Best overclocking 2Gb (250+ bus) set ?

Peter Mann

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 22, 2000
Messages
82
I currently have 2 old 512 OCZ EL PC4000 copper's running 1:1 at 267 fsb / 3.4.4.8

I bought and returned an 2GB OCZ EB Platinum dual channel kit. To my shock and horror, while it was among the most expensive memory out there it would only do 255 fsb stable. While it did run better timings the overall result was a lower overclock and slower system.
I was annoyed that memory that expensive would be so poor at overclocking.

Note; I spent 2 days trying every possible combination of Bios setting tweaks from looser timings to more/less voltage and every other idea I could come up with.
My 2GB EB would boot windows at 260fsb but would get all squirelly. It was 255 max.

What 2GB set would have a better chance at me keeping my 267fsb?

Cheers!
Peter
 
IBE (In Before Eclipse)...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231021

you can't beat that price from the egg right now and these seem to be a very good kit of the UCCC 2GB kits out there. most guys from what i have seen are getting 270-280 ish out of them. obviously that isnt' gauranteed but UCCC seem to be pretty good on the whole. i have a fine set of UCCC from the fields of Corsair that run 280+ 1T in my DFI, i think the date on my ICs is 0534 so they are older and lately some of the UCCCs that have shown up aren't clocking as good but hopefully they can still reach your goal of 270. HTH
 
Alright, so I bought that set for $197 in Jan and thought it was a great deal and have loved them. I can't believe how cheap they got...you just can't beat that. Get them! Mine do about 275 and that's pretty typical.
 
You realise that in all probability the better timings at 255Mhz actually give better overall performance? Have you run a memory bandwidth benchmark such as MemTest86 or Sisoft Sandra? I'm running 2GB of Corsair XMS3500LL at 245Mhz 2.5-3-2-8 since it gives better performance than running it at 270Mhz with loose timings. Mem bandwidth shows around 2755M in MemTest86 and 6860M in Sandra for reference.
 
JDAdams said:
You realise that in all probability the better timings at 255Mhz actually give better overall performance? Have you run a memory bandwidth benchmark such as MemTest86 or Sisoft Sandra? I'm running 2GB of Corsair XMS3500LL at 245Mhz 2.5-3-2-8 since it gives better performance than running it at 270Mhz with loose timings. Mem bandwidth shows around 2755M in MemTest86 and 6860M in Sandra for reference.
Perhaps so, and there are a lot of nice low latency sticks out there, but the high end sets are damn near $100 more than the new price on the 'Skills...

Even if there would be a slight benchmark difference, it likely wouldn't be noticable real world to a human, and certainly wouldn't make the price on these any less appealing.
 
Corsair sux. Only the value stix are worth their price.

I also think 270 @ 3 4 3 is better. Here is proof.




DO THE G.SKILL. ESPECIALLY AT THIS PRICE.
 
These dont need high voltage.

Anywhere between 2.5-2.7 is good for them. These are great. Mine like 2.65 best.

Highly reco them.

Like various have shown. Tighter timings, 1t vs 2t is not that much of a big deal like most ppl believe. I myself was shocked when i tested them.

Do the G.Skills
 
Guys, you are wrong. You are running into the SAME problem I ran into.
I bought the 2gb Gskills and the best OC I could get was 235fsb...pathetic. My previous OC with the OCZ el Plat 1gig kit was over 255 easily. I then thought the gskills were an RMA, and I returned it for Corsair. With corsair I could manage 240fsb with lower voltage and tighter timings. (keep in mind this is all 1:1 with full CPU multiplier).

Now, after talking to Corsair techsupport, I have found out a reson for this. He told me that all corsair ddr500 modules pass a test at 275mhz in dual channel before leaving the facility. It is NOT the ram. He said that the limiting factor is the MEMORY CONTROLLER ON THE CPU. Overclocking with 2, 512 sicks is much easier on the mem controller that with 2 1gig sticks. He also mentioned that you would be able to get an even higher overclock with 256mb sticks than 512mb, but no one cares about 256megs of ram of course.

