unlock the pipes/ at least OC it, and it should give you the 50 FPS that a GT could. But that being said, you could OC a 6800 GT and get 60 FPS... But for $300, instead of $200.

http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2381&p=6


Heres their Far Cry comparision of the 800 XL and the 6800 GT at 1600x1200

http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2299&p=6

Pretty close either way...with the 6800 GT getting a decent edge with no AA or AF on at 16x12 (60 FPS compared to 54).

I would bet a 6800 NU would get you in the 50's as well.


So if it was me, I would go with a 6800 NU, for $200. If you need that little extra then go with a 6800 GT for around $300.

Thats my suggestions.

Chris
 
My PNY card plays about 6 hours of WoW a day for several months now without an issue. The caps falling off were with a black Friday, 6800NU deal.
 
Actually, you guys are wrong about the 6800 NU. The 6800 NU is actually slower than the 6600GT due to the 6800 NU's extremely low memory bandwidth. The 6800 NU uses regular DDR memory, which has a much lower theoretical maximum transfer rate than the GDDR3 memory used in the 6600GT. Second, the 6800's memory runs at a molasses-slow 300MHz (600MHz effective), versus the 6600GT's memory clockspeed of 550MHz (1.1GHz effective). Both of those factors add up to a higher-numbered GPU which underperforms a lower-numbered GPU.

(Note that I'm referring to a stock 6800 NU versus a stock 6600GT. You'll need to unlock the remaining 4 pipes on that 6800 NU just to even come close to equalling the performance of a stock 6600GT.)
 
E4g1e said:
Actually, you guys are wrong about the 6800 NU. The 6800 NU is actually slower than the 6600GT due to the 6800 NU's extremely low memory bandwidth. The 6800 NU uses regular DDR memory, which has a much lower theoretical maximum transfer rate than the GDDR3 memory used in the 6600GT. Second, the 6800's memory runs at a molasses-slow 300MHz (600MHz effective), versus the 6600GT's memory clockspeed of 550MHz (1.1GHz effective). Both of those factors add up to a higher-numbered GPU which underperforms a lower-numbered GPU.

(Note that I'm referring to a stock 6800 NU versus a stock 6600GT. You'll need to unlock the remaining 4 pipes on that 6800 NU just to even come close to equalling the performance of a stock 6600GT.)

you are compairing a 6800nu PCI Express to a 6600GT
he is looking for 6800nu AGP... so stock core clock is 700mhz not 600... and im also supposing u just threw the 12 pixel pipelines out the window to put the 6600GT above it like that huh?

i have a 6800nu PCI express in one of my minis that i upgraded from a 6600GT and it IS an upgrade (ever so slight) but still an upgrade... i have only run into 1 review that rates the 6800nu lower than the 6600gt and thats toms hardwares latest PCIe VGA charts... and they were obviously somokin some funky stuff to come up with the results they did, as my mini with the 6800nu PCIe was at least 10-15% faster than their 6800nu in their tests and that is with my 6800nu machine being slower than their test machine...
 
My PNY card plays about 6 hours of WoW a day for several months now without an issue. The caps falling off were with a black Friday, 6800NU deal.

Agreed. I too have a PNY, have had it since Black friday even... and it runs great, all caps in place... and it OC'ing awesome too.

Actually, you guys are wrong about the 6800 NU. The 6800 NU is actually slower than the 6600GT due to the 6800 NU's extremely low memory bandwidth. The 6800 NU uses regular DDR memory, which has a much lower theoretical maximum transfer rate than the GDDR3 memory used in the 6600GT. Second, the 6800's memory runs at a molasses-slow 300MHz (600MHz effective), versus the 6600GT's memory clockspeed of 550MHz (1.1GHz effective). Both of those factors add up to a higher-numbered GPU which underperforms a lower-numbered GPU.

(Note that I'm referring to a stock 6800 NU versus a stock 6600GT. You'll need to unlock the remaining 4 pipes on that 6800 NU just to even come close to equalling the performance of a stock 6600GT.)

Eagle, I have no idea where you are getting that info. Please show me a review ANYWHERE where a stock 6600gt beats out a 6800 NU. ANYWHERE.

