Ati or Nvidia...what to use

Status
Not open for further replies.

DNAlevelC

Gawd
Joined
Jul 3, 2004
Messages
810
Ok I am not looking for a Flame war. If this gets to that point I will ask to have this locked.

I have an ATI x800Pro 256 AGP and I am gettin a 6800GT 256 for free. Now one will be in my comp and the other will go in my g/f's comp so she can have a better vid card. *COUGH* and so I can play Desert Combat and or BF2 *COUGH* ummm excuse me... ;-)

now my system specs are in my sig. I am an ATI fan. I have not used an Nvidia card that I have liked. (they were all cheapo's...Geforce 2MX, Geforce 5700LE).

I want some opinions on what you guys think.

Thanks in advance

DNA
 
It's really a toss up in reality, I have 2 6800gt's and 1 x800pro agp and I can not tell any difference in the 2 cards except doom3 is a little better on the 6800gt.
 
I am on AGP till later this year or next year. 4 kids can kill the upgrade path.
 
6800gt no doubt. SM3.0 support alone is worth it.The ATI card is still good but you want the better of the 2. Spend $40 on a Zalman gpu cooler to keep temps down better.
 
in the past 5 years i have built 4 gaming rigs and all them have geforce cards in them. the oldest one (i forget exactly what it is but its 64 megs of ram isn't even ddr) is still running just fine and my latest, an fx 5500 right at a year old, is also running just fine. i have had no problems with any of my nvidia cards. on the other hand, several years ago when i first started building comps, i tried 2 different ati cards. one of them was an all-in-wonder card and it fizzled out on me after only 3 months. and when it comes to support for drivers and such, it seems much easier for nvidia cards than it does for ati cards. i'm about to upgrade from my fx 5500 to a 6800 gs. i have read nothing but great review for the 6800 gs. years ago it was night and day between ati cards and nvidia cards but these days, from all that i have heard, both brands are pretty comparable. for me though, i'll always use nvidia.
 
ATi and nVidia are generally toe-to-toe with certain models (these 2 included), and both are very good cards. However, nVidia has the advantage of having SM3.0. If you play shader-intensive games like Doom 3 or F.E.A.R., the 6800 will do you much better than the X800.
 
These days it all comes down to cost $$$

At just about every level they both perform about the same and look about the same.

Best performance for a lot of money and a single card = ATI

However NVIDIA takes the low, middle and uber high end (SLI GTX512).

Heck any video card you find in the dumpster will do better than a standard PS2/XBOX (480i).
 
slickmitch - I have many fans in the comp, so temps aren't a prob.

I just got the x800pro about a month before xmas for about $180 and i love it, but as I said the 6800gt is free. It doesn't matter all that much on which one I use. I jus want to use the one that will give me a lil more life. Shader 3 isn't a big deal to me. Here are the games I play:

GTA:SA, Fear (once in a while), Battlefield 1942 (Desert Combat Final), BF2, Quake 4 (once in a while), and NBA Live 06

those are all I really care about, Unless something badass and new hits soon. I usually play my DS anyways.
 
They are both good cards, but I agree with the rest, the 6800GT has SM 3.0.

6800GT FTW
 
Tried unlocking the X800 Pro? If you can, my vote would go to that over the GT. If not, grab the GT, especially as it's free!
 
I did try to unlock my card, but it seems to be very unstable. I know my card can't overclock for shit, so I used the bios that keeps the clocks the same and opens the pipes. It didn't like that too much when I played BF2. If the bios changes the voltage cause of the pipes, my shitty PSU could have been at fault there too. I do have a new PSU...I chould try it again. It won't hurt anything to do it.

Any Ideas?
 
id say the 6800GT. Should be able to overclock pretty well, at least a little better than your x800. BF 2 likes Nvidia cards a bit better at lower res and lower iq(1280 with a little AA) Plus it has SM 3.0... Not like that would mean anything anyway...

BTW, I have always used ATI cards in my high end systems... So I am not a Nvidia !!!!!!...

edit: thats weird... sorry using that word... err
 
I switched from the x800xt to a 7800gt. i know they are not on the same platform but having the sm3.0 will make a difference in the future. id go with nvidia
 
DNAlevelC said:
I did try to unlock my card, but it seems to be very unstable. I know my card can't overclock for shit, so I used the bios that keeps the clocks the same and opens the pipes. It didn't like that too much when I played BF2. If the bios changes the voltage cause of the pipes, my shitty PSU could have been at fault there too. I do have a new PSU...I chould try it again. It won't hurt anything to do it.

Any Ideas?

umm...like everyone is saying go with the 6800gt. The 6800 core clocks well but warm, hence the Zalman gpu suggestion. You want a little more life right? You are gonna want sm3.0 support. All the new cards are doin it mang ...come on join the green team!!
:p :mad:
 
DNAlevelC said:
Ok I am not looking for a Flame war........ I am an ATI fan. I have not used an Nvidia card that I have liked. (they were all cheapo's...Geforce 2MX, Geforce 5700LE).
too late... [the shot heard around the world] all over again!
 
The 6800gt doesn't really have the performance to make use of sm3.0 making that a completely moot point, but it should be a tad faster than the x800pro anyway, so I'd use it.
 
bobzdar said:
The 6800gt doesn't really have the performance to make use of sm3.0 making that a completely moot point
Not really. For the most part, SM3.0 is there to increase pixel shader flexibility and shader performance via dynamic branching. Also, geometry instancing is possible with SM3.0, which means Battle for Middle Earth, Oblivion and a couple other titles will see a slight boost with SM3.0 cards.

No current titles use displacement maps (that I'm aware of), so there should always be a performance benefit when using an SM3.0 path as opposed to an SM2.0 path.
 
I am surprised that this thread has survived this long. I never did get the 6800GT. I actually had to RMA my x800Pro and when I got my new one I did some tests. I was able to turn it into an X800XT PE. Now last week I went and did a new upgrade. I put in a K8N Neo4-F mobo and I got an X1800XT. Hell I even put a lil more ram in. The system is beautiful and I don't see a vid card upgrade for another year. Next month I am gonna buy either a A64 X2 3800+ or a 4200+. I do a lot of multitasking and I think that will be better than an FX or Opteron. The computer kicks ass once again. BF2 and CS Source look amazing.

DNA
 
ive noticed this a lot lately, people are bringing back old threads. this should be stopped. its annoying. oh shit im contributing the annoyingness. NOOOOO.
 
LMAO...old threads are good if they help out and don't have stupid shit in them


DNA
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top