Behold the MacBook Vending Machine

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Kind of a neat idea and I’m sure the university officials knew in advance that by using MacBooks, no student would keep one longer than five hours anyway so they were safe. :D Need a laptop for library work or several classes? Just drop by the MacBook machine, swipe your student ID and take out a free MacBook. Drexel University is testing out the idea to give all students and faculty access to technology and to cut back on campus muggings.

For now it’s a demo project with single vending machine, but it could grow over time. “This is obviously going to be very popular,” Gianakaris said. “We’ll evaluate their use and, depending on the results determine how many more we can install.”
 
That's where my tuition went right there...

It's an interesting idea, will be interesting to see where it goes.
 
So before it was
Mug and steal laptop?
Now it is
Mug steal wallet, swipe card, steal laptop.
 
I guess I'm missing something, but couldn't the library just have a computer lab?

They have quite an extensive one, but I imagine the idea is to use this when working with others to study at a table or something.
 
So before it was
Mug and steal laptop?
Now it is
Mug steal wallet, swipe card, steal laptop.

Yeah, that's what I was thinking... They didn't think it through.

So now you jack someones card or find someones card, get a laptop.. and they're liable.

I wonder if they even have a camera watching the machine
 
Yeah, that's what I was thinking... They didn't think it through.

So now you jack someones card or find someones card, get a laptop.. and they're liable.

I wonder if they even have a camera watching the machine

The whole building is key card access, with a guard verifying the scanned ID of the person, so you'd be hard pressed to get in in the first place. If they start putting them in other, easier to get to buildings though...
 
The whole building is key card access, with a guard verifying the scanned ID of the person, so you'd be hard pressed to get in in the first place. If they start putting them in other, easier to get to buildings though...

So I go into the building with my card, then use the card I stole/found to get the laptop.

Still a problem unless they have a camera on the vending machine, or an rfid chip in the laptop to catch you when you try and leave the building, although the rfid chip could be defeated with a properly lined backpack.
 
So I go into the building with my card, then use the card I stole/found to get the laptop.

Still a problem unless they have a camera on the vending machine, or an rfid chip in the laptop to catch you when you try and leave the building, although the rfid chip could be defeated with a properly lined backpack.

I hear you. Only time will tell to see if this actually helps.
 
The whole building is key card access, with a guard verifying the scanned ID of the person, so you'd be hard pressed to get in in the first place. If they start putting them in other, easier to get to buildings though...
With a live guard on hand why do they need a vending machine?
 
So I go into the building with my card, then use the card I stole/found to get the laptop.

Every college ID I've seen had a picture on it.

With a live guard on hand why do they need a vending machine?

I was sort of wondering this as well, only reason I could think of was the free up the librarian from having to handle it.

Why exactly are they using Macs?

Are we really gonna start this? Does every [H] thread have to be a Mac/Rep+Dem/Metro sucks argument? Maybe they got a nice bulk or education deal, or even something as stupid as whoever started the program happen to like them?
 
Are we really gonna start this? Does every [H] thread have to be a Mac/Rep+Dem/Metro sucks argument? Maybe they got a nice bulk or education deal, or even something as stupid as whoever started the program happen to like them?

Penny pinching and continious budget cuts. A mac isn't exactly something i'd call economical. How much did this trial run cost? How much would it have costed if it had been PC laptops or many more units for the same budget?
 
This is a great idea. Students NEVER lose their student id's. :rolleyes:

What's your point?
I can't even get into my Uni at night without an ID let alone use a free laptop.
Why would you lend a laptop to someone who can't even keep track of a card you keep in your wallet?

Also, cant borrow books without an ID
 
So... I'm guessing that if I wanted to use a PC Laptop instead, I'd be out of luck.

Well at least this would be a sure fire way to make sure none of the people renting the MacBooks would be gaming on them, nothing recent, anyway.
 
How absolutely idiotic!

They could simply have a row of desks with desktops on them that are anchored down and secure from theft with easier to use full size keyboard and external mouse (touchpads suck) with a nice 24-27" 1080p screen at a FRACTION of the cost of an overpriced laptop vending machine, which always carries the risk of either theft or simply dropping it or knocking it off a table or spilling a drink on it (which with a desktop you're only likely to get a cheap $10 keyboard damaged in the same scenario).

Some jackass Apple fanatic in the faculty probably pushed this in spite of the inefficiency.
 
Chromebooks?

Well you have to find some in stock first but.............
 
And what really angers me about crap like this is that its one of the big reasons that an education is so damn unnecessarily expensive!

Especially in the information age and with such large classrooms, a college education should be cheap, but when universities are absolutely throwing money away on crap like this and millions more spent on football teams and other such nonsense, of course the tuition is going to end up being twenty grand a year... and btw tuition costs have been on steep INCLINE of late.
 