From personal experience, Gskill is an inferior product to Corsair. Keep your modules. Find a frequency where you KNOW your proc is stable. Like 2.6mghz for example. Run your ram to 275, increase voltage for the ram, REDUCE the cpu multiplier. This way you can run at 2.6mghz, and ddr550 ram. You may not get as high of a clock on the CPU side, but thats the price you pay with 2 gigs.
 
kdog said:
Guys, you are wrong. You are running into the SAME problem I ran into.
I bought the 2gb Gskills and the best OC I could get was 235fsb...pathetic. My previous OC with the OCZ el Plat 1gig kit was over 255 easily. I then thought the gskills were an RMA, and I returned it for Corsair. With corsair I could manage 240fsb with lower voltage and tighter timings. (keep in mind this is all 1:1 with full CPU multiplier).

Now, after talking to Corsair techsupport, I have found out a reson for this. He told me that all corsair ddr500 modules pass a test at 275mhz in dual channel before leaving the facility. It is NOT the ram. He said that the limiting factor is the MEMORY CONTROLLER ON THE CPU. Overclocking with 2, 512 sicks is much easier on the mem controller that with 2 1gig sticks. He also mentioned that you would be able to get an even higher overclock with 256mb sticks than 512mb, but no one cares about 256megs of ram of course.

From personal experience, Gskill is an inferior product to Corsair. Keep your modules. Find a frequency where you KNOW your proc is stable. Like 2.6mghz for example. Run your ram to 275, increase voltage for the ram, REDUCE the cpu multiplier. This way you can run at 2.6mghz, and ddr550 ram. You may not get as high of a clock on the CPU side, but thats the price you pay with 2 gigs.

Just because you got a bad set, we're all wrong? What kind of logic is that? And please stop blatantly spreading this marketing. G.Skill is far superior to Corsair, in the DDR1 market anyway.
 
I got the G.Skill HZ 2x1gb PC4000 and they ROCK! I am at 272 stable with them and they are somehow outperforming my old ballistix clock for clock.

This is at 3-4-4-8, 1t, dual channel

memoryhtt2729ky.jpg
 
Bona Fide said:
Just because you got a bad set, we're all wrong? What kind of logic is that? And please stop blatantly spreading this marketing. G.Skill is far superior to Corsair, in the DDR1 market anyway.

Its not that im right and you're wrong. You guys are wrong in automatically assuming its the memory -- I am pointing out that a memory controller is a much bigger issue when going from 1g-2g. And from my experience, Gskill is definately far from the best. Cheapest does not always equal best. I will say OCZ is better then Gskill. And so is corsair, but thats just my opinion.

PS. I am not spreading marketting. If all Gskill modules passed DDR550 before leaving the factory, mine wouldn't have BSOD'ed at 235fsb. I have never once heard a bad thing about corsair.
 
So what? You got a bad pair, it's called RMA them back and get a new pair. On the topic of opinions, opinions are like assholes, everyones got them.
 
Or I can reverse it. And say that you got a "good" pair. And thinking that Gskill is the best DDR1 manuf is also your opinion :)
 
kdog said:
Or I can reverse it. And say that you got a "good" pair. And thinking that Gskill is the best DDR1 manuf is also your opinion :)

When the opinion is agreed upon by 95% of its owners [not counting unfortunate people such as you], the opinion itself tends to hold higher value. You are one of the first people I've heard saying good things about Corsair. Everyday, there are dozens of threads in this section about how great ______'s G.Skill RAM is performing.
 
Bona Fide said:
When the opinion is agreed upon by 95% of its owners [not counting unfortunate people such as you], the opinion itself tends to hold higher value. You are one of the first people I've heard saying good things about Corsair. Everyday, there are dozens of threads in this section about how great ______'s G.Skill RAM is performing.

Like all things, opinions change based on where you look.
My challenge to you: I will paypal you 5 dollars. Promise.
Show me 1 bad review for Corsair TWINX2048-4000PT.
Official review, not a dude spouting stuff on a forum.

Please, do this and you will shut me up.
 
