Automobiles May Prevent Drunk Driving

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
In the not so distant future, if you have been drinking, you may have to fool your own car, rather that the police to let you go. QinetiQ North America, a Waltham, Mass. R&D facility previewed a prototype automobile system that might stop you right dead in your drunk tracks.

LaHood disputed that the technology would interfere with moderate social drinking, and said the threshold in cars would never be set below the legal limit.
 
if anything I think the thousands of dollars this inevitably will end up adding to the cost of a car isn't worth it.

Drunk drivers suck, mmmmkay, but I don't want a special tax on my new car purchase just because I'm able to know when to drive and not.
 
if anything I think the thousands of dollars this inevitably will end up adding to the cost of a car isn't worth it.

Devil's advocate here. Adding to the cost of the car would hurt our pocketbooks but you buddy being dead is ok? Seatbelts and airbags were not cheap in the beginning either. I am not saying this is a great idea because I believe individual responsibility is just getting thrown out the window on a daily basis but this is what it has come to. The, "I can't trust anybody to do the right thing so I have to rely on others to make sure they do" type of mentality is horrible but we are talking about families being ripped apart.
 
if anything I think the thousands of dollars this inevitably will end up adding to the cost of a car isn't worth it.

Drunk drivers suck, mmmmkay, but I don't want a special tax on my new car purchase just because I'm able to know when to drive and not.

This would increase the cost of cars by thousands of dollars? seams a little over the top don't you think? maybe a couple hundred dollars at the most?

A friends sister was killed by a drunk driver when walking home from her 18th birthday party, it's so not worth making all drivers pay to avoid people who drive drunk from killing people.

A human life is so not worth anything when it comes to money. :rolleyes:
 
Devil's advocate here. Adding to the cost of the car would hurt our pocketbooks but you buddy being dead is ok? Seatbelts and airbags were not cheap in the beginning either.
It is added cost for a feature that would never work. When you get into an accident, it may not be anyone fault. Think Toyota gas peddle, or losing control in icy conditions. In which case, having seat belts and airbags is a great idea.

Drinking and driving is a different story. We're basically saying, "we know you're so god damn stupid, that we decided to let you drink but not drive". We put a KITT in your car to determine if it's safe to let you drive.
I am not saying this is a great idea because I believe individual responsibility is just getting thrown out the window on a daily basis but this is what it has come to. The, "I can't trust anybody to do the right thing so I have to rely on others to make sure they do" type of mentality is horrible but we are talking about families being ripped apart.
It's stupid beyond belief. I got too many people in my life who can't deal with the decisions they make in life. It's very simple folks, for everything you do, there are benefits and consequences to your actions. You can't avoid the consequences, EVER!

You drink, and you wanna drive, you'll find a way. No gadget on earth can stop you. But now, we have an excuse for people to drink more, and get wasted to the point when that guy next to you, looks like a Hot Blonde with huge tits. Despite how incomprehensible everything must be, you have enough genius to bypass any alcohol test that car might have.
 
This would increase the cost of cars by thousands of dollars? seams a little over the top don't you think? maybe a couple hundred dollars at the most?

A friends sister was killed by a drunk driver when walking home from her 18th birthday party, it's so not worth making all drivers pay to avoid people who drive drunk from killing people.

A human life is so not worth anything when it comes to money. :rolleyes:


Sorry about your friends sister. But no, it's not worth adding a few thousand or even a few hundred dollars for a system that drunks, just like the current ones, can so easily bypassed by just wearing driving gloves or carrying a couple balloons in the car.

Don't worry if you want this big brother tech in cars though, the insurance companies will see that it becomes mandatory in the decades to come.

I don't drink, but I will not buy a car that had something like this in it on principal alone. Then again, I don't buy cars made after 1975 just on principal theses days either.
 
Sounds like it only prevents the car from starting; it doesn't say anything about a car that's left running (hopefully in a garage with the door closed and the inebriated driver 'sleeping' in it).
 
Don't worry if you want this big brother tech in cars though, the insurance companies will see that it becomes mandatory in the decades to come.
Bingo, you won't have to worry about government mandating this, the insurance companies will either refuse to write a policy or else triple or quadruple the rates for anyone who refuses to have this on a new car. That's the Free Market in action, doncha know? :p
 
Sounds like a nightmare, there are enough things in my car that can go wrong already. I don't need my car not starting before work in the morning b/c it is malfunctioning and thinks I'm drunk.
 
mm I don't drink, please keep this crap off my future car =.=
 
I don't drink, so thanks for the social engineering bullshit that I will wind up paying for.
and yeah, I can imagine the fun with a malfunctioning sensor turning the car into a useless hunk of metal.