Yeah it's going to be really nice working on a laptop you rented knowing that just a few hours before some guy was spanking it to BBW porn just because he could.

I don't know the tuition rates at that particular school -- but I'm betting they are high. If you can afford to pay 10 or 20K a semester -- you can afford a laptop. i said *A LAPTOP* not some fancy unnecessary macbook.

If you spend 1500 dollars on books, you can afford a 500 dollar basic laptop that will do everything the Mac can.

No wonder our country is 13 trillion in debt... the scary part is thinking how these same people are going to be in office in 10 or 15 years.
 
Wow, to me, that is not a smart move.. I'd give it an year or so before they shut down the machine. :)
 
My college library also lends out laptops (the PC kind), but with one key difference. You have to go through a real person to get the laptop, so it is no good if you steal someones ID. Also just because a building has a card unlock on it doesn't mean that you can't get someone else to open it for you. That type of social hacking is easy.
 
so many angry people in this thread. I bet if it was a Windows PC vending machine you guys would think it's cool and great that universities have students safety in mind and that it saves cost dealing with stolen laptops and possibly stolen information within the laptop.

This isn't public school. It's a university. You can forget about budget cuts. As for spending money to improve the school, its not like they spend money they don't have. Universities aren't the government. Unlike the government, private entities need to have money (or be granted a loan) to spend it, and this vending idea was probably on the budget books and was within their means.

Yes, colleges are getting more and more expensive, but this isn't the reason. Some of you guys may be surprised to know that gas and oil giants come second to American colleges and university when it comes to profit and hoarding money. Trust me, colleges can afford things like this without batting an eye, even if they all suddenly decide to cut tuition by more than a half!
 
schools have been using Apple products since you guys were in diapers. Not sure why you're shocked about this. Apple has partnership, support, and discount programs for thousands of schools around the United States.

Not everyone is a teenager like you (see what I did there? made a stupid ass assumption like you did).

What is hilarious about your comment is that businesses have been using PC's and not Macs for over 20 years, so why are colleges using devices that are going to hinder people in the business world?

so many angry people in this thread. I bet if it was a Windows PC vending machine you guys would think it's cool and great that universities have students safety in mind and that it saves cost dealing with stolen laptops and possibly stolen information within the laptop.

This isn't public school. It's a university. You can forget about budget cuts. As for spending money to improve the school, its not like they spend money they don't have. Universities aren't the government. Unlike the government, private entities need to have money (or be granted a loan) to spend it, and this vending idea was probably on the budget books and was within their means.

Yes, colleges are getting more and more expensive, but this isn't the reason. Some of you guys may be surprised to know that gas and oil giants come second to American colleges and university when it comes to profit and hoarding money. Trust me, colleges can afford things like this without batting an eye, even if they all suddenly decide to cut tuition by more than a half!

This is a symptom of whats wrong with education, if they are stupid enough to spend a hundred thousand dollars (rough guess) on this vending machine, what other stupid purchases are they making.

Your "colleges can afford it" argument also sinks like a rock considering tuition has been rising quite rapidly. It is kind of hard to justify spending money on something that hinders students in the real world while also raising tuition.

Edit: It also doesn't help that you are well known to be a giant Apple fanboi.
 
My thoughts exactly.

Probably because it's "cool". :rolleyes:

Apple should sell licenses for virtualized OSX. I could see allowing thin clients to connect to virtualized OSX environments as being a viable revenue stream for them.
 
Edit: It also doesn't help that you are well known to be a giant Apple fanboi.

I am? News to me! I only have one iPhone and one iPad given to me from work, but own a great many PC. Oh hey, assumptions! :rolleyes:

I also love Windows 8. I guess that puts me in the same fanboyism category as our friend heatless.

the diaper comment was an emphasis on how long Apple products have been in school - a long fucking time. It wasn't meant to be a personal insult. Take a chill pill.
 
universities are absolutely throwing money away on crap like this and millions more spent on football teams and other such nonsense, of course the tuition is going to end up being twenty grand a year...

It's obvious from your two posts that you know nothing about how schools use money. I don't even know all that much but I do know that almost every major school makes a KILLING on football and that's why money is invested in to it.

Here's a little excerpt from Forbes on how much the Texas Longhorn football team is worth:

"Texas’ total value is driven largely by a football profit of $71 million last season, up from $65 million in 2009. Texas football generated $96 million in revenue, $36 million of which came from ticket sales. Another $30 million was comprised of contributions tied to amenity seating like club seats and luxury suites. The Longhorns also benefited from $10 million worth of sponsorship deals, with Coca-Cola, Nike and PepsiCo’s Gatorade giving a combined $2 million last year."

Still think schools are "throwing their money away on crap like this"? Didn't think so.
 
It's obvious from your two posts that you know nothing about how schools use money. I don't even know all that much but I do know that almost every major school makes a KILLING on football and that's why money is invested in to it.