You have your facts right, but your analysis wrong. The only thing that the 6600 GT has going for it over the NU is the clock speed on the memory., you are right. But, it doesn't make up for the extra 4 pipes, and the 256 K bus. The 128 k bus on the 6600 gt is its limiting factor. Think of it as a funnel. No matter how much Water you have (speed of the mem chips) if you cant get it through the funnel(128 K), you get a back up. The 6800 Nu's Funnel is twice as big(256 K), and its got more push (12 pipes vs 8) to pump the water through.

Also the AGP version of the 6800 nu (which is what the poster needs) is 700 on the mem, not 600 like the PCI-e version.


The 6600 GT in no way can compete with a 6800 NU, electronically, just not possible.

Chris
 
bradyapba said:
Agreed. I too have a PNY, have had it since Black friday even... and it runs great, all caps in place... and it OC'ing awesome too.



Eagle, I have no idea where you are getting that info. Please show me a review ANYWHERE where a stock 6600gt beats out a 6800 NU. ANYWHERE.

You have your facts right, but your analysis wrong. The only thing that the 6600 GT has going for it over the NU is the clock speed on the memory., you are right. But, it doesn't make up for the extra 4 pipes, and the 256 K bus. The 128 k bus on the 6600 gt is its limiting factor. Think of it as a funnel. No matter how much Water you have (speed of the mem chips) if you cant get it through the funnel(128 K), you get a back up. The 6800 Nu's Funnel is twice as big(256 K), and its got more push (12 pipes vs 8) to pump the water through.

Also the AGP version of the 6800 nu (which is what the poster needs) is 700 on the mem, not 600 like the PCI-e version.


The 6600 GT in no way can compete with a 6800 NU, electronically, just not possible.

Chris
I was referring to a PCI-Express 6600GT versus a PCI-Express 6800 NU. (In that case, the 6800 NU would be bottlenecked not only by the significantly lower memory bandwidth, but also by the AGP-to-PCIe bridge.)

If these were AGP versions of those two cards, then things become different. (The AGP 6600GT uses a PCIe-to-AGP bridge, in this case.) The AGP 6800 NU, on the other hand, runs its memory at a slightly faster 350MHz (700MHz effective), and its GPU core speed is also slightly faster. Worse for the AGP 6600GT, many such cards run at (slightly) slower GPU speeds than the norm for PCIe versions of the same card. Thus, in the case of the AGP 6600GT vs. 6800 NU, things will become topsy-turnvy.

Same thing happens with a 6800GT versus a Radeon X800XL: The 6800GT is faster than an X800XL (except in perhaps HL2) in AGP - but an X800XL equals or beats a 6800GT (except in Doom3) in PCIe. That's due to the bridge chips used in the PCIe 6800GT and the AGP X800XL. Get it?
 
yup, thats exactly what i was thinking, a 6800 Nu for around $200. The evga gets decent reviews as well, and does unlock the pipes.... i think thats a very good card for the price!

thats what I would recommend, other wise your looking at about $290 for the next set of cards up, and i cant see spending the Extra dough.

Chris
 
guito13 said:
Thanks guys. Please, no !!!!!! stuff just need an agp card that can work well with new games on the 2005FPW at 1680 x 1050.

What do you think about this?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130202

Thats the 6800NU that we were telling you about. it has 12 pixel piupes, clocked at 325 mhz. it has 128 mb of DDR mem on a 256 bit bus.

If money isnt really a factor like you said, then i might go with this 6800GT, more bang to play with

it has 16 pixel pipes at 325 mhz, and 256 of DDR3. so for 100 dollars more, you're getting 4 more pipes, and a metric shitton more memory bandwidth. An in my opinion, worth the extra money. It would be my choice to go with. but the card you picked out aint bad either. so do what you want.
 
CodeWaste said:
Thats the 6800NU that we were telling you about. it has 12 pixel piupes, clocked at 325 mhz. it has 128 mb of DDR mem on a 256 bit bus.

If money isnt really a factor like you said, then i might go with this 6800GT, more bang to play with

it has 16 pixel pipes at 325 mhz, and 256 of DDR3. so for 100 dollars more, you're getting 4 more pipes, and a metric shitton more memory bandwidth. An in my opinion, worth the extra money. It would be my choice to go with. but the card you picked out aint bad either. so do what you want.
Actually, the standard 6800GT GPU runs at 350 MHz, not 325 MHz. My particular 6800GT is factory-overclocked to 370MHz on the GPU.
 
E4g1e said:
Actually, the standard 6800GT GPU runs at 350 MHz, not 325 MHz. My particular 6800GT is factory-overclocked to 370MHz on the GPU.


