Best AV for Server.

turb0

Gawd
Joined
Aug 20, 2004
Messages
636
I'm looking to replace the Trend Micro AV I have on my 2k3 Ent. Server and looking for the best protection / options out there.

Server is currently running SQL Server 2k5 and Terminal Server for a special medical touchscreen application for a doctors office.

Important part:
I'm not looking for the cheapest option by any means. But I am looking for the best option to cover the Server only. The TS Clients open directly into the Special Program only and do not allow the employees access to anything but the program, so a Client based AV is not needed. The Clients are all running NOD32.


Any help, opinions, experiences are greatly appreciated.
.
 
if you already have nod32 on the clients too its a no brainer, get it on the server, and manage it all from the server
 
so the standard NOD32 AV4 will work on Server OS just like the XP or Vista?

I'm sorry for my minor bout of noobish'ness here, when I first got Trend Micro like 2 years ago, I had a really [H]ard time finding a decent Server based AV as many of the basic AVs will not run on the Server OS.
 
need the Business Edition version.

how do you have ur client machines setup? you have individual username and pass for each one?
 
need the Business Edition version.

how do you have ur client machines setup? you have individual username and pass for each one?

Business License for the machines but they are not controlled by a central server in the office.

Looking to change that in the future when I can get a new server for File sharing and set up AD.
 
that you should change as soon as you renew

myself or yeolde are the hardforum resellers =)
 
F-Secure for Exchange works great for us. We also have another security layer at the network edge, and by that i mean a Cisco IronPort C150 with the SOPHOS av engine enabled.
 
so the standard NOD32 AV4 will work on Server OS just like the XP or Vista?

The business edition is the same installer for Vista, XP, Win200Pro, Server 2008, Server 2003, Server 2000.

Although for my clients servers, I'm still using NOD 2.7, not 3 or 4. 4 just came out, no use putting a brand new program on production servers til they iron out a few more kinks over the next month or so. I don't like 3 on servers, I stick with 2.7.
 
The business edition is the same installer for Vista, XP, Win200Pro, Server 2008, Server 2003, Server 2000.

Although for my clients servers, I'm still using NOD 2.7, not 3 or 4. 4 just came out, no use putting a brand new program on production servers til they iron out a few more kinks over the next month or so. I don't like 3 on servers, I stick with 2.7.
\
Thank you all wise StoneCat!

Is 2.7 still an option to purchase? I'll prolly be buying this by week's end if possible.
 
Hate to say it, but for large enterprises Norton Corporate is still good, but my personal preference is KIS 2009. But from cost and ease of managing 220k nodes, Norton is hard to replace. That said Norton is one of the slowest to update their signatures, ENOD, AVG, Trend, Karp all do it much faster.
 
Hate to say it, but for large enterprises Norton Corporate is still good,

//shudders and trembles from years of nightmares with that beast.

Oh the countless hours spent manually cleaning up workstations that got the SAV upgrade corrupted.
 
//shudders and trembles from years of nightmares with that beast.

Oh the countless hours spent manually cleaning up workstations that got the SAV upgrade corrupted.

Dont know what to tell ya we have over 27000 servers and 180000WSs, and in 10 years of running Norton AV we have never deployed a Signature update that got corrupt. It has happened in testing, but thats why our AV Team tests things before they roll them into production.

So I question change management and testing procedures when I hear comments like yours.
 
Congratulations on never failing a signature update..those are probably pretty hard to fail at, I had never had a definition update fail. How did you mighty testing team manage to get a sig update to fail? :confused:

But program upgrades..such as upgrading a clients network from SAV 8 to SAV 9, or SAV 9 to that hideously 100+ meg eating version 10.

I had been a reseller of SAV since around version 5.0...I liked it up until about version 9, when it became as useless as tits on a nun as far as detecting malware, and I lost so many hours doing the "push install" upgrades on networks when a handful of quite healthy workstations were prone to have hideous errors starting the services on a reboot. Requiring many tedious hours of manually removing all the components and installing again.

Quite a few other IT peeps here share these views...many of us here have groaned over it. And on other tech boards.

Management and testing proceedures..that's fairly non-existent when it comes to SMB consulting. Small Business Network clients don't have resources to go send me several hundred bucks ahead of time to go "test" a software upgrade in some sandbox of their network. They get their subscription renewed, they expect a new version of said product to install and upgrade what they have.
 
Signature corruption is rare but it happens, and you are right about malware, but please do not lecture me on small companies not affording a sandbox, you dont need to spend a lot of money to have a test server and WS to test an update, I'd go as far as to say companies cannot afford not to.

Granted my company size is very large, but its not about affording a sandbox, its about how much it will cost us if we send out an update that takes down 200k workstations, and that cost is the hell of a lot bigger.

