Best gaming/work video card + CPU combo?

dderidex

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Oct 31, 2001
Messages
6,328
Looking for a combination that games very well, and handles alt-tabbing out of a game (say, Battlefield 2 or Planetside - memory hogs, basically) extremely well.

Two options for a big upgrade would be - presuming 2gb of PC3200 already in the system:

$272 Athlon64 '3500+' (Venice)
$604 GeForce 7800GTX
====
$876

$579 Athlon64 X2 '4200+' (dual-core Manchester)
$304 GeForce 6800GT (after rebate)
===
$883

Effectively the same price. Which option would be better?
 
For gaming? The 3500+ and the 7800 GTX. It will definitely give you more power for games. The X2 gives you an edge in multitasking of course... that's the whole point of these dual cores. Unless of course these rumored multi threaded drivers come out... but then again that's just a 5-20% increase in performance.
 
Well, the question is not PURE gaming. I mean, I'm definitely MOSTLY talking about gaming - for pure application work, pretty much any CPU will do and a dual-core one best, clearly.

I'm thinking more....you are playing BF2 and YahooIM pops up that a buddy just came online. You want to alt-tab out to the desktop and bring up YIM to chat at them and let them know you are in BF2 at such-and-such server, wouldn't it be cool if he could join? Then alt-tab back to the game and keep playing.

Or, maybe, alt-tab to the desktop and surf the web some while waiting for a base cap to finish in Planetside (very similiar system demands to BF2 - gods only know why, though!).

Or, perhaps, the Teamspeak server you are on crashes and you need to alt-tab back to the desktop to drop your TS connection and reconnect, then alt-tab back to the game.

etc.

Right now I'm running an A64 3000+, GeForce 6800 vanilla, and 1gb PC3200. And Planetside takes right around 2 and a half minutes to bring up the desktop when I alt-tab out of it. Totally unacceptable!

I understand 2gb of ram is an important advantage in this regards (and I believe that - I remember the huge difference in alt-tabbing out of Tribes 2 1gb made vs 512mb), but I'm curious what other element would make a difference. Again, this isn't the ONLY concern.

I mean, clearly, a 7800GTX pwns a 6800GT in performance. It's a sweet card! But, an A64 4200+ dual-core pwns a 3500+ single-core in multi-tasking....to what extent? Enough to almost make up the performance difference between a 6800GT and 7800GTX? Or, is it such a minor difference that the 7800GTX performance simply speaks louder?

That's the question!
 
As for alt tabbing out and checking aim or yim... I used to do that on my rig (specs in sig) and it didn't lag at all. Of course.. I haven't run BF2 on it yet. However.. I've run Guild Wars in a window while talking on aim at the same time. Although normally I'd just concentrate on my game and forget about messaging clients. I usually play some type of music in the background via media player / winamp. Don't know if that's much of a multi task at all. All in all.... you'll probably still get the better deal with the 7800 gtx and the 3500+.

But now... I've got my new laptop on aim all the time while I game on my desktop right next to it :D
 
Venice + 7800GTX would give you the best gaming experience, and you dont seem like you do that much multitasking that the dual core would be worth the lose of the 7800GTX.

Your last theory is the most true one really.

Plus if for some reason in the future you'd like to upgrade to dual core you can do it.
 
I'm not too big into Intels, but wouldn't a nice P4 with HyperThreading be good for that kind of use?

-wil
 
pigwalk said:
I'm not too big into Intels, but wouldn't a nice P4 with HyperThreading be good for that kind of use?

-wil

Not really, you can generally get the same effect of HT by just using proper cache tweaking utilities. Also, a P4 of equal performance is not gonna be coming cheap, a 3.6Ghz is upwards close to $400, and anything less than on a P4 is losing a decent amount of gaming performance.
 
intel Pentium D 820 Smithfield 800MHz FSB 2 x 1MB L2 Cache LGA 775 Dual Core, EM64T Processor - Retail

$258.99

You could get a Dual Core P4 & a 7800GTX in your price range.
 
PRIME1 said:
intel Pentium D 820 Smithfield 800MHz FSB 2 x 1MB L2 Cache LGA 775 Dual Core, EM64T Processor - Retail

$258.99

You could get a Dual Core P4 & a 7800GTX in your price range.


This is true. Problem being the hidden costs of the 955 chipset and a DDR2 upgrade.
 
