Best "short" video card?

mavalpha

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Jan 3, 2005
Messages
10,448
Trying to put together an ultra-compact gaming rig, and found an unexpected constraint: the length of the card. Double-slot is fine, but I don't have room beyond the PCIe connector. I wanted to put in a 9600GT or similar, but it's just too long.

Here are my options:
X800/X850
X1650XT
3650
7600GT
8600GTS

Which would you recommend? I don't particularly care about DX10 support, as I don't play any brand-spanking-new games that will utilize it. I really wish I could fit that Galaxy 8800GT in, but no dice. :(

This will probably be paired up with an e6600, and either 2GB or 4GB of RAM. Most frequently played game, I'm guessing UT3.
 
How long is too long? Dimensions would be nice.

You might want to check out the 8800GS. It's shorter than the GT.
 
Nope, the GS is still too long. Don't have numbers yet, the board is coming in this week.
It's a picoBTX build (Intel DG965PZ) with a Type II (low profile) heatsink; if the card is too long, it'll hit the CPU cooler.
If I had to guess, I'd say I had around 200mm.
 
Out of those, probably the 8600GTS or 3650 (haven't seen too many benchmarks...
 
What board and cooler are you trying to use? Ive fit bigger cards with picobtx and you shouldnt have an issue as long as nothing from the case gets in the way. I just recently crammed a Ninja and 7950gt into a nanobtx build without an issue.

Apollo makes some shorter 38x0 series cads. They are considered lower quality but should perform better then the cards you specified. Id also look into some non-reference 38x0, such as the apollos, or 8800 cards as you may get lucky. Sometimes these will come in smaller then the reference designs. Asus also just debut the 3850 mobile card for pc which is suppose to be shorter. Smaller form factor then a traditional pc graphic card and should also have lower heat/power consumption to boot.
 
here is a small card i have it its only an inch and a half past the slot
http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?WebProductID=770334
Saw it, but doesn't look like it'll be available State-side. :( Just in case, though- where did you buy yours? Maybe I could arrange overseas shipping...
What board and cooler are you trying to use? Ive fit bigger cards with picobtx and you shouldnt have an issue as long as nothing from the case gets in the way. I just recently crammed a Ninja and 7950gt into a nanobtx build without an issue.
Intel DG965PZ, reference design Type II heatsink in an Aopen B200 case (with a riser card). And Picobtx is smaller than Nanobtx, though not by much.
Apollo makes some shorter 38x0 series cads. They are considered lower quality but should perform better then the cards you specified. Id also look into some non-reference 38x0, such as the apollos, or 8800 cards as you may get lucky. Sometimes these will come in smaller then the reference designs. Asus also just debut the 3850 mobile card for pc which is suppose to be shorter. Smaller form factor then a traditional pc graphic card and should also have lower heat/power consumption to boot.
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?p=1032477664
Yep, saw both of those. Asus' is just a proof-of-concept unfortunately, and Apollo/Triplex is impossible to get in the US.
 
I think the 9600GSO will be short enough. It's the same card as the 8800GS, but the PCB has been shortened to reduce costs. Probably worth waiting for. The 8800GS is a pretty fast card (for lower resolutions).
 
Out of those, probably the 8600GTS or 3650 (haven't seen too many benchmarks...

Searching for a relatively cheap card, I gave the 3650 a shot. I was unimpressed; mediocre framerate on medium settings in Oblivion. Although, my rig is more of a tarted up e-machines box: 3.3 ghz celeron processor, 2 gigs ram. I installed an 8800GT, and a new power supply and it runs almost flawlessly.

I already returned the 3650, so I can't give any dimensions, but it was really small. I just barely passed the hook at the end of the PCI-E connector.
 
i bought it from overclockers.co.uk mate i will be selling it soon if you want to buy it and pay for shipping
 
Where are the 9600GSO available? Don’t see them state side. I have mini tower that can take only cards 8600gt and smaller in length because of the hdd cage.
 
I asked the same question over a week ago on my picoBTX build. I found a really low cost HD 2600XT 256MB card at buy.com. It's only ~1.25" longer than the x16 PCI-E slot (the connector, not including the retainer tab next to it). It fits perfectly in my AOpen B200 case:



It's only $20AR using google checkout, or $5AR if you have a $25 off $75 coupon in your google checkout account like I had. http://www.buy.com/prod/diamond-vip...it-800-mhz-pci-e-x16/q/loc/101/205073855.html The picture is wrong. The card uses a smaller heatsink and PCB like the one pictured above.

The 8600GTS is faster, and if it fits in your case, that's probably a better choice. I had an 8600GT that fit, but one of the PSU rails was too weak to power it. I needed something that could be powered off the slot. It might work, but I don't want to fry the PSU. It would be expensive to replace.

edit: I just read your other post above. I have the same set up: DG965PZ in a B200 case. :D You'll need to be careful of the power rating of the card you plug in. While the ATX 12v plug (12V2) has 13.5A, the other rail (12V1) is only rated at 5.0A. That's why I didn't plug my 8600GT, which requires a molex plug, into the system.