As far as other admins moaning, I'm not here to defend norton, hell I dont use it on my home PCs, but the fact is, that properly managed it works well.
 
symantec: is too resource heavy (sucks dealing with a development team about resource usage)

bit defender: (don't get me started, stay away!)

sophos: (was ok, but really lacking in managability)

ESET NOD: using it right now, it's pretty light weight, the centralized management is good, but lately it's missed a few things here and there, but still best of the bunch
 
PCs, but the fact is, that properly managed it works well.

What does "properly managed" have to do with program upgrades failing from the push install, or hell..even pulling from the client, failing? Properly managed before it goes to the CD stamping and shipped....but nothing from properly managed as far as the machines it's installed on. There's normally no magic in upgrading antivirus software.

SAV management console running for years, healthy server, healthy workstations, DNS/WINS/name resolution running properly, rights on workstations, SAV console is easy peasy, it's intuitive and a no brainer (I'll give them that). Upgrade rollout is normally a simple straightforward process. The error that occured on the clients that tanked was quite common, Symantsuck even had articles on how to address the issue. Googling the error back then showed many other techs moaning over the issue.
 
Top the OP. Yes you can download 2.7 instead of 3 or 4 when you get a license. Exchange servers still need to run 2.7 unless they added the agent in 4(haven't messed with 4 yet).

If you have been happy with eset I'd continue to run it. So far it seems to be one of the best choices.

Hate to say it, but for large enterprises Norton Corporate is still good, but my personal preference is KIS 2009. But from cost and ease of managing 220k nodes, Norton is hard to replace. That said Norton is one of the slowest to update their signatures, ENOD, AVG, Trend, Karp all do it much faster.

//shudders and trembles from years of nightmares with that beast.

Oh the countless hours spent manually cleaning up workstations that got the SAV upgrade corrupted.

I'm with YeOlde on this one. 10 sucks ass with detection of malware and 11 is a steaming pile of shit.

Endpoint protections console has issues. The network and proactive agents in endpoint cause nothing but issues. I spend a few hours on the phone with symantec who couldn't figure out why endpoint was killing backup execs remote agent on one of are clients. Ended up reloading 10 on the server to fix it. Can't wait till I can move them to eset or kaspersky. This client is also having issues with symantec going nuts and filling the workstation hard drives with temp files. It has done it to at least 10 machines and they have no clue why.

Endpoint was screwing with act on another clients network. Removing the network and proactive agents from the server and workstations didn't seem to fix it. For them we took them down to 10 as well as their subscription is up in a few months. Sage is the one that ended up saying to do this. Didn't bother with symantec.

The 3rd example I can think of was with 08 server. The network monitor was pretty much killing file shares. Disabling it did nothing to fix the issue. Ended up having to uninstall it.

Out of the 3 kaspersky's console is the best. That being said kaspersky's detection rates have gone down over the last year. We have been having more malware issues with them. The xpantivirus/av08/av09/etc keeps getting past it. I personally don't like symantec's new console(old one was better even though it was unorganized) and esets is pretty crappy although once you get the hang of it you can get shit done quick.

All of this is on top of the fact that endpoint is a huge memory hog. Yea I know mr3 fixed a lot of shit but it still sucks.
 
Anyone still using McAfee? We are still on 8.5 and it is a nightmare. And now that spending has been cut, I can't convince the right people to look for another solution. I bought NOD32 for my Workstation just to free up resources.
 
Anyone using Trend? What are the thoughts of Trend out there? Bad enough to move to NOD32? My company is going through a struggle and some people are wanting to move to a different software suite.
 
Anyone using Trend? What are the thoughts of Trend out there? Bad enough to move to NOD32? My company is going through a struggle and some people are wanting to move to a different software suite.

Trend Micro use to be a pretty good suite although I've never messed with the business version. My understanding is that they have gone down hill. If you are having issues with it though call eset and get a 30 day trial license and load the admin server and set it up on a few workstations. See if it does enough to warrant a switch.
 
our clients that were on nod were pushed to trend.

didn't have nething bad to say bout trend, just easier to manage one software then others =)

come to myself or yeolde if your serious about nod for business, we can get you a good price
 
We're rocking Symantec Endpoint v11 at work (300-500 employees 200-300 servers) and I hate it with a passion. I feel it gives false-positives on a daily basis and doesn't do shit worth scanning. The higher up Admins wanted to go with it because they were "familiar" with it. I installed a few other products, nod32, avira, sophos, trying to get them to go a different route (Avira personally) but no dice.

Good thing is the subscription is up in Sept so I'll have another shot and getting them to purchase a worth while solution.

Anyone using Avira for enterprise?
 
Back
Top