Skrying said:
Not really, you can generally get the same effect of HT by just using proper cache tweaking utilities. Also, a P4 of equal performance is not gonna be coming cheap, a 3.6Ghz is upwards close to $400, and anything less than on a P4 is losing a decent amount of gaming performance.


Don't really agree with that. Compare say a 3.2E with a 7800gtx vs a FX55 with a 6800gt. Any decent amount of gaming performance, realistically, is lost in the GPU.
 
To the original poster, tough choice. Either way you'll be happy :) . Personally i think the X2 would be the better investment, but i don't spend the majority of the time i use my computer playing games.
 
That's a hard choice. I had an AMD and Intel box to the seperate tasks but sold them to go with an 4400+ and 7800 gtx. The X2 has been amazing but I haven't been able to game with it yet. The BFG 7800 gtx arrives tomorrow.

For mostly gaming use, it would seem that the 3700+ and 7800 gtx would be more efficient. The graphic card will always help while half of the 4200+'s power would be unused most of the time.

As awe-inspiring as the AMD dual cores as to me, the single cores make the most sense when primarily gaming. Going single core now, and upgrading later to dual core when they are cheaper and better supported will give the biggest returns.

I'd scrimp and save for a while to get another $300 to have both an X2 and 7800 gtx though. :D
 
Playing games is so crazy, when going between zones it seems to be seamless now. Normally when I go from one instance or zone or map to another I get lag for like 15 or so seconds as soon as I enter a map. Not any more. Also when online normally if a bunch of people jump into an area at once my computer would slow down and 10 seconds later people are all over the place and i'm dead. Not anymore. Its sad that games like unreal tournament move so fast I have to stop playing because the motion gets me kinda sick at times.
 
sixandout said:
Playing games is so crazy, when going between zones it seems to be seamless now. Normally when I go from one instance or zone or map to another I get lag for like 15 or so seconds as soon as I enter a map. Not any more. Also when online normally if a bunch of people jump into an area at once my computer would slow down and 10 seconds later people are all over the place and i'm dead. Not anymore. Its sad that games like unreal tournament move so fast I have to stop playing because the motion gets me kinda sick at times.
Are these applications even utilizing the second core? I'm pretty sure nothing is optimized yet, meaning the 2nd core is doing jack shit (unless you run a TON of stuff in the background while you game, and that is why it was slower in the first place). Are you sure you just aren't seeing a performance boost from the increased clock speed over your previous CPU?
 
all i can say is I LOVE MY NEW X2 4400!! im running it at 2.6 ghz and it is rock solid. BF2 is SO much better now. i guess the extra gig of RAM helps it too. i have no worries ALT-TABing to check ventrillo, or change my music. it is the best thing i have ever bought for a computer! best money i ever spent!

Athlon 64 X2 4400
Asus A8N-SLI Prem
BFG 7800GTX OC
2X 1 gig Crucial ballistix PC 4000
Silverstone ZEUS 650 Watt PSU
WD Raptor 74 Gb
WD Caviar 200 Gb SATA II (storage)
Plextor SATA DVD burner +/-R
SONY DVD-ROM
ThermalTake SHARK Case
Zalman 770Cu 120mm
AS ceramique
 
jervonics said:
all i can say is I LOVE MY NEW X2 4400!! im running it at 2.6 ghz and it is rock solid. BF2 is SO much better now. i guess the extra gig of RAM helps it too. i have no worries ALT-TABing to check ventrillo, or change my music. it is the best thing i have ever bought for a computer! best money i ever spent!


I agree with the 4400. I also have mine running at 2.6ghz, on stock cooling. I love the processor. Best proc I have ever bought. Though for right outta the box gaming, the 3500 and 7800 would be your best choice.
 
spend $100 on a shitty laptop from ebay & use that for IM while gaming ;)
 
From a practical point of view, if the AMD roadmap is correct and they only want to go up from X2 4800+ to X2 5000+ by next year, you may as well get the X2 4800+ now. You may be spending a little more now, but I've seen FX chips get phased out rather than go lower in price. Some higher end products just don't seem to go down in price much. And we won't see very much speed increases in the next year.

Given that the 6800 GT is one of the better deals out there without being excessively overpriced, I'd go for that combo, X2 4800+ & 6800 GT.

Of course, some people save money by buying the 4400+ instead.

\EDIT: The 6800 GT should be good until they come out with the Geforce 8 line next summer. :p
 
Back
Top