Best Linux Distro

laxmiddi44

Gawd
Joined
Jan 10, 2005
Messages
863
I am looking to install a version of linux. I really like OS X and Vista so I'm looking for something that looks nice but that isn't too hard to use since its my first time using linux. I was looking at the freespire 2.0 alpha but I'm not sure if thats the best option.

Thanks for your help!
 
Ubuntu might be worth a look. It (supposedly, I used it for a whopping total of 20 hours) has an awesome community, and is pretty good at "working" And for looking nice it has the crazy awesome (and proportionately unstable) Beryl OGL-based desktop, though there will be some configuration to make it work.

My personal favorite is fedora, but that is probably only because I never really tried to learn much on Ubuntu. Note that in asking this question you will get all kinds of answers, there are people that hate and like just about every conceivable combination of distros.

Also, as a newbie (like me :) ) it is probably best to go with a large, well supported, developed distro. Anything with alpha after it's name is probably going to be a little messed from the start.
 
well, I've been using xubuntu and love it so far.

installing programs is a BITCH if there isn't already a pre-made package for it.


my recommendation: start at the Ubuntu forums and learn how to MANUALLY install drivers and programs from scratch before you jump into anything else.... that way you'll learn a fair amount about how the power user stuff is done in Linux, and it gives you a huge leg up.

I love Linux so far..... I was able to resurrect a pentium 2 with 32mb of RAM with Damn Small Linux......

but yea... it truely is a smart man's OS, and the real geeks are the Linux ones.....

*still loves Windows too though*
 
Knoppix, because...

Ubuntu, because...

Yellowdog, because....

SuSe, because....

Mandrake, because....

Xandros, because.....

Redhat, because....

Gentoo, because...

There is no "best" linux distro. There are different distros for different things.
 
ScYcS said:
Knoppix, because...

Ubuntu, because...

Yellowdog, because....

SuSe, because....

Mandrake, because....

Xandros, because.....

Redhat, because....

Gentoo, because...

There is no "best" linux distro. There are different distros for different things.
qft. i cant believe people are still civil to people who post "which linux distro for..." posts :)

try a bunch, and keep your favorite.
 
There's a reason there are so many distros available.

If one of them was the best, or even a small set best because of different needs, then those would float to the top and everything else would fade away.
 
Fryguy8 said:
If one of them was the best, or even a small set best because of different needs, then those would float to the top and everything else would fade away.
Until then, confusion reigns supreme.

Langford said:
I'll vote for Kubuntu and/or Ubuntu.
http://kubuntu.org
http://ubuntu.com
Any particular reason for your votes? Even among those two, how does one choose?
 
mikeblas said:
Any particular reason for your votes? Even among those two, how does one choose?
He said he was a beginner, and both Kubuntu and Ubuntu are just about the easiest distros to get started with. Additionally, either can be installed from a single CD, come with a streamlined set off apps, and can get more software over the internet. The main difference between them is that Kubunu installs KDE by default and Ubuntu installs Gnome by default. Both Gnome and KDE are attractive and easy to use, but Gnome may look a little friendlier. I like KDE because I feel like I have more control.
 
Langford said:
He said he was a beginner, and both Kubuntu and Ubuntu are just about the easiest distros to get started with. Additionally, either can be installed from a single CD, come with a streamlined set off apps, and can get more software over the internet. The main difference between them is that Kubunu installs KDE by default and Ubuntu installs Gnome by default. Both Gnome and KDE are attractive and easy to use, but Gnome may look a little friendlier. I like KDE because I feel like I have more control.


Or if you want to be able to play with BOTH Gnome and KDE at the same time - Fedora Core 6.

It has a large community and user base similar to Ubuntu's.
Or you could try MEPIS - It's very easy to get started!

Distrowatch's top 4 the other day was-
1. Ubuntu
2. OpenSUSE
3. Fedora
4. MEPIS

I've played with 3 of them -
I don't recommend having to learn Linux/Unix by using HP-UX 10.2
It sucks a big one and I am required to use it by my employer. We've got some dedicated machines that use it and there is NO possibility of an upgrade or change. :(

Good Luck!
 
Another vote for Ubuntu. I just started using linux and tried to start with Fedora Core 6. ATI driver support with linux is really bad and I couldn't get Fedora to play nice with my X1900XTX for the life of me after changing my xorg.conf for hours. Ubuntu worked out of the box for me. :)
 
I absolutely love the IDEA of linux, and would love to use it. However, I have played around with Linux several times in the past and have always ended up frustrated and swearing, often losing data.

Can someone recommend a good place to go to learn beginner stuff about linux so that a guy like me (who knows nothing about it) can start to use it? To give you an example of where I am with Linux: when they say type .rpm to get a repository, I ask, "What's an .rpm? What's a repository? Where the hell did my file go?!" I need a place that starts at the absolute beginning and takes you through.

Thanks!
 
wussboy said:
I absolutely love the IDEA of linux, and would love to use it. However, I have played around with Linux several times in the past and have always ended up frustrated and swearing, often losing data.

