ATI Catalyst drivers have a problem - The Inq

Wow, and there I thought my Catalyst drivers worked just fine. I must go leap off a ledge now.
 
Whatever people want to believe about the 6800 is fine by me. I don't see why its so hard to believe that ATi is not 9.0c and Nvidia is not 9.0 original. Now that 9.0c is out, I would think Nvidia peeps would be breathing a sigh of relief.

Shader models are different, as in order to have 3.0 compliance you have to have 2.0 (b) and automatically have the minimums and all preceding versions first. But I'm not talking about instruction length here.

If people are so sure that Nvidia is 9.0 compliant, please show any Nvidia documentation anywhere, where it says that it is 9.0 without a +, or without saying "enhanced", or saying with PVS 3.0 (which is essentially saying version c) You won't find it, as Nvidia is covering their legal bases on this one.

All Radeon 9x00 and X800 are not TruForm Hardware compliant, even though it has the ability to render it without any errors. There is extensive documentation about it, you can even toggle it off and on even in the newest of cards. The only TruForm Hardware compliant card was the Radeon 8500.
 
R1ckCa1n said:
I can't believe you actually posted that link to suggest IQ problems with CAT's. What a joke.

They still are not anywhere near this CRAP from a 6800. :D

You should try reading the rest of the thread instead of just looking at pictures next time.

GabooN said:
As for the pictures
They don’t look as good because I compressed them; each picture in its original format was over 5megs.
And I was posting about a bug with Tiger Woods Golf as they do look like crap.. Anyway I do run AA and AF but allot depends on the games.

His issue is most likely just a bug in the game or the settings that he is using or the fact he didn't install his drivers properly or many other things. In the case of the X800's they are using lower filtering quality.

John Carmack said:
The benchmarking was conducted on-site, and the hardware vendors did not have access to the demo before hand, so we are confident that there is no egregious cheating going on, but it should be noted that some of the ATI cards did show a performance drop when colored mip levels were enabled, implying some fudging of the texture filtering. This has been a chronic issue for years, and almost all vendors have been guilty of it at one time or another. I hate the idea of drivers analyzing texture data and changing parameters, but it doesn't visibly impact the quality of the game unless you know exactly what to look for on a specific texture.

http://www2.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NjQy

datamage said:
burningrave,

The 4.9 beta Catalyst drivers have no IQ differences from the 4.7s. Just as mentioned, if you force AF through the CP, there is no problem. I know you swore an oath to criticize/discredit/attack ATI whenever possible, but you should give it a rest.

- D.

According to what? lol

Can you not see those screenshots for yourself? And that was just ONE part of ONE level. Unless you have some sort of proof you can pull up somewhere that shows without a shadow of a doubt there is no IQ difference between the two then you have no idea what your talking about.

If you force AF through the CP, which your not suppost to do in games where you can select AF in-game because in-game AF is more correctly applied then forced AF, it applies AF to everything causing a performance hit that you have to HACK your way around using the Humus HACK.

So here we have TWO instances in DOOM 3 where the ATI cards are NOT doing what their suppost to.

1.) They are doing bilinear AF when AF is enabled in-game which causes lower AF quality.

2.) They are applying AF to EVERYTHING with CP AF and hurting performance.

You really should go out and get the facts before you try to discredit someone upon something you know nothing about.

I sure do hope i'm not hurting yours or anyone else's feelings by "criticizing/discrediting/attacking" precious ATI and if i am then i am truly and very deeply sorry. :D
 
Brent_Justice said:
IMO all of this is a non issue

ATI has a fix to pass WHQL certification

and GI isn't being used in any game currently

this really isn't a big deal

if we start seeing GI used in games showing great advantages in performance, then it will be an issue...

right now, not so much

I agree...totally not a big deal. The only place this could hurt them is with OEMs and I'm sure they'll side-step that landmine. It doesn't bode well for SM2.0b though...here and I thought it was cool to just makeup new features and roll with it...

This might give them problems getting 2.0b in games later on though...
 
burningrave101 said:
You should try reading the rest of the thread instead of just looking at pictures next time.



