Bad board?

nitefallz

2[H]4U
Joined
Nov 15, 2000
Messages
2,366
I set up an HTPC near the end of 2008 running Vista and for the most part it worked great, but there were random crashes (BSOD + memory dump) mostly when watching blu-ray movies. Vista logs didn't tell me anything useful. The crashes then became more likely to happen when I tried to game on it and when I started watching just about any video. I think I narrowed it down to either the processor or the motherboard, but I want a 2nd opinion.

Specs:
AMD Athlon 64 X2 5200 Brisbane 2.7GHz Socket AM2 65W
ASUS M3A78-EM AM2+/AM2 AMD 780G HDMI Micro ATX AMD Motherboard
2x G.SKILL 2GB 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800
SAPPHIRE 100255U Radeon HD 4670 512MB 128-bit GDDR3 PCI Express 2.0 x16

The original system was with only 1 stick of 2gb G.Skill ram and no video card (using onboard which seemed fine). I thought maybe the onboard video was a problem and thus addition of the video card. I then added another stick to boost some gaming performance. The problems still persisted for both physical BD movies and ripped BD movies.

My next step was a reinstall of Vista, same problems. For some reason I thought that the onboard sound was responsible, so I started using the HDMI audio from the video card, same problem. I tried without running other unnecessary programs, same problem. I then removed the original memory stick and used only the newer one, same problem.

So I installed XP, same problem. I started using Prime95 to stress test, and usually the same problem. I monitored the temps and I thought I was onto something, so I opened the case and put a window fan blowing into the system and the temps were below 50c and it still crashed. Now, the northbridge heatsink gets hot sometimes, to hot to touch, but the sensor only reports up to like 60c. I've seen the individual core temps go up to 80, but crashes have happened at lower temps.

I've boosted all voltages that I could, same problems.

I'm frustrated because otherwise the system is good for what I needed it to do, and now the fiance is bugging me to get a standalone BD player, which I might, but I still want to be able to use the system for something.

So my question is now, which is more likely to be the problem, the processor, or the board? Have I missed anything?

thanks!
 
Did you try it without the videocard? Please list your PS.

What was the error message for the BSOD?
 
I have the ASUS M3A78-EM.

A few of my friends have it too.

We all hate it with passion.

Prepare to start hating yours too OP.
 
Did you try it without the videocard? Please list your PS.

What was the error message for the BSOD?

I was using the onboard video (Radeon HD 3200) originally, before I added the videcard, with the same problems. I though the video was buggy thats why I added the card.

PS is 430 that comes with the Antec Fusion case.
 
Is it the Earthwatts 430W? Probably not very likely, although it is possible.

Not sure on the specific model, other than it was in the Antec Fusion case it came with.

Gladly, Asus approved an RMA for me today, though after reading some posts here and on Newegg, I doubt I'll get anywhere with a replacement.
 
Back
Top