"YOU ARE DRUNK MOTHERFUCKER! I AIN'T TAKING YOUR ASS ANYWHERE!"
 
Bingo, you won't have to worry about government mandating this, the insurance companies will either refuse to write a policy or else triple or quadruple the rates for anyone who refuses to have this on a new car. That's the Free Market in action, doncha know? :p

Just like with seat belts, airbags, and 5mph bumpers, the insurance companies will start by giving discounts for equipped vehicles to create demand where it did not exist b4. Simultaneously, they will lobby to make it a federal mandate for new cars sold. Once they have the mandates, and they will eventually get them, the discounts will slowly dry up. The insurance lobby groups are some of the most powerful in existence.


Edit, I am not saying that airbags, 5mph bumpers, or seat belts are a bad thing. I do disagree with the means the insurance lobby uses to force them on us.
 
Sounds like it only prevents the car from starting; it doesn't say anything about a car that's left running (hopefully in a garage with the door closed and the inebriated driver 'sleeping' in it).

If that is true it is less than useless, a pair of driving gloves and the old balloon and chip bag clip trick for a car mounted breathalyzer is all that would be needed to bypass the system.

If it is the ambient air type of breathalyzer then it could be fooled several different ways from Sunday. A cap of rum poured in the a/c vent of an equipped car would disable that car, or a piece of tape covering it's sensors disable the system from working and allow a drunk to drive. The tech is cool, but should be left to law enforcement in an environment where tampering is less likely.
 
Sorry about your friends sister. But no, it's not worth adding a few thousand or even a few hundred dollars for a system that drunks, just like the current ones, can so easily bypassed by just wearing driving gloves or carrying a couple balloons in the car.

Don't worry if you want this big brother tech in cars though, the insurance companies will see that it becomes mandatory in the decades to come.

I don't drink, but I will not buy a car that had something like this in it on principal alone. Then again, I don't buy cars made after 1975 just on principal theses days either.

To be honest i don't like the idea of it being fitted to every car as many people don't even drink, i do think it would be a good idea for it to be used as a punishment for anyone who drives that ever gets caught drunk driving and really in that way the cost of having it fitted could be seen an an extra fine.

I'm just against the argument of cost being a good reason to stop extra safety features being used even if they are silly features :p

No matter what is tried there is no way possible to stop all drunk driving accidents.
 
Yet another attempt to bandaid a societal problem with a gadget. How about not letting drunk drivers get 30+ DUI's and then waiting to do something once they finally kill a car full of people? Here's my solution:

1st DUI: $1,000 fine and 6 months vehicle impound and suspended license.
2nd DUI: $5,000 fine, 1 year in jail.
3rd DUI: $10,000 fine, 5 years in jail mandatory, no bail, license suspended permanently. Best get used to biking or riding the bus. You're too stupid and dangerous to be given the privilege of driving a car.
Any DUI that results in a fatality: 2nd degree murder charge, no bail, no parole, license suspended permanently IF you get out of prison.

Yes, I'm a hard ass, but I have no tolerance for irresponsible people.
 
i do think it would be a good idea for it to be used as a punishment for anyone who drives that ever gets caught drunk driving and really in that way the cost of having it fitted could be seen an an extra fine.

Agreed. Only a minority of people drive drunk, but those who do are often repeat offenders.
 
Yet another attempt to bandaid a societal problem with a gadget. How about not letting drunk drivers get 30+ DUI's and then waiting to do something once they finally kill a car full of people? Here's my solution:

1st DUI: $1,000 fine and 6 months vehicle impound and suspended license.
2nd DUI: $5,000 fine, 1 year in jail.
3rd DUI: $10,000 fine, 5 years in jail mandatory, no bail, license suspended permanently. Best get used to biking or riding the bus. You're too stupid and dangerous to be given the privilege of driving a car.
Any DUI that results in a fatality: 2nd degree murder charge, no bail, no parole, license suspended permanently IF you get out of prison.

Yes, I'm a hard ass, but I have no tolerance for irresponsible people.

This I could get behind. Not sure how we would afford the extra prisons though. Because your typical drunk can not accept that they are drunk half the time, our prisons would fill up rather quick.
 
I really don't like the idea of putting in a device which could easily malfunction and immobilize the car. Breathalyzers aren't especially reliable, and the consequences of a car failing to start can be pretty bad; you can get stranded in the wilderness, you can get stuck in a blizzard, you can get immobilized in traffic (for examine, if you killed a manual transmission at a light), you can get fired for being late for work, you can be late for a job in which other people might suffer (doctors and such), etc. This has the potential to totally screw over a lot of innocent people.
 