His issue is most likely just a bug in the game or the settings that he is using or the fact he didn't install his drivers properly or many other things. In the case of the X800's they are using lower filtering quality.



http://www2.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NjQy



According to what? lol

Can you not see those screenshots for yourself? And that was just ONE part of ONE level. Unless you have some sort of proof you can pull up somewhere that shows without a shadow of a doubt there is no IQ difference between the two then you have no idea what your talking about.

If you force AF through the CP, which your not suppost to do in games where you can select AF in-game because in-game AF is more correctly applied then forced AF, it applies AFto everything causing a performance hit that you have to HACK your way around using the Humus HACK.

So here we have TWO instances in DOOM 3 where the ATI cards are NOT doing what their suppost to.

1.) They are doing bilinear AF when AF is enabled in-game which causes lower AF quality.

2.) They are applying AF to EVERYTHING with CP AF and hurting performance.

You really should go out and get the facts before you try to discredit someone upon something you know nothing about.

I sure do hope i'm not hurting yours or anyone else's feelings by "criticizing/discrediting/attacking" precious ATI and if i am then i am truly and very deeply sorry. :D

You know what I hate...people who take one thing out of an article and blow it completely out of proportion...read the conclusion of the article burningrave...EB said there was no noticeable difference...and it's not like ATi is getting a huge boost from the 4.9 cats...so who cares...

Not to mention it's completely off topic...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
You know what I hate...people who take one thing out of an article and blow it completely out of proportion...read the conclusion of the article burningrave...EB said there was no noticeable difference...and it's not like ATi is getting a huge boost from the 4.9 cats...so who cares...

Not to mention it's completely off topic...
exactly.
Burningrave101, take a hike.

You are off topic. Thank you, don't let the door hit you on the way out.

As for the topic, I still stand by what I've said and I've gotten no comments...

If this were Supersample AA vs rotated grid AA vs multi AA, MS certified Nvidia as they were in full compliance and dropped ATI because a feature unrelated to AA wasn't up to spec...

Where would you stand then? Not SM3.0, so GI isn't an allowable feature? I just don't see it. If only one company supports it, odds are not in our favor that the gaming industry as a whole will support it either. The shitastic part of this situation is both companies support it, MS has a corncob up their ass because ATI didn't play the game completely to their specs.

And for the record, I am not a big fan of ATI at the moment...
 
0ldman said:
exactly.
Burningrave101, take a hike.

You are off topic. Thank you, don't let the door hit you on the way out.

As for the topic, I still stand by what I've said and I've gotten no comments...

If this were Supersample AA vs rotated grid AA vs multi AA, MS certified Nvidia as they were in full compliance and dropped ATI because a feature unrelated to AA wasn't up to spec...

Where would you stand then? Not SM3.0, so GI isn't an allowable feature? I just don't see it. If only one company supports it, odds are not in our favor that the gaming industry as a whole will support it either. The shitastic part of this situation is both companies support it, MS has a corncob up their ass because ATI didn't play the game completely to their specs.

And for the record, I am not a big fan of ATI at the moment...

As a general rule, you don't want to be the graphics company playing catch-up. Whether it's useful or not, whether games use it right now or not...it pays to be in the drivers seat...the mere perception of a superior featureset is enough for most people to buy a 6800 over an x800.
 
^eMpTy^ said:
You know what I hate...people who take one thing out of an article and blow it completely out of proportion...read the conclusion of the article burningrave...EB said there was no noticeable difference...and it's not like ATi is getting a huge boost from the 4.9 cats...so who cares...

Not to mention it's completely off topic...

There is a clear difference in the screenshots if you look for it and that was the point i was making.

People make a big deal out of any kind of IQ degradation at all. I mean look at 3Dc vs DXT5. There would most likely be no noticeable difference in-game and yet people tout 3Dc as having better IQ because of blown-up screenshots.

I'm not completely off topic ither. I started with commenting on someone else's reply. Head on back and see what i said in my first post.

And besides, the title of the thread is "ATI Catalyst drivers have a problem" and i was addressing some of their problems. :p
 
When a team loses a game in basketball there are always players in that losing team who still think they won that game. Same ignorant people in here that do the same with this crap. ATI ignorants please flush your self down that toilet and accept it. YOU LOST THIS TIME.
 
burningrave101 said:
People make a big deal out of any kind of IQ degradation at all. I mean look at 3Dc vs DXT5. There would most likely be no noticeable difference in-game and yet people tout 3Dc as having better IQ because of blown-up screenshots.

