Benchmarks Of The $5 Raspberry Pi Zero

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The alternative OS gurus over at Phoronix have taken the recently announced $5 Raspberry Pi Zero out for a spin to see what it can do. How does it stack up against Intel's Compute stick and NVIDIA's Tegra K1? Hit the link to find out. Here's a quote to whet your appetite:

The Raspberry Pi Zero launched one week ago as the foundation's cheapest board yet (just $5 USD!) and also their smallest at about half the size of a Raspberry Pi Model A+. The Raspberry Pi Zero features a 1GHz single-core ARM processor, 512MB of RAM, mini HDMI and USB OTG ports, and a 40-pin header. There isn't any onboard Ethernet so you'll need to end up using a USB-based Ethernet or WiFi adapter. The Broadcom SoC in use by the Raspberry Pi Zero is a BCM2708.
 
kind of a dumb test... would have been more interesting to see what the performance to price ratio was between all of those devices though

a bar chart with those current bar charts values divided by how much the device cost...
 
I'm really amazed with the whole Raspberry Pi scene.
The Pi Zero is missing the 1 thing that would make it fly off the shelf and that is built in Ethernet. Of course it wouldn't be $5 then.
But say $5 and Ethernet ; a 1000 node distributed computing rig? And with the tiny size of the board, that would be a very interesting setup.
 
Amazing for $5.

Now make that into a $15 wifi/cell phone and we have another winner.
 
I think the Pi2 is a much better value. Just adding the adapters to make PiZero run will bring it pretty close or even past the Pi2 price plus the Pi2 can run windows for IoT.
 
I know nothing about programming but I have a use for one of these. I'd like to create a sound generator for electric model airplanes. Basically taking the PWM signal from the channel and using it to output sound and/or modulate pitch of sound samples. There are off-the shelf units out there but they are in the $150-200 range. It would be a fun project but I have no clue where to start.
 
I'm really amazed with the whole Raspberry Pi scene.
The Pi Zero is missing the 1 thing that would make it fly off the shelf and that is built in Ethernet. Of course it wouldn't be $5 then.
But say $5 and Ethernet ; a 1000 node distributed computing rig? And with the tiny size of the board, that would be a very interesting setup.

The cost for that would be very high, especially for what little return you would get; also, this has already been done at least twice.
It's not very cost effective, but for learning purposes, it is great.

Even I was able to setup a four-node Raspberry Pi cluster (1 master, 3 slave), but the biggest bottlenecks are the CPUs and the Ethernet controller sharing bandwidth over USB.
 
I know nothing about programming but I have a use for one of these. I'd like to create a sound generator for electric model airplanes. Basically taking the PWM signal from the channel and using it to output sound and/or modulate pitch of sound samples. There are off-the shelf units out there but they are in the $150-200 range. It would be a fun project but I have no clue where to start.

For plastic models, or R/C?
 
Would've been killer if it had at least ethernet connectivity. Hanging a bulky dongle off of something this tiny makes no sense. Otherwise, specs are minimal but probably sufficient for a home file/media server.

Still shopping but Odroid C1+ seems to be the sweet spot right now.
 
I'm really amazed with the whole Raspberry Pi scene.
The Pi Zero is missing the 1 thing that would make it fly off the shelf and that is built in Ethernet. Of course it wouldn't be $5 then.
But say $5 and Ethernet ; a 1000 node distributed computing rig? And with the tiny size of the board, that would be a very interesting setup.

I think the Pi2 is a much better value. Just adding the adapters to make PiZero run will bring it pretty close or even past the Pi2 price plus the Pi2 can run windows for IoT.

Would've been killer if it had at least ethernet connectivity. Hanging a bulky dongle off of something this tiny makes no sense. Otherwise, specs are minimal but probably sufficient for a home file/media server.

Still shopping but Odroid C1+ seems to be the sweet spot right now.

People really seem to miss the point with this one.

The Pi Zero isn't for these types of situations. They already have the model 2 B+ that has ethernet, 4 usb ports, quad core cpu, and 1GB of RAM. If your project needs ethernet or more usb devices, get the bigger model. It won't get bogged down with the more intense compute load. The second you add a usb hub to a pi zero, you've defeated the purpose of the device's small size.

The Pi Zero is more for single dedicated projects that aren't too complex. Use it to run some sensors or a servo. Have it offload certain basic tasks from a main box then report back on the serial line.

I can think of a couple instances where you might create a dedicated remote sensor that needs no other external input (keyboard or otherwise) and you might need an ethernet adapter. In that case just plug in a USB adapter or just by the better Pi B or B+.
 
People really seem to miss the point with this one.

The second you add a usb hub to a pi zero, you've defeated the purpose of the device's small size.

Huh? It's not the 70's anymore. All devices need connectivity and the most basic and cheapest is ethernet for things like OS patches, transferring data, downloading software, etc. Buying a bulky dongle defeats the purpose more than having it built in in the first place.
 
You guys are all about Internet-of-things around here. Having a GPIO header AND being able to use normal modern programming languages is really nice for making small projects. This easily brings it down to PIC prices and you do not have to learn a new language to program the PIC.
 