Can someone recommend a good place to go to learn beginner stuff about linux so that a guy like me (who knows nothing about it) can start to use it? To give you an example of where I am with Linux: when they say type .rpm to get a repository, I ask, "What's an .rpm? What's a repository? Where the hell did my file go?!" I need a place that starts at the absolute beginning and takes you through.

Thanks!

damb must of been a while since you tried it. Most of the more user-friendly (Ubuntu, FedoraCore) have a GUI which you can just search for what you want

also if you want to enable some of the extended repositories both Ubuntu and FedoraCore have very good forums with dedicated howtos of what files (normally just 1) in /etc needs to be edited
 
mikeblas said:
Until then, confusion reigns supreme.
until people spend 20 minutes reading about different distributions. until people are willing to do THAT, confusion reigns supreme.
 
The really fun part is that you can get started learning linux by using windows. :D
Microsoft and Interix have released an upgrade that allows a lot of common linux apps to run under windows.
Hell, the second edition of Server 2003 has it installed out of the box.

Read a webpage about a guy that needed a lot of linux apps on a windows box - by the time he was done he had gcc and everything else running on that box. He was using KDE as a desktop.

here are the links
http://www.interix.com/
http://www.microsoft.com/technet/interopmigration/unix/sfu/default.mspx

Google search
http://www.google.com/search?q=inte...s=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a

Have fun!
 
santaliqueur said:
until people spend 20 minutes reading about different distributions. until people are willing to do THAT, confusion reigns supreme.
Can you recommend a good reference which compares all the different distros side by each?
 
mikeblas said:
Can you recommend a good reference which compares all the different distros side by each?

Try Distrowatch - www.distrowatch.com

They have a summary page for each of the distros that they monitor. Including links to home page etc.
 
hey, just try a bunch of them and find out what u like the best, different distros had different capabilities for different needs, like Edubuntu.
i did that and found that my favorite was Unix itself, it might be a bitch to install but ive had it for 3 years and never had it crash, but then i had to uninstall it cuz it wouldnt run the source games.
point is, just try a bunch of them.
 
Private TEMPLAR said:
point is, just try a bunch of them.
Point is, who has the time? I've got a job; I don't want to spend my limited free time installing OSes, learning about them, getting apps configured, then rebuilding the machine again anyway.

If a perscriptive recommendation isn't possible, then there's something wrong.


rodsfree said:
Try Distrowatch - www.distrowatch.com

They have a summary page for each of the distros that they monitor. Including links to home page etc.
Thanks for the link! It's an intersting site, but it gives me more questions than answers. There's a top ten list, for example; but no indication of how they're ranked. (Popularity? Stability? 3rd party software support?) The descriptions describe several features of the distributions without explaining the utility or value of the feature, so it's hard to make a comparison based on the information there.
 
mikeblas said:
It's an intersting site, but it gives me more questions than answers. There's a top ten list, for example; but no indication of how they're ranked
yes there is. the column is entitled HPD, which means hits per day, which is shown at the bottom of the rankings. not a great way to rank them, but it is explained. click on each distribution to learn a little about them.

if you google "linux comparison", distrowatch is the first link. the third link is a wikipedia article that lists other details of a ton of distributions. only 10 minutes in, and you have a general idea about each of the top 5 or 10 distros.

Point is, who has the time? I've got a job; I don't want to spend my limited free time installing OSes, learning about them, getting apps configured, then rebuilding the machine again anyway.
you may not want to do that, but surely you must understand there are people who want to. linux is not for you, and that's fine. i have a job, i have limited free time, and i enjoy installing new OSes and learning about them. a few years ago, i spent a decent chunk of my free time learning about linux, and now i never have to pay for windows again, and i have no need to. i consider it a small investment, and i had fun doing it. it's not for everyone, and nobody suggested it was.
 
Private TEMPLAR said:
hey, just try a bunch of them and find out what u like the best, different distros had different capabilities for different needs, like Edubuntu.
i did that and found that my favorite was Unix itself, it might be a bitch to install but ive had it for 3 years and never had it crash, but then i had to uninstall it cuz it wouldnt run the source games.
point is, just try a bunch of them.


Ummmm, So you've installed Unix huh?

So which one? BSD, Solaris, AIX, HP-UX, SCO? I'd be interested to get your further opinion.
 
santaliqueur said:
yes there is. the column is entitled HPD, which means hits per day,
HPD is presented on the home page, sure. That's clearly called "page hit ranking". What I'm looking at is the "Top ten Distributions" list, which, along with some other lists on the same page, doesn't show any information about how they're ranked. The list isn't the same as the HPD list, and is only described as "generally considered as most widely used by Linux users around the world." Which are weasel words: generally considered by whom, using what measure? Why doesn't that "general consideration" agree with the stats the site itself is tracking?

santaliqueur said:
it's not for everyone, and nobody suggested it was.
Nobody suggested that somebody suggested that it was for everyone. TEMPLAR suggested it for me, and I'm telling him it's not for me. I hope that's okay with you!

santaliqueur said:
linux is not for you, and that's fine.
Maybe it is, maybe it ain't. It's not easy for me to tell, given the information at distrowatch.com.
 
mikeblas said:
Thanks for the link! It's an intersting site, but it gives me more questions than answers. There's a top ten list, for example; but no indication of how they're ranked. (Popularity? Stability? 3rd party software support?) The descriptions describe several features of the distributions without explaining the utility or value of the feature, so it's hard to make a comparison based on the information there.

