ATI and NVIDIA cards do NOT support HDCP!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
:eek:

Not quite sure what to think. Not that I planning on watch movies on my x1900xtx....
 
I can't speak for ati cards, I will say from an industry insider perspective that Nvidia cards from the 7 series and up ALL support HDCP. I know this to be true upon internal documents which will not be discussed here. As for ATI i'd highly expect the same for the X1000 series and above. If not I would be shocked.
 
Lord_Exodia said:
I can't speak for ati cards, I will say from an industry insider perspective that Nvidia cards from the 7 series and up ALL support HDCP. I know this to be true upon internal documents which will not be discussed here. As for ATI i'd highly expect the same for the X1000 series and above. If not I would be shocked.

In the article on FS they said that nv gpus since the fx5700 and ati gpu's since the 8500 have suported HDCP, only problem is that the board manufactures have not implemeted it on there boards. except for a few 6200 and 6600’s sold in sony pc's
 
Lord_Exodia said:
I can't speak for ati cards, I will say from an industry insider perspective that Nvidia cards from the 7 series and up ALL support HDCP. I know this to be true upon internal documents which will not be discussed here. As for ATI i'd highly expect the same for the X1000 series and above. If not I would be shocked.

please read the article. The GPU supports it but NO card manufacturer has installed the de-crypting chip required to watch hi-res movies.
 
Thats probably because the standard wasnt even finalized until recently...and there is still descent amongst manufacturers. It's VHS vs Beta all over again.

BUT: After reading the article, it looks like the required component is an encryption key chip. Who wants to make bets that teh DVD drives themselves will end uup having these chips?

And again...just wait until some hacker reverses the encryption and creates a ripper that removes protection.

It will happen. Personally, I don't care at this point because I don't see a lot of drives or media that support the format. Thats next years hardware, and the new to come cards will most likely support it.
 
This is no surprise at all. These bastards will always look for new ways to squeeze us as much as possible.

We all have to buy new motherboards, memory, CPUs and graphics cards so much more often these days, even though raw CPU clockspeed has remained virtually unchanged.

When the PS3 comes out, I am going to buy two. One to play Blue ray disks and install a hacked version of open source, the other will be for gaming. Got to beat the bastards at their own game.
 
BBA said:
Thats probably because the standard wasnt even finalized until recently...and there is still descent amongst manufacturers.

It's VHS vs Beta all over again.

This is exactly why!!! 100% agree with BBA
 
Lord_Exodia said:
I can't speak for ati cards, I will say from an industry insider perspective that Nvidia cards from the 7 series and up ALL support HDCP. I know this to be true upon internal documents which will not be discussed here. As for ATI i'd highly expect the same for the X1000 series and above. If not I would be shocked.

According to the article, the GPU supports HDCP but the board does not. So it's pointless that the GPU supports it.

This is really a major screw-up by the people looking to push HDCP on us. All the more reason to delay migration to Vista and Blue-ray or HD-DVD. If they think everyone is going to rush out to upgrade their monitors, OS, Graphics cards, and DVD players, they are seriously mistaken.

I believed that this would be in place by the end of the year but now I am thinking that HDCP through the PC will not be relevant for another 2 years or more. Especially give the high-cost of the first players.

However, if you plan on watching cable on your monitor through direct connection to the cable box and not the PC, then HDCP on the monitor may be relevant now.

Bottom line is that the organization standardizing HDCP and the entertainment industry were foolish not to make it a no-brainer for MS, monitor manufactures AND ATI and Nvidia to impliment this encryption method. Now they only have themselves to blame when the market drags it's feet to adopt this scheme.
 
feck HDCP it will be cracked before either format becomes mainstream. Since I am not a pirate I will be the first to by the pass through that allows me to watch legally purchased HDCP content at full res on my system. If no crack exists then I simply won't buy the content. It's idiotic they think this will help anything, companies that enforce this protection just lose out either way.
 
wonkman said:
According to the article, the GPU supports HDCP but the board does not. So it's pointless that the GPU supports it.