Duh, thanks, i forgot about that. yeah guito13, make sure, if you get the 6800gt, to get one that specifically lists 350 on the core mhz. the bfg oc ones will be higher by 20 mhz for 370. dont get the one i linked to.
 
Same thing happens with a 6800GT versus a Radeon X800XL: The 6800GT is faster than an X800XL in AGP - but an X800XL equals or beats a 6800GT (except in Doom3) in PCIe. That's due to the bridge chips used in the PCIe 6800GT and the AGP X800XL. Get it?

I most certainly get it.

But in the posters 1st post it says
I have no restrictions other than that it has to be an AGP card

So why even bother to bring PCI-e into the discussion? All it does is confuse the issue, and bring up points and fact that has nothing to do with the posters question, and leads him to a misinformed choice.


If money isnt really a factor like you said, then i might go with this 6800GT, more bang to play with

Hes right, definately more bang for the buck... but also 47% more expensive. Increasing your cost almost 50%... are you going to get 50% improvement? Say from 50 to 75 FPS? Probably not. Thats why i think the 6800NU is the best bang for the buck. Certainly the 6800gt will be more powerful, all depends if you want to spend the $$.
 
bradyapba said:
I most certainly get it.

But in the posters 1st post it says


So why even bother to bring PCI-e into the discussion? All it does is confuse the issue, and bring up points and fact that has nothing to do with the posters question, and leads him to a misinformed choice.




Hes right, definately more bang for the buck... but also 47% more expensive. Increasing your cost almost 50%... are you going to get 50% improvement? Say from 50 to 75 FPS? Probably not. Thats why i think the 6800NU is the best bang for the buck. Certainly the 6800gt will be more powerful, all depends if you want to spend the $$.


he did say the ONLY restriction was that it had to be AGP. if money was a concern, i think he would have said so. I mean, we could reccomend that he get the 6800 ultra, but the performance increase there does not warrent even greater amount of money increase.
 
bradyapba said:
But in the posters 1st post it says
I've re-read the AGP part. I did not read it when I made my previous posts. So ignore most of what I said previously, except for the AGP-relevant parts of my posts.

In this case, between the 6800 NU and the 6600GT, I'd go for the 6800 NU. (Unless that 6800 NU is out of the OP's budget, in which case I'd recommend waiting till the prices drop.)
 
CodeWaste said:
he did say the ONLY restriction was that it had to be AGP. if money was a concern, i think he would have said so. I mean, we could reccomend that he get the 6800 ultra, but the performance increase there does not warrent even greater amount of money increase.


Money is not a factor but i dont want to blow cash if i wont see a good improvement over a 9700 Pro. Basically, I want something that will be VERY noticably better than my 9700 pro while not buying the top notch that has very insignificant differences over the next grade card.

AGP is a must, that is all. Please only talk about that since I do not have a PCIe board.

I appreciate all your comments!
 
guito13 said:
Money is not a factor but i dont want to blow cash if i wont see a good improvement over a 9700 Pro. Basically, I want something that will be VERY noticably better than my 9700 pro while not buying the top notch that has very insignificant differences over the next grade card.

AGP is a must, that is all. Please only talk about that since I do not have a PCIe board.

I appreciate all your comments!

The 6800GT is literally double the performance of your 9700 pro. The difference in performance will be amazing
 
guito13 said:
Money is not a factor but i dont want to blow cash if i wont see a good improvement over a 9700 Pro. Basically, I want something that will be VERY noticably better than my 9700 pro while not buying the top notch that has very insignificant differences over the next grade card.

AGP is a must, that is all. Please only talk about that since I do not have a PCIe board.

I appreciate all your comments!
I stand corrected on my previous posts. If you have an almost limitless budget on an AGP card, then you'll need to upgrade to at least a GeForce 6800GT just to substantially outperform your current Radeon 9700 Pro. (The 6800NU will outperform your 9700P, but it's a tough call as to whether the performance increase is worth the going prices on the 6800NU.)
 
guito13 said:
I am leaning towards this:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16814130203

Any objections / suggestions before i get it?
That's one of the "standard" 6800GT cards which many of us [H] users have had success in overclocking. Some of those get overclocked by their owners to over 400MHz GPU and over 550MHz (1.1GHz effective) memory clockspeeds - roughly the level of a 6800 Ultra.
 
