Athlon64 3400+ vs 3700+

lelliott731

[H]ard DCOTM April 2017
Joined
Mar 15, 2002
Messages
941
Hey guys, I saw at Newegg.com a 3700+ going for $535 and a 3400+ going for $293. They are both socket 754, and both operate at 2.4GHz. The only difference is the 3700+ has 1MB of Level 2 Cache, whereas the 3400+ has 512k. I currently am running an old 3400+, with 1MB of Level 2 Cache onboard, and I was wondering if either of these would actually give me a performance boost? Or should I just sell what I have and move to the Socket 939 platform so I can have Dual Channel memory? Any ideas would be greatly appreciated. Also, any suggestions as to configs for a good Doom 3 system would be helpful. I'm trying to stay under $3,000 for the sytem in total. I think I want to get a CRT monitor though, I have a 19" Viewsonic, but it's refresh isn't all that great, and for Doom 3, I'm sure you need a good refresh rate, or am I wrong? Thanks for any advice.
 
I have seen reviews that placed the 3700+ below the 939 cpu's but, I also saw the opposite from reviews. Having OC'ed my 3000+ to 3700+'s mhz I can say it must be a great speed boost as mine runs great and the 3700+ has a full meg cache. However I would imagine using the money for better video would be of much great value, or perhaps getting the massive display you always dreamed of.
 
the extra cache helps a little, but is not nearly worth the money. Its a 5% increase, max. The onboard memory controller lowers the need for a lot of cache, as the CPU can access the RAM quicker and this negates the need for the cache. Also, because of the onboard memory controller, dual channel doesn't make a big difference, because the CPU already has all the bandwidth it needs.

In other words, you would see a performance boost, but if you could overclock your processor another 200mhz, it would beat out the new 3400, and would probably beat the 3700 (higher FSB).
 
So you think my motherboard will run at 220MHz? I have a Asus K8V Deluxe, 3400+ Clawhammer core, 1GB (2x512MB) Corsair XMS PC3200 memory with 2-3-3-6 timmings. A IDE hard drive, and a nVidia GeForceFX 5700Ultra. My motherboard doesn't have AGP/PCI lock does it?
 
lelliott731 said:
So you think my motherboard will run at 220MHz? I have a Asus K8V Deluxe, 3400+ Clawhammer core, 1GB (2x512MB) Corsair XMS PC3200 memory with 2-3-3-6 timmings. A IDE hard drive, and a nVidia GeForceFX 5700Ultra. My motherboard doesn't have AGP/PCI lock does it?
do you know if you can run async timings? i was pretty sure all motherboards can, and i know nforce can, i'm not sure about via tho. i believe you could loosen your memory timmings to 2.5-4-4-8 or something like that, and you could probably hit 220

edit: If your board can run async, running 5:6 lets your memory run at 200mhz, and the CPU run at 240mhz.
 
Hey lelliott i have more or less same system as you i just have the MSI K8Neo and 3400 and i was thinking to do same thing as you.If you upgrade please say if it's faster cause i might get the 3700 .
 
Hey guys. I'm running the 3400+ with 2 X 512 of Corsair XMS DDR 4000 RAM. Maybe since we are on the topic of the 3400's maybe you guys could help me out. I'm running the Gigabyte K8N Pro (nforce 3 250 chipset) and I'd like to up my ram. Would it hurt my performance running 3 X 512 since my board doen't utilize the "dual data"?
 
[BB] Rick James, It won't nessecarily hurt performance. But it could cause you to have errors because of compatability with the ondie memory controller and it will require lower timmings and possible higher memory voltages when overclocked. Also you should calculate your new wattage requirements and ensure your powersupply is adequate. http://www.jscustompcs.com/power_supply/

Also go to gigabytes website and check out their memory compatability list plus fag's to see if your board has any specific problems.
 
MLF said:
[BB] Rick James, It won't nessecarily hurt performance. But it could cause you to have errors because of compatability with the ondie memory controller and it will require lower timmings and possible higher memory voltages when overclocked. Also you should calculate your new wattage requirements and ensure your powersupply is adequate. http://www.jscustompcs.com/power_supply/

Also go to gigabytes website and check out their memory compatability list plus fag's to see if your board has any specific problems.

Well I've got an Enermax 550 Watt and I'm not overclocking anything on my system so running 3 X 512 so I would think I would be good to go. In terms of gaming performance will I pick up some?
 
Probably not alot, 1 gig seems to be the best right now for gaming performance. Though I have hear a lot of different storys about doom3 so I cannot guarrantee it.
 
Back
Top