This is really a major screw-up by the people looking to push HDCP on us. All the more reason to delay migration to Vista and Blue-ray or HD-DVD. If they think everyone is going to rush out to upgrade their monitors, OS, Graphics cards, and DVD players, they are seriously mistaken.

I believed that this would be in place by the end of the year but now I am thinking that HDCP through the PC will not be relevant for another 2 years or more. Especially give the high-cost of the first players.

However, if you plan on watching cable on your monitor through direct connection to the cable box and not the PC, then HDCP on the monitor may be relevant now.

Bottom line is that the organization standardizing HDCP and the entertainment industry were foolish not to make it a no-brainer for MS, monitor manufactures AND ATI and Nvidia to impliment this encryption method. Now they only have themselves to blame when the market drags it's feet to adopt this scheme.


I agree with what your saying, except that Vista will be the biggest push for everyone to upgrade their systems. They DO expect you to upgrade Your monitor, videocard, & possibly system and they are banking on it. Sadly many people will and regardless on how strong a stance you make to refuse to upgrade the os will be a blazing success.
 
Actually, the whole point of HDCP is that its built into the hardware so I do not know how easy it will be to hack, at least effectively.

Personally, I'm not all that worried about it for the moment. HD disc content isn't even out yet, and I'm not going to buy it at a cost premimum.

Besides, to play that HD content is going to require a $500 dollar drive anyway at least at the start.
 
Lord_Exodia said:
Vista will be the biggest push for everyone to upgrade their systems. They DO expect you to upgrade Your monitor, videocard, & possibly system and they are banking on it. Sadly many people will and regardless on how strong a stance you make to refuse to upgrade the os will be a blazing success.

Not if the market gets fed up. Monopolies and cabals invariably greed themselves out of existence.

The first cracks in the armor were seen with WinXP, with individual users, small businesses and corporate America all but ignoring it -- still -- not only to save retraining costs but also because of WPA. Even six years after its introduction, Win2K installations still outnumber XP.
 
A while back, Sigma produced the Hollywood DVD decoder cards that used pass-through cables to work with regular video cards. How difficult would it be to make a 1x PCIe card with an HDCP decoder chip and pair of pass-through DVIc connectors to decrypt the signal before sending it along to the next device?
 
Frank DC said:
Not if the market gets fed up. Monopolies and cabals invariably greed themselves out of existence.

The first cracks in the armor were seen with WinXP, with individual users, small businesses and corporate America all but ignoring it -- still -- not only to save retraining costs but also because of WPA. Even six years after its introduction, Win2K installations still outnumber XP.

I still dont see it making an impact. Everyone in hard forum can boycott the OS and I still see people lined up around the block to get one.

Microsoft " We are Vole, you will buy Vista, Resistance is Futile"
 
taht will suck, i mean, even if all board manufacturers have to do is rework the board, still, thats another pile of $$$ to fork out for HDCP (and Vista!)
 
Lord_Exodia said:
I agree with what your saying, except that Vista will be the biggest push for everyone to upgrade their systems. They DO expect you to upgrade Your monitor, videocard, & possibly system and they are banking on it. Sadly many people will and regardless on how strong a stance you make to refuse to upgrade the os will be a blazing success.

Money talks and BS walks. How quickly this gets adopted will depend on whether the market sees enough benefit to drop a load of cash on new equipment. Did you see that Poll where something like 50% of people with HDTV thought they were watching HD when they were actually watching standard definition? They don't even know what Hi-def is.

"Enthusiasts" will upgrade fairly quickly but mainstream is not going to jump to buy right away. How many people are still using dialup when at least DSL is available, or DSL when cable is available, or cable when FiOS is available. I know many people and businesses still using Win95 long after XP came out. And how many people have recently purchased TVs that don't have HDMI (HDCP built-in to this input standard)? Are they going to rush out to buy a new TV after one year? And who want to buy a $500-$1000 player with no media to play? And who wants to buy Blue-ray only to find out that HD-DVD won the game (anyone buy a Betamax)? Maybe people will move to Vista relatively quickly but it won't be because of High-Def playback.

