Backup to internal IDE drive or external drive?

speedlever

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 29, 2006
Messages
447
My Asus P5B-3 mobo has internal connections for 2 SATA drives and 1 PATA drive. I currently have a WD 74 Gb raptor (sata) used for OS and programs, a Samsung 320 Gb (sata) for data, and a 300 Gb Seagate (IDE) for backup.

The Seagate is just about full so I'm looking to replace it. The biggest internal IDE drive I see on Newegg is a WD Caviar Blue 500 Gb drive. (3 year warranty) ~ $88 w/shipping.

The external drives go well beyond what I need in terms of storage capacity. But I am concerned about heat failure issues. I've had problems with drives in an external enclosure fail before... which I think was related to heat issues. But that was a 3.5" drive in an external enclosure. Perhaps the 2.5" drives connected by USB/Firewire do not run so warm. I don't know.

My P5B-E mobo has an external Firewire port. From a performance and durability perspective, would I be better served by an internal IDE drive or an external USB or Firewire drive? Maybe a 2.5" laptop drive in an external enclosure? I think that would run cooler than a 3.5" drive in an external enclosure. Or maybe a WD passport type drive? I would also like to have more than 1 year warranty too.

I'd prefer to stay in the vicinity of $100 +/-. What do you suggest for a 500 Gb to 1 Tb storage drive? I backup several computers to it with drives ranging from 60 Gb to 320 Gb. It's taken me about 3 years to load up the 300 Gb Seagate. So I'm comfy with 500Gb to 1 Tb for the next few years.
 
Sell both the Samsung and Seagate drives and get one 1-1.5TB SATA HDD.
 
While that makes sense in one way, the logistics of moving my data from my current 320 Gb Sammy scare me away from this solution.

I just had to replace the 74 Gb WD Raptor under warranty as it failed nearly 3 years after I built this box. I'm skittish about replacing anything but the current storage drive unless I have to.
 
Heat really doesn't have a significant effect on harddrives. Your harddrive failures were likely due to other manufacturer deviations/defects. I wouldn't fear that route.

Internal drives are the cheaper route. But with your motherboard limitations, I wouldn't fear external drives. I use Vantec aluminum enclosures with WD Green drives. Stick with 3.5" drives.

For Backup, you don't really need a lot of speed. The 5800ish rpm "green" drives are perfect, and USB/firewire/esata/sata doesn't really matter, don't get caught up in it. Go with cheapest.

Seagate has had some quirky issues lately in their 1TB+ drives, I think it's been worked out but I would still shy away. WD EADS drive (not EARS) would be my pick of the highest capacity you can get.

Use the new 1+TB drive for your backup location. Split your current data across your old two 300&320GB drives the best you can.

Edit: Example, if it were me, on a strict $100 budget I'd do this:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817816007R
+
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148445

If flexible I'd do this:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817145167
+
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136490
or
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136513

Guess EADS drives aren't readily available anymore =(
 
Last edited:
Heat really doesn't have a significant effect on harddrives. Your harddrive failures were likely due to other manufacturer deviations/defects. I wouldn't fear that route.

Internal drives are the cheaper route. But with your motherboard limitations, I wouldn't fear external drives. I use Vantec aluminum enclosures with WD Green drives. Stick with 3.5" drives.

For Backup, you don't really need a lot of speed. The 5800ish rpm "green" drives are perfect, and USB/firewire/esata/sata doesn't really matter, don't get caught up in it. Go with cheapest.

Seagate has had some quirky issues lately in their 1TB+ drives, I think it's been worked out but I would still shy away. WD EADS drive (not EARS) would be my pick of the highest capacity you can get.

Use the new 1+TB drive for your backup location. Split your current data across your old two 300&320GB drives the best you can.

Edit: Example, if it were me, on a strict $100 budget I'd do this:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817816007R
+
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148445

If flexible I'd do this:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817145167
+
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136490
or
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136513

Guess EADS drives aren't readily available anymore =(

You may be right about the heat issues. OTOH, I'm having a hard time shaking my belief that heat is a major enemy of electronics... especially hard drives. My Antec Solo case has 2 fans up front blowing over the 3 hard drives... just for some insurance... or maybe just peace of mind.

IAC, reviewing the specs of the Vantec enclosure, the overview says up pto 750Gb but the specs say up to 2 Tb. ???

How about this Rosewill enclosure with built in 80mm fan? And maybe that 1Tb WD green drive you referenced.

Edit: I just realized that my mobo supports esata too. So I could use an external esata interface instead of USB2 (USB ports are at a premium on my setup anyway).

Edit 2: NewEgg has a 24 hour sale on a 1.5 Tb WD green drive.

So much for my $100 budget.
 
Last edited:
In the end, I ordered the WD Green 1.5 Tb drive for 99.99 from NewEgg. I plan to stop by a local shop and pick up the Vantec NexStar 3 usb/esata enclosure.

Thanks for the advice!

Edit: researching the active cooling enclosures mentioned above, I heard too many problems with the fans. Hopefully the green drive will run cool enough that cooling will not be an issue. I plan to connect the NexStar 3 via esata.
 
Back
Top