Best AGP Video card

DandyBear

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 1, 2004
Messages
355
Been out of the video card market for a long time. My old ATI 1800XT PE just blew up. One of these days I'll get a new computer. Until then, whats the best AGP video card out there. Thanks for the assistance.
 
3650 AGP
I doubt there will ever be a more powerful AGP, not sure if the driver issues were resolved though, do some research on it.
 
I think there was a 3850 agp card if you still find one I beleive that was the fastest agp card made.
 
Sorry! had my head up my ass. Sometimes the numbers all run together. Anyway, lets try this again....

The 3850 most likely will be the most powerful AGP card ever made.... :eek:
 
...because most AGP systems have single-core CPUs which are not able to run the 3850 AGP to its full potential.
 
Yep 3850, I tried it but the drivers just plain sucked and are unsupported by amd/ati. Got tired of screwing around with it and sent it back. If you try it - get it from newegg so you can be sure you can get a hassle free return.
 
...because most AGP systems have single-core CPUs which are not able to run the 3850 AGP to its full potential.

You are right but there are a few S939 boards that support X2 processors w/ AGP 8x. But these are few and far between, especially these days. :p
 
Did you check X800 ? it was my last AGP vga before i switched to PCI-E. And it was the best.
 
Did you check X800 ? it was my last AGP vga before i switched to PCI-E. And it was the best.

Did you bother reading the OP? He said he had a X1800XT PE and your telling him to go buy a X800?


HD3850 for the best there is or a X1950Pro / 7900GS for an somewhat equivalent card as your old one.
 
I had a Sapphire 3850 agp for about six months This card brought my 3d mark6 score from 1800 with a x1650 pro to 6800 with the 3850 .It was an awesome card but I killed it with too aggresive an overclock. I was able to max out all the setting on older games like BF2 or Halflife2. On COD4 and Crysis I could run medium setting with an average framerate of 25 fps. This was on a single core amd 3800 running at about 2700mgz.My cpu core temp has dropped about 5 degrees C since I put the X1650pro back in. Either the 3850 was restricting airflow or the card was running hot. Anyway My agp days are over .I building an intel system. The prices have come down low enough I would recommend not wasting money on An agp card. I paid 160.00 dollars For the 3850 and I would have been better off building a new system.
 
The prices have come down low enough I would recommend not wasting money on An agp card. I paid 160.00 dollars For the 3850 and I would have been better off building a new system.

decent LGA775 DDR2 motherboard: $70-$100
2GB DDR2-800 RAM: $5-$20
Intel e5200: $75 (overclocks like crazy with the right motherboard)
nVidia 9800GT or ATi 4830: $100-$110
decent PSU: $40-$60 (can usually find an Earthwatts or Corsair in that range on sale)

total: $300-$400

When you can do this, there's no reason to stick with AGP anymore. You don't need a $2000 i7 DDR3 system to have a really quite decent gaming computer.
 
Yep 3850, I tried it but the drivers just plain sucked and are unsupported by amd/ati.

Not quite true. They offer a hotfix version available through their knowledge base that supports the AGP version.

As someone who bought the 3850 AGP, I found it largely useless in the sense that the system I used it in was still heavily limited by my P4. It's just not worth it any more.
 
I used the HD 3850 AGP for a year and never had a single issue, it was coupled with a Pentium M overclocked to 2.70GHz which was able to rival the Athlon X2 4200+ in multi threaded games, and outperformed the Athlon X2 4800+ in single threaded games. The only game that wasn't playable was Far Cry 2 which has a terrible CPU dependency, I was able to play Crysis with a mix of medium and high settings and was playable. And was a nice performance jump from the X1950XT that I had before.
 
decent LGA775 DDR2 motherboard: $70-$100
2GB DDR2-800 RAM: $5-$20
Intel e5200: $75 (overclocks like crazy with the right motherboard)
nVidia 9800GT or ATi 4830: $100-$110
decent PSU: $40-$60 (can usually find an Earthwatts or Corsair in that range on sale)

total: $300-$400

When you can do this, there's no reason to stick with AGP anymore. You don't need a $2000 i7 DDR3 system to have a really quite decent gaming computer.

Good estimates, but sometimes, the difference between $150 and $300 is a lot. Shrug. Sometimes, the limitations of the budget are more important than what you're getting for the money.

Although I have to say, I was looking at a 3850 AGP for a long, long time and did in fact end up upgrading everything. Lol. I had waited so long, deliberating, that I ended up having enough money saved for a whole new build.
 
Having spent 3 months researching this purchase and installing the Sapphire 3850 AGP card in my system 4 days ago, I would consider myself an expert on this subject.

Previously owned an x800 AiW on a Socket 939 with an Opteron 170 and 2GB of DDR RAM.

The replacement of this card was painless. As the Newegg reviews will validate, the driver support issues have been resolved.

Saw my 3dMark06 score jump from 2200 to 8300. Running Bioshock at 1600 x 1200 perfectly fine, bumped the AA to 4X and it made the game slightly choppy so I backed it down. I still haven't loaded up Left 4 Dead, but I expect to move up from my previous 1280 x 1024, to 1600 x 1200 as well.

For $125 I've now got a system that will run wonderfully for another year or two. I'd love to upgrade but a new PCI-Express video card means new memory, motherboard, and CPU. Something I don't feel the need to do right now. The Opteron is OC'd to 2.4, and I can make it 2.8 if I become CPU limited.

The argument for $300 or $400 systems doesn't seem fair if the system won't have SLI and a comparable strength video card.
 
I would agree with the statement made by evilsofa. I'm at this same point with my system. I have a P4 system and had a BFG 6800 card that crapped itself and lucky enough my lifetime warranty got me a 7800GS in exchange. If I still wanted to game on PC again I'd build something like what was mentioned. You don't need to go nutz to build a kickass PC.
 
The argument for $300 or $400 systems doesn't seem fair if the system won't have SLI and a comparable strength video card.

SLI or Crossfire is irrelevant to a $300-$400 system; SLI/Crossfire only makes sense when a single card like the GTX285 isn't fast enough, which means a 2560x1600 system which is in a completely different realm than we're talking about here.

The 9800GT or 4830 are nearly twice as fast as a 3850, so I don't know what you mean by not having a comparable strength video card.
 
I personally like the Nvidia cards... And the best bang one of those is the 6800 Ultra. You could probably find one on ebay for cheap. And I've always thought that the Nvidia drivers were much better.

If you want ATI/AMD... I'd say the HD3650. :)

-Brett
 
Back
Top