This appears to be an uncoordinated mess that won't straighten itself out for a couple of years.

I agree with peacetilence. I'm ready to reject this until the last possible minute that I can hold out. Pretty movies aren't going to make me trash a perfectly good system.
 
illgiveumorality said:
Can't most CPU's play 1080p videos anyway? I thought my G5 can fine

HDCP in not about the ability to playback at high resolution. It's an encryption scheme that requires compliant equipment to play at full resolution. It's included in the Blue-ray and HD-DVD standards to be released this year.
 
Zamboni said:
How difficult would it be to make a 1x PCIe card with an HDCP decoder chip and pair of pass-through DVIc connectors to decrypt the signal before sending it along to the next device?

That just makes too much sense, ms/nvidia/ati/lcd manufacturers wants you to buy a new video/monitor card rather then some decoder card.
But even then i doubt it'll be cheap, look here
 
forcefed said:
That just makes too much sense, ms/nvidia/ati/lcd manufacturers wants you to buy a new video/monitor card rather then some decoder card.
But even then i doubt it'll be cheap, look here

Um okay I don't really care about movie quality that much if its going to have me go threw this crap, I mean I still watch videos at 512x384 or 624x352 on my 1280x1024 lcd, and they still look pretty good to me, games however I can tell a big difference.
 
Just watch, we will end up getting forced to buy brand new hardware. The hardware will be extortionately priced to cover the $0.005 per-device fee, then when we go to watch movies, we see that we are in fact watching some upsampled 480i video. I'll guarantee that this is what will happen. Intel/Microsoft/Hollywood will extort money out of people and then not deliver their end of the bargain.

I'm sure (hope) it will get cracked very easily.
 
I bought a 23" acd from my local apple store and the manager there said apple were supporting BluRay Technology and all the Current ACDs will be able to show BluRay Movies, He said if it didnt i was welcome to get a full refund, he even stated this on the receipt. I hink everyone is worrying about nothing, iwas also told that the encryption will be decoded by software on pcs and macs. I find it all really strange,i dont know what to believe but whatever happens my back is covered display wise!!
 
illgiveumorality said:
Can't most CPU's play 1080p videos anyway? I thought my G5 can fine


I'm not sure about most but I can play 1080p .ts movies fine. Though I have dual core and a 7800GTX512. The .ts movies are like 16 gigs each and play back at something like 16-20mbps. Regular dvds playback at something like 4-9mbps. So I think protection schemes are the dead weight and not hardware. I can playback .264 files as well using FFDshow and media player classic but hardware is a limit since I don't have proper decoders (though it's really not that bad considering you're meant to have the latest version of Quicktime and built in hardware decoders etc.) Instead of perfectly smooth playback I get a bit of choppyness. This was with a single core cpu though. I haven't tried with my Opteron 170 yet.
 
IMO this isn't a big deal, other than showing what a failure these MPAA-forced security standards will be.

Running at sub-standard resolutions is going to turn many people off to the newer protection racket. Why buy a next generation HD-ROM (Blu-Ray or HD-DVD) for your computer when it's not going to look much better than a current DVD? Fewer people have HDCP monitors/TVs than have HDCP video cards so the lack of HDCP video cards isn't a big deal. You need both to support the "secure" protocol. This HDCP scheme reminds me of that the RIAA did to DAT: protected it to consumer failure.

What about HD-ROM content? Look at DVD-ROM to see how long it will take for HD-ROM to support content other than console games and movies. Most PC games and software still don't come on DVD-ROM, but DVD+/-R has become a convenient recording medium.
 
Is there a reason why they can't just build the decoder right into the HD or BluRay DRIVE?

I mean I know it sounds stupid to have hardware that actually does what it's advertised to do, but then 90% of the population who buys one of these drives will be completely ignorant about the details of the hardware needs.

Somehow it just doesn't seem like good marketing to me to sell something to people if it's not going to work for most of them, especially since the vast majority of people won't realize why it's not working. Talk about endless returns for "defective" parts, and tons of complaints.