1. Objections - none.

2. Suggestions - Buy me one too!

Yes, that will be a very nice upgrade over your old card!!! you will see a noticable improvement.
 
Yeah that's good... I can play Far Cry at 1680x1050 on a 6800GT...

but, I can't have any antialiasing at that res. Guito, If AA is important to you, you might be better off going wtih the AGP x850xt for $100 more.

In any case, either card is leaps and bounds better than the 9700pro
 
Sorry to throw something new into the mix but, newegg also has deals on the AGP X800XT AIW's and they are going for around 330 after 50$ rebates. These cards are faster than the 6800GT's in most cases and they have TV tuners. NOrmally they run around 400$ so its a great deal. As for the 6800NU, I think the 128MB ram will limit you if you run that big LCD at native resoultion. 128 isn't enough for current games at high resoulutions and surely wont be much good for next years games at 1600x1050.
 
Zinn said:
Yeah that's good... I can play Far Cry at 1680x1050 on a 6800GT...

but, I can't have any antialiasing at that res. Guito, If AA is important to you, you might be better off going wtih the AGP x850xt for $100 more.

In any case, either card is leaps and bounds better than the 9700pro

I am not a videocard guy by any means. Will antialiasing give me significantly better graphics and or speed?
 
"anti alaising" is something you can turn on and off inside a game.

It improves graphics smoothing edges, etc...

it signifigantly reduces speed :)
 
banned_user said:
Sorry to throw something new into the mix but, newegg also has deals on the AGP X800XT AIW's and they are going for around 330 after 50$ rebates. These cards are faster than the 6800GT's in most cases and they have TV tuners. NOrmally they run around 400$ so its a great deal. As for the 6800NU, I think the 128MB ram will limit you if you run that big LCD at native resoultion. 128 isn't enough for current games at high resoulutions and surely wont be much good for next years games at 1600x1050.

I dont need a tuner, i already have a PVR card, but thank you. Who else thinks the X800XT > 6800GT based on numbers not personal preference?
 
guito13 said:
I am not a videocard guy by any means. Will antialiasing give me significantly better graphics and or speed?

Antialiasing reduces the jaggieness of the graphics on the screen. because of games being rendered as pixels, which work in a grid fashon, there is a jaggieness to the graphics as they are drawn.

think of a staircase from from the side. there is an up and over jagged line. what antialiasing does is draw smaller squares between the big ones so that from farther away, the diagonal line that follows the stairs looks less broken. im probably not explaining this well, perhaps someone else could do it better, but essentailly antialiasing and anistropic filtering are all graphics enhancements.
 
We're rumored to be a month away from a new Nvidia card. If it comes out June 22, you might see better prices or a faster card.

I'd hold out if you can.
 
Go for the 6800GT as it is the best performance vs. price for AGP. At a tad above $300 the 6800GT will run everything you throw at it without spending the cash to pump out an extra 10-15FPS in games.

The 6800GT is your best bet, however if it was PCI-E I9 would suggest getting the X800XL because it's cheaper and outperformans the 6800GT which is more expensive.

Bottom line: 6800GT AGP.
 
BloodRayne said:
Go for the 6800GT as it is the best performance vs. price for AGP. At a tad above $300 the 6800GT will run everything you throw at it without spending the cash to pump out an extra 10-15FPS in games.

The 6800GT is your best bet, however if it was PCI-E I9 would suggest getting the X800XL because it's cheaper and outperformans the 6800GT which is more expensive.

Bottom line: 6800GT AGP.

There is a X800XL that is agp, i have seen them at best buy.
 
CodeWaste said:
There is a X800XL that is agp, i have seen them at best buy.

I dont think he ever said there isnt an AGP version but said that for AGP the 6800GT performs better
 
Yes, I'm aware that there is an AGP version fo the X800XL, but my choice would be a 6800GT for an AGP card since they are both in the same price range and the 6800GT still has a slightly better performance. My choice would still be the 6800GT instead of X800XL. Although these cards are very similar you would also have the choice of X800XL, my choice would be the 6800GT altough between these cards it's all about preference.
 
6800 GT

or

6800 regular (6800 OC by bfg is very good)

if you cant afford one of those try

6600GT
 
I say get your computer working stably first before you buy ANYTHING. Chances are that something else is destabilizing the system. What makes you suspect its the 9700 pro?
 
Back
Top