Best Card for 1280x1024?

drew829

n00b
Joined
Jan 30, 2007
Messages
32
I was wondering what is the best video card out there for 1280x1024 resolution. Right now I have a Radeon x1900xt with a AMD Athlon64 3700+, 2gb of memory and a 680w psu but I'm going to get a new CPU, mobo and memory as a christmas/birthday present this winter so I won't mind a bottleneck for a while.
 
The best is obviously a 4870X2 ;) But a 8800 GT/9600 GT would be the best for the least $ at that resolutuion.
 
I previously had a 9600gt, worked great for me at 1280x1024. I maxed everything and got 60+ frames on average. Except for crysis of course. Grid was amazing, Dirt worked, Call of Duty 4 was perfect, everything was great.
 
An 8800GT would pretty much destroy at that res and is getting darn close to the $100 mark with rebates. That would be my choice. Or for a bit more a 4850.
 
I would get either an 8800gt new.(cheap too)
Or an 8800gtx used.(cheap)
Or a 4850.
At that resolution you probably wont see a difference in any of those. Obviously, going to a faster card will cost more. You just have to decide weather you will be upgrading your monitor any time soon. I personally don't see the need to go higher than 1080p, but others will disagree.
Also, take into consideration that CPU's seem to be lagging behind GPU's of late. In the recent video card reviews it is clear that some games are CPU limited. Running at 1280x1024 will make this even more pronounced.
I game at 1280x1024 with an 8800gts640 SSC. Even that card is CPU bound with my current opteron 165@2.6GHz. Granted, that CPU is slow compared to the newer intel core CPU's but I am poor. On 32player TF2 servers during heavy fights I see frames in the 40s. Again, to some, this is just fine. To me, it is down right horrid. I get the same frames with everything set to max as I do with everything turned off. Max around 160 and min around 40.
Damn, I need a new processor.:p
 
Lol. 8800GT at max.

I'd get either a 3870, 9600GT, or 8800GT.

Anything above that is pretty much overkill.

With my setup I max all my games @ 1680 x 1050...
 
Lol. 8800GT at max.

I'd get either a 3870, 9600GT, or 8800GT.

Anything above that is pretty much overkill.

With my setup I max all my games @ 1680 x 1050...

QFT. I run a similar setup and the same res. I used to be on a 1280x1024 and could max pretty much anything. It's so cheap there's almost no reason not to get one.


Unless you have plans for a monitor upgrade in the near future?
 
QFT. I run a similar setup and the same res. I used to be on a 1280x1024 and could max pretty much anything. It's so cheap there's almost no reason not to get one.


Unless you have plans for a monitor upgrade in the near future?

Well I do have a 30" CRT HDTV close to my computer so if I wanted to use that as a monitor, I'll just buy a 18-20 feet cable and a wireless keyboard & mouse and I'll be in business.
 
Well I do have a 30" CRT HDTV close to my computer so if I wanted to use that as a monitor, I'll just buy a 18-20 feet cable and a wireless keyboard & mouse and I'll be in business.

In that case you might want to spend a bit more and get a 4850. They're pretty cheap now and can be had for the 160-200$ range. It would definitely be a bit more future proof and help with higher res.
 
I had a 17" 1280x1024 monitor before and my 8800GTS 512MB was enough to max out any game except Crysis (We need an abbreviation for that since it's always every game except Crysis, EGEC). 4870X2 would be total overkill unless you hack it so you can use 64xAA or something =P
 
Getting the fastest card you can afford won't hurt, even at that res. You can always use the spare horsepower to enable highe quality AA and AF settings and a faster card will allow you to keep using FSAA in new games coming out. A 4870X2 is probably overkill, but even a 4870 might make sense if you can afford it, provided you get a newer, faster CPU. The 4850 is also a good choice.
 
i have 19'' 1280*1024 monitor and today i bought a 4870:)i compared it with my friend's gtx and noticed that the bottleneck problem is not obvious.games run smooth like silk:)maximising the aa and af will make your cpu take a breath if you use an old dual core.i use a X2 5600 @3ghz and i dont have any problem now with bottleneck.
it is certain that the new high-ends are perfect cards.and every cpu will bottleneck.the problem is that;how much will it reflect this problem to you?will it make you feel the b.neck problem?
and i have a strange idea:)48XX series has 800 sp and i think this helps cpu run easier with these cards than gtx series.i think nvidia cards are more cpu bound than ati ones...what do you think?