If one of these technologies does build the decoder into the PC drives, and the other requires outside parts.... Well it's pretty obvious which one people will prefer.
 
There failures occurred at so many different levels. I’ve probably burned a few bridges in this article, and I probably won’t be reviewing any video cards in the near future.

I have to give the writer of that article a lot of credit. If hardware websites aren't literally sucked the dick of the hardware manufacter then they'll never get new hardware to review.

Not like it matters if they do a video card review. Everyone is going to review the $400+ video cards that only a fraction of the people buy. Besides I can't remember the last time I read a video card review anyway.

This is the kinda stuff that helps the consumer. If this information gets around the sales of video cards are going to halt. A lot of negative responses will be thrown around to MS, Nvidia, and ATI. The hacking community might even get huge support from the public. Maybe at some point hackers won't always be looked down upon.

To be ohnest I don't think HD-DVD or Blue-Ray will even take off at all. First off not many people like to watch movies on their PC. Second not many people own HDTV. It'll take a long time before the price of HDTV's will even go down in price so that everyone can own one. Finally the DVD format is just fine for most people.

I mean for god sakes we still don't have DVD as mainstream yet either. They still sell VCRs in stores. Even PC games haven't moved to the DVD format. It'll be hard to convice people that it's worth it to move to HD-DVD or Blue-Ray. Especially with the consideration of the higher prices of HD-DVD or Blue-Ray movie costs.

Also people maybe moving to more portable content like cell phones and ipods. It may not be worth it for them to sit home and watch a movie so sharp that you could see the bumps on peoples skin.
 
arentol said:
Is there a reason why they can't just build the decoder right into the HD or BluRay DRIVE?

If one of these technologies does build the decoder into the PC drives, and the other requires outside parts.... Well it's pretty obvious which one people will prefer.

It's about end-to-end encryption, not just decoding the content once so it can be displayed. They want the content encrypted at ALL times, so just "decoding in the dvd drive" isn't going to work because they won't let it travel unencrypted through the system where it could be ripped or copied.
 
da sponge said:
They want the content encrypted at ALL times, so just "decoding in the dvd drive" isn't going to work because they won't let it travel unencrypted through the system where it could be ripped or copied.


Speaking of which, what ever happened to that crap that they wanted to use to lock us out of our own moterboards? (cant remember what its called.) They want to make it impossible to hack the stream while it is the hardware.

I heard a bunch about it months ago, then all went silent.
 
kvn5000 said:
I heard a bunch about it months ago, then all went silent.
It's still there.

AMD has Presidio and Intel has La Grande DRM/security support. Presidio will infect AMD CPUs later this year and La Grande has been out for months. ;)

DRM/security is not all negative. Portions of Presidio and La Grande are actually very nice to have: real local security built into the CPU.

I saw an old [H] thread about moving over to Apple due to DRM on the PC. Apple now has the worst of it in the new models: La Grande and security chips. LOL Think it's bad having to buy a new video card and monitor? Early Intel Mac adopters have to buy a whole new system. :p
 
Yes thats it, i think i just stopped reading about. I didnt want to know any more. I am more worried when it gets hardware implemented into the MB, without that the cpu's drm wont work to its full intentions most likely.
 
This is all still way out... I am not worried by any of this. I would even to say it will almost a year before this gets major main stream on the PC. by that time I will be upgrading again...

but, it's all good info...
 
Yes the problem with it being 10 months away is . These new GPU's allow such high res that guys are upgrading to 24"lcd's also. So lets say you buy today 2 7800GTX sli with the latest M/B = $1500 and lets say a 24" mon.= 800 / Buy my math = $2300 for 10 months. You can say I won't use Vista . OK fine I will with Xfired R600(R620) A nice new 24" mon. HD optics or blue ray , Fastest available Conroe Cpu . And all I have to do is realize is my present system is fast. and I can hang in there to make a smart buying decision DID I include Vista OS.
 
Man, this is crap. I just bought my 2405fpw 6months ago which is NOT HDCP compliant. Anyone want to start a fund to try to crack this hdcp crap? I'm game to put in a few bucks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top