Here's a little excerpt from Forbes on how much the Texas Longhorn football team is worth:

"Texas’ total value is driven largely by a football profit of $71 million last season, up from $65 million in 2009. Texas football generated $96 million in revenue, $36 million of which came from ticket sales. Another $30 million was comprised of contributions tied to amenity seating like club seats and luxury suites. The Longhorns also benefited from $10 million worth of sponsorship deals, with Coca-Cola, Nike and PepsiCo’s Gatorade giving a combined $2 million last year."

Still think schools are "throwing their money away on crap like this"? Didn't think so.

How to put this to you....

It *heavily* depends on the school....but overwhelmingly, revenue and money generated by athletic department tickets and merc activity STAYS in said athletic department. Or to put it more bluntly, football and sports doesn't do any positive economic boost to the academics of an institution. Again, it varies. But usually football at best only distracts universities from their mission.

The Marching Band of my NCAA div1 school for ONE weekend away game is larger than the discretionary budget for my academic department for an entire fiscal year (~$100k). The reason the marching band can afford trips and shiny instruments and clean uniforms? Because said band is entirely funded by the Athletic Department and not the music department...otherwise they'd be playing tin cans and wearing canvas bags.

As to the larger issue, kids these days overwhelmingly use Apple machines in school. Overwhelmingly. It isn't even close. And no, kids don't pay retail for their Apple machines they purchase either. Odds are this vending machine program was subsidized by someone anyway...and many NCAA div1 institutions already have laptop borrowing programs in place....this just automates it a bit.
 
I stand corrected, next time leave out the "How to put this to you..." part. I'm not a child.
 
But on second thought. If the money a team makes stays in the athletic department then why would a school have to spend money on said athletic dept?
 
But on second thought. If the money a team makes stays in the athletic department then why would a school have to spend money on said athletic dept?

Again it depends. Often athletic departments are close to self sustaining in cost of building buildings and buying equipment.

At my institution for example, a given department is responsible for its own discretionary spending (toys/trips), as well as the costs of maintaining their toys, and the manpower to staff the department. What is the (local) department not responsible for?

-Utilities bills. The music school in my school is not responsible for their concert hall's electric bill-which runs into thousands of kWhrs every day and night there is a rehearsal or concert. You don't want to know how many dozens of 10s of thousands of kWhrs a football stadium or athletic venue burns in one game, just for lighting nevermind audio gear and the productions trailer.

-Another thing thing building problems. One of the buildings on my campus had a broken elevator recently. Per the Americans with Disabilities Act. all buildings must have handicapped access elevator...building no longer had it. Cost to fix said elevator was 2.5X the annual discretionary budget of the entire department....only reason it got fixed was because it was the university at large that had to foot the bill.

There's a very large "MINE MINE MINE" mentality in departmental funding and costs. I.e. if the university owns a fleet of university vehicles available for departmental usage...the department will have to pay rent for that vehicle: even though the department is a university department and the vehicle is a university vehicle. If another department wants to use another department's concert hall they pay building rent as well as rent for the manpower they incur in billing. These are general guidelines. As truth be told, large university funding budgets are things that to really follow money and understand you need an entire team of forensic accountants. AAMOF, the local department I work (large concert hall) for employs FIVE full time accountants in addition to the other budget/admin office staff.
 
Again it depends. Often athletic departments are close to self sustaining in cost of building buildings and buying equipment.

At my institution for example, a given department is responsible for its own discretionary spending (toys/trips), as well as the costs of maintaining their toys, and the manpower to staff the department. What is the (local) department not responsible for?

-Utilities bills. The music school in my school is not responsible for their concert hall's electric bill-which runs into thousands of kWhrs every day and night there is a rehearsal or concert. You don't want to know how many dozens of 10s of thousands of kWhrs a football stadium or athletic venue burns in one game, just for lighting nevermind audio gear and the productions trailer.

-Another thing thing building problems. One of the buildings on my campus had a broken elevator recently. Per the Americans with Disabilities Act. all buildings must have handicapped access elevator...building no longer had it. Cost to fix said elevator was 2.5X the annual discretionary budget of the entire department....only reason it got fixed was because it was the university at large that had to foot the bill.

There's a very large "MINE MINE MINE" mentality in departmental funding and costs. I.e. if the university owns a fleet of university vehicles available for departmental usage...the department will have to pay rent for that vehicle: even though the department is a university department and the vehicle is a university vehicle. If another department wants to use another department's concert hall they pay building rent as well as rent for the manpower they incur in billing. These are general guidelines. As truth be told, large university funding budgets are things that to really follow money and understand you need an entire team of forensic accountants. AAMOF, the local department I work (large concert hall) for employs FIVE full time accountants in addition to the other budget/admin office staff.

Thanks. Good info.
 
Back
Top