I find it amazing how some threads go off on a flaming tangent ;)

JDAdams:
Yes, the OCZ PC4000 EB Platinum @ 257fsb/ 3.3.2.8 (could bench 257 but occasionally would crash) was fast but my OCZ EL coppers @267/ 3.4.4.8 was faster in Sandra 2004, 2005 in EVERY category. Not by a huge amount... but consistently faster... all the time.
This was also true in 3DMark '03 and Aquamark3. I did bench the sticks and felt cheated that after buying premium OCZ PC4000 ram it was not as fast as my 2 year old OCZ ram.
I know that the chips on the ram are different... but to call this stuff that can do a 5 MHz stable overclock "PLATINUM" is a sad joke !

KDOG;
Did you even read my original post?
We're talking here about 2GB PC4000 dual channel kits. [H]Opteron pointed me to a set of GSkill PC4000 also. If your PC4000 couldn't go faster than 235..... then it's an RMA situation since PC4000 is DDR500 (250MHz stock). I wonder, did you get a replacement set of GSkill ...and what did they do?

I'm still running a Northwood 2.4 so having it @ 3.2GHz with a big fat 267fsb is what makes it a half decent (if aging) machine. In fact I know this CPU will do 3.3/ 3.4 but I refuse to use memory dividers and I don't think I can find 2 GB kits that will go anywhere as fast 1:1. I'd like to upgrade to 2GB because even after I build myself a Conroe rig, I'll still want this as a second 'game capable' computer for the kids or friends on the LAN.

Unlike you guys my memory controler is in my northbridge, not on the die, so it's somewhat of a diferent situation.

Isn't the OCZ EL Gold GX XTC PC4000 2GB /3-4-3-8 Dual Channel Memory Kit also UCCC?
or the Mushkin XP PC4000 2X1GB DDR500 CL 3-4-3-8 ? UCCC ?

Peter
 
Peter,
I sent the G Skill back for a refund and got Corsair.
Three reasons for this.
1) I did not want to get dissapointed a second time.
2) I read many threads about compatibility issues b/w Gskill & Asus motherboards.
3) I could not find a SINGLE bad review for corsair ram, and I could find no reference regarding compatibility issues.
 
Well, I don't have any problems with mine and my A8N32, but maybe some do. I also don't see any bad reviews about the G.Skill either.
 
I take no heed of 'proper reviews' of RAM really - if anyone chastises it, they're not likely to get another pair sent from the manufacturer in the future, are they? I place much more credence on forum members posting in their own timings and overclocks.
 
Peter Mann said:
KDOG;
Did you even read my original post?
We're talking here about 2GB PC4000 dual channel kits. [H]Opteron pointed me to a set of GSkill PC4000 also. If your PC4000 couldn't go faster than 235..... then it's an RMA situation since PC4000 is DDR500 (250MHz stock). I wonder, did you get a replacement set of GSkill ...and what did they do?
I don't think kdog addressed this. If he got PC4000, then he either got bum sticks OR (and this is important) his motherboard didn't like them. Very possible. I've seen Asus boards that HATE most memory that works just dandy in other boards. If he got PC3200, nice OC, dude. LOL
 
My Gskill HZ ram was only capable of 250fsb and I actually had to loosen some timings below the recommended for it to be stable with just that... I bought it about a week ago just before the price dropped, my guess is that is the reason why the price has dropped...


So I guess what is the best 250+ ram if it's not G.Skill anymore?



(BTW this was with a DFI motherboard, I spent 3 days just fooling around with different memory settings, the DFI and the ram were a total bust)
 
peacetilence said:
My Gskill HZ ram was only capable of 250fsb and I actually had to loosen some timings below the recommended for it to be stable with just that... I bought it about a week ago just before the price dropped, my guess is that is the reason why the price has dropped...


So I guess what is the best 250+ ram if it's not G.Skill anymore?
That sounds like a dud to me. Or... Asus board?
 
IMO I just think the ram isn't very high quality anymore. There has got to be a reason why the price dropped so much lately.
 
peacetilence said:
IMO I just think the ram isn't very high quality anymore. There has got to be a reason why the price dropped so much lately.
However, if it's not doing the timings and clock that it's advertised to do, then something's wrong with at least your sticks.