There's not enough clearance for longer cards like the 9600GSO above the type II cooler. Components like capacitors and heatsinks get in the way.
 
The 2600XT and the HD3650 are pretty much the same card, but the HD3650 has lower power requirements, is a tad faster and smaller*? Sounds like the HD3650 is a good bet for this mobo/power supply. It performs about on par with the 8600GTS.

I love the super mirco size pc in the pic above. Might have to biuld me one for my living room media center.
 
You're recommending an S3 graphics card? That is the slowest card on the market, even slower than a geforce 8400gs or radeon 3450.
 
Where are the 9600GSO available? Don’t see them state side. I have mini tower that can take only cards 8600gt and smaller in length because of the hdd cage.
the 8800gs and 9600gso use the same pcb. they are the same cards just renamed.
 
I asked the same question over a week ago on my picoBTX build. I found a really low cost HD 2600XT 256MB card at buy.com. It's only ~1.25" longer than the x16 PCI-E slot (the connector, not including the retainer tab next to it). It fits perfectly in my AOpen B200 case:

http://img117.imageshack.us/img117/7206/2600xtshortgx9.th.jpg

It's only $20AR using google checkout, or $5AR if you have a $25 off $75 coupon in your google checkout account like I had. http://www.buy.com/prod/diamond-vip...it-800-mhz-pci-e-x16/q/loc/101/205073855.html The picture is wrong. The card uses a smaller heatsink and PCB like the one pictured above.

The 8600GTS is faster, and if it fits in your case, that's probably a better choice. I had an 8600GT that fit, but one of the PSU rails was too weak to power it. I needed something that could be powered off the slot. It might work, but I don't want to fry the PSU. It would be expensive to replace.

edit: I just read your other post above. I have the same set up: DG965PZ in a B200 case. :D You'll need to be careful of the power rating of the card you plug in. While the ATX 12v plug (12V2) has 13.5A, the other rail (12V1) is only rated at 5.0A. That's why I didn't plug my 8600GT, which requires a molex plug, into the system.

There's not enough clearance for longer cards like the 9600GSO above the type II cooler. Components like capacitors and heatsinks get in the way.
sorry but Im confused. first off the 2600xt and 8600gt use within 5 watts of each so that makes no sense. also the 8600gt does NOT have a molex plug. it is powered only by the slot. :confused:
 
cannondale06 said:
sorry but Im confused.
Sorry, I can't help with that. :p
first off the 2600xt and 8600gt use within 5 watts of each so that makes no sense. also the 8600gt does NOT have a molex plug. it is powered only by the slot.
The eVGA 8600GT 512MB card I have right in front of me has a molex connector just like pictured in these links: http://www.mwave.com/Mwave/Skusearch.hmx?scriteria=AA71674 or http://www.buy.com/prod/evga-e-gefo...al-dvi-sli-supported/q/loc/101/205483824.html or http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/searchtools/item-Details.asp?EdpNo=3301408 It's not too useful to argue that since I have the card right in front of me. :p And it's not ornamental; I can see the 12V traces from the molex plug go directly to the power supply section of the card.

Another thing that might not "make sense" is the rating on the PSU. As I mentioned, the 12V1 rail has a 5.0A rating (60W) and 12V2 rail has a 13.5A rating (162W). Since I'm using a hard drive, DVD burner and have a couple of fans shared on that 12V1 rail, I don't feel comfortable plugging in a 12V1 rail molex connector to the video card.

Like I said, it may work but I don't want to risk blowing out the PSU. Like most very SFF cases, it uses a custom sized PSU. I *do* however feel comfortable plugging in a video card that's powered completely from the slot since the 12V2 rail has more than enough power. I'd be more than happy if you would like to send me a different 8600GT, but the one I have is not entirely powered by the slot. ;)
 
Sorry, I can't help with that. :pThe eVGA 8600GT 512MB card I have right in front of me has a molex connector just like pictured in these links: http://www.mwave.com/Mwave/Skusearch.hmx?scriteria=AA71674 or http://www.buy.com/prod/evga-e-gefo...al-dvi-sli-supported/q/loc/101/205483824.html or http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/searchtools/item-Details.asp?EdpNo=3301408 It's not too useful to argue that since I have the card right in front of me. :p And it's not ornamental; I can see the 12V traces from the molex plug go directly to the power supply section of the card.

Another thing that might not "make sense" is the rating on the PSU. As I mentioned, the 12V1 rail has a 5.0A rating (60W) and 12V2 rail has a 13.5A rating (162W). Since I'm using a hard drive, DVD burner and have a couple of fans shared on that 12V1 rail, I don't feel comfortable plugging in a 12V1 rail molex connector to the video card.