They are rated by number of downloads.

The idea being that the most popular, most downloaded distro will be the one that appeals to the most people. i.e. people who aren't super uber computer nerd/geeks.
Also generally thinking that the most downloaded distro will be the one that offers the features and ease of use for the most people.

Example - MEPIS is designed to be the easiest to install and use linux distro there is. It's design intent is to offer a complete office type desktop operating system from the start.
Upon install it already has all of the Linux equalivent applications and utilities that a Dell business desktop computer with Windows and Office preinstalled would have, and more.
It's also designed for a user to rarely ever have to open a terminal window. IMO MEPIS is as close as you can get to Windows in Linux distros.

Ubuntu - It's focus is more upon the community of users than it is upon applications and performance. It actually has the motto of being the friendliest distro there is. If you have a question, post it in the ubuntu forums and a blue million people will reply. And the odds are there won't be any noob flaming in any of the replys. If some one does flame you for asking something that might be noobish, the rest of the community will come down on the flamer like the Wrath of God.

And my favotite - Fedora Core - in all of it's many flavors.
FC is first and foremost a test bed distro. It is the bleeding edge of Red Hat's technological development. Red Hat uses FC to develop new technology and mature it before it integrates it into the Red Hat Enterprise distributions which Red Hat makes money off of - so the entire distribution is in a constant state of evolution and testing. And every 6 months you get a new distribution. It also offers the biggest variety of installation options of any distribution IMO and one of the slickest installers of any OS that I've ever used. Including ALL of the flavors of Windows, OS/2 Warp, and all of the Linux distros I've played with.

That's the 3 of the top 4 that I've played with.

Have fun!
 
mikeblas said:
HPD is presented on the home page, sure. That's clearly called "page hit ranking". What I'm looking at is the "Top ten Distributions" list, which, along with some other lists on the same page, doesn't show any information about how they're ranked. The list isn't the same as the HPD list, and is only described as "generally considered as most widely used by Linux users around the world." Which are weasel words: generally considered by whom, using what measure? Why doesn't that "general consideration" agree with the stats the site itself is tracking?
i agree that the ranking is somewhat shaky, but it does hold true somewhat. the list isn't totally off, that is to say that a distro from #50 probably isnt going to appear at #1 on someone else's list. believe it or not, distrowatch is not the only website that has information comparing distributions.

...and I'm telling him it's not for me...
Maybe it is, maybe it ain't...
well, youve answered your own question before you asked it again. IF you don't like tinkering around and learning about new operating systems in your free time, we'll just assume you won't like linux, without a definitive answer from you.
 
doh said:
Just use Gentoo.
Tried that. I couldn't get my mouse to work, and got flamed when I asked about it on the Gentoo forums.

moetop said:
There is also the Linux Distribution Chooser It has a limited selection, but covers some realy good distributions.
Thanks for the helpful link! Curiously, Mandriva, Kubuntu, Xandros, Linspire, and Ubuntu were all listed as "perfect matches" for my workstation machines. The site doesn't give me a way to decide between them. Even links to screenshots don't work.
 
doh said:
The last time you asked about the incident, I posted a link for you. If I remember right, it was in the Webmastering & Programming forums here.
 
mikeblas said:
Tried that. I couldn't get my mouse to work, and got flamed when I asked about it on the Gentoo forums.

Thanks for the helpful link! Curiously, Mandriva, Kubuntu, Xandros, Linspire, and Ubuntu were all listed as "perfect matches" for my workstation machines. The site doesn't give me a way to decide between them. Even links to screenshots don't work.

For good reason too. They are nothing more then suggestions. Offers, that you can test for your own needs. I wouldnt trust any site that said that I have to use this or that distro. But if I have a site that says this and this distro can fit my needs, then I can try them both and choose the one I like best.
 
duby229 said:
Ummmm, So you've installed Unix huh?

So which one? BSD, Solaris, AIX, HP-UX, SCO? I'd be interested to get your further opinion.

lol I still have an old version of SCO on 50 something floppies. Circa 1993 :p
 
squishy said:
lol I still have an old version of SCO on 50 something floppies. Circa 1993 :p

Ah, the good ol' days. When things were simple. Not anymore though. Things are changing too fast right now. I think somebody needs to standardize a common syntax for ALL config files.
 
In the electronic world just about everything must abide standards. We have organizations such as FCC, and ASCII, and ANSI, and ISO, to create and enforce them.... And in the Open Software world we have FSF.org, and Freedesktop.org, as well as a few others that are trying to make open source standards.

I believe that a standard syntax should be created for all configuration files in unix-like operating systems.
 
Linux 2.6 is your best bet

laxmiddi44 said:
I am looking to install a version of linux. I really like OS X and Vista so I'm looking for something that looks nice but that isn't too hard to use since its my first time using linux. I was looking at the freespire 2.0 alpha but I'm not sure if thats the best option.

Thanks for your help!
 
Back
Top