ATI taped out R520, again

ReDgUaRd008

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 7, 2005
Messages
495
http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=24446 Looks like ATi fans will have to wait for the R520 again.

ATI taped out R520, again

Each time it costs five to six million dollars


By Fuad Abazovic: Thursday 07 July 2005, 09:46


ATI IS STRUGGLING hard to get its 90 nanometre R520 chip to market. Nvidia already has its G70, Geforce 7800 GTX, the 7800GT is coming and ATI still doesn't seem to have an answer to this. ATI is experimenting with yields, and as we have already reported, the company has been sampling R520 for some time.
We reported it will work at 600MHz or more, but we know that ATI was not happy with its initial yield numbers. The first tape out meant ATI got itself a nice performer but many chips from the wafer haven't worked, so the Red Boys decided to re-tape it out again. ATI did so in order to increase the yields, of course.

It takes four to six weeks to tape out the chip again and ATI did the second re-tape just before Nvidia launched G70 chip, but sources claim the results were unsatisfactory. The chip is fast but not too many chips on the wafer actually work as they should.

You can confirm those re-tapes and additional costs at ATI conference calls as it cannot hide the additional operating costs from its investors.

I just cannot understand one thing. How come ATI was able to ship millions of R500, Xbox 360 chips to Microsoft's launch scheduled for October, when it seems to having trouble with yields for the R520? Both chips are using the same new 90 nanometre marchitecture. µ
 
ATI dosn't own nor do they produce the R500, that is Microsoft that is the player there...

Terra...
 
Terra said:
ATI dosn't own nor do they produce the R500, that is Microsoft that is the player there...

Terra...

Yes, which is further evidence that while the Inq does provide good info at times, a lot of the time they're completely clueless. ATi isn't shipping any r500's at all.
 
Does this mean the rumors of ATI stockpiling chips is nothing more than that?
 
Sly said:
Does this mean the rumors of ATI stockpiling chips is nothing more than that?

If they just taped out the R520 again, they can't be stockpilling anything...logic for even chickens in cages ;)

Terra - *bork* ;)
 
Yeah dumb question :p

Still, there are bound to be some chips that worked in the preliminary runs. Maybe HardOCP'll get one of them :D Get an early review :)
 
Why didn't they just stay at the .11 process and just run it at 500mhz so they would have a product against nVidia? Then just do a refresh at .09 when it was ready. I have bought a lot of stocks and sat in on a number of conference calls and have never seen a company pull this kind of shit 2x in a row and someone not get fired. Someone should be canned over this debachle. You ppl don't see the investor side of things too well. No matter what numbers you post on ATI, they are not breaking new ground any where. Crossfire is a paper launched joke. Should have eaten it and got on SLI. They have not proven anything with their Motherboards other than being a low end OEM board that still no one really buys into like an Nforce board. I and you should not have to buy their "crappy" motherboard to do "Crossfire". What? Truth hurts? Try investing your own hard earned cash into a money fucking pit. Fact is ATI has not made a decent motherboard in 3 years(No return on it hardly). LEAVE WELL ENOUGH ALONE!!! Stick to Vid Cards and spend the money on further developing smaller graphics tech like cell phones and mini tv's like you are.(Keep investors happy. :) ) DROP MOBO's!

Sorry, really had to get that off my chest. This company has such great promise and to pull 2 bonehead moves in a row is just unacceptable.

Oh and paying nVidia for an agreement on SLI would have costed less in the long run than developement costs of "Crossfire". But, we have to One up everyone! Dumbasses.
 
Man, I just want ATI to get out a competetive product to combat nvidia. If nvidia becomes the sole high end chip maker prices will skyrocket for enthusiast boards, moreso than they already have. ATI really needs to light a damn fire under this one. They will go the way of 3dfx if they release a product 6 to 8 months after the competetion. In 6 to 8 months, nvidia will already be gearing up for their next card. I hope this doesn't become a voodoo 4/5/6 scenario. They were good boards no doubt, but half a year or more too late. Of course, ATI is much larger than 3dfx ever was and has many sources of income beyond the high end market, so they won't just go under. For the sake of the consumer, they really need to get this product out.
 
perplex said:
but maybe Crossfire will destroy SLI when it's released!
remember, ATI said u can have more than two cards in crossfire. So if a crossfire board had, well lets say 4 pci 16x slots, four r520's running together for those supper rich enthusiasts, hmm that sounds insane.
 
.09 was/is evil for Intel.

I think ATi delayed the jump as long as they could, eventually they would have to make the move to .09

That they waited until this chipset was probably a good idea. That they have had bad yeilds is no surprise. That they seem to be targetting a 32 pipe core and 600mhz is very surprising though, ATi took a risk and tried a new process for their high end chip and got burned a couple months as they retape.

Nvidia took the more conservative road with the low clock, 24 pipe 7800 card. The street price definitely gives no indication of it though...

Maybe the R520 will be selling for $1K?
 
ZenOps said:
.09 was/is evil for Intel.

I think ATi delayed the jump as long as they could, eventually they would have to make the move to .09

That they waited until this chipset was probably a good idea. That they have had bad yeilds is no surprise. That they seem to be targetting a 32 pipe core and 600mhz is very surprising though, ATi took a risk and tried a new process for their high end chip and got burned a couple months as they retape.