And I bitch at them too. Either way, the 4.9s were a joke...3fps? who cares...not even worth arguing over...
 
burningrave,

Pity that you waste your time with trivial matters. Even worse for me, that I waste my time replying to your nonsense. I don't need to go look at any pictures for evidence. I have an XTPE, I have played Doom for hours with the 4.7 drivers, and then the 4.9 betas. So unlike you, who has to rely on little articles and pictures from websites, I can determine for myself the effect of each driver. Also, there is no rule that I have to use AF in-game, I prefer to force AF through the CP, and not set it per game. I have never noticed a difference either way, and as for performance, hell, if I'm losing any performance, I sure as hell could afford to lose it.

You are fighting a lost cause. There are plenty of people here who prefer Nvidia over ATI, but they handle matters in a much better way, and argue their case much better than you.

Anyhow, no more wasting my time replying to your usual posts. Congratulations, you're the first person to be added to my ignore list. Have a pleasant night.

- D.
 
datamage said:
burningrave,

Pity that you waste your time with trivial matters. Even worse for me, that I waste my time replying to your nonsense. I don't need to go look at any pictures for evidence. I have an XTPE, I have played Doom for hours with the 4.7 drivers, and then the 4.9 betas. So unlike you, who has to rely on little articles and pictures from websites, I can determine for myself the effect of each driver. Also, there is no rule that I have to use AF in-game, I prefer to force AF through the CP, and not set it per game. I have never noticed a difference either way, and as for performance, hell, if I'm losing any performance, I sure as hell could afford to lose it.

You are fighting a lost cause. There are plenty of people here who prefer Nvidia over ATI, but they handle matters in a much better way, and argue their case much better than you.

Anyhow, no more wasting my time replying to your usual posts. Congratulations, you're the first person to be added to my ignore list. Have a pleasant night.

- D.

Give me a break lol. :rolleyes:

The fact that you "determined" there was no IQ difference doesn't mean its not there. If an article reported IQ degradation using a 6800U and yet an end user didn't ever notice it then that wouldn't mean its not there. It just means you dont see it and good for you.

And there is no rule that says your suppost to use in-game AF but when a game gives the ability to use in-game AF thats the method of choice because it doesn't FORCE the AF and it applies it the way the author intended and not the way nVidia or ATI see fit. In D3D games you want to always use in-game AF on ATI hardware because CP AF is lower quality because of being more heavily optimized.

And i'm glad that you have me on ignore because now i wont have to stop and reply to more of your ignorant posts that try to replace facts with fiction.
 
HeavenX said:
When a team loses a game in basketball there are always players in that losing team who still think they won that game. Same ignorant people in here that do the same with this crap. ATI ignorants please flush your self down that toilet and accept it. YOU LOST THIS TIME.

um, no, people with an X800 based card did NOT loose

they do provide a great gaming experience


can people not understand that you can have great performance cards from two different IHVs in the same generation?
 
The fact that you "determined" there was no IQ difference doesn't mean its not there

No, it means its not noticeable to his eyes, and you have even stated that if its not noticeable there is no problem with it. so instead of arguing why don't you be happy that it's not a problem for him, and it's not even a problem for you, why can't you just simply stop arguing about it, it's not like people are repeatedly saying their card is better than yours
 
Brent_Justice said:
can people not understand that you can have great performance cards from two different IHVs in the same generation?

you lost me here Brent, I have no idea what you're trying to say...;)
 
Brent_Justice said:
can people not understand that you can have great performance cards from two different IHVs in the same generation?
No, no they can't. People have to convince everyone that what they own is the best so that their e-penis is 0.1" longer.
 
IHV = independant hardware vendor

(for those who dont know what it means, i had to look it up :D )
 
HeavenX said:
When a team loses a game in basketball there are always players in that losing team who still think they won that game. Same ignorant people in here that do the same with this crap. ATI ignorants please flush your self down that toilet and accept it. YOU LOST THIS TIME.

What did they lose sxactly? How did buying one videocard to play games with translate that you lost something.

Let see..

Buy ATI Videocard
Install
Play Doom 3 and Half life 2 (eventually)
Play lots of other games

OMG! you got it right!! what losers!!!
 
Back
Top