Barnes and Noble E-Reader ‘Nook’ Facing Challenges

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
The much-ballyhooed e-reader from Barnes & Noble, the Nook, was recently reviewed by the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times and the results were less than stellar. To add insult to injury, B&N is also facing a lawsuit from a company that claims the Nook’s design was copied from their own e-reader. eWeek has the details on both issues.

Reviews by Mossberg and Pogue have a reputation of being able to make or break products. In his book "Inside Steve’s Brain," an account of Steve Jobs at Apple, author Leander Kahney discusses how Apple—not exactly a company known for expansive interactions with the press outside of carefully orchestrated events—will send the two of them devices well ahead of time for their review.
 
I stopped by B&N yesterday to check out the Nook. In a nutshell, it is worse than the already poor impression I got from the Engadget video review: http://www.engadget.com/2009/12/07/barnes-and-noble-nook-review/

The interface had poor responsiveness, the page refresh on the e-ink screen was actually slower than that of first gen Kindle, there is no point comparing it with the faster Kindle 2, navigation is atrocious, and the UI got in the way of accessing the material. What readers like the Kindle and the Sony readers do so well is that they provide easy navigation and access to your books. The UI with both devices gets out of the way. With the Nook it is step after step which leads you to a book synopsis page before you get to pick up where you left off. Do you really need to go to a book synopsis every time you want to read something? You're already sold on the book and reading it, ridiculous! Physically the device didn't impress me either. The buttons didn't have the nice positive click that the Kindle's or the Sony's had. You couldn't quite tell exactly where the physical point to change the page was, it was all really mushy.

The more I used it the more it pissed me off. I've hated on the Sony readers a lot because they cannot wirelessly download books, but the Nook is worse. If you have a choice, buy a Kindle for the build quality, speed, wireless downloads, cloud backups of notes/bookmarks/furthest page read, and book selection, and if you have to get a Sony reader for whatever reason then get that. I wouldn't recommend a Nook to anyone unless they completely overhauled the interface and improved page refresh speeds. I'm not sure if page refreshes can be helped by a firmware update or of it is a physical constraint of the e-paper display that they used. LCD responsiveness looks to be completely a function of it having no horsepower. The UI navigation needs a complete overhaul to be competitive with the Kindle or the Sony.
 
I like my Sony eBook reader (PRS-600 Touch Edition) since it's very easy to pick up and use, and like the user above me posted, its interface doesn't get in the way. I actually prefer that it doesn't have the wireless connection, since it saves battery life. I don't mind purchasing/downloading books from my PC. I also don't have to worry about having only one source to buy books, and don't need to worry about books disappearing on me because of a misunderstanding between the seller and the publisher. It was this point that made me absolutely refuse to buy a Kindle.

As for the Nook, it pretty much lives up to my expectations upon reading about the device. I knew the LCD would eat battery life quick, and that it would probably rely on the eInk display for a fair bit of navigation as well (which makes things slow). It also illustrates why I have no faith in things like the Apple Tablet, or anyone who says that "tablets will make eBook readers obsolete." I am tired of this "one device for everything" idea.
 
I like my Sony eBook reader (PRS-600 Touch Edition) since it's very easy to pick up and use, and like the user above me posted, its interface doesn't get in the way. I actually prefer that it doesn't have the wireless connection, since it saves battery life. I don't mind purchasing/downloading books from my PC.

Wireless can be turned off. I only use it when I'm getting a new book, so the battery life is what you'd expect (thousands of page refreshes). I've used it for weeks at a time without plugging it in. USB book transfers are also an option if you are absolutely opposed to the idea of wireless downloading or you don't have access (I did this when I was in Budapest).

I also don't have to worry about having only one source to buy books, and don't need to worry about books disappearing on me because of a misunderstanding between the seller and the publisher. It was this point that made me absolutely refuse to buy a Kindle.

I read that one story of that happening, but this has been a non-issue for me, that and you can also read any of the tens of thousands of .mobi file e-books in the public domain. Either way, the Kindle has a much larger library than what is available on the Sony, which is the main reason I went with it aside from the wireless options it has.

As for the Apple Tablet, I think people are missing the big picture by saying that it will be solely competing with e-book readers. The e-paper display is the main advantage of devices like the Kindle, Nook, and Sony readers. Go to an LCD and you go to a device that isn't made for reading books for hours at a time, eyestrain becomes the new problem since you are staring at a surface that emits light through color filters instead of physical pieces of "ink" that are on an opaque surface.

People didn't pin down what the iPhone was entirely going to be before it came out, and I suspect that the analysts don't know what purpose or UI innovation the Apple tablet is going to fill out either. It has been in the works for almost the last ten years, you don't go prototyping and tossing out failed ideas and developing that much if its just for the "obvious" thing. The result of the obvious thing would be something like Windows based tablet PCs, devices can run Windows on a touchscreen tablet but without a well defined purpose for that form factor in mind.

Whatever they come up with will likely be functionally unique and specific in a way that few will accurately predict, and I reckon most of us will be asking "why the hell didn't someone else do this before?". I will be surprised if its sole purpose is "replacement for e-book readers". Its been done before, very well, and LCD screens in their current state aren't purpose built for that kind of reading in the same way that e-paper displays are.
 
All that said, a full color e-paper display with a refresh rate closer to LCDs, that will be an awesome and amazing and completely useful technology. I can't wait for that. :)
 
All that said, a full color e-paper display with a refresh rate closer to LCDs, that will be an awesome and amazing and completely useful technology. I can't wait for that. :)

That does sound amazing. Sadly it sounds like a ways off still.
 
My biggest dig against the Kindle is the lack of ePub support. The eBook market is definitly in its infancy right now but at least the publishers have standardized a format so you aren't locked into one device which is a plus. The other nice bonus I like about the Sony Reader is I can check out books from my library on it.
 
Back
Top