Nvidia took the more conservative road with the low clock, 24 pipe 7800 card. The street price definitely gives no indication of it though...

Maybe the R520 will be selling for $1K?
ATI dug themselves a grave if the r520 sells for $1,000
 
slamgoku said:
ATI dug themselves a grave if the r520 sells for $1,000

the people that pay 600+ for a card make up such a small percent of their gross each year, it will barely make a dent. all their money comes from dell, hp, and other oem's. the high end stuff says nothing but who is the fastest at the time.
 
tornadotsunamilife said:
I think he's talking about the original Prescott core's heat problems but I thought this has been resolved.

The prescott had a lot more transistors added to it. It wasn't simply a die shrink like the A64's were. A 130nm prescott would be unuseable.
 
Interesting point. When they shrunk the CPU's that meant more heat per surface area.

How big is the R520 going to be again? It's going to be the biggest GPU chip out there as well as highest density when it comes out right? (Can't remember if this is the one) I'd like to see what kind of cooling solution they're gonna put in.
 
It took intel a loooong time to figure out .09 on complex chips (prescott) Some would even say they still haven't figured it out, and are basically writing off .09 as fast as they can to get to .065.

Dothan is very simple chip by comparison, and came much later... You could say after intel figured out how to tweak the .09 process by the time Dothan showed up.

I think ATI got a little cocky with the R500 (complex sure, but nowhere near as transistor packed as the R520)
 
The Xenos/C1/R500 is broken into a mother die and a daughter die. It has just as many tranistors with those two combined has the G70. I'm betting R520 will have a comparable number too.

Going to 90nm is amazingly hard. It was hard for Intel, AMD, and now ATi. Nvidia will have their own share of problems too. I think it was stupid for ATi to move directly to 90nm without testing it out on a mid range or lower end chip first like both Nvidia and ATi have done before. But we'll see how it pays off for them.
 
PhoenixC5 said:
the people that pay 600+ for a card make up such a small percent of their gross each year, it will barely make a dent. all their money comes from dell, hp, and other oem's. the high end stuff says nothing but who is the fastest at the time.
even people who have cash to blow i see them more likely buying two cards for $1200 than one for $1000
 
BossNoodleKaboodle said:
IBM is working with 65nm and their 90nm/AMD's 90nm and even Intel's new 90nm cores are fine.

Its when you first go the process that you get trouble, not 6 months later.....
 
trinibwoy said:
Yes, which is further evidence that while the Inq does provide good info at times, a lot of the time they're completely clueless. ATi isn't shipping any r500's at all.
I read that comment as a sarcastic jab at the XBox360 vs PS3 !!!!!! arguments.

XBox360 crowd: "But our hardware is already ready and has been demo'd, PS3 is nothing but vaporware!"

Well....guess what? If ATI is still retaping the r520 over and over and over, that XBox360 hardware doesn't exist yet EITHER.
 
BossNoodleKaboodle said:
IBM is working with 65nm and their 90nm/AMD's 90nm and even Intel's new 90nm cores are fine.


Someone can correct me if im wrong, but you cannot used strained silicone for the chips of VPUs like you can for CPU's making the leakage elimination a pain in the ass. I believe thats correct. If not i do know that a major part of the process of CPU shrinking can not be employed on VPU shrinking, and that VPU shrinking is more complex.

dderidex said:
I read that comment as a sarcastic jab at the XBox360 vs PS3 !!!!!! arguments.

XBox360 crowd: "But our hardware is already ready and has been demo'd, PS3 is nothing but vaporware!"

Well....guess what? If ATI is still retaping the r520 over and over and over, that XBox360 hardware doesn't exist yet EITHER.

Well you'd be completely wrong. Allow me to enlighten you. Microsoft paid for a design which ATI has given them, this chip was in development for alot longer then the G70 or RSX which are both directly linked and as such the R500 contains alot of things VPUs dont, the two major things being embedded ram and unified shader architecture. Microsoft also owns the design and manufacturing of the chip meaning they can start production when they choose and do what ever they want with it, it has absolutly no connection to the R520 in its creation process. Obviously someone hasnt read the detailed Xenos write ups. Its completely different from any computer VPU.

Further more Microsoft has dedicated themselves to a holiday launch, pre-orders are already out at the large game stores, the PS3 is sometime in 2006. Which one has its hardware further along? I havent seen one working in game demo off the PS3 and i was not impressed by the massive amount of pre-renders from E3 that they showed.
 
dderidex said:
I read that comment as a sarcastic jab at the XBox360 vs PS3 !!!!!! arguments.

XBox360 crowd: "But our hardware is already ready and has been demo'd, PS3 is nothing but vaporware!"

Well....guess what? If ATI is still retaping the r520 over and over and over, that XBox360 hardware doesn't exist yet EITHER.

Xenos and R520 are NOTHING alike. In fact, Xenos is a one of the kind, nothing is even close to like it and Xenos is vastly different than R520. You can not compare the two. Also, Xenos's production and fab process is now totally controlled by Microsoft.
 
By the time ati comes out with the r520 nvidia will have already put out something comparable in speed and their 7800gtx will be cheaper and everything. I think ati are shooting themselves in the foot.
 
Back
Top