Unfortunately, I think the mad scientist known as Eclipse is off doing things non-computer involved, so... No answers from him quite yet.

I would probably put money on him recommending Micron based Team Xtreem, but they're impossible to find. The UCCC based Team Xtreems would be the same as the G.Skill.
 
"The UCCC based Team Xtreems would be the same as the G.Skill"

... as would be the OCZ EL Gold GX XTC PC4000 2GB 2X1GB DDR500 CL3-4-3-8,
or the Mushkin XP PC4000 2GB 2X1GB DDR500 CL 3-4-3-8 no?

I also considered some 2GB Mushkin Redlines (different chips, same as OCZ EB Plats)... but rumors going around suggest a bad run with poor overclocks.... as was the case with my 2 OCZ sticks.

Maybe everyone is ramping up DDR2 production and quality is down with the older lines.
 
Peter Mann said:
"The UCCC based Team Xtreems would be the same as the G.Skill"

... as would be the OCZ EL Gold GX XTC PC4000 2GB 2X1GB DDR500 CL3-4-3-8,
or the Mushkin XP PC4000 2GB 2X1GB DDR500 CL 3-4-3-8 no?

I also considered some 2GB Mushkin Redlines (different chips, same as OCZ EB Plats)... but rumors going around suggest a bad run with poor overclocks.... as was the case with my 2 OCZ sticks.

Maybe everyone is ramping up DDR2 production and quality is down with the older lines.
Essentially, yeah, as long as their on a decent PCB.

I sure as hell hope that the G.Skills are still good. LOL I was about to order some Tuesday.

Has anybody else gotten the G.Skill HZs recently?
 
wow, ok. i told myself i was gonna take a break for a while, but gilmour pointed this thread out to me, and i must say, i'm quite dissapointed in the amount of misinformation and arguing. to set some things straight.. ;)

Peter Mann said:
I bought and returned an 2GB OCZ EB Platinum dual channel kit. To my shock and horror, while it was among the most expensive memory out there it would only do 255 fsb stable. While it did run better timings the overall result was a lower overclock and slower system.
I was annoyed that memory that expensive would be so poor at overclocking.

Note; I spent 2 days trying every possible combination of Bios setting tweaks from looser timings to more/less voltage and every other idea I could come up with.
My 2GB EB would boot windows at 260fsb but would get all squirelly. It was 255 max.
first off, nobody has directly addressed this issue. the chips in that set of memory are infineon CE-6.. it's known to usually not do higher than 260-270mhz except for in rare cases. looks like you just got pretty unlucky, or else have a board that hates those sticks.


JDAdams said:
You realise that in all probability the better timings at 255Mhz actually give better overall performance?
you might be surprised how little timings really do to performance compared to mhz... though 3-3-2 at 255mhz should be roughly equal to 3-4-4 at ~280-285mhz


kdog said:
Now, after talking to Corsair techsupport, I have found out a reson for this. He told me that all corsair ddr500 modules pass a test at 275mhz in dual channel before leaving the facility. It is NOT the ram. He said that the limiting factor is the MEMORY CONTROLLER ON THE CPU. Overclocking with 2, 512 sicks is much easier on the mem controller that with 2 1gig sticks. He also mentioned that you would be able to get an even higher overclock with 256mb sticks than 512mb, but no one cares about 256megs of ram of course.
and i guess it never occured to you that 2x1gb is a much greater load on the memory controller? if you're limited to 255mhz with 2x512mb by the memory controller, don't expect to be able to touch it with any set of 2x1gb.. especially now that gilmour pointed out that you have an asus board, something known to me to have SERIOUS PROBLEMS with memory compatibility. tbh, i hate asus these days, and scorn all of their amd boards... intel is a different story, cause their dev team actually gets money :rolleyes:

kdog said:
Like all things, opinions change based on where you look.
My challenge to you: I will paypal you 5 dollars. Promise.
Show me 1 bad review for Corsair TWINX2048-4000PT.
Official review, not a dude spouting stuff on a forum.

