Bad Motherboard?

allenwr1505

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 16, 2003
Messages
106
I was recently got a Compaq Presario 5000T for free from someone at work. They had thought that it was broken, but I had somewhow fixed it. Or supposedly "fixed it." I took it home and installed a 120GB Western Digital Hard Drive and then installed Windows XP. Its specs are as follows.

667mhz PIII
Micro ATX Compaq motherboard
256mb 133mhz SDR
integrated graphics card
120 GB 8mb cache WD drive
235watt Powerman power supply

At first when I installed Windows XP it worked fine. However, when I was installing from Windows Update, the computer rebooted before the updates were complete, and it hanged when it was entering Windows. I tried rebooting several times without success. I then ran the Windows XP cd again. I ran check disk, and it fixed a couple of errors. I then told it to "fixmbr" to fix the master boot record, which it said was corrupt. After that the computer worked, and I finished installing the updates and transferring my files. A little while later, when I was transferring my files, the computer rebooted again. This time I could still get into Windows, but this worried me. I examined the computer, and noticed that the fan on the power supply wasn't working. I got a new 235 watt power supply and thought that the source of my problems had been the power supply overheating.

However, to test out the computer, I tried running Prime 95 overnight. When I woke up the next morning, the computer had all of its power LEDs on. From the light, it appeared that the hard drive was working constantly, which was kind of strange. I tried turning on the monitor, but nothing came up. Frustrated, I tried pushing the power button on the front of the case, but it wouldn't even turn off. I tried even opening the CD-ROM, but it wouldn't respond either. Eventually I just flipped the switch on the power supply. I rebooted the machine, and it would get to the Windows logo "loading Windows" screen, and would then hang. The screen would go blank, as if I was restarting, and all of the power LEDs would light up. Nothing would respond. I tried opening the CD-ROM again, but even that wouldn't respond.

I used the Windows XP Cd to run chkdsk and fixmbr again, but they didn't fix the problem. I still had the same problems when going into windows.

When the guy gave me the PC, he told me that he thought that there wa a problem with the motherboard. Is this a problem with the motherboard? I know that all of the parts work, and I've tried two power supplies. He used to have this same problem. What kind of problem would make all of the LEDs light up, and nothing respond? What kind of problem would prevent the CD-ROM from even opening? I thought that the CD-ROM could open independent of the state of the motherboard, as long as it had power. So is it a problem with the power supply? Should I buy another motherboard? And where would I get one that would fit in that Compaq case?
 
could be motherboard,RAM, CPU or HD at this point....you need more information...try swapping some parts if possible to try to isolate the problem....
 
I am using a different powersupply, hard drive, CPU, and RAM than originally came with the system. Even though those components are different, the problem still persists, leading me to believe that they are not the cause. Also, the previous owners tried swapping out parts of the system.
 
you've pretty much already narrowed it down to MoBo...make sure your new PSU can supply enough juice get a 300 Watt, 235 is pretty weak when your going to run a massive hard drive like that.
 
Strange things have been happening. When I allow the computer to idle for too long, the monitor goes blank, the activity LEDs light continuously, and the computer becomes unresponsive. I can't even boot into Windows. However, when I try it a while later, it again works. I had it go unresponsive on me yesterday, and I turned it on today to try it out, and it works. Strange. I'm typing on it right now. I already tried updating the BIOS, to no effect.

I wonder if the northbridge or southbridge is overheating. Perhaps something is utilizing them continuously, which could explain the loss of video (it's integrated) and the continuous hard drive activity and nonresponsive nature of the CD drives (the hard drive and IDE ports are controlled by the southbridge). However, neither of those bridges are hot to touch. Neither of them have heatsinks either.
 
We have a lot of those same or similar model Compaq machines at work. Probably around 60-80. I've never seen that problem before. You might want to check the BIOS Power Management settings and make sure they're not jacked up. Check the timeouts and make sure they're disabled.

If you're using the crappy IDE cable that was in the system already, swap it out for another one.

If you're getting a Blue Sceen of Death before you have these lockups it usually signifies a memory or hard drive failure. If the drive itself is fine, then it's probably the IDE controller on the motherboard that's giving you a problem. Turn off automatic rebooting in XP so it'll stay on the blue screen.
 