This would increase the cost of cars by thousands of dollars? seams a little over the top don't you think? maybe a couple hundred dollars at the most?

A friends sister was killed by a drunk driver when walking home from her 18th birthday party, it's so not worth making all drivers pay to avoid people who drive drunk from killing people.

A human life is so not worth anything when it comes to money. :rolleyes:

Have you seen the technology they are talking about using?

It's reject tech from the 1990's that has been recycled.

If it can't measure blood sugar accurately, what makes you think it's going to work any better measuring BAC?

Beyond that, I can think of a damned good way to circumvent the system.....just wear gloves. Yeah, that system is going to work real well...at helping Rite Aid sell lots of boxes of latex gloves. I don't drink, but I'm pretty damned sure if I had a car like that, there would be a box of latex gloves in the glovebox, just in case.
 
Funny thing is... These clowns from QinetiQ are defense contractors I end up working with when I arrive at military installations.
 
Yet another attempt to bandaid a societal problem with a gadget. How about not letting drunk drivers get 30+ DUI's and then waiting to do something once they finally kill a car full of people? Here's my solution:

1st DUI: $1,000 fine and 6 months vehicle impound and suspended license.
2nd DUI: $5,000 fine, 1 year in jail.
3rd DUI: $10,000 fine, 5 years in jail mandatory, no bail, license suspended permanently. Best get used to biking or riding the bus. You're too stupid and dangerous to be given the privilege of driving a car.
Any DUI that results in a fatality: 2nd degree murder charge, no bail, no parole, license suspended permanently IF you get out of prison.

Yes, I'm a hard ass, but I have no tolerance for irresponsible people.

fuck the 3 strikes your out crap. keep #1 & make #2 5,000 fine & 2 years in Jail. license suspended permanently.
 
fuck the 3 strikes your out crap. keep #1 & make #2 5,000 fine & 2 years in Jail. license suspended permanently.

Oh and make them all felonies, so if the idiot still does not get the point and drives without a license to get their third DUI they can go up for 20 no parole under the 3 strikes laws many states have.
 
the problem isn't dui's it's the people that don't know how to drive. If I can beat you on a closed circuit race drunk then the problem isn't intoxication it's that you can't compete mentally.

Now you're thinking what does a race have to do with anything, it's comprehension, and the idea that those that can't compete shouldn't have a voice or a driver's license. Nobody has a realistic perspective these days.
 
This I could get behind. Not sure how we would afford the extra prisons though. Because your typical drunk can not accept that they are drunk half the time, our prisons would fill up rather quick.

I'm also of the mind that prisons should not be resorts. No TV, no weights (sorry but I don't like physically strong bad guys), cram 'em 6 to a cell and VERY basic nutrition. Get overcrowded, the excess go into tent cities with razorwire. Let 'em deal with some weather. That's not cruel and unusual if linemen do that as part of their job every day. Too hot? Get in the tent. Too cold? Get in the tent and bundle in the sleeping bag. There are solutions if society would stop being so pansy about it.

4LC4PON3: I like the way you think. :cool:
 
I agree that harsher penalties will have better chance of making a difference.

Drunk drivers should have their license suspended for a year or more.

And anyone who end up killing someone while drunk driving should be charge with manslaughter and imprisoned

Maybe then people will start taking it seriously.
 
It's crap like this on why I don't buy modern cars.
Ever have an airbag pop going down an interstate? Sensor malfunction.
I've also had ABS modules fail (not as bad, just have to pump the brakes)

People forced to buy crap like this will make me rich disabling it.
 
People forced to buy crap like this will make me rich disabling it.

The problem there is that the government loves to pass laws and regulations that forbid tampering with "safety" features. If it can be proven that you disabled one of these government-mandated features you'll be prosecuted, and if a customer of yours was injured or killed in an accident and it was found you had tampered, they'd throw felony manslaughter charges at you. I certainly agree with your sentiments, but they play dirty when it comes to this sort of thing. It's the Nanny State mentality at work.

To give you an idea how ludicrous it can be, there's a mandatory seat belt law here. Yet, motorcyclists threw a fit over the mandatory helmet law, and the state deemed it unconstitutional. So technically motorcyclists have more rights than automobile drivers. Sure, it's the right to get your skull caved in when thrown off your bike, but it hardly makes sense that one can be considered an unnecessary imposition while the other is not. That's government for you.
 
Back
Top