ATM Vendor Gets Security Talk Pulled From Conferences

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How anyone can act surprised that Defcon and Black Hat yanked a live demonstration on hacking current ATM machines is beyond me. It’s not like this is the first time it has happened and it definitely isn’t the last. I’m not saying it should have been pulled, I am saying people shouldn’t be surprised when it happens.

Juniper Networks says it pulled a talk on a flaw in ATM software one of its researchers was scheduled to give at the security conferences at the end of July after the ATM vendor complained. In his presentation entitled "Jackpotting Automated Teller Machines," Barnaby Jack was planning to discuss local and remote attack vectors on ATMs and provide a live demonstration of an attack on an unmodified ATM.
 
The ATM company has probably know about this flaw for a long time and figured security through obscurity was good enough. Assholes.
 
The ATM company has probably know about this flaw for a long time and figured security through obscurity was good enough. Assholes.
Therefore it's perfectly OK to spill the beans? Hope you don't work IT/security. :eek:
 
Therefore it's perfectly OK to spill the beans?

If the vendor already knew about the issue then Yep, as the vendor is forced to issue a patch, otherwise they dont bother and the few people who do know of the exploit carry on using it to gain funds they shouldnt have.
 
Therefore it's perfectly OK to spill the beans? Hope you don't work IT/security. :eek:

If it gets them to fix it or lets consumers know how badly their financial info is being handled - yes, absolutely. Not saying go publish a how-to manual, but spill the beans, definitely, if that's what it takes.
 
Normally a responsible person would approach the company, explain / demonstrate the flaw and give them the opportunity to protect their customers before giving public "how-to" demonstrations.

If the vendor is negligent in fixing the flaw / exploit I can see going public.

As always, people usually feel different about this stuff after they have had their bank accounts cleaned out by scammers. While your money is insured, victims still have to wait to have their money replaced by the bank even though all the while your bills still keep coming in - need to be paid.

It will be interesting to find out if these guys actually did approach the company with this or if they went all asshatty and decided to do the demo for their 15 minutes. I'll reserve judgment until there is confirmation that they did / didn't do the right thing first.
 
If it gets them to fix it or lets consumers know how badly their financial info is being handled - yes, absolutely. Not saying go publish a how-to manual, but spill the beans, definitely, if that's what it takes.

Fuck Yea!! Then Investigate the ones that knew and did nothing, see how many times they have exploited it.
 
Yeah, at least a cursory "hey, did you know you have this huge backdoor in your software?" contact. It's hard to know the full backstory. If the security hole gets fixed, then even the threat of publishing can spur increased security. There are also a lot of "bad apple" examples e.g. Diebold & MA Transit Authority that tend to predispose consumers to assume the company is the one behaving badly.

Publishing your results is also a key part of a researcher's career...it's fully possible that they're trying to get the "scoop" instead of acting in the way most likely to protect the security of the people involved.
 
^^ re this:

Normally a responsible person would approach the company, explain / demonstrate the flaw and give them the opportunity to protect their customers before giving public "how-to" demonstrations.

I should type faster. :p
 
Giving just a live demonstration is one thing, discussing about attack vectors is another. They were right to pull it. Just because it's out there doesn't mean that everyone has a right to know.
 
Back
Top