Astral Abyss said:
We have a lot of those same or similar model Compaq machines at work. Probably around 60-80. I've never seen that problem before. You might want to check the BIOS Power Management settings and make sure they're not jacked up. Check the timeouts and make sure they're disabled.

If you're using the crappy IDE cable that was in the system already, swap it out for another one.

If you're getting a Blue Sceen of Death before you have these lockups it usually signifies a memory or hard drive failure. If the drive itself is fine, then it's probably the IDE controller on the motherboard that's giving you a problem. Turn off automatic rebooting in XP so it'll stay on the blue screen.


No BSODs. I don't think that it is a problem with Windows at all. I've tried using Windows 2000 on it and Windows XP, and it makes no difference. Also, the hard drive and the cable are both brand new. I just bought the 120 gig hard drive from Frys. I think that it might be something about the power management too. But I think that something in the BIOS is screwed up. Not a setting, but possibly something in the chip. I've tried flashing the BIOS, to no success. The reason I think that it may have something to do with power management is that the computer seems to last longer (ie not go into frozen, blank screen mode) when I tell it to go into standby after ten minutes. I left it in standby, and eventually it became frozen, but it lasted a good deal longer. This is a strange problem.
 
Have you tried totally disabling power management in the BIOS? You'll lose the ability to go to standby but it might help you find the problem if you haven't tried this already.
 
Astral Abyss said:
Have you tried totally disabling power management in the BIOS? You'll lose the ability to go to standby but it might help you find the problem if you haven't tried this already.

Compaq's BIOS is a piece of crap. It gives me barely any options. I can't enable or disable power management in the BIOS. It barely lets me set my boot order.
 
Heh I once got asked if I could make a computer just like a compaq for the same price....I found all the parts and it turned out to be cheaper but a better system....couldn't believe it. Those Compaq BIOS options SUCK, so does HP so don't trade it in on one of those either.... :)
 
allenwr1505 said:
Strange things have been happening. When I allow the computer to idle for too long, the monitor goes blank, the activity LEDs light continuously, and the computer becomes unresponsive. I can't even boot into Windows. However, when I try it a while later, it again works. I had it go unresponsive on me yesterday, and I turned it on today to try it out, and it works. Strange. I'm typing on it right now. I already tried updating the BIOS, to no effect.

I wonder if the northbridge or southbridge is overheating. Perhaps something is utilizing them continuously, which could explain the loss of video (it's integrated) and the continuous hard drive activity and nonresponsive nature of the CD drives (the hard drive and IDE ports are controlled by the southbridge). However, neither of those bridges are hot to touch. Neither of them have heatsinks either.



Ok a couple of other things to try.....MAKE SURE the cd or DVD is on a secondary channel and hard drive is on primary....I found a lot of these older systems with newer drives puke if they try to operate on the same channel. also MAKE SURE the jumpers are set correctly on the drives....if they are on CS and on the wrong connectors there will be trouble. You stated it has trouble comming out of idle mode this would indicate a problem with it trying to spin-up...make sure the MOLEX connector for the HD and CD/DVD are ALSO on seperate channels. if this doesn't fix it, we'll go on to the next step.
 
Gruntled Employee said:
Ok a couple of other things to try.....MAKE SURE the cd or DVD is on a secondary channel and hard drive is on primary....I found a lot of these older systems with newer drives puke if they try to operate on the same channel. also MAKE SURE the jumpers are set correctly on the drives....if they are on CS and on the wrong connectors there will be trouble. You stated it has trouble comming out of idle mode this would indicate a problem with it trying to spin-up...make sure the MOLEX connector for the HD and CD/DVD are ALSO on seperate channels. if this doesn't fix it, we'll go on to the next step.

The hard drive is on the primary IDE channel and is on a separate molex connector from the CD drives. I usually do that. Also, the problem that I have been describing doesn't only happen when the computer idles. A couple of times I have been surfing the web on it, and the computer will become frozen, exhibiting the characteristics that I have described before.
 
Back
Top