Huh? It's not the 70's anymore. All devices need connectivity and the most basic and cheapest is ethernet for things like OS patches, transferring data, downloading software, etc. Buying a bulky dongle defeats the purpose more than having it built in in the first place.
No it doesn't need that at all. Why does a dedicated micro controller have to be connected to the net all the time? You are awful narrow minded on how you view this device's use. You could use this thing to run a robot or conveyor belt. You don't always 100% of the time need internet access, and when you did you would just buy the better B+ model instead. The Pi Zero, just like all the other Pi's, has an sd card slot to load the OS and other necessities. You make a program for it, it runs the program. You can make the program on the device through the OS's tools, or you can write it elsewhere and load it to the SD card. In the case that actually program it while in the Raspbian OS, then yes you would hook it up to a hub temporarily.

The Pi zero is not intended to be a full fledged PC. The Pi B and B+ have the features you are talking about and can be run as full PC's.

You guys are all about Internet-of-things around here. Having a GPIO header AND being able to use normal modern programming languages is really nice for making small projects. This easily brings it down to PIC prices and you do not have to learn a new language to program the PIC.

Finally, someone else gets it.
 

Ah yeah I see now, are you referring to Benedini? That's some really cool stuff. I'm not sure if it could be done cheaper (or more importantly, lighter) with a Pi vs the stuff that is already out there. The hard part seems to be finding an amp/speaker combo that has enough power without weighing down the aircraft too much.
 
No it doesn't need that at all. Why does a dedicated micro controller have to be connected to the net all the time?

Don't be so closed minded. Ethernet is not only for network connectivity but also for power over ethernet, serial over ethernet, etc. One multifunctional universal interface instead of multiple to keep the device compact and cost low.
 
Don't be so closed minded. Ethernet is not only for network connectivity but also for power over ethernet, serial over ethernet, etc. One multifunctional universal interface instead of multiple to keep the device compact and cost low.
Lol. It already has a multifunctional universal interface. It's called GPIO and with it you can talk to just about anything be it an Arduino, electronic sensors, motors/servos, other raspberry pi's, etc. All of those things you mentioned can be accomplished through other means on the Pi zero. It can send serial information through GPIO, it can get power through the micro USB port or by soldering wires directly to the board, it has header ports for adding your own expansion. Hell, if you wanted to and were capable enough you could wire that stuff right to the board yourself. This device is obviously not for you since you aren't grasping this concept. So again, this device DOES NOT need an ethernet jack. They sold out of the first run of these (20,000 units) so obviously there are 20,000 people who understand what this device is for and chose it specifically over its more capable and more expensive brethren the Pi 2 B+.


What you aren't understanding is the Pi Zero is a niche product for a niche use. As has been stated multiple times already, if you need those specific features step up to the next model in line that does have them... in this case the Raspberry Pi 2 B+.
 
I really want to purchase a few Pi Zero's its dirt cheap and perfect to build some arcade units from it with MAME. Don't need Ethernet for that.

If I needed higher connectivity onboard the other Pi's are dirt cheap too.

Looking forward when the Pi Zero is back in regular stock supply. :)
 
At least it's faster than anything AMD can manage to produce :p

55231964.jpg
 
Amazing for $5.

Now make that into a $15 wifi/cell phone and we have another winner.

I backed this on Kickstater. $9 board.

http://getchip.com/

Wifi, Bluetooth and 4GB of storage built in with the tradeoff of having composite video built in over hdmi. IMHO, Worth the extra $4. Chip does, however, have daughterboards for VGA or HDMI.
 
It would have been nice if they compared it to the original one. I sold mine on EBay for $25 just yesterday.
 
What are these nvidia products in the benchmarks? I looked them up and they cost hundreds of dollars when a celeron nuc is way faster.
 
I'm so glad they released this, I was going to buy a bunch of controller boards as external data points and use the pi2 as a node server.

I hope these handle multiple bt connections well!
 
The Pi Zero should have had a direct audio out rather than composite video headers. A missed opportunity for build your own wifi speakers to mp3 player to an intercom.

People are talking like adding a ethernet dongle is the end of the world. If it had it built in, it wouldn't be $5. Also if you worried about how it looks, were you planning to let the bare board hang out or something. Not exactly a good look either unless you're an uber nerd. Put the ethernet dongle in the same box as the pi. Problem solved

OTOH its not the 2000'a, it's the 2010'a and wi-fi isn't a horror story anymore, Its not perfect but for most people its not worth retrofitting ethenet cable through their home. There's always exception like if rooms in your house are Faraday cages or you live in front of a radar dish. I would be upset if they had baked a ethernet adapter and its cost on there, which most people wouldn't need or be able to use.
 
What are these nvidia products in the benchmarks? I looked them up and they cost hundreds of dollars when a celeron nuc is way faster.

The reason they are so much is due to the embedded GPU functionality, which the others lack, at least for CUDA-based applications.
If one doesn't need an NVIDIA GPU for the embedded project, then any of the others would instantly be a better choice.
 
Pretty nice and great price point. Lots of uses for this. Do kinda wish it had ADC but, not hard to add that to it and probably better that it doesn't as it would never have enough ports no matter how many it had.
 
Back
Top