Best firewall for a cable/dsl setup?

RavinDJ

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Apr 9, 2002
Messages
4,578
So I want the best (as long as it's under $1,000) form of protection against the crap on the net... what sort of firewall should I be looking into for my cable/dsl setup?

Dedicated hardware firewall? Linux box acting as a router/firewall? Or, would a stupid little BEFSX41 (Linksys VPN router) suffice? I don't really need VPN... just want to make sure my servers and other machines are protected 24/7 from the crap out there.
 
I'm kinda fond of the idea of using a nix box...figure it'll probably give you the most flexible solution. However many times something much less complicated is "good enough". Depends how paranoid you are, how much you even care, what type/size of network it's protecting...
 
If you have $1,000 to burn, i'd say go to ebay and pick up a cisco 2600 router and learn how to use cisco devices. If you get the enterprise ios, there is all kinds of firewall features you can play with.
 
Well, he could also go with a PIX, as it is more powerful as a firewall than the limited capabilites of a Cisco 2600 router.

There is also firewall devices, such as the Netscreen 5XP or Fortinet Fortigate 60.

Personally, I use a Linux machine but that is only because I do quite a bit of strange things that require the flexibility I gain from using the Linux machine.
 
thanks for the input, guys!

yeah, i'm VERY paranoid about my network :eek:)

I'm either going for the PIX 501 after doing some reading on it or a dedicated *nix box... I have a bunch of old computers that i didn't know what to do with them, and now i do :eek:)

which *nix distro do you recommend as a firewall? should the *nix box also act as a router? dhcp server? anything else??? web? ftp? file? or, should it just be DEDICATED just for the FIREWALL?
 
I use a Linux hardware firewall here at home. It's really nice to have a complete computer instead of a simple router because it can double as a server for all kinds of tasks. There are a few ready-made distros out there which work really well such as IPCop, Clarkconnect (which I use), Smoothwall, and Monowall. They'll usually have a nice web based GUI so you'll never really have to use the Linux command prompt if you don't want to.

If you're really paranoid about security then your Linux firewall should be a firewall only (and DHCP server of course), but you honestly can run a very secure webserver/ftp server/file server/whatever from the same machine.
 
If you have a bunch of old hardware sitting around anyway you might as well limit its functions to network stuff and use a different box if you want a web/file server.
 
So the order is like this?

DSL/CABLE ---- DSL/CABLE MODEM ----- *NIX FIREWALL w/ 2 NICs ------ SWITCH ---- bunch of PC's

?
 
That's the general idea, yes.
Given how PPPoE works, it should actually work as well (and be as safe) to do it this way:
DSL->modem->switch->{*nix-box, computers}
(IOW, just connect everything to the switch and only have one NIC in the *nix-box).

The packets will travel PC->switch->*nix-box->switch->DSL-modem->DSL-over-phoneline, of course.
(Cable and DSL-"modems" that are actually routers are another matter, but PPPoE is an encapsulated affair that you can switch safely on your local network.)
 
And for the record, most of your alternatives will do just fine if all you're going to do is blocking and forwarding ports + NAT. The simplest little box will do that.
I'd still recommend a BSD box + pf. Decent flexibility/difficulty balance, and if you've already got the hardware, there's no monetary costs.
 
Back
Top