Like I said, it may work but I don't want to risk blowing out the PSU. Like most very SFF cases, it uses a custom sized PSU. I *do* however feel comfortable plugging in a video card that's powered completely from the slot since the 12V2 rail has more than enough power. I'd be more than happy if you would like to send me a different 8600GT, but the one I have is not entirely powered by the slot. ;)
well that is odd because I have never seen an 8600gt with molex connector. It certainly isnt needed because the card doesnt even draw 40 watts under load. In fact the 8600gt draws LESS power than the 2600xt gddr3 under load. :confused:

Edit: heres a link to a 2600xt gddr4 review. the gddr4 uses less power than your gddr3 version and still consumes 1 more watt under load than the 8600gts. your 2600xt gddr3 will actually consume at least 5 watts more than the 8600gts. so the 8600gt will end up using much(10-15 watts) less power than your 2600xt. http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/radeon-hd2600xt-gddr4_5.html#sect0

Edit 2:yep even the 2600xt gddr4 uses 17 watts MORE than an 8600gt. so your 2600xt gddr3 actually uses around 20 watts more than 8600gt. http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3023&p=4

now is that enough proof that what you said makes no sense? the 8600gt uses 20 watts LESS power than your 2600xt gddr3. ;)
 
edit: I just read your other post above. I have the same set up: DG965PZ in a B200 case. :D You'll need to be careful of the power rating of the card you plug in. While the ATX 12v plug (12V2) has 13.5A, the other rail (12V1) is only rated at 5.0A. That's why I didn't plug my 8600GT, which requires a molex plug, into the system.

There's not enough clearance for longer cards like the 9600GSO above the type II cooler. Components like capacitors and heatsinks get in the way.
I picked up a $33 X1650XT for now, buying an 8600GT SSC next week off a buddy of mine. Thanks for the pic, definitely makes my life easier! Which CPU do you have in there?
i bought it from overclockers.co.uk mate i will be selling it soon if you want to buy it and pay for shipping
Could you measure the length, please?
Another thing that might not "make sense" is the rating on the PSU. As I mentioned, the 12V1 rail has a 5.0A rating (60W) and 12V2 rail has a 13.5A rating (162W). Since I'm using a hard drive, DVD burner and have a couple of fans shared on that 12V1 rail, I don't feel comfortable plugging in a 12V1 rail molex connector to the video card.
I ended up replacing my PSU; StarTech (ugh, but made by ATNG) makes a 350W CFX model with 10/16A rails. That's the highest-rated CFX supply I've seen, honestly. They're about $55 online, but I got lucky- MicroCenter carries them! I paid $20 on discount. :D
Like I said, it may work but I don't want to risk blowing out the PSU. Like most very SFF cases, it uses a custom sized PSU. I *do* however feel comfortable plugging in a video card that's powered completely from the slot since the 12V2 rail has more than enough power. I'd be more than happy if you would like to send me a different 8600GT, but the one I have is not entirely powered by the slot. ;)
I was thinking along similar guidelines. I'm still not sure which chip to put in there, though- I don't suppose you've tried putting in a Q6600 on that board? It isn't on the supported list, but it would be a nice surprise!

Oh, and pxc: why no wireless in yours? I'm buying a 4965AGN, and mounting some antennae in the low-profile PCI slot under the video.
 
I picked up a $33 X1650XT for now, buying an 8600GT SSC next week off a buddy of mine. Thanks for the pic, definitely makes my life easier! Which CPU do you have in there?

I ended up replacing my PSU; StarTech (ugh, but made by ATNG) makes a 350W CFX model with 10/16A rails. That's the highest-rated CFX supply I've seen, honestly. They're about $55 online, but I got lucky- MicroCenter carries them! I paid $20 on discount. :D

I was thinking along similar guidelines. I'm still not sure which chip to put in there, though- I don't suppose you've tried putting in a Q6600 on that board? It isn't on the supported list, but it would be a nice surprise!

Oh, and pxc: why no wireless in yours? I'm buying a 4965AGN, and mounting some antennae in the low-profile PCI slot under the video.
I have an E6600 in it right now. I haven't tried plugging in a Q6600, but I wouldn't be surprised if it worked. The stock 275W PSU could probably handle it. I already have 3 Q6600 systems and I don't need another. :p

I got a couple of those B200 cases for $37 each shipped. The 275W PSU is good enough for my uses and there's no longer any MC stores around here (couldn't compete with Fry's). I just wish the rails had slightly different ratings, but the board has to support power hungry Pentium D CPUs. Oh well. Hopefully mid-range next generation video cards are faster and won't require external power so I can upgrade.