Please, do this and you will shut me up.
heh, you'd have to be retarded to take up that bet. corsair routinely sends hand-picked samples to reviewers from what i can tell, and if a reviewer has problems with the ram, he/she is gonna talk to the MFG to resolve the issues first, then get the review done.

Peter Mann said:
Isn't the OCZ EL Gold GX XTC PC4000 2GB /3-4-3-8 Dual Channel Memory Kit also UCCC?
or the Mushkin XP PC4000 2X1GB DDR500 CL 3-4-3-8 ? UCCC ?

Peter
the rev 1.1 OCZ's are micron 5b F, but yes, the rest are UCCC, and the mushkin is as well.
 
kdog said:
Like all things, opinions change based on where you look.
My challenge to you: I will paypal you 5 dollars. Promise.
Show me 1 bad review for Corsair TWINX2048-4000PT.
Official review, not a dude spouting stuff on a forum.

Please, do this and you will shut me up.

Expert opinions have their own pitfalls as well, as I'm sure you are aware. Companies frequently send cherry-picked models to reviewers so as to garner a good review. Add on a tag saying "Results may vary." and you have instant marketing. So, by that token, user reviews tend to say far more about a product's consistent quality. Especially on a forum such as [H], where the majority of users are well-knowledged in computer hardware and have years of experience.
 
peacetilence said:
My Gskill HZ ram was only capable of 250fsb and I actually had to loosen some timings below the recommended for it to be stable with just that... I bought it about a week ago just before the price dropped, my guess is that is the reason why the price has dropped...


So I guess what is the best 250+ ram if it's not G.Skill anymore?



(BTW this was with a DFI motherboard, I spent 3 days just fooling around with different memory settings, the DFI and the ram were a total bust)

I bought mine around christmas and they were the least problematic piece of hardware in my entire setup. My system has been down for a while but i'm pretty sure I just set the timings (I'm almost positive I didn't though) and the fsb was at my disposal. They maxed out around 265 but i haven't messed with anything else yet to get them faster.

But if they didn't work at 250 with the specified timimgs I would return them in a second...
 
personally I enjoy my 4x512mb mushkins running 265-270mhz 2-2-2-5. The stupid-low latencies make up for the 2t hit.
 
kdog said:
Guys, you are wrong. You are running into the SAME problem I ran into.
I bought the 2gb Gskills and the best OC I could get was 235fsb...pathetic. My previous OC with the OCZ el Plat 1gig kit was over 255 easily. I then thought the gskills were an RMA, and I returned it for Corsair. With corsair I could manage 240fsb with lower voltage and tighter timings. (keep in mind this is all 1:1 with full CPU multiplier).

Now, after talking to Corsair techsupport, I have found out a reson for this. He told me that all corsair ddr500 modules pass a test at 275mhz in dual channel before leaving the facility. It is NOT the ram. He said that the limiting factor is the MEMORY CONTROLLER ON THE CPU. Overclocking with 2, 512 sicks is much easier on the mem controller that with 2 1gig sticks. He also mentioned that you would be able to get an even higher overclock with 256mb sticks than 512mb, but no one cares about 256megs of ram of course.

From personal experience, Gskill is an inferior product to Corsair. Keep your modules. Find a frequency where you KNOW your proc is stable. Like 2.6mghz for example. Run your ram to 275, increase voltage for the ram, REDUCE the cpu multiplier. This way you can run at 2.6mghz, and ddr550 ram. You may not get as high of a clock on the CPU side, but thats the price you pay with 2 gigs.


Yes I've definately noticable between having some G.skills HX (2x1g) and Team Cronus DDR 500 3-3-2-8 (2x1g) that BOTH of those wont allow me to do 9 x 316 like my 2 x 512 valueram allowed me. I have to lower it down to 9 x 305. It seems it did this on most of the multiplers. I've narrowed it down to either the mb or the memory controller on my 170. But I assume it's got to be the memory controller as it's happening with only those 2 x 1g sticks and not happening on my 2 x 512mb sticks.
 
Back
Top