ATX or BTX for my cooling?

3-Phase

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 16, 2004
Messages
312
I am building a new computer soon and I am using a CM stacker (see sig) which can be used as either ATX or BTX. Will one form be better for cooling than the other?

Most video cards run hotter than the processors do when they are under load. I was wondering if the BTX form would be better since the video card is above the processor, and so all of the heat could rise up and out of the case instead of going towards the processor (the fan would be facing up on the video card). What do you think?
 
Remember though that heat != temperature.
The heat output of a modern CPU, esp. pressies, will be much higher than even the hottest GPU. That being said, I'd try both and see what works best
 
I may be mistaken but wasn't improved cooling the main motivation for the BTX standard? Is there a situation where ATX would cool better? I don't see any reason why you shouldn't just go for the BTX.
 
RawsonDR said:
I may be mistaken but wasn't improved cooling the main motivation for the BTX standard? Is there a situation where ATX would cool better? I don't see any reason why you shouldn't just go for the BTX.
The only thing which is cooled better with BTX is the CPU.
 
RawsonDR said:
I may be mistaken but wasn't improved cooling the main motivation for the BTX standard? Is there a situation where ATX would cool better? I don't see any reason why you shouldn't just go for the BTX.

BTX motherboards, yet. BTX motherboards have several changes, including horizontal RAM slots, compared to the vertical RAM slots of current motherboards (which would allow airflow over the RAM, not hitting it from the side).

BTX cases, however, don't change anything except the motherboard placement. Regular cases have the videocard on the bottom; BTX cases flip the motherboard upside down so the videocard is up top (with the heatsink facing up), and the processor at the bottom.
 
Processors and video carda can bennefit from BTX cooling. Like what was said before, though you won't really see much improvement if any going BTX with an ATX mainboard.

I've got a CM stacker and have considered doing the same thing myself.
 
BTX was primarily designed to provide better cooling in a smaller form factor case. If you have seen that review of that aopen B300 case, the design just makes more sense then how the standard mATX desktop case is laid out.
 
i thought that you could use any board as a BTX just by fliping the board over. I know that there are some boards made for it but can you just flip them over?
 
Vertigo Acid said:
Remember though that heat != temperature.
The heat output of a modern CPU, esp. pressies, will be much higher than even the hottest GPU. That being said, I'd try both and see what works best
Umm... I think you've upmixed backwards things a bit.
I've never seen anyone who normally runs their cpu at over 55c and my video card idles at 55c... load is 78c, extremely heavy load.
 
killernoodle said:
BTX was primarily designed to provide better cooling in a smaller form factor case. If you have seen that review of that aopen B300 case, the design just makes more sense then how the standard mATX desktop case is laid out.
One big disadvantage of BTX is that there's hardly any opportunity for airflow over the HDD(s), as all incoming air is first directed over the CPU. Worse, this warm air (30+ C) is then exhausted into the case, ensuring that the case temperature will be higher, and consequently the rest of the system's component's operating temperature, shortening their lifespan.

The videocard, for example, is hit with the full heat from the CPU's thermal module, negating any benefits the inverted positioning of the videocard on the mainboard might have.
 
Elledan said:
One big disadvantage of BTX is that there's hardly any opportunity for airflow over the HDD(s), as all incoming air is first directed over the CPU. Worse, this warm air (30+ C) is then exhausted into the case, ensuring that the case temperature will be higher, and consequently the rest of the system's component's operating temperature, shortening their lifespan.

The videocard, for example, is hit with the full heat from the CPU's thermal module, negating any benefits the inverted positioning of the videocard on the mainboard might have.

The CM stacker has an intake in the front that blows fresh air directly on the HDDs. With mine I am also getting the cross flow fan which will also be blowing fresh air across every motherboard component.
 
Elledan said:
One big disadvantage of BTX is that there's hardly any opportunity for airflow over the HDD(s),
Specific reviews on small form factor cases mention poor HDD cooling, but you can't confuse the downfalls of a specific case as a downfall of the BTX form factor. Some poorly designed or compromised ATX cases have poor HDD cooling as well.


Vertigo Acid said:
Remember though that heat != temperature.
The heat output of a modern CPU, esp. pressies, will be much higher than even the hottest GPU. That being said, I'd try both and see what works best
Umm... I think you've upmixed backwards things a bit.
I've never seen anyone who normally runs their cpu at over 55c and my video card idles at 55c... load is 78c, extremely heavy load.
What Vertigo Acid was referring to was the fact that a penny at 55 deg C contains nowhere near the heat energy as a car engine at 55 deg C. In this sense temperature != total heat energy. So, in some cases, a video card could run hotter than a CPU but may not actually be putting as much heat into your case (sometimes they are about on par though). So your case cooling has to take that into account as well.
 
RawsonDR said:
Specific reviews on small form factor cases mention poor HDD cooling, but you can't confuse the downfalls of a specific case as a downfall of the BTX form factor. Some poorly designed or compromised ATX cases have poor HDD cooling as well.
I realize this, and probably should have said something like "One big disadvantage of BTX is that there's hardly any opportunity for airflow over the HDD(s) without the inclusion of an additional fan".
 
RawsonDR said:
I still don't see how its any different for ATX.
The point with BTX is to have air pulled from the front over the CPU, which equals one intake fan. Then there are the exhaust fans of the PSU and of the case (if any). At this point you've got exactly as many fans as in many ATX-based systems, yet in the latter case most or all intake air is first directed over the HDD(s).

So the conclusion is that with BTX a second intake fan has to be used if the HDDs are to be cooled as well as with a (properly designed) ATX system.

Even better: at least with ATX no intake fans are needed at all, as long as the intake holes are in the right part of the case (the front). In some OEM systems (e.g. Dell) air drawn over the CPU's heatsink is directly exhausted, so that there's only a minimum of fans in those systems (one CPU/exhaust, one PSU).
 
killernoodle said:
99.9% of hard drives that I have seen do not need forced air cooling. Its that simple.
Sure, and a HDD stuffed into a closed external enclosure will work just fine for a long time as well. This doesn't mean that doing so won't decrease its lifespan and reduce its reliability.

HDDs shouldn't operate at more than 10C above ambient.
 
Back
Top