I finally got a gigabit switch recently so I just wired it up to that. The system is probably going to be acting as a HTPC with remote internet access and i'd prefer to just leave it wired only. I have a second DG965PZ + E2200 + B200 I'm setting up that might get a WiFi PCI-E mini card.

------
cannondale06: It doesn't matter how little power the 8600GT uses when it's drawing current from a pretty constrained rail that I don't feel comfortable loading. It's not the amount of power that worries me, it where the power is coming from. :p During start up, all connected devices will almost certainly overload 12V1 with that 8600GT 512MB installed.

The performance difference doesn't bother me vs the 8600GT. I just hope when I plug it into my LCD HDTV that it doesn't turn the image purple like my old X1650 Pro HDMI did at 1920x1080/60p. :rolleyes:
 
------
cannondale06: It doesn't matter how little power the 8600GT uses when it's drawing current from a pretty constrained rail that I don't feel comfortable loading. It's not the amount of power that worries me, it where the power is coming from. :p During start up, all connected devices will almost certainly overload 12V1 with that 8600GT 512MB installed.

The performance difference doesn't bother me vs the 8600GT. I just hope when I plug it into my LCD HDTV that it doesn't turn the image purple like my old X1650 Pro HDMI did at 1920x1080/60p. :rolleyes:
still doesnt make sense. thats still a regular 8600gt and it uses power the same way the 2600xt does which is through the pcie x16 slot. that slot provides enough power for either card and I cant imagine that the molex even has to be plugged in in the first place since its whole point is to provide additional power if the pcie x16 slot cant provide enough. well since I have clearly showed you that the 8600gt uses less power than the 2600xt then you should have nothing to worry about. the 2600xt is actually straining your psu more than the 8600gt.
 
You're missing the point. There are 2 rails. Re-read what you quote. :rolleyes:
 
You're missing the point. There are 2 rails. Re-read what you quote. :rolleyes:
why the hell are you rolling your freakin eyes at me? youre the one who thinks the 8600gt uses a specific rail but the 2600xt doesnt. get a clue buddy because the 8600gt DOES NOT NEED external power. the 8600gt and 2600xt BOTH get their power from the pci-e x16 slot. even if this 8600gt has a molex plug it would only draw the extra power from it if it exceeded the 75 watts that the slot provides and it doesnt do that. BOTH cards are stressing your psu in the same way and the 8600gt would actually stress it less because it uses less power. :rolleyes: back at you :p
 
Currently running an X1650XT, soon to be replaced with an 8600GT SSC. Using the beefed up 350W power supply and a Q6700- yay! The DG965PZ does support Quads, including G0 steppings. I also tested with a G0 Q6600, just in case anything fried.

The downside is cooling; my Q6700 gets to a max of 63C just sitting in the BIOS, and the system just rebooted from overheating- again, just sitting in BIOS watching the temps.

Option 1 is to Dremel an exhaust fan into the case, option 2 is to drop down to a Pentium Dual-Core or something much cooler.

Edit:
Stay away from the 350W. Two reboots later, the PSU fried. Horrible smell. It can't even run half its rated capacity.

Edit2:
The FSP-made AOpen is a better supply, though generally I don't think either one was really built to be the only exhaust fan in the case (part of the picoBTX design). I think the low-profile heatsink isn't cut out for Quads, since even with an open case it's sitting at 50C in the BIOS. I think I'll drop in a dual and cut a blowhole instead of the video card. Onboard video, boo hoo. :(
 
I usually find that towards the end of a products lifespan they start making compact versions of the card. So maybe by the end of the year we will have a tiny 8800GT.
 
Edit:
Stay away from the 350W. Two reboots later, the PSU fried. Horrible smell. It can't even run half its rated capacity.

Edit2:
The FSP-made AOpen is a better supply,
Ouch. Mine has been running great with the stock PSU. I haven't measured the power draw yet with an E6600, but I can't imagine the DC draw being more than ~150W max for everything.

I would have thought that the stock Intel type II cooler could have handled a 95W CPU. I have my case with the feet installed in a tower configuration. The cooling seems to work great with a 65W CPU. I have another BTX system I'm setting up and that one has the beefy 130W Type I cooler. Too bad I can't fit that one in the picoBTX case. :p

edit: power usage on my E6600 + HD 2600XT system (measured at the wall, DC power is lower)...

idle on desktop (XP) ~75W
with Orthos running on 2 cores ~105W
with Orthos running on 2 cores and a large RTHDRIBL window running ~129W

I should see what the other one pulls with integrated video and an E2200, hopefully only around 50W.
 
saw this thread and couldnt help myself from posting my exact same aopen case and Intel DG965PZ system.. i have a 7600GT running with a lowend celeron 430 Conroe-L 1.8GHz 35w. ill be updating the cpu in comming months, just had the celeron laying around.. its the perfect cs1.6 computer for lans :D

posted this in the SFF gallery couple months ago..

p10101393if1.jpg
 
Back
Top