and edit:dont do something crazy like buying a 4870x2.it is waste of money for that resolution:)
 
i have 19'' 1280*1024 monitor and today i bought a 4870:)i compared it with my friend's gtx and noticed that the bottleneck problem is not obvious.games run smooth like silk:)maximising the aa and af will make your cpu take a breath if you use an old dual core.i use a X2 5600 @3ghz and i dont have any problem now with bottleneck.
it is certain that the new high-ends are perfect cards.and every cpu will bottleneck.the problem is that;how much will it reflect this problem to you?will it make you feel the b.neck problem?
and i have a strange idea:)48XX series has 800 sp and i think this helps cpu run easier with these cards than gtx series.i think nvidia cards are more cpu bound than ati ones...what do you think?

and edit:dont do something crazy like buying a 4870x2.it is waste of money for that resolution:)

The current gen cards are definitely not perfect. If they were, they would be able to run anything now and in the future without a worry to upgrade. CPU bottlenecking isn't as obvious or apparent as one might think. Most of the time, with a decent dual core vs. even a highly oc'd 45nm chip, the difference won't be that great once you turn everything up in game. Games are mostly video card restricted nowadays when you start turning up all of the effects for maximum eye candy.

nVidia cards being more cpu restrictive than ATi cards? I've never heard of that either.
 
I've seen a few 4870s at $200 AR now, but failing that a 4850 would be your next best bet, and I'm only recommending those because you might use the HDTV with it at some point in the future.
 
For low cost and enough power, I'd get the ATI 3850 for $60 AR (in the deals forum).
 
The current gen cards are definitely not perfect. If they were, they would be able to run anything now and in the future without a worry to upgrade. CPU bottlenecking isn't as obvious or apparent as one might think. Most of the time, with a decent dual core vs. even a highly oc'd 45nm chip, the difference won't be that great once you turn everything up in game. Games are mostly video card restricted nowadays when you start turning up all of the effects for maximum eye candy.

nVidia cards being more cpu restrictive than ATi cards? I've never heard of that either.


They would be able to run anything now and in future without a worry to upgrade???for this reason they arent perfect right?:))
i think we arent talking about the same thing.these manufacturers should make money to give us better cards.and we need development to reach better...we call this as technology:))
and if you talk about crysis with saying ''anything'';we all know that crysis is bad optimised.may be not optimised any:D even a single leaf has a its own shadow in the game...no need so much detail...
Chinspecial;accept or dont...but these are the latest cards we can buy.this is the latest technology.and this makes them perfect for me.till a better one comes:D
 
You said you're gonna upgrade this winter...


4850 FTW. When winter comes, 90% chance that you'd be grabbing a CF-supporting motherboard, then add another 4850.
 
The 4850 is going to be the best bet for 1280x1024. It has a lot of muscle at that resolution and should compliment nicely your new system this winter.
 
Most games don't use the CPU very much, but some games are very limited by the CPU. World in Conflict for example is very CPU limited. 4850 is a good card and will work very well at that resolution, don't really need the extra bandwidth provided by GDDR5 at that resolution even with AA and AF.
 
I had a similar rig as you before i bit the bullet. I went with a 4850, its really awesome, and at 1280x1024, you really do need some levels of AA, which the 4850 can easily handle with no noticeable performance hit. Grid for instance owns at 8xAA, tf2, cod4 at 4x, its really amazing. Love the card. Way better than my old x1900, and much less whiny too. The other nv cards and the 3850 are good too, but the 4850 is a lot more future proof i think, plus full 1080p upscaling, dx10.1 and crossfire support make it a killer buy.
 
I would get either an 8800gt new.(cheap too)
Or an 8800gtx used.(cheap)
Or a 4850.
At that resolution you probably wont see a difference in any of those. Obviously, going to a faster card will cost more. You just have to decide weather you will be upgrading your monitor any time soon. I personally don't see the need to go higher than 1080p, but others will disagree.
Also, take into consideration that CPU's seem to be lagging behind GPU's of late. In the recent video card reviews it is clear that some games are CPU limited. Running at 1280x1024 will make this even more pronounced.
I game at 1280x1024 with an 8800gts640 SSC. Even that card is CPU bound with my current opteron 165@2.6GHz. Granted, that CPU is slow compared to the newer intel core CPU's but I am poor. On 32player TF2 servers during heavy fights I see frames in the 40s. Again, to some, this is just fine. To me, it is down right horrid. I get the same frames with everything set to max as I do with everything turned off. Max around 160 and min around 40.
Damn, I need a new processor.:p

I would have to agree and say that you should look at some of the used stuff in these forums. There are some great deals in there
 
If your staying at that res then I would get the 8800GT and start saving toward a newer proc and mobo for the future. that should last you a little while.
 
Back
Top