AXP/X800Pro vs. A64/9800Pro/XT

Negotiator

n00b
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
23
Been doing some price checking and it seems that you can put together a complete 2500+ system with an X800Pro for roughly the same price as a A64 3000+ with a 9800 Pro (around $900, w/OS,HD,MB,OD,RAM,PSU,Case,HSF, no monitor). Assuming that you would overclock the 2500+ to at least a 3000+, which of these systems would perform better, assuming all other parts are equal?

I know that you can OC the A64 and the 9800 Pro, but lets just assume that you did not. Sure, the XP line is getting phased out, and the 64's seem to be clocking well, but if it is the same price, and the CPU isn't going to bottleneck the video card, the first option might be the way to go.
 
Negotiator said:
I know that you can OC the A64 and the 9800 Pro, but lets just assume that you did not.

the 64-bit

1]More future-proof
2]More cache
3]Less memory latency
 
For gaming performance, i'd take the AXP and and x800. Carnival you dont know what you're talking about the amount of cache doesnt matter, the memory latencies dont matter, WHAT MATTERS IS THE PERFORMANCE AT THE END OF THE DAY, and just so you know the diff between 1mb and 512k is a few percent. HAVING SAID THAT, yes, the A64 is by far the better CPU, BUT having fast cpu isnt gonn make up for the difference between an 9800 pro and x800.
 
the guy above is right,

Even if the Athlon XP is slower then the Athlon 64, the X800 is around 2X as fast as the 9800 pro, while the Athlon 64 3000+ is around 25-50% faster then a 3200+ Barton.
 
Yeah, the AXP & X800 are better than the A64 & 9800.

Having said that, I run the system in my sig, and I can play quite a few games at a decent FPS... At a low, low quality :rolleyes: :p

But If you could get an A64 & X800, you'd be set. Then again, its cheaper to upgrade from an AXP --> A64, than a 9800 --> X800.
 
I'm with most people here, the X800/XP combo would be the better choice for right now. If you actually wanted to keep this system current for a while I'd go with the 64-bit system and just deal with the 9800 until I could save up enough for the X800.
 
If you are a serious gamer take the AXP w/ the X800, if you do more multimedia and less gaming take the A64 setup w/ 9800. Both are strong systems, but for gaming more relies on the video card than the processor.
 
Back
Top