Best storage solution to move OS off data drive

nerr

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 19, 2008
Messages
216
I've got three 1TB drives and one 640GB drive in my home server right now. The model is an Acer easyStore H340, with an additional 4-bay enclosure attached via eSATA, allowing for eight devices total. One of the 1TB drives contains both my operating system (Ubuntu Server 10.04 LTS) and a fair amount of data. I'd like to move the operating system to its own storage device, allowing me to use that drive purely for data, as with the other 3 hard drives in the system.

What would be the best (small) storage solution to keep my operating system away from my data drives? To put this in perspective, I only have about 10GB total to store, between operating system, swap, and a small home partition. The way I see it, there are four solutions:

1) 16GB OCZ Diesel USB flash drive, it's about two years old, and I don't use it. ($0) I could always buy a new one for about $20-$40.
2) 16GB CompactFlash card with SATA adapter (~$50)
3) 80GB SATA HDD (~$50)
4) Small SSD ($80-$100)

Which of these solutions would make the most sense? Using my flash drive or CompactFlash worries me, as I don't need these wearing out and taking my OS with them, although I will have system image backups on one or more of the data drives. The HDD is viable, although I'd prefer not to have a full-size mechanical drive generating a lot of unnecessary heat and noise. SSD is also an option, but I feel it'd be overkill for a home server.

Pros and cons, or proposed solutions would be appreciated! Thank you very much!
 
My linux system ran 2 4GB CF cards in RAID0 for a couple years. 8GB of space at fist was more than enough. But later I upgraded system to do more and 8GB was no longer enough. I ended up buying a 32GB Jmicron SSD and that was a mistake, and now I have a 40GB Intel SSD for piece of mind.

So anyways, I'd recommend just buying a 40GB Intel SSD. Its not THAT expensive, and in the long run will be worth it.
 
Last edited:
An SSD would be a wonderful choice, but at $120, it's a little more than I'd like to spend just to get my operating system off my data drive. That, coupled with the fact that I'd want to put the SSD in my desktop/laptop before server makes it a tough choice to swallow. :p
 
Several USB flash pendrives in RAID would seem a simple, fast (access times) and cheap solution. Though keep in mind these simple pendrives likely have high write amplification and simple wear leveling; so they could run out of write cycles pretty soon. Try to keep writes to the filesystem to a minimum.
 
Purchase a 16GB flash drive that has a physical lock button so you can prevent (or control) your OS changes.

This idea is wonderful when you have an external facing web server. Every other day i just reboot the server, it boots off of the read only thumb and I dont have to worry about virus, hax, etc. Load it on an internal PC, change what needs to be changed, lock it again and throw it back in the server